34

Would You Rather #46

In dramaland, leading ladies often find themselves torn between the love of two equally attractive men — a choice none of us would want to make! But what if you did have to pick between the frustrating lawyer and the adorkable police officer? In this feature, we ask you to make the difficult decisions — and we aren’t limiting our options to dreamy oppas.

Vote via the poll and feel free to use the comments to explain exactly how you were able to choose! So, Beanies:
 


 
WOULD YOU RATHER #45 RESULTS

In the battle of Rain versus Rain, which Rain reigned supreme? That would be bodyguard Rain — although, if @seeker @midnight @hopefulromantic and the rest of you thirsty Beanies had your way, you’d invite all versions of Rain up to your rooftop apartment for some ramyeon.

Unfortunately “all of the above” was not an official option for this prompt, so either a good many of you played eeny meeny miny moe and left your vote up to fate, or 64% truly want to be the Whitney Huston to his Kevin Costner. Among the latter was @gikata, who easily picked the version of Rain that would keep her safe and follow her around looking “hot in a stylish black suit.” Many others — like @jillian and @sunnyboo — agreed that the option without a husband was far less of a commitment or hassle.

And then there is @lordcobol, who has no use for a husband at all, so he picked the more practical option of a bodyguard. Sorry, Lord Cobol, just assume that whatever prompt I come up with, you can gender swap for your favorite K-drama actress.

 
RELATED POSTS

Tags:

34

Required fields are marked *

But what if your first love was your best childhood friend?

Anyway, I have to go with the childhood best friend. I just think I'd want a friend over a lover. But also, would I even still love my first love? Life isn't a KDrama where the answer is "yes" 9 times out of 10, so the childhood friend seems like the safer option.

8
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

That is the dreamy ideal in my head too - a best friend who is also your lover. But as you said, life is not a kdrama and the stars don't align quite like that for many of us.

1
reply

Required fields are marked *

First love isn't necessarily the one we would end up with. And at times, they might be someone we are better off without. So, I am more inclined to reunite with childhood friends and rant about just anything.

8
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

So true. We are just better off without some people.

1
reply

Required fields are marked *

This one gave me a short pause as both are interesting options. But I chose to go with reconnect with your best childhood friend since it offers an easier conversational pathway to the present.

3
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

I like your reason! That conversation with a first love would be so awkward! Unless they were also kind of a friend or part of a friend group.

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

However strong the love is, uncertainties of life can change the one who receives the affection of one's love.

And, for something to make me not be with my first love, then there's no reconnecting to do. This is where I'll separate dramaland from my reality. Only extenuating circumstances can make us reconnect. A desire or a wish? Never. Not happening.

I voted reconnecting with your best childhood friend. This one is a different kind of reunion of its own. And there's a lot of catching up to be done.

Reconnecting with my first love will definitely be fraught with mixed feelings of nostalgia, joy and regret on what was lost and would have been. With friendship, we are simply catching up on lost time.

6
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

It's interesting that time spent with friends can have a different flavour and can take on different meaning to time spent with romantic partners/lovers/first loves. I'm always fascinated by how intimacy "complicates" relationships.

1
reply

Required fields are marked *

To reconnect with someone you really bonded with sounds better than the first love that is now someone you don't really know. I'm still best friends with my school mate and we can pick up where we left off no matter how long its been since we last met.

5
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

Sometimes friendships feels more able to weather many storms than romantic relationships, don't they?

1
reply

Required fields are marked *

I'm definitely going with reconnecting with my childhood best friend! She was great, and we were close for a long time, but time and distance and busy schedules make it hard to reach out in a meaningful way, so it would be great if I had some better way of making that happen.

My first love was my high school boyfriend, who I wisely broke up with my senior year. He wasn't an awful person, but he had some red flags that I was too young and infatuated to recognize. Now I'm happily married to someone way better for me, so no need to reopen a relationship that I have no unanswered questions about and for which I have no nostalgia.

6
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

Well, the fact that you broke up with him tells me you saw the red flags eventually and acted 🥰 I know the whole point of red flags is to see them and take a left but in many situations it seems to take a while for many of us to truly register them as red flags.

1
reply

Required fields are marked *

I am still lucky enough to be in touch with my best childhood friends. So it would be interesting to meet my first love with no expectations.

3
2
reply

Required fields are marked *

The expectations part is key, isn't it? If it's a hi, bye kind of reunion, fine, but exchanging numbers and whatever else may come after that, is another thing altogether.

1
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

So true. Its just out of curiosity and nothung else.

1
reply

Required fields are marked *

This is one of those polls I clicked “view results.” There are REASONS why the first love did not turn into everlasting and why childhood friend did not turn into adult friend. It’s like selecting between two baggage — I’d rather leave both behind.

2
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

🙌🏾 Well said. Yes to this.

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

How about just reconnect with your first love? Reunite seems a bit much. It seems like such a long time ago. But, all I did as a child was play basketball and video games and make sarcastic jokes with my closest friend. Not a great reason to reconnect.

1
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

Reunite seems a bit much.

😂😂 I don't know why I find that funny. You make a good point! I might not even want to reconnect long term, just a quick catch up for a coffee and then we can go our separate ways would do just fine.

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Reuniting with your first love would only be worthwhile if it was mutual. Sadly, my life is littered with unrequited, unhappy first loves. People who didn't have or didn't want a clue, or people that I should have known better and kept away from!
Mind you, I would love to know how Cameron from third grade is doing- I hope he is happy!

2
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

Riggght?? Mutuality is the magic word here. I would say it even applies to childhood friendships that ended because of some misunderstanding.

I have *so* many unrequited first loves too. But your Cameron is doing well whereever he is!

1
reply

Required fields are marked *

Is it cheating if I have two scenarios of how this vote would play out? 😍

In my fantasy version of this poll, I'm reconnecting with my best childhood friend because he happens to be my first love and I want the best of both worlds. What is love but a friendship on fire?

But in the real life version of this, I vote to reunite with my first love because my childhood friends are mostly already within my orbit. But he disappeared. Not that I wanted to see him after he found another girl 🙄 (I love how kdramas idolise first loves).

3
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

My childhood best friend is still my best friend (we've known each other for 34 years!), so I don't need that. The reunion with my first love sounds interesting because I don't really know who gets that honor -- I had one-sided crushes, a couple of almost-relationships, and an awkward first relationship, so it might be interesting for fate to show me who it was by letting us meet again.

5
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

My best childhood friend was a selfish, backstabbing bitch who always took me for granted. I was a very lonely kid so I just didn't know better. But no one's patience is limitless - certainly not mine - so at some point I stopped trying to reconnect with her and, unsurprisingly, she didn't bother to do that herself either. It's a bit of complicated situation since she is daughter of my mom's semi-former bestie herself, so both older women were attempting to force us to make up multiple times, but I'm too old to fall for this now and she probably just doesn't care.

My "first love" was in kindergarten and that bastard forgot me entirely after mere months since we moved. I do not want someone empty-headed like that back in any form, tyvm. Nor do I wish to reunite with any of my exes, ewww, what a nasty idea... tho I'd like to know if some of them are OK because they are decent people and life has been rough for all of us here lately. Ironically, the only guy I don't feel much of sympathy like that is also the only one who literally lives nearby and I keep stumbling upon him regularly so I know for sure that snake is fine. And pathetically acts like he doesn't recognize me - likely in a fear of well-deserved belated beating...

In short, both options SUCK, I'll pass this round.

1
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

I neither have a first love nor a best childhood friend.

I've never fallen in love with any of the dudes I had dated and having attended an all-girls Catholic school from kindergarten to year 10, dating was a non-starter until university.

And I had to contend with the Queen Bees and Mean Girls all through school.

So I'm sitting this one out.

3
5
reply

Required fields are marked *

Note: I am not Catholic but my parents liked the idea of the strict discipline at a Catholic girls' school so little 5-year-old 9TailedVixen was packed off to the town's only such school and there I was made to remain until I finished my GCSE equivalents.

1
3
reply

Required fields are marked *

I get that … Catholic schools really do a number on you. I, too, had the great misfortune to get packed of to a Catholic all girls boarding school, fortunately only for one year (there's no happy end here, only more boarding schools) and honestly, these places should not exist. They bring out the worst in Mean Girls and Mean Boys (in co-ed boarding schools) and more often than not the teachers join the bullying.
I mused occasionally when the "One day, I'll laugh about all that"-moment would come, but it's safe to say it never will.

1
2
reply

Required fields are marked *

Mine wasn't a boarding school but every day I thought about how my parents were soooo determined to send me back into the Piranha-infested waters of that school because "it's for your own good".

It was also a Chinese Catholic Girls School (TM) which means a triple whammy of forcing girls to be obedient, teaching rote learning, and overbearing discipline with no provisions for anyone unless you prove to be unusually gifted with no neurodivergent conditions hampering your brilliance.

Great breeding ground for Overachievers Anonymous and sociopath-level competitiveness. girls can be worse than boys at sabotaging their rivals without getting caught.

I'll stop here before I go on a full-on rant.

Suffice to say, school was so traumatising I never looked back after I left.

1
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

And seriously, that might be the healthiest way to deal with this.
We survived.
It's over.
Let's never go there again.
Our lives are happier now, and if they aren't, they damn well should be.

1

I feel your trauma. 🙁. I wish I could give you a hug.

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

So, on a slightly happier note: Since my so called "first love" is not unlike the illustrious Kavanaugh, I'd rather jump from a helicopter into an active volcano than see that guy again.
My childhood friend wins … not only because the competition is really bad :)

1
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

I say heck to the no on both counts.

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

I have two childhood best friends and we have stayed friends for the last 30+ years. Though we no longer spend hours on the phone with each other, we text and visit.

I've never had a first love or any love. I've had minor crushes here and there, but have never encountered anyone who gave that "first love" feeling as depicted in dramas. I guess I'll pick "reunite with my first love" since I have yet to meet him and want to.

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Easy. My childhood best friend passed away way too soon. I still remember getting the phone call about his passing from his mother so vividly. It’s been well over a decade and I miss him dearly. I’d give anything to reconnect with him.

1
0
reply

Required fields are marked *