The Secret Romantic Guesthouse: Episode 1 (First Impressions)
by mistyisles
The first episode of The Secret Romantic Guesthouse breezes by, introducing us to our major players in familiar and fun fusion sageuk form. It kind of feels like K-drama comfort food: easy and enjoyable to watch, even though (or because?) the ingredients aren’t really anything we haven’t seen before.
Editor’s note: Continued drama coverage is pending based on Beanie feedback.
EPISODE 1
We start off with two tiny orphaned children bonding over their shared grief. She’s the daughter and sole mourner of a now-deceased scholar; he’s LEE SEOL, the son of the newly deposed prince — and, as such, he’s being hunted by palace soldiers. After the girl hides him from said soldiers, he promises that next time they meet, he’ll tell her his name. Judging by the swell of romantic music, these two will most certainly meet again as adults.
Then we jump ahead thirteen years, where our leading lady, YOON DAN-OH (Shin Ye-eun), runs the inn Ihwawon (meaning “Flower Garden”) out of her late father’s old house. Whether Ihwawon is a guarantor of scholarly success or a haunted house depends on whether you ask Dan-oh or… pretty much anyone else. Still, Dan-oh throws herself wholeheartedly into trying to lure new customers in.
So far, she has two: YOOK YOOK-HO (In Gyo-jin), a perpetual student who’s been trying to pass the civil service exam for upwards of ten years now, and JUNG YOO-HA (Jung Geon-joo), the noble, studious type of “Flower Scholar” with a very obvious crush on Dan-oh.
While Dan-oh is out drumming up business, she encounters two new Flower Scholars. First is the flirty and carefree KIM SHI-YEOL (Kang Hoon), who blissfully wakes up in a gibang only to be tossed out on his head for failing to pay for last night’s drinks.
He steps in to save Dan-oh from an unwanted suitor, but she ends up doing some of the saving for him since he’s not very good in a fistfight. (He is, however, good at making distractions and then running away.) He’s promptly dragged away to pay his unsettled debts, but turns up at Ihwawon that night, hair tussled and face scuffed, but cheery grin firmly in place.
Our final Flower Scholar isn’t actually a scholar at all, but a *mysterious* warrior who carries a wooden sword. His name is KANG SAN (Ryeoun), and when he’s pressured into hiring an armed escort through dangerous territory, he beats off the neighborhood thugs himself and gets his money back from the useless “bodyguards.”
San isn’t swayed by Dan-oh’s attempts to win him as a customer, but she seizes an opportunity to swipe his pack when he leaves it unattended (trying to stay out of sight from approaching soldiers), forcing him to come to Ihwawon to get it back. It’s already curfew by this point, so Dan-oh gleefully points out he has no choice but to stay for at least one night — and to pay her jacked-up price.
San grudgingly agrees, and both he and Shi-yeol get the rundown of how Ihwawon works. Rule #1: Stay out of the annex. Rumor has it that’s where the ghost lives, but Dan-oh doesn’t confirm or deny.
While the three Flower Scholars plus Dan-oh make an unlikely and prone-to-bickering foursome (Dan-oh and San especially use bickering as their primary mode of communication), they’re soon united as a team by an urgent plea for help: a young mother’s infant child has been stolen. The woman is a former servant of Yoo-ha’s household, and her child was taken into a nearby inn as collateral against her husband’s debt.
The four fan out to surreptitiously search the inn. Yoo-ha is the first to catch a glimpse of the back room where the baby is being kept under guard, but he’s caught and kicked out before he can fully investigate. Dan-oh follows up after him and is able to take the baby and run, but she doesn’t get far before the guards catch on and give chase.
Just as they’re closing in on her, a masked San appears. Despite getting his wooden sword chopped in half, he fights off the guards and shields Dan-oh and the baby from a toppling shelf. Operation: Rescue the Baby proceeds without further incident, and after reuniting the child with his mother, our four heroes walk off into the sunset, enjoying the rush of victory and tossing playful gibes at each other.
When they return to Ihwawon, however, they’re greeted by a violent crew of creditors come to collect on Dan-oh’s father’s outstanding debt — a debt so high she’ll have to sell the house to even begin paying it off. The boys jump to her defense, both sides squaring off for a fight.
Unbeknownst to them all, however, they’re about to have even more company. See, there’s a bigger political drama at play, and our little team may have already gotten themselves unintentionally involved. The king’s consort (Gil Eun-hye) is on the verge of giving birth and desperate for a son — so desperate, in fact, that she’s got a backup plan in case her child isn’t a boy. (Which is certainly convenient timing for a servant woman’s baby to be quietly kidnapped, isn’t it?)
As for the king (Hyun Woo), he learns from a blind shaman that a son isn’t in his future — but complete destruction is if he doesn’t stop searching for a certain person. Does he stop? Apparently not, because as soon as he learns that Lee Seol has been spotted amongst the scholars in town, he sets his men on the chase.
The hunt is led by one JANG TAE-HWA (Oh Man-seok), who bears a wicked-looking scar on his face and a deeply personal investment in finding Lee Seol, though what exactly that is remains a mystery. Tae-hwa and his men search through every inn, confident they’ll recognize Lee Seol when they see him. After their search turns up zero results, they’re left with one last place to look: Ihwawon.
If there’s one complaint I have about this first episode, it’s that the characters feel more like character types than real people. It makes it easy to follow the action and know who we’re supposed to root for, because we’re treading familiar territory even though the story itself is new, but I also don’t necessarily feel like I know any of these people just yet. But it is only the first episode, so I’m hopeful that now that we’ve gotten the setup out of the way, we’ll start to dig a little deeper into the characterization.
In spite of that one small complaint, however, The Secret Romantic Guesthouse is so far hitting all the right buttons for me. It’s pretty, it’s fun, and it’s just a little bit mysterious. I’m definitely looking forward to seeing where we go from here!
RELATED POSTS
- Premiere Watch: The Secret Romantic Guesthouse
- Politics and peril in The Secret Romantic Guesthouse
- Introducing the players of The Secret Romantic Guesthouse
- The Secret Romantic Guesthouse readies for lodgers
- News bites: March 9, 2023
- News bites: February 25, 2023
- Shin Ye-eun welcomes Joseon F3 in Flower Scholars’ Love Story
Tags: Jung Geon-joo, Kang Hoon, Ryeoun, Shin Ye-eun, The Secret Romantic Guesthouse
Required fields are marked *
Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *
1 Lord Cobol (Kdramas, like water, flow downhill)
March 22, 2023 at 12:38 AM
Keep covering it.
Since the show is just a slight but slick reshuffling of things we have seen before, you can just cover it by reshuffling pieces of old recaps and weecaps while pretending to be surprised :)
Required fields are marked *
2 Decraew
March 22, 2023 at 1:06 AM
I’ll give this one a go, the first two episodes weren’t too convincing, but I like spunky FLs. Also there’s been a lack of a lighter hearted drama, I’m a bit done with revenge drama’s & the like.
Required fields are marked *
3 Kurama
March 22, 2023 at 1:28 AM
I watched episode 1 only for now.
The FL meeting the 3 men reminded me D'Artagnan meeting the 3 Musketeers, without the duel part.
I agree with the fact the characters look like cliché for now : the warrior, the seducer, the serious one. We got the usual FL very hardworking and full of joy even if her life is very difficult...
For the actor, it's weird to see Jung Geon-joo with a new Dan-Oh, his last duo with a Dan-Oh was memorable. Kang Hoon is good in this role. I don't know why but I have "issues" with Ryeoun in a sageuk.
Shin Ye-Eun is Shin Ye-Eun... I like her but I never like her dramas 😅
Required fields are marked *
4 Toodlepip
March 22, 2023 at 1:29 AM
This looks relatively light so will stick with it for the moment. Not looking for anything too taxing and the leads make a fun group. As long as the Palace politics is kept at bay.
Required fields are marked *
Reply1988 -❣️Mother Bean❣️
March 22, 2023 at 5:20 AM
You do know, in a couple of weeks you will be coming back to this comment and saying you jinxed it, don’t you?🤣
Required fields are marked *
Toodlepip
March 22, 2023 at 5:31 AM
I absolutely do. 🙄
Required fields are marked *
5 Isa is always time travelling
March 22, 2023 at 1:41 AM
Thanks for the recap!
My opinion is the same as yours. I enjoyed it, so I'll keep watching it. This is the first time a live-watch a k-drama, wow.
By the way, it is sooo obvious who is the prince and who are going to be the main couple, that I wish there was some surprise there, for a change...
How many SML are we getting here?
Required fields are marked *
Isa is always time travelling
March 22, 2023 at 1:42 AM
* This is the first time I live-watch a k-drama. (If I don't count Alchemy of Souls 2, that I watched weekly in Netflix).
Required fields are marked *
6 jerrykuvira
March 22, 2023 at 1:47 AM
I liked this episode despite my reservations. It's not bad.
My permutations: Kang San is most likely not the deposed Lee Seol. But he's a bodyguard on a mission to search for Lee Seol and protect him.
The palace politics has to be interesting. You can't just give us a crazy and delusional King and yet another crazy Queen and still make it an annoying arc.
Required fields are marked *
Isa is always time travelling
March 22, 2023 at 1:55 AM
I think I know who is the prince but only because the young actor who plays him resembles a lot to the adult one.
Maybe the writer is playing with us. That would be funnier.
Required fields are marked *
Dami
March 23, 2023 at 12:14 PM
Who do you think it is? I want her to end up with Kang San(the warrior) but i don't think he's the prince although they are giving mixed signals...i just think it's too obvious 🤔but i still want her to end up with him even if he's not
Required fields are marked *
Dami
March 23, 2023 at 12:24 PM
But then again i feel like they are trying to trick us into thinking it isn't him but it actually is him and isn't that complicated 🤷🏾♀️
Required fields are marked *
Isa is always time travelling
March 23, 2023 at 12:39 PM
Writernim is trying to trick us even with the dog's name XD
Isa is always time travelling
March 23, 2023 at 12:27 PM
After the first episode and a half of the second I also thought the runaway prince was Kang San (the resemblance with the young prince is huge). But at the end of the second episode I started to think that he could be the nice scholar.
Required fields are marked *
jerrykuvira
March 23, 2023 at 12:36 PM
The scholar is the son of a Concubine who was brought in into the suddenly. My money is on him.
But the mischievous character played by Kang Hoon also gives me vibes. There might be some story behind his frivolous exterior.
Dami
March 24, 2023 at 4:02 AM
True...but then someone got me thinking, they were like since the prince is snowflake and only one poster shows her walking in snow with one of the guys which is Kang San that the director may just be putting it in our face without being too obvious...but anyone could be honestly.
7 john
March 22, 2023 at 4:39 AM
It was an easy watch . Fluff OBY isn’t working for me, so perhaps this.
Required fields are marked *
8 Gikata
March 22, 2023 at 4:56 AM
Well, this looks like a mashup of good ol' retro (deposed prince in disguise secretly returns to capital after years of unknown whereabouts and meets his destined from childhood lady) and last decade+ "fresh" trend of making every sageuk a "funny" youth reverse harem full of cardboard cliched male "routes".
Required fields are marked *
Isa is always time travelling
March 22, 2023 at 5:46 AM
I get the classic vibes too. It might sound crazy, but it even reminded me of classic (XVII century) theatrical comedy plays from my country...
It has that kind of comedy + picaresque + naivety.
Required fields are marked *
Gikata
March 22, 2023 at 6:02 AM
That's actually a good analogy - good for a drama, I mean, because classical theater comedies are classics for a reason. Not sure it stays this way for long though.
Required fields are marked *
ladynightshade wants her own ryu sunjae
March 22, 2023 at 11:47 AM
That’s a good point! I think that can be a strength for the drama if they choose to lean into the more retro trends. Easy way to differentiate yourself from the scores of other reverse-harem fusion sageuks and give itself its own unique identity.
Required fields are marked *
Gikata
March 22, 2023 at 12:31 PM
Latest sageuks kinda made me realize I DO in fact miss the more old-fashioned ones with long expository prologues, slower pace that allowed to build all the plot arcs naturally, tighter internal structure and all that. AND more patient viewers. Pretty much everything other than crappy abrupt and often open endings))) Not that I'm against the progress or being experimental by any means, but not all of those things needed to be fixed to the point of complete eradication.
Required fields are marked *
9 hacja
March 22, 2023 at 8:35 AM
I think if I wasn't watching Blooming Youth or if I hadn't started to watch Forbidden Marriage I might be a little more inclined to continue this one. The spunky heroine, the multiple men interested in the spunky heroine, the evil official (and in this case, evil royal usurper) are just a little too familiar.
I was struck by the parallels between the bordello and the "romantic" guest house--the prostitutes 3 beautiful girls, the boarding house 3 beautiful guys. I wonder if the writer is doing that on purpose, although I doubt the guys will start selling their services to help the "madam" of the house. In my experience, its okay (and regarded as amusing) to show female prostitutes or concubines in light sagueks; its not quite as funny to show male prostitutes, because then you'd have to really start thinking about sexual exploitation, which is not what this drama wants to do.
Required fields are marked *
10 Flix_Crusin
March 22, 2023 at 11:07 AM
The FL makes this drama for me. Not too spunky or too angelic. The charisma of the actress really sells me in this one
The mystery of the identity of the son of the "wasted hand" might not be a mystery at all, revealed, trecherously, by rom com's rigid male lead hirerchy. I hope I am wrong, and if not, that my man Shi- Yeol will get the sentience to realise how ridiculous it all is.
When they talked abkut huanted building I had a Love in the Moonlight flashback, lol.
Required fields are marked *
11 ladynightshade wants her own ryu sunjae
March 22, 2023 at 11:44 AM
Honestly, this was just what I needed. Nothing new or revolutionary, but fun, breezy characters with plenty of charm and prettiness. Now they just have to keep the palace intrigue squarely in the background at all times. I’m certain that won’t happen, but I’ll complain when those episodes come out!
Required fields are marked *
12 Firewife5
March 22, 2023 at 2:09 PM
I watched the first two episodes and also got a "retro" vibe, in a good way. So far, it's not too deep, just kind of light and fun, which I expected from the trailers. I think @mistyisles was spot on, this is Kdrama comfort food - familiar and yummy, but nothing new. So do we like it because it works, or does it work because we like it? Either way, I'm going to keep watching and crossing my fingers it doesn't dissolve into an angsty, crazy royal family, mess of porridge.
Required fields are marked *
13 kdramapedia
March 22, 2023 at 7:08 PM
After the first episode I wasn't convinced, but since it's such an easy watch, I went ahead and watched the second. It did get better.
I think the Operation Baby Rescue happened too fast and didn't make sense narratively. I actually think the meat of the show is going to be palace politics, because I want to know more about the king and queen. I think their eventual demise will be fun to watch. But because it's so straightforward, everyone's actions will probably be predictable, but sometimes you need an easy watch.
Required fields are marked *
14 Lonestar Girl
March 22, 2023 at 8:00 PM
I started this without knowing anything about it and was pleasantly surprised. Sadly, all of the other current dramas just aren’t doing it for me, so think I’ll stick with it. For now. 🤞🏼 I like the FL; she’s spunky without being rude. The ML’s are handsome, kind, and team players. Not a rude, cold one in the bunch. And even the palace politics has me intrigued. I’m with everyone else about it’s retro vibes being part of its appeal. We’ll see what happens.
Required fields are marked *
15 OldLawyer
March 22, 2023 at 10:33 PM
We liked it well enough to keep watching.
Required fields are marked *
16 Zarita
March 23, 2023 at 7:02 PM
I was looking forward to this show, but after the FL fell 3 times in the first 22 minutes I figured it's just another story about a spunky, poor, clumsy girl who all the guys fall in love with.
Required fields are marked *
17 irmar
March 24, 2023 at 3:29 PM
No, not worthy of your time, I'd say. After two episodes, it's a clone of Hwarang, Joseon Marriage Agency and many others. Everything we've already seen: characters, situations, plot, including all the old and tired k-drama tropes cold but warm-hearted lead, assortment of the usual stereotyped secondary characters, birth secret, bickering enemies who turn lovers, met as children, evil Left State Minister... And the scene in episode 2 when instead of leaving they waited (not putting any details here for fear of spoiling) while all the Timed Comments shouted at them "Run, idiots!" was the last straw.
Required fields are marked *