205

You can only pick one: Sageuk


You can only pick one, and boy the pressure is on. The DB team will answer a new prompt in each post, and you’re invited to do the same in the comments. Ready to play?
 

You can only pick one sageuk (historical drama)


 
quirkycase: My absolute favorite sageuk has to be Nokdu Flower. Beyond the high quality of the storytelling, acting, and production, it depicts a historical period that isn’t the usual focus for sageuks. I didn’t know anything about the Donghak Peasant Revolution before this drama, but it’s a moving piece of history that was fascinating to learn about. Unlike the usual 50+ episode count for sageuks, this one clocks in at 24 episodes, so it stays tight and well-paced. I sometimes find the palace politicking tiresome in sageuks, so I loved that Nokdu Flower is more social than political in nature. Think freedom fighting and social unrest as opposed to men in winged hats arguing. Be prepared to feel stirring emotions and to get that beautiful “Blue Bird” song stuck in your head for weeks.

mistyisles: I think this is the hardest You Can Only Pick One prompt yet! I can’t possibly name only one sageuk as my *favorite* over the others, so I guess I’ll just pick one to highlight that I haven’t written about recently: Rebel: Thief Who Stole the People. It’s an epic fairytale with a fabulous cast and a stirring OST, and I still catch myself thinking about some of its most powerful scenes at really random times, even years later! It also struck me as one of the only sageuks I’d seen at the time wherein the characters actually sing (and boy do they sing!). It does start off a little slow, but once the main story gets going the buildup and eventual payoff is so, so worth it.

solstices: There are a number of strong contenders, but the one that stands out the most to me would be Six Flying Dragons. From its stellar cast to its evocative soundtrack, this drama was polished from start to finish. I don’t think I can even begin to sum up the immense scale of the hope and tragedy that this show delivered; it was a deeply moving tale of humanity, loyalty, and a dream of a brighter future. Muyiyiya remains one of my favorite drama OSTs of all time — Byun Yo-han’s voice is as poignant as his acting — and Yoon Kyun-sang’s impassioned roar of “Warrior Moo-hyul!” will always bring a fond smile to my face. Plus, this drama was my introduction to the amazing Han Ye-ri — her layered portrayal and graceful sword fighting instantly turned me into a fan. I could sing a million praises about Six Flying Dragons and it still wouldn’t be enough.

Unit: Hands down, Empress Ki (which I think is Ha Ji-won’s finest work till date)! Whether as a “man” or as a maid, a consort and finally the empress, her journey wasn’t smooth. But if there’s one person who’ll use the stones that trip her feet to build a palace, it’s Empress Ki. And to oppose her at every turn, the drama gave us formidable villains in El Temur (and sons), the dowager, and Baek-an. Not these caricature kinda villains that now populate the sageuk space. I love almost everything about the drama from the plot to the palace politicking and scheming, to the OSTs and the costumes (the Goryeo era will always be superior to the Joseon era). My favorite character asides the empress was Tal Tal (I even shipped them at some point) and my least favorite was the spineless emperor. I only liked him because he was played by Ji Chang-wook. Heh. Btw, I’ve rewatched all 51 episodes of the drama three times. And each time, I relieve the pain of having spoiled the identity of the Eagle House boss for myself on my first watch. *Sob* I should probably add that it took me two weeks to move on when I first watched the drama.

Dramaddictally: At the risk of having pitchforks thrown at me, I’ll admit I don’t really like sageuk. Modern romance is more my thing, but there are a few historical dramas that have captured my heart and The King’s Affection sits at the top of that list. NGL, I went into this drama with my eyes on Rowoon and came out with them fixed on Park Eun-bin (which is probably true of everything I’ve ever seen her in because she always steals the show). Here, she portrays the prince with such complicated strength and beauty, it’s hard not to fall for her character — the same way Rowoon does, even when he thinks she’s a man. The thing I love most about this story of gender-role reversals is that we get a lead couple that seems highly modern in their egalitarianism. They’re equals when they sword-fight the villains, when they develop complex schemes, and when they confess their feelings. The heroine breaks the mold in this one — not only because she’s pretending to be a man — but because she’s dedicated to discovering her true self, no matter how long she’s forced to play the role of someone else.

alathe: Favorite sageuk? Well, I don’t know… there are so many to choose from, and — okay, no, I can’t even pretend. It’s Six Flying Dragons, folks. It was never not going to be Six Flying Dragons. Have I mentioned that I really love Six Flying Dragons??? From start to finish — and boy, that’s a long journey — it’s a show practically tailor-made for me. It has convoluted political scheming and fraught ideological debates! It has impeccably characterized anti-villains for whom I’ll cheer till the bitter end! It has swords! But, above all, it has nuance. Of all the sageuks I’ve loved, it’s one of the best I’ve seen at grappling with the sheer hugeness of history. It juggles an immense ensemble cast, all of whom are constantly at political odds with one another, and most of whom are so very easy to adore. This isn’t a show with easy answers. In fact, as you’d expect from a story all about the ruthless rise of King Taejong, it takes moral absolutes and bludgeons them to death atop a bridge at night. And, what’s more, it’s entirely justified in doing so. (As was Bang-won. I will not be taking questions.) I gave this series fifty hours of my life, plus a significant portion of my soul — and, if asked, I’d do it all over again.

 
RELATED POSTS

Tags: , , , , ,

205

Required fields are marked *

Without question Six Flying Dragons and Empress Ki (and I thought JC W surpassed himself as the emperor). Then The Tree with Deep Roots. The story of Hangul will always stay with me. The more recent Bloody Heart was satisfying at a whole new level. But there's a film that I'll never forget and that's The Throne, that terrible story of the salt chest that is scored into the brain of every Korean. And then at the end is the dance with his father's fan by So Ji-sub. No words for the brilliance. There's so much history and it's all so dramatic. Another one is The Admiral: Roaring Currents and I'm still waiting to see the second film in the trilogy. I can't draw a line between dramas and film when it comes to fabulously engaging k-history

6
3
reply

Required fields are marked *

I liked both The Throne and Roaring Currents. Other good movie sageuks are Masquerade and The Royal Taylor.

3
2
reply

Required fields are marked *

Me, too! Do you watch historical Chinese movies, too? The Last Emperor, The King of Masks, Snowflower and the Secret Fan

1
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

I have not watched any Chinese historical movies.

1
reply

Required fields are marked *

The Princess's Man - what's not to love about a smash up of Romeo & Juliet, The Count of Monte Cristo and Richard III.

6
4
reply

Required fields are marked *

Oh no now I’m really interested in watching The Princess’s Man. I love the Count of Monte Cristo & Romero and Juliet stories (not so much the dying parts - I love a happy ending) but this show is not showing in my region on Viki TV.
Australia lagging behind again.. sad face.

2
2
reply

Required fields are marked *

It's an oldie - 2011, so Viki may have taken it down years ago.

2
reply

Required fields are marked *

It did show up on Rakuten Viki when my VPS was set to USA.

1
reply

Required fields are marked *

Perfect description!

1
reply

Required fields are marked *

I'm usually not in the mood for sageuk these days, but when I started watching kdramas I'd eat that stuff up: Faith, Dr. Jin (one episode), Rooftop Prince... Most of my favorites have been mentioned by others already, so following the rule of you-can-only-pick-one-that-no-one-has-mentioned-yet, Shine or Go Crazy.

5
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

It's 'Nokdu Flower' all the way for me. I came for Jo Jungseok but end up loving the story and most the casts. (I may like the upcoming "Sejak" too because he will be in it).

However, I can't actually pick one. There are other dramas that I like very much:
Dae Janggeum's "Jewel in the Palace" for its story
"Dongyi" because of Ji Jin Hee
"Mr Queen" for the comedy
And lastly, "Under the Queen's Umbrella" for the mother's passion.

8
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

My vote goes to one not mentioned as yet, Yi San, Wind in the Palace, an oldie but a goodie.

Picking just one is pretty much impossible - although its not really true (yet) I feel like I've watched hundreds of sageuks, and liked most of them. But beanies here have added a lot to my watch next list!

Still, the ones that have made the deepest impression on me are those that draw out some aspect of Joseon or earlier culture/society/institutions beyond the political story, even if it means a bit of confabulation of real history to achieve!

So I really enjoyed Rookie Historian for the whole annals creation stuff; Deep rooted tree as the best of the bunch dealing with the creation of Hangul (and hard to go wrong with Han Suk-kyu as the lead!); Under the Queen's Umbrella for its female perspective (and of course the fabulous Kim Hye-soo), and Red Sleeve for the palace staff perspective.

Yi San covers more or less the same events as Red Sleeve, and although I love Red Sleeve, in many ways I think Yi San is better (mind you with 77 episodes in total it had a lot more time to develop things). You get a fascinating backdrop on the role of musicians and artists in the service of the State, as well as the Palace Inspector ladies and so forth. The stuff on relations with China was great too. The leads were great, and so were many of the secondary characters - the overambitious friend of King Jeongjo, Hong Guk-yeong played by Han Sang-jin (Kang Hoon, who I'm now a huge fan of thanks to Secret Romantic Guesthouse, played the same role in Red Sleeve) was particularly memorable, as was the actor who played Yeongjo (Lee Soon-jae).

But there are so many great ones - I loved Bossam, Iljimae, Arang, Royal Gambler, Moonlovers...).

7
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

Oh yes, how could I have forgotten Yi San? I went back and rewatched some scenes after watching Red Sleeve and remembered how much I loved the two leads.

1
reply

Required fields are marked *

Queen Seondeok would be mine. I favor the older over the “fusion” , although Mr. Queen is worthy of mention.

The C drama Go Princess Go, the source material for Mr. Queen, is certainly worth the watch, be aware, it’s pure “trash” and that is what makes it so much fun.

5
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

I like stories about fictional characters but set in a real historical background (Chuno, Mr. Sunshine, Nokdu Flower) or fictionalized dramas about real historical characters like Queen Seondeok.

6
reply

Required fields are marked *

I absolutely adore sageuks, and they're easily one of my favorite Kdrama genres. I started watching them because I love historical Korean fashion, especially the elaborate gowns of the Royal Court and aristocracy throughout various dynasties. Korean and Chinese historical garb, particularly the ceremonial gowns, are two of the only global fashion histories where I appreciate both men's and women's fashion, so I got hooked on the modern-day portrayals/interpretations in Kdramas and Korean films.

I also came to appreciate the historical educational elements of sageuks as well. Some follow true historical reality better than others, but having grown up and being educated in the U.S., I relied on these Kdramas and the internet to get a more colorful perspective on Korean life throughout history. Thankfully, there's better access to Korean history books in English now, even in the U.S.

Like many historical dramas, sageuks have been intense viewing, so I really have to be in an intellectual mood to start one. Historical Korean Royal Courts were no less intense, refinely violent, and drama-filled as those of the more famous European or the lesser-known (at least in Western society) Chinese Courts, so I usually can't watch them without intellectualizing them. They're usually pretty good insights into the sociocultural psyche of their Eras, especially the ones based on socioeconomic themes.

So many good ones have already been named, and for me, it'd be literally impossible to pick one so I'll throw one out that hasn't been mentioned yet. JangYungShil was a great one, one of the sageuks with themes centering around technological innovation, socioeconomic, and historical cultural issues under King Sejong's reign. It used to be available with English subtitles some years back on OnDemandKorea.com though not sure where now with English subtitles. There's so many other great ones, but my favorite top must-see sageuks to truly appreciate the genre would probably include:
- Dae Jang Geum
- Painter in the Wind
- Goddess of Fire
- Saimdang (although not a traditional sageuk, great narrative about a strong FL and the art of historical East Asian paper-making)
- Haechi
- The Royal Tailor
- Queen Seonduk
- Hwangjini
- Tree with Deep Roots
- Jang Ok Jung

7
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Kingdom...no kidding. I don't like the zombie genre but somehow the story captivated me. Great cinematography and the actors: Ju Ji-hoon, Bae Doona, and others were wonderful. That young actress who played the badass young queen consort was also wonderful. Is season 3 coming out, yet?

2
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Here's my List:
1. Empress Ki-Hajiwon is my alltime favorite actress.
2. Damo
3. Queen seunduk
4. Mr. Queen was really funny
5. The Red Sleeve Cuff
6. Jumong
7.Under the Queens Umbrella
8. Alchemy of Souls Part 1 only because of Somin
Can i include Mr. Sunshine? Tho it's not around that tl

4
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

I'm sorry, I am very late to this but ONLY ONE SAGEUK?
That's absurd. I object to this entry for this topic more than most others.
You could make a decent argument for this being like asking "you can only pick one drama ever..."
They're not even remotely in the same league as other genres or sub genres or classifications you've had in the past; they're in a league and class of their own!
All the more power to and reason for this Article Theme just becoming "List Your Faves in this Arbitrary Topic" :P

7
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Hands down! Chuno, aka The Slave Hunters. A week after seeing it, I would remember....and cry - in public! It's a birthday rewatch every year. I didn't there even WERE slaves during the Joseon period and my mind was immediately blown with their plot line. Of course, there was Jang Hyuk's gut-wrenching performance. I became not only his fan and also of almost all the cast members. I cried over the despicable assassin bowing goodbye, alone, before his mother's door. The unforgettably beautiful (and innovative) soundtrack haunted me. The cinematography? Breathtaking. I'm getting ready for the next rewatch.

3
5
reply

Required fields are marked *

Nothing quite like it. I would rewatch it too, but it is no longer legally available to me.

2
3
reply

Required fields are marked *

Fortunately, I downloaded it many, many years ago.

1
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

Do you have the WITH S2 subtitles?

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

You can find it in myasiantv if you are in US.

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

It's a beautiful series. The production looked very authentic which adds to its flavor. I also realized the brother/slave is the same man who played the King in Our Blooming Youth. He looked so good in this. It's gritty. It's not the kind I like but it's one of the best I have seen.

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

A bit late to the party, but I had to put my thoughts in. Sagueks are my husband's favorite genre and we end up watching quite a few of them. Most of the ones we watched are recent ones (unless they are horror, so Kingdom was out after two episodes). The one that struck a chord somewhere deep was Our Blooming Youth. I absoloutley loved the meaningful love story between Yi Hwan and Min Jay Yi. I loved their bickering, their flirting, the sass, the 'hand tied behind the back' ache of loving someone totally out of reach. I loved its feminist hero. I loved how each relationship was given ample time to develop. The second couple is one of my favorites out of any drama (close to Business Proposal I think, High Society does not count). The backstory hit a raw nerve. It brought home many points of unfairness that we struggle around the world even today - whether it's not having agency as a woman, or people being pawn in the larger scheme of things where love has no place, or greed for power that vanquishes an entire population without remorse and gloats for more. I loved its shovel metaphor (one of the most genuinely hilarious scenes ever that I have watched in any show across the world) and how it was used to define the uphill battle against the class struggle in the end. But above all, I loved that this story was about trust, friendship and a willingness to make the right choices, even though it is difficult. It is not perfectly crafted, but it has so much heart that it checks many boxes that make a drama endearing. Oh, and did I say I am in love with its background score and all the OSTs? It's on my Spotify loop.
VERY honorable mentions:
Under the Queen's Umbrella (LOVED this)
Mr Queen
The red sleeve
The moon embraces the sun
The King's affection (only and only for Park Eun Bin and a truly formidable villain).

3
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Moon Embracing the Sun.

I loved and understood every character and lived for them (except the female lead's acting 😩). Simply beautiful.

I also loved Under the Queen's Umbrella, Gu Family Book (I brayed in tears like a donkey for this one), 100 days My Prince (지금 나만 불편하는가 😂), Mr. Sunshine (another tearjerker), Love in the Moonlight 💓 and Rooftop Prince

1
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Yes yes yes i agree six flying dragons!! I just finished watching it again (the last time was a few years ago) and after reading more theory I am still so impressed at how they explained concepts like dialectical materialism (the way Bangwon and Sambong would constantly remind themselves and others to always be considering the past, present and future before coming to conclusions) and how different it is from actions that are reactionary(thinking what needs to be done right now without looking at the future implications of actions/acting while only considering the reality of the present moment)

I am very interested in reading Mencius after learning about his ideas too, I feel like this show is wildly educational not only on history but on how to move in society and what to consider, (with actual lessons and from a perspective that considers things like autonomy over land for everyone, a concept that many many radicals have written about) similar to Nokdu flower and Queen Seondeok, I wish there was a name for this niche of dramas lolll

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *