[Drama catnip] Fighting against fate
by solstices
When tragedy has already been etched into the chronograph of history, how can anyone hope to defy the flow of time and space? How can anyone possibly parse through the chaos that is sure to follow, and rewrite the past into something better?
Yet, relentlessly, protagonists take their destiny into their own hands, making an agentic choice about the life they want to live. It creates incredibly compelling tales about tenacity, and utterly inspirational characters with boundless mettle.
One of my favorite instances of defying prophecy is Choi Yoon (Kim Jae-wook) in The Guest. Despite the ghastly voices that told him he’d lose his life trying, Yoon refused to shed his priestly robes and stop saving others. Instead, he gritted his teeth through the bone-deep anguish that tormented him, culminating in a heartbreaking act of self-sacrifice for someone he’d grown to care for. In the end, Yoon’s willingness to trade his life for his friend’s was their salvation, subverting the curse and breaking the shackles of the past.
And there’s Deok-man in Queen Seon-deok — played wonderfully by both Nam Ji-hyun and Lee Yo-won — who swallowed an entire jade piece when she realized that both the proffered choices would spell her doom. When caught between a rock and a hard place, she forged ahead and carved out a third option. Her ascension to the throne was made possible by her initiative and ingenuity, allowing her to rise above the birth divination that once constrained her.
Faced with the impossibly futile task of averting their preordained deaths, the protagonists of 365: Repeat the Year raced against both the ticking clock and a mastermind who knew when their lives would come to a premature close. It was a thrilling mystery, elevated by a solid ensemble cast and the warning cards foretelling the murders with ominous lines of poetry.
Determined to save their fellow time-travelers, our sleuthing duo Lee Jun-hyuk (as Ji Hyung-jo) and Nam Ji-hyun (as Shin Ga-hyun) pieced together disparate clues to pinpoint the ruthless killer and reverse their fates. And when they were eventually backed into a corner by the sting of betrayal, their mutual trust was the key to devising a way out of the endless loop of resets.
When it comes to a race against time, who can forget Lee Je-hoon, Jo Jin-woong, and Kim Hye-soo in Signal? Their steely determination to prevent horrific crimes committed in the past, via their tenuous link through time, had me rooting for them to succeed despite the odds. Similarly, the camaraderie of the trio in While You Were Sleeping shone through as they used their premonitory dreams to alter the present, with an extra side of sass from our leading lady.
Another spunky and proactive heroine — and one of my favorite heroines, really — is Kim Hye-yoon’s Eun Dan-oh from Extraordinary You. When Dan-oh realized she’d been created for the sole purpose of furthering others’ relationships and functioning as a plot device, she could have easily wallowed in her miserable circumstances. But instead of lamenting the cruel fate that the Writer had planned for her, she decided she’d break free of the story’s trappings and write her own future.
Dan-oh’s character trajectory was all about asserting that she was the main character of her own life, so she was going to live it the way she wanted to. And how utterly relatable is that? How many of us can say that we’ve never felt overshadowed before, or that we’ve never been demoralized after being upstaged? Dan-oh proved that you can create your own destiny and chase your own happiness regardless — you are significant simply by virtue of being alive.
Bulgasal: Immortal Souls told an epic, bloody tale of lifelong regrets and intertwined fates. It all came heartbreakingly full circle when Hwal (Lee Jin-wook) realized he was the very creator of the destiny he’d been trying to prevent. Yet he still endeavored to cling onto the last bit of his humanity, in an effort to prove that he wasn’t the monster everyone assumed he was.
It’s what I hope Ban’s journey in Island will focus on — him overcoming his demon blood and overturning the notion that all demons are destined to hurt and destroy. And I’m also hoping that Goong-tan will be able to break free from the vicious cycle of vengeance and pain. (The drama has four episodes left to pleasantly surprise me, as well as give Kim Nam-gil and Sung Joon more to work with. Fingers crossed.)
So what makes this trope my catnip? The idea of fighting against a cosmic force infinitely larger than yourself — one that makes you feel terrifyingly helpless, and is one rooted in futility and despair. And so it is the sheer courage of rising up to the challenge — of facing your fear and overcoming it one arduous step at a time — that becomes so brilliantly inspiring.
It’s railing against the walls that box you in. It’s refusing to accept your lot in life because you know you have the capacity for more. It’s looking fate in the eye and saying no, I will not be subjected to your whims. My life is mine to live and mine alone. What could possibly be more empowering than that?
RELATED POSTS
- [Drama catnip] Can you pet the puppy?
- [Drama catnip] Understated healing melos
- [Drama catnip] Charismatic female antagonists
- [Drama catnip] Complicated camaraderie
- [Drama catnip] Ramp up the camp
- [Drama catnip] Swordplay of the ancient era
- [Drama catnip] Spot the cameo!
- [Theme of the Month] Tell us about your dramaland catnip
Tags: editorial, Theme of the Month
Required fields are marked *
Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *
1 Kurama
March 1, 2023 at 10:10 AM
In Signal, it made the death of Lee Je-Hoon's big brother so sad. They tried but still couldn't prevent it. Chani was good in this role.
Dan-Oh is one of my favourite FL! I liked the last lesson about Heidegger!
Required fields are marked *
2 Soyesterday
March 1, 2023 at 11:06 AM
"Extraordinary You" is honestly one of my favourite dramas, people who dismiss it because its a "teen or youth" drama should give it a chance, it somehow manages to subvert, make fun of and fully embrace every single trope associated with teen drama's.
The heroine is smart, likeable and sympathetic too. (Kim Hye-yoon is excellent here)
Also to add, every single poor female lead in makjang dramas fights against fate, she will get slapped, get water thrown in her face, fall pregnant and run away for 5 years, go from being a cashier to a ceo in a year and finally end up with the love of her life (who survived amnesia, a stabbing and 3 car accidents)
Required fields are marked *
ar_arguably romantic
March 1, 2023 at 4:56 PM
For makjangs, I see it as the baddies desperately fighting their fate. I want to scream "You're not the main character here. You will be defeated no matter how hard you try!"
Required fields are marked *
3 Gikata
March 1, 2023 at 11:33 AM
Belief in fate is so strong in eastern - namely korean - mentality, that when the theme is fighting against it, things often get funny. As in crazily messy, not actually funny. In one hand, making a hero go against cosmic order no less gives a room for an epic story, which is always a plus. In another, winning against fate is rarely ever a real option (because obeying what's bigger than you is a virtue, Confucius totally said so), and when this happens anyway, it's mostly treated as "correcting" fate rather than "defying" it. So in the end, everything still goes according to plan and weak mortals can't really do much on their own without someone or something above approving their seemingly free will choices. Which from my western, utterly rebellious by nature perspective is just sad and bleak. So while I like and wholeheartedly support the concept of this catnip in theory, practically in kdramas I never expect much from it. Lower your expectations and save yourself from heartbreak of disappointment. And never, NEVER dig too deep, especially if the ending is not that bad. Even scratching the surface is a bad idea, honestly... The less you think about this impressive win against fate, the less questionable it looks. And we don't want to question our hard earned happy endings, right?
Required fields are marked *
4 wheguhreh
March 1, 2023 at 12:15 PM
I'm not that big on fate or fighting, and especially fighting something like fate that requires way too much suspension of disbelief, so I'll just chime in with my two sense on LYW. Not only is she great in Queen Seon-Duk, but many other dramas as well. She's especially good in strong, no-nonsense FL roles where she delivers beatdowns to idiot villains or otherwise annoying characters.
Required fields are marked *
technicat
March 1, 2023 at 2:36 PM
She was one of my early favorites, first saw her in 49 Days and Bad Love. Was happy to see her again in Ms. Temper.
Required fields are marked *
wheguhreh
March 1, 2023 at 3:03 PM
Miss Temper was probably one of my favorites, especially since the annoying character she lost her temper most often with was truly a cringe to watch. I liked 49 Days, but didn't like her depressed character. She was definitely undercasted in that role.
Required fields are marked *
PYC
March 2, 2023 at 6:33 AM
I always love her deadpan face which somehow conveys different emotions needed in the scenes. LYW is one unique actresses.
Required fields are marked *
wheguhreh
March 2, 2023 at 11:22 AM
Yes, I completely agree! She has the most expressive deadpan look I've ever seen.
Required fields are marked *
5 Babylilo
March 1, 2023 at 6:13 PM
Kairos employed a premise very similar to the one in Signal: two people communicating across time via technology (walkie talkie/cellphone) and working together to change fate. My brain was working overtime to keep up with Han Ae-ri (Lee Se-young) and Kim Seo-jin (Shin Sung-rok), each time they decided to change something in the past to influence the future…and having to deal with some unintended consequences. The plotting was ingenious and (from what I could tell) hole-free. I was grateful to the writers for showing the two of them working together as a team, without feeling the need to bring romance into the picture.
Required fields are marked *
6 jerrykuvira
March 2, 2023 at 1:52 AM
As a son born of Mishil and the dethroned King, Bidam in Queen Seondeok had a fate branded on him the moment his mom saw clearly she had no use of him, and that is the fate of a traitor and a threat. The moment he displayed just one moment of unhinged disposition, his father figure and mentor never stopped seeing him as a threat to the Kingdom based on blood of Mishil that coursed his veins. For that, a limit was placed on him by Munno. He wasn't allowed to dream, he wasn't permitted to achieve his full potential, his master didn't even want to teach him his one last fighting technique - all because of that one moment. And all that morphed into insecurities for him.
Yet, Man persevered, learned by watching, showed his master he was nothing like his mother, became the Queen's right hand man, even became the Queen's husband.
His fate caught up with him at the end thanks to those who never stopped seeing him as a threat. He fought his fate, won, but remained misunderstood. A tragic one.
Required fields are marked *