A Good Day to Be a Dog: Episode 11
by Unit
It’s a good day to make choices! Following last week’s dive into the past, our heroine finally learns about the origin of her family’s curse. The good news is: the curse can be lifted. But the bad news is: it’s going to cost her more than she could ever imagine.
EPISODE 11
A Good Day to Be a Dog has fully leaned into its dark side, and it makes me wonder what happened to the fun doggy show we started out with. This has become quite the tedious watch, and that’s never a good sign.
Moving on to the happenings of the week. Ji-ah recovers the memories of her past life in bits and pieces, and she makes good on Cho-young’s promise to find Bo-gyeom. At first, he acts like he has no idea what she’s talking about. But when she persists, he insists that past lives are a thing of the past, and she should live a peaceful and comfortable life in the present. Really, Bo-gyeom? This entire story is hinged on your refusal to let go of the past, but okay.
Ji-ah sees beyond Bo-gyeom’s walls, and she promises to be on his side and help him so that he doesn’t continue to suffer from the hurt of the past. Still, he tells her not to ever come to see him again. But later on, we glean from Bo-gyeom’s conversation with the vice principal that he shutdown Ji-ah’s attempts to reach him because the Bo-gyeom that Cho-young knew is gone. No kidding.
On to some good news: Woo-taek was able to revive Hae-na’s dog uncle, and I’ve never been happier for an uncle who isn’t mine. Phew! But the show said “hold my beer,” and provided us with even better news: dog uncle transforms back to human! The way I gasped! This transformation is a miracle that shocks Woo-taek and excites Hae-na’s entire family.
The transformation arc is also fodder for some humor now that Uncle has to re-learn human behavior. Like eating with his hands instead of wolfing down food, and picking things with his hands instead of his mouth.
Uncle has no idea how he turned back to human. But thanks to his time as a dog, he was able to sniff a tiger scent from the suspicious bracelet the vice principal gave to Hae-na. I almost forgot about the existence of this bracelet. Uncle’s observation doesn’t make any sense to Hae-na, so she pays it no mind. For now, what is most important is figuring out how Uncle transformed without a kiss. And my guess is Bo-gyeom’s visit to the vet clinic had everything to do with the “miracle.”
Hae-na figures things out when Bo-gyeom comes to their house — this time, dropping his “ordinary high school teacher” pretense. “I put the dog curse on you,” he reveals, and to prove that he’s not lying, he instantly turns Yoo-ra into a dog. Messing around with humans must be fun for this mountain spirit.
“Who are you?” Hae-na spurts. And this time, Bo-gyeom returns to his beloved vague persona. He tells her to take her time and think about it. But he gives her a hint: he had been around their family for a much longer time than she might think. Curiously enough, Yoo-ra transforms back to human after Bo-gyeom leaves, but she has no recollection of either his visit or being turned into a dog.
Hae-na pours through old picture albums and finds Bo-gyeom in the background of one of her childhood photos. But it looks like she’s not the only one with a childhood encounter with the vengeful mountain spirit. It turns out that Seo-won also met Bo-gyeom back when he was a boy. And of all times to drop by, Bo-gyeom chose the moment little Seo-won was almost attacked by a dog. Yunno, the incident that led to his dog phobia.
Bo-gyeom is not done putting Hae-na and her family through the wringer, so he turns Uncle back into a dog. What!? When Hae-na demands to know the rationale behind his actions, Bo-gyeom takes her down memory lane to her Joseon past. In the memory, Soo-hyun is flat on the ground (presumably dead), and an angry Bo-gyeom holds his favorite sword to Mak-soon’s neck. When she begs him to spare the child in her womb, at least, he placed the dog curse on said child and all its descendants.
Through a more recent flashback, we see that Bo-gyeom orchestrated the events that led to Hae-na kissing Seo-won and activating the curse — which in turn led them to falling in love. In the present, Bo-gyeom tells Hae-na that he’ll lift the curse on her family on one condition: she’ll have to put things back to the way they were originally. Meaning Seo-won will lose all his fond memories of Hae-na. Sigh. Not this show giving me terrible flashbacks of See You in My 19th Life.
Hae-na is given one day to make the biggest choice she’ll probably ever have to make in her life: will she lift her family’s curse? Or will she choose her love for Seo-won instead? Curse you, Lee Bo-gyeom! Curse your mountain and curse your sword!
When Seo-won learns about this, he goes to confront Bo-gyeom and in the process, he grabs the sword. Ugh! If I see this sword one more time! “Because of the two of you, I lost [Cho-young]. It’s only fair that you two pay for it too, don’t you think?” Bo-gyeom calmly states. But Seo-won is confident that even if his memories of Hae-na are wiped, they’ll still fall in love again. “All right, then,” Bo-gyeom smirks. And the game is on!
Seo-won reiterates his stance to Hae-na and tells her to choose lifting the curse over him. He loved her before the curse-activating kiss, and even if their memories are gone, their feelings will remain. “So I’ll go to you. If you take a step back, I’ll take two steps towards you. Even if I get a little lost, I’ll be okay because I’ve walked the path before.” How reassuring.
We get some more boring and repetitive scenes from last week’s Joseon flashback. *Yawn* But we learn something new: when Mak-soon heard that Soo-hyun will be beheaded for helping Cho-young escape, she ended up ratting Cho-young out to the authorities in a bid to save his life. Damn!
So Mak-soon snitched. Big deal. I’m not exactly defending her actions, but I still can’t empathize with Bo-gyeom’s plight. Maybe the problem is me, or maybe it’s in his characterization that just screams “villain.” Indeed, he’s a “victim” of the past life incident, but he just doesn’t feel like it. Instead, he’s essentially giving off antagonistic vibes that makes me want to side with the perpetrators of his misfortune.
We end the week with Seo-won and Hae-na walking past each other without a word. But while Seo-won turns around giving off a posture of familiarity, Hae-na walks away without a backward glance. Hmmmm. Hae-na is built like me for real, because I’m almost tempted to walk away from the show. This is what happens when you over-stretch a story beyond its capacity in an attempt to squeeze out unnecessary angst.
On a lighter note, we got the “stranded on an island and stuck in a one room” trope with Yoo-ra and Woo-taek. They poke fun at themselves for falling victim to the stereotypical trope, but things soon get awkward. I wonder when the show will make them official. Also, when will the show remember it has a character named Yul and bring him back to the forefront? And when are we going to return to the earlier cuteness? So many questions, so few answers from the show.
RELATED POSTS
- Premiere Watch: A Good Day to Be a Dog
- Love is in the air in A Good Day to Be a Dog
- Canine cuteness in A Good Day to Be a Dog teaser
- First look at Cha Eun-woo in A Good Day to Be a Dog
- It’s A Good Day to Be a Dog for Park Kyu-young
- News bites: September 12, 2023
- News bites: September 11, 2023
- News bites: August 23, 2023
- Park Kyu-young
- Cha Eun-woo
- Lee Hyun-woo (2)
Tags: A Good Day to Be a Dog, Cha Eun-woo, Lee Hyun-woo (2), Park Kyu-young
Required fields are marked *
Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *
1 welh
December 22, 2023 at 9:14 AM
The Mountain God plays all his cards and power to emotionally abuse Hae-Na’s family. I thought the worst for uncle last episode, but the twist to show that the curse is reversible was cruel. The Mountain Tiger is merely playing with its prey. But most of the rest of the episode was Joseon era filler. Is BG’s petty destroying SW and HN’s current love by erasing their memories going to make him infinitely happy? No. He could have done that before. I guess it will be up to Teen Shaman to slap some “humanity” and spiritual enlightenment into BG since she has figured it all out.
Last week I wondered “I would rather have the story continue with the "aftereffects" of breaking the dog curse (for example if some dog traits are now hard wired into her personality and actions.)” Well, we got a taste of that with uncle’s transformation. It seems like a wasted comic opportunity for the leads.
I think all the flashbacks and playing up the curse story over the romance is a way the producers are trying to keep the audience guessing because of the network limitations and scheduling issues. I don’t think it is working well.
Required fields are marked *
vienibenmio
December 22, 2023 at 3:05 PM
To be fair the comic deals with the curse and its origins at this point too, but it's much more low key
Required fields are marked *
2 CasualDramaFan
December 22, 2023 at 9:27 AM
The mountain god has turned into a vengeful spirit now. On one hand he asks Ji ah to forget about him as she is not Cho young but on other hand, he is hell bent on punishing Hae-na and Seo-won for supposed crime of Mak-soon and Soo-hyun.
How he can apply one set of rules for one person and another for different? It has ventured into horror category where a vengeful ghost from past is trying to harm the leads.
Where is the exorcist when you need it? I vote for Priest Johan from the Island. The show doesn’t need to pay any extra. (and I don’t want any other actors to be associated with this show)
Required fields are marked *
3 Asha13
December 22, 2023 at 10:20 AM
This has become quite the tedious watch,—-
@unit gurrrl you said it. I’ve been putting this off since Wednesday
Required fields are marked *
vienibenmio
December 22, 2023 at 3:04 PM
I was just waiting for it to be over so I could watch Soundtrack #2
Required fields are marked *
4 dlrgy
December 22, 2023 at 11:26 AM
The trademark "kdrama midway 180 genre flip" is predictable, but always disappointing. I keep hoping each time they'll avoid it even when the tell tale signs are there (I'm aware this is the definition of insanity). Alas, A Good Day to Be a Dog: I mourn thee truly.
Bring back Yul!
Required fields are marked *
5 bbstl 🧹
December 22, 2023 at 12:58 PM
“ Hmmmm. Hae-na is built like me for real, because I’m almost tempted to walk away from the show.”
You and me both, @unit! Thank you for the dryly funny recap of a show I am so over! I am disappointed to learn it’s not ending at 12 episodes 😒 Ugh, bring back the cute and fun please!
Required fields are marked *
6 bunnylita
December 22, 2023 at 2:10 PM
I don't mind when shows get angsty, but this is just a mess. Even knowing the backstory I'm not interested in Bo-gyeom's vengeance, so nothing involving him works for me. It seems like he's playing games with peoples' lives just for fun. And I'm not getting to see characters I do like because of all the repetitive flashbacks. At least involve all of Haena's family in this like they did with Yuna's boyfriend and the reporter. Give us something.
Required fields are marked *
7 vienibenmio
December 22, 2023 at 2:14 PM
I really, really don't like the past life stuff. It was entirely different in the comic. And from the preview, they're gonna change something that I was most looking forward to.
I did laugh at the dog uncle stuff. Low hanging fruit but eh. I'm weirded out that Bo-geum's former love is a student and he's a teacher. Eghh
Required fields are marked *
DancingEmma
December 22, 2023 at 2:34 PM
I agree. That is inappropriate-adjacent and even though he has only briefly interacted with her, is conceptually still icky.
Required fields are marked *
8 GySgt213
December 22, 2023 at 2:57 PM
Just a little rant. Don't mine me.
K-drama writers are so predictable, and as I watch more and more of them (I just started during the pandemic), I get the feeling that they write from a boilerplate script.
1. Spend too many early episodes denying the main couple's attraction to each other.
2. Make the male lead an asshole.
3. Break up the main couple. Usually after one episode as a couple.
4. Send someone off to the States for some dumbass reason and forget about Facetime and texting, let alone calling.
5. Last episode, put the main couple back together even if they haven't communicated for 2-3 years.
To be fair a lot of interesting stories start out pretty well and then fall back on the above in some way.
Required fields are marked *
Reply1988 -❣️Mother Bean❣️
December 25, 2023 at 11:24 PM
‘Send someone off to the States for some dumbass reason and forget about Facetime and texting, let alone calling’👈🏾this is the one that always pulls me out the drama when long distance calls and texts were a mortgage it made sense for some situations but NO ONE in k-dramaland communicated in that way and they never used email or letters and half the time one person was super rich so it made even less sense.
Required fields are marked *
9 Gikata
December 22, 2023 at 3:56 PM
Good thing that uncle is alive - and hopefully uncursed now after a false alarm. Another good thing is that the show finally bothered to give a little more depth to SH-MS past life romance, so I was less annoyed at their story than last week... Still doesn't make much sense for them to jump each other's bones before actually eloping how they were planning to, but oh well, young lovers under pressure are prone to do impulsive things. And didn't MS try to deny snitching on CY before BG cut her off? Perhaps she had some plan but things went wrong... Also damn, he really killed SH, left an innocent child an orphan but STILL felt that his revenge was not enough? That's one petty spirit right here...
Everything else was... not great, sorry. As much as I liked SW and HN openly talking about their supernatural "problem" and promising to fight for their love, magical amnesia or not, the whole sequence was a bit too anticlimactic. Is the real angst reserved for next week? Sis and vet guy should've gotten closer far earlier imo. And I'm with the mom here - whatever reason uncle's first love had to let him down like that, it happened 20 freaking years ago, dude, just move on! Or focus on more pressing matters first at least. Like getting used to the lack of fur and re-learning to do your bathroom thing NOT under the nearest bush...
BG doesn't make any damn sense. Not that he ever did, but wow, telling Jiah off and proceeding to torture others for the sake of his revenge right after? He just LIKES to be evil and bully mortals with his powers, that much is painfully obvious now. Wonder why there is no repercussions for all his actions, seems really unwise from whoever put them in the mountain god position in the first place. Idk if he's supposed to be "nice to people" as HN once wondered, but surely messing with humans to such an extreme extent shouldn't be allowed by heaven's law or something. Also, the way he compared MS to a dog... yikes. Someone pls exorcise this ancient being back to the past!
P.S. With the way CY played cupid for MS and SH from the start I'm now even more sure she did THAT to herself. Poor thing, she gave her supernatural boyfriend way too much credit in the
brainkindness department...Required fields are marked *
Reply1988 -❣️Mother Bean❣️
December 25, 2023 at 11:32 PM
‘P.S. With the way CY played cupid for MS and SH from the start I'm now even more sure she did THAT to herself’ 👈🏾 I agree. He didn't see what happened so I was wondering exactly the same thing. Besides, with his powers he could have dealt with her situation by transporting to where she was or moving her away from danger things we have seen him do whilst in this timeline instead he chose to waste time engaging with soldiers who can’t hurt him anyway😬
Required fields are marked *
Gikata
December 26, 2023 at 1:01 AM
It's downright ridiculous in terms of plot convenience - why did he even separated from her in the first place? She'd be 100% safe from anything and anyone had they just stayed together. He didn't care much for MS's life anyway and his gumiho servant what's-his-name-again could surely take care of himself, so what he left CY all alone for exactly?
Required fields are marked *
10 Dylan [Suffering from Judge from Hell brainrot]
December 22, 2023 at 5:40 PM
I am so done with this drama. Sure, maybe it wasn't possible for the live-action adaptation to make me feel the same feelings as the webtoon but... they're making so many unnecessary changes and not for the better? the preview for next week shows this story going in even more ridiculous direction.
I really want to drop this but there's only 3 eps left and I'd feel foolish...
Required fields are marked *
Reply1988 -❣️Mother Bean❣️
December 25, 2023 at 11:35 PM
I have heard beanies dropping at the last episode or part way through the last episode as the drama was not bringing them joy. No shame to acknowledge the adaption has not worked for you despite you giving it plenty of chances to redeem itself.
Required fields are marked *
11 Dylan [Suffering from Judge from Hell brainrot]
December 22, 2023 at 5:51 PM
Also, at the end of all of this, if the centuries old Bo-gyeom ends up with Ji-ah - his 19?20? year old high school student - I will personally report him to the FBI. I don't think they have jurisdiction in South Korea or over mountain animal deities, but I will give it the ol' college try.
Required fields are marked *
DK-Drama 🫘 Giffing n Space Cadetting🍉🌱
December 27, 2023 at 1:43 PM
But in this case, at least Ju-ah is a couple of centuries old, too.
Still, let's agree it's those last years that count, the fact that even if none of them look 200-300 years old, he still looks about double her age.
Required fields are marked *
DK-Drama 🫘 Giffing n Space Cadetting🍉🌱
December 27, 2023 at 1:47 PM
Though actually, she is 26 and he 30. Not a horrifying age difference.
Required fields are marked *
12 lapislazulii
December 22, 2023 at 7:56 PM
"This is what happens when you over-stretch a story beyond its capacity in an attempt to squeeze out unnecessary angst." 1000000%. I struggled to stay invested this week, literally was like 😐 the entire way through because I simply could not find it in me to care about Bogyeom's past, or Maksoon/Soohyun, or the angst that the show was trying to create. IT was a bazillion times better when it was fluff, light, swoony and just didn't try to explain the rationale behind the fantasy bits. Why on earth bring in - or try to bring in - a tonal shift in the 11th hour?!
And it's a shame because I've really enjoyed this drama for the most part 😭😭😭 The only nice bit is that we all seem to share the same opinion on our dislike of ep 11 - yay for camaraderie!
Required fields are marked *
DK-Drama 🫘 Giffing n Space Cadetting🍉🌱
December 27, 2023 at 1:50 PM
Problem is, we never felt why Cha should want to kill her, and we never felt why mountain God-nim should feel so strongly about it. Apart from the fact that he didn't look the moment she disappeared, so we are far from sure Cha actually did anything. To me it looked like he had made a deal with her, like "I pretend to be threatening you, so that I won't get arrested, and you do that other thing, where ..."
Required fields are marked *
13 Kurama
December 23, 2023 at 12:55 AM
If I was a Mountain God in Korea I will send a protest truck to Kdrama compagnies who always portrays them being completely stupid...
He's a god and he's the one who failed to protect the woman he loved. The 2 mere humans tried and one ended in prison... I mean even if she betrayed her (but I think she didn't), it was to protect her baby and the man she loved. After all, what could happen to Cho Young who was with a god?
His revenge is just petty at this point.
Required fields are marked *
14 late as always
December 23, 2023 at 2:08 PM
I am still holding out hope for this one. Hope that Bo Gyeom will relent, with help from Ji Ah. Hope that Mak-soon's snitch was some kind of clever play that didn't go the way they planned. Hope that we've mostly come to the end of the flashbacks. Hope that we'll get some more lovely, color-saturated scenes like the umbrella moment.
You can do it, Show!
Required fields are marked *
15 fitra
December 23, 2023 at 6:28 PM
Why Eunwoo stopped emoting again?
I wanna see Seowon's laugh 😮💨
Required fields are marked *
DK-Drama 🫘 Giffing n Space Cadetting🍉🌱
December 27, 2023 at 1:52 PM
He is obviously bored, so that's what he's emoting. 😉
Required fields are marked *
fitra
December 28, 2023 at 5:45 AM
Actually it's sarcasm for viewers who said Eunwoo stopped emoting 😁
Required fields are marked *
DK-Drama 🫘 Giffing n Space Cadetting🍉🌱
December 28, 2023 at 8:14 AM
Sorry, I actually stopped following one episode after FL had been saved. I was hoping that maybe it would become fun and exciting again, and I came here to see whether I was missing out.
I don't think it seems like I need to see this, but then again, if they are fun and cute a little bit every time, I don't get the chance to see that.
Required fields are marked *
16 Reply1988 -❣️Mother Bean❣️
December 25, 2023 at 11:16 PM
Thanks for the weecap @unit I came back from holiday with a long list of dramas to catch up on and this and Castaway diva are the ones I was struggling to dive back into which you summed up beautifully 👉🏾 ‘A Good Day to Be a Dog has fully leaned into its dark side, and it makes me wonder what happened to the fun doggy show we started out with. This has become quite the tedious watch, and that’s never a good sign’
I loved this show at the start it made me laugh out loud every week and the one episode a week or not even that was annoying but now slogging through my pet peeve of ‘light shows turning unnecessarily dark’ I am glad I didn’t binge watch from the start. I read and enjoyed the webtoon and I don't remember it being this dark for this length of time unless I purposely missed some episodes like I had to when reading Death’s game which I went in to knowing was DARK.
I am only watching on because I know there will be a return to the fun element but I will be VERY disappointed if they stretch this darkness into the final week and we only get ten minutes of the old joy at the end.
I also miss Yul, his actions have always brought the funny and his only return to that side was his liberal use of salt in the ‘follow the light scene’🤣 and that was buried in at least 5 episodes of heavy so was not enough to lift the mood.
Required fields are marked *
DK-Drama 🫘 Giffing n Space Cadetting🍉🌱
December 27, 2023 at 1:55 PM
It doesn't just seem dark, it seems kind of purposeless dark. As an audience, you don't feel the dilemma that could *possibly* make ML slit the throat of past Ji-ah, and you don't feel the despair and anger of that mountain God.
Required fields are marked *
17 DK-Drama 🫘 Giffing n Space Cadetting🍉🌱
December 27, 2023 at 11:49 AM
Poor, brave you who is watching this for the rest of us.
Required fields are marked *
18 Andini
January 2, 2024 at 3:01 AM
This drama is soooo good, i love their chemistry, they're so sweet, and the kissing scene is like real
Required fields are marked *