I still love this drama, but I felt ep 10 drag a bit because they toned down the comedy and focused on entirely resolving the mysteries. Ep 9 was nice because it had a right amount of emotional punch!

Yeo Jin Gu is really good at crying and I felt so sad by watching his parents refuse to let go of his lost sister and learn to live in the present with Gye Hoon. Even Won Tak's dad was horrible for making his son suffer by not letting go of his pride which makes Da Hyun's grandma and mom seem like angels even if they accidentally caused someone to die.

Also the kiss was nice, but I thought after his breakdown a hug would have been appropriate and more memorable.

I agree with some of the other beanies theories which are:
1. As kids, Da Hyun and Jin Geun entered some bad guys house or grandma/mom's divorced abusive husband's house, got assaulted and in the ensuing tussle caused Gye Young's death.
2. Da Hyun saw Gye Young kidnapped, visited the kidnappers house with Jin Geun to save her, but mom/granma came to know about it and escaped with Da Hyun, leaving behind Gye Young.
3. Jin Geun's parents are the culprit because from who else would he have got stalker genes🙄

I seem to be sitting in front of the TV completely dull. Because I didn't think about Gye-hoon's father (I just assumed he was dead), nor did I seriously consider why only Gye-hoon feels Da-hyun's emotions but not the other way around. That it might be because Gye-hoon has closed himself off so much and not allowed any feelings, that's not what I thought about.

I was a little bit annoyed with Da-hyun. I would have liked her to tell Gye-hoon earlier that she knew his sister.

I'm happy that Da-Hyun finally told Gye-Hoon about the fact she maybe saw his sister the famous day.

Until now, Jin-Geun has too much power on them because he's the only who knows what happened. I wish the grandma speaks now. Because in the past, maybe Da-Hyun was too young to deal with the truth, but clearly she never completely forgot about it and had nightmares and now it put her in danger at at Jin-Geun's mercy.

Won-Tak's situation is so sad. He did the right thing to talk to the Police in the past, but the Police didn't do their work and let his father to be accused of murder. He tought during his whole life that his father was guilty and now, he knows that it's not true and feels guilty about it.

Gye-Hoon's parents were so awful, they both forgot they had a son. The fact both of them accused him because he wasn't there for his sister is really vicious. They're lucky that he grew up as good man. I'm happy to see him ready to open himself to happiness! He deserves it.

The OST is really good.

Thank you, @quirkycase, for the weecap! With only 6 episodes left, I have some guesses on the people who know what happened (aside from Jin-geun). Because of his shifty eyes, one is Chief Seo, I'm thinking Gye-hoon's father (why else would he abandon his family if not for the guilt) and mom and halmoni also know something.

Breaking news:
A new milestone has been reached everyone, between Sic and a Yeo Jingoo drama: we've reached beyond the half way point and she isn't QUITE grumpy enough to want to defenestrate anything! (Except for his styling that is...)
Le gasp. how shocking.
Will we both make it to the 75% marker and beyond, or will there be broken windows.
Stay tuned to find out.

(I have some so far mainly minor issues with this show and I do wish it'd balance its black comedy and dark melo across like, the whole thing, but this really is a milestone for me so I'm content to just sit on those for now and decide later if they're more than minor 😂😂😂)

I can’t believe how good these guys are at communication! Sure, they don’t share everything, but Gye-hoon keeps talking her where he’s going, why and what Jin-geun has said to him now. It’s so refreshing!

Also they’re so cute ^^ What a brilliant confession.

I had to pause after the talk between father and son at the bus station.It was so real, so emotional. The writer did a great job there.

‘What are you sorry for? You did well’ you can literally see her brain short circuiting omg I LOVE HER. That has got to be one of the best post kiss scenes I’ve ever seen. I even love her more so for dealing with the whiplash from GH’s mood swings and seeing through them to understand what he’s actually doing (‘he’s chosen to run away again’ made my heart hurt for a bit). She’s proven herself to be brave, compassionate, and wonderful character time and time again, and is definitely going to go down as one of my favourite kdrama FLs of all time.

I’m not exactly tired of this giant Among Us game yet but I am finding it painful not having ANY real clues as to who was behind GY’s disappearance, but I guess that’s the kind of torture they’re aiming for. Like some other beanies have said previously, the only one I’m currently suspecting is the Police Chief because he’s goes HARD on the defensive every time the topic is mentioned. Also I’m glad DH did come clean about the fact that she knew GY and that she might be involved, I was wincing in anticipation for potential angst to be caused every time she didn’t tell him when she had a chance.

This drama is getting better and better. Episode 9, I'm crying with Gye Hoon. My heart felt heavy for him, his mother and his father. They must've been feeling like living in a hell. Is there a way for them to move forward...😢

I remembered the day we lost our 3rd child just for a brief moment at an open park at a foreign land. I remembered the tremble, fear and feeling like I can't go on living if we can't find her. That short moment, was a hell. While I'm thankful we found our precious kid, I can't imagine the agony of parents and family who lost their kids without any news or knowing what's happening. I'm praying God help to heal their heart...

Eun Jeung is right, at least she got a closure; she finally found her sister's corpse. At the very least, while it's still sad, at least she got a closure...

The scene where Da Hyun shop with Eun Jeung, omo.. I cried my eyes out... For Eun Jung for missing her sister so deep, for Da Hyun who felt like she's the replacement of their missing loved ones

This week throw a lot of questions while also giving a lot of sweet scenes. I applaud the cast and the director for such a great job!

Who's Jin Geun meeting at the alley?
Who's house is it, the red gate one?
What is it that Halmoni and Omoni know?
What is the worst thing Da Hyun can do to Gye Young that cause Jin Gen said that?

It's also a relief to learnt about the blood on Mr Han's shirt. I feel sorry for Won Tak and his father..

On a second thought, this felt a bit similar to Beyond Evil (Jin Goo's previous drama). That his police partner lost his sister. But in the end his sister's corpse was found at his family home inside the wall... He didn't know... His mother didn't know... His father didn't know that lead to his suicide... If only they knew... I cried a river at that scene.

I don't have a clue what to expect for Link.

Anyway, can't wait for next week!! Hoping for more of the police couple scene, bromances scene, and more comedy.

Awww that was a sweet kiss, but as mentioned above a hug would have been more impactful and made more sense, but we were at episode 9, so due for a kiss, lol. Also shame on Won Tak's father for holding on to his pride, shame on him. I am glad he was able to get a lovely hug from Min Jo, he really needed it.

Im gonna said the adults in this drama is awful and yes its including dahyun's mom and grandma and gyehoon's parents. Its like everyone have a part in the incident but refuses to acknowledge it. So everyone blame the easiest target aka gyehoon.
Gyehoon lives while his parents silently blame him, hate him and refuse to look at him for 18 years. His father last word "be happy, like others" is like a curse. Told him you dont deserve to be live like someone else. Imagine live like that for 18 years. He cant even stand the sight of his reflection smiling. And his first ever relationship have tragedy wait for them.

Finally a KISS and not just any tentative, awkward, not-sure-what-I'm-doing kiss but a truly passionate, yearning and heartfelt kiss...I disagree (respectfully) that a hug would have been more appropriate because he was just bursting with pain and emotion then and needed love, and not just comfort. But it was nice that he said sorry afterwards (since he didn't ask beforehand) and cute that she replied "well done." They may have gone on if it hadn't been for Jinsoo barging in (his timing almost but not quite impeccable this time, so funny). The couple scenes in Episode 10 were so sweet (how he motioned for her to sit next to him, wrapped his fingers in hers and leaned his head on her shoulder in bliss).
I'm so interested in DaHyun recovering her memory, I get the sense she was also held with Gyeyoung...maybe Jin-guen lured her there, perhaps it was his house and one of his parents was the culprit? We haven't figured out who his parents were but my guess is the father at least is still lurking there, perhaps even one of the police officers.
I was wondering if the police woman might be GyeYoung but I'm now thinking she really died...if the police woman was her I feel we would have gotten more of her back story by now. On the other hand maybe they haven't given us her back story because they want to surprise us.
The red gate so eerie looking...some beautifully filmed scenes in this drama

I have not been able to watch a Kdrama in 10 days and life has not been fun😩😩. Binging the last 4 episodes is just the right amount of sweetness and fun I needed to get back on my kdrama train.

I can't stop salivating when I see Gyehoon cooking. When is the damn restaurant opening? I won't mind a chef boyfriend/husband😂!

My heart breaks so much for Wontak! Ugh, I hope he heals.
Sigh... I have been wondering at what point Dahyun will realise that people can repaint their gates especially after 18 years...

I love that Dahyun came clean to Gyehoon as soon as she put some pieces together, it would have been unnecessary to pull things although I'm really not looking forward to the forbidden love trope angst.

I love the mom and halmeoni but I'm really rolling my eyes hard at them keeping what ever secret from Dahyun! She's an adult.

Gyehoon's awful parents remind me of Taejun's parents 😒😒.

I'm suspecting the chief at this point and the dad even 🙄

Even though this show deals with a lot of painful emotions and past trauma it somehow manages to balance out the pain with sweetness so expertly that I always enjoy watching it. And just when I might forget what a great actor Yeo Jin-gu is, he has a scene like that flashback with his dad and I'm all impressed again. That was so well played, especially since we've only ever seen Gye-hoon bottle up his emotions.

I wasn't sure how the romance would progress, and thought it was the weakest part of the show, but I've changed my mind after these two episodes. I completely buy the evolution of their feelings. I also like that they're both a bit awkward and inexperienced, but I still felt like I was watching two adults, not 30-year old teenagers freezing up the minute their hands grazed, lol.

And I love that we see women over 50 heavily featured and treated like fully formed human beings who exercise, socialize, eat, and have fun together. I often struggled with a lot of the characterizations of parents or gossipy women in small towns that we see so often in kdramas. Watching them berate or hit their children when they're disappointed or expect complete respect from those younger women and men that they openly insult can be both tedious and infuriating. There was a little of that type of thing in the beginning of the show, but now I'm really loving the way the women in the town interact and live their lives. And the love between mom, grandma, and Da-hyun is so obvious and beautifully portrayed.

I remember, while watching, saying to myself that "they defo painted over the gate like its been years and the culprit isnt that dumb to not cover up his/her tracks" and was so glad to see that I was right.

At this point in the show, I'm just waiting for the mystery to unravel tbh. The romance aspect isnt really cutting it for me (I got such a shock when he went in for a kiss after having a whole breakdown .5 seconds ago)
It was sad to see GH's parents just completely fall apart and neglect him and I too forgot about where his dad was, I really just thought he was elsewhere or passed on or smth.
Looking forward to the upcoming eps!