34

[Drama catnip] Swordplay of the ancient era

By @jerrykuvira

Sword fights have always been a point of interest to me, and have always been a factor I considered before watching a K-drama. But if you throw in a swordswoman character, it’s definitely a must-watch for me. It’s only been six years since I began watching modern K-dramas without prejudice, but sageuks have always been — and will always be — my thing.

However, in all honesty, recent sageuks are lacking in the fighting department. The choreography might have improved, but there is far less time spent with these kinds of scenes. I miss the good old days of Age of Warriors, Yeon Gaesumun, Gwanggaeto the Great Conqueror, Jumong, Queen Seondeok, Iron Empress, et al. I hoped Alchemy of Souls would deliver on this end, but somehow I stopped wishing and began savoring the breadcrumbs. The scene where Jin Cho-yeon is fighting a lost battle to save her father’s life — in full wedding garb — is one of the crumbs I rewind to savor to my satisfaction.

Swordplay is all about heightened adrenaline, and I find it more interesting to watch a character fight for survival using swords and knives than other weapons and modes of fighting. Many a time, the action in a present-day story that leads to the end of a fight scene isn’t action enough, but in sagueks, we get to see blade-clashes and blade-clangs. And, when it’s a series with great direction and choreography, we get to enjoy the beauty and elegance of swordplay. Seeing characters fight to preserve their lives with such grace and class seals the deal for me each time.

Jumong (the hero from Jumong) was the character that set the bar for swordsmen in my K-drama journey — and yes, many have come and gone. But since then, two have made solid impressions as good fighters, even besting Jumong: Munno from Queen Seondeok and Sagal Hyeon from Gwanggaeto the Great Conqueror. In Queen Seondeok, we got to enjoy Munno singlehandedly defending and rescuing a baby, as well as beating a troop of soldiers without his sword in hand. Sagal Hyeon also made an impact — especially with his introduction to the series where he went from helping the king fight off a bunch of soldiers, to having a one-on-one as soon as the soldiers were cleared. Munno and Sagal Hyeon were both both fierce defenders up until their dying breaths.

But there are also favorite swordswomen characters, and number one is our lady in white, Cheok Sa Kwang, effortlessly played by Han Ye-ri in Six Flying Dragons. She maintains the top spot. Anytime she wields the sword using the deadly Goksan Technique, we all know who’s going down and it’s definitely not her. The aura she carried as a wielder of the sword has etched her name in my K-drama history as a badass swordswoman.

My final favorite swordswoman is Du-yan in Iron Empress. She had great stealth, and her reputation preceded her — only a few men could defeat her in her home country. She was a master of the art of the blade, and stood her ground against the elite Goryeo warriors.

In addition to being skilled and heroic, something unique to all four of these sword-wielders is that they weren’t rough fighters. Gentleness and grace emanated from them when in they were in action. They all lived by the sword. All but one of them died by the sword. Yet, one thing is sure – in life or in death, these four followers of the way of the blade could defend their titles and win.

 
RELATED POSTS

Tags:

34

Required fields are marked *

I also prefer elegant swordfights over more brute force fight scenes. One of my favorites is from Empress Ki, where she tries to save her newborn baby with nothing but a stick, on a cliff, against like ten armed soldiers, right after giving birth. But I think I loved the sentiments and emotions in that scene more than the actual action.

4
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Personaly, I'm not a big fan of sword battle with a lot of "parasite" moves that look cool but not really useful.

I liked Han Heri 's fights in Six Flying Dragons. She used very well her background in Korean dance in the fights.

I think I'm more focused on the energy than the technics. Some actors doesn't show any energy neither strength even the fight looks good like IU in Hotel del Luna.

I liked the fights in My Country, they weren't elegant and classy but pretty messy. But WDH and YSJ were very convincing.

Now, I think they don't really have time anymore to focus on that. The dramas are shorter, they always run after the time and it's complicated to learn the choreo. In AoS, they took the time for the first part and then used Uk's powers to finish the battle in one move of the arm...

7
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

Absolutely agree with Han Heri's flight scenes in Six Flying Dragons. Her fighting scene reminds me of a traditional dance. There are some very memorable swords fight scenes in SFD including Han Heri's. I was also very impressed with the fighting scene's OST by Lee bong Geun( Ddangsae's avenge). The song give me shivers.

4
reply

Required fields are marked *

I was rewatching River Where The Moon Rises and was just thinking how good the sword fights were even with the time and budget constraints of re-filming the whole drama. My favourite was the fight scene between Kim So Hyun and Gochuga. It’s rare to see female leads get intense sword fight scenes. The only other actress I’ve seen do proper sword fights is Ha Ji Won. Another idea for drama catnip is hanboks especially from the 3 kingdom era.

1
4
reply

Required fields are marked *

Ha Ji Won in Damo! She also had a cool sword dance in Hwang Jin Yi.

2
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

Female leads who engage in sword fights are rare and need more appreciation.

3
reply

Required fields are marked *

Sword fights, manes of glory, and twirling hanboks (both 3 Kingdoms and Joseon) are my kind of catnip too! Just add some tragic event in the past and some epic music, and I am all in!

2
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

Hanboks of the three kingdoms were especially glorious and beautifully accessorized.

3
reply

Required fields are marked *

The tragic swordsman is one of my favorite tropes, so naturally the sageuks is my favorite genre. My favorite sword fights are in Six Flying Dragons and Chuno (The Slave Hunters). The combination of choreography, directing/editing, and cool music make the fighting scenes in these dramas truly memorable.

7
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Finally a catnip I can get behind! Tho in my case it's more like any type of martial arts action rather than swordplay alone. I'm a kid from martial artist's family myself and those things were always a huge part of my life, MA movies included. So when I first discovered kdramas and their beautiful action scenes in sageuks... you can guess. Initial excitement soon cooled down once I discovered that not all k-actors starring in those dramas can actually do their impressive stunts for real unlike in the movies I saw as a child (and trust me, it's even more jarring when you personally know tons of people who do kung fu as a morning workout routine) . Since then it became a quest - watching closely to pick up rare true martial artists in the sea of "I slay enemies with my handsome face and editor will do the rest". Thankfully, my hard work wasn't in vain and I found some people I follow religiously when it comes to their action projects, historical and modern. Adding one more name to that still way-too-short list is always a huge celebration. Sadly, it's been a while since I've had any new discoveries from kdramaworld... China is doing better at it currently, despite them abandoning the traditional approach of casting MA-skilled actors for action shows ages ago. Some of their kids (and plenty of veterans) still got moves, thank heavens!

Surprised that no one mentioned Chuno yet - now that's the high class action sageuk, jaw-dropping swordplay included. They just don't make them like that anymore, which is a tragedy for the genre... Also the movie Duelist (2005) was really pretty in that aspect.

6
5
reply

Required fields are marked *

I mentioned Chuno! It is my favorite drama. I don't know anything about martial arts, but the fight scenes are breathtaking! And all of them are part of the story and move the plot forward.

3
3
reply

Required fields are marked *

Yes, I'm familiar with your love for that show)))

Fights in Chuno were so impressive because of 3 things: great choreography, even greater directing/camera work (just looked it up and wow, PD is still working... but not on action dramas - what a waste of talent!) and AMAZING performances from actors who knew the damn well what they were doing (they did real MA techniques, just exaggerated/polished to look cooler rather than cause bigger harm). Jang Hyuk in particular is one of the best, if not the best martial artist among current k-actors. His smooth, seemingly effortless moves (that remind you of a lazy yet deadly elegance of felines) even when he aren't actually fighting are very telling - it takes DECADES of very hard work to get to this level. And then even more work to keep such form despite aging and accumulating injuries. He was at his physical peak there (right age, right role, right state of mind too probably), so even more of a visual feast to us. But nearly everyone else there was fantastic stunts-wise. Insanely strong team overall, such a pity they only did 1 drama together.

6
2
reply

Required fields are marked *

The same PD also did "Conspiracy in the Court," another awesome sageuk, but the martial arts there were not as prominent as in Chuno. I agree that Jang Hyuk's performance in Chuno is legendary. As a musician, I know what it takes to achieve effortlessness and fluency, so I am very impressed with martial arts sequences done well.

2
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

I've heard about that one, but story seemed a little too grim for my taste.

0

Now you're talking! I love them too and admire their work and dedication to making the swordfighting/action scenes. Marital arts has been with me since 1998 and I love them with all my heart!

3
reply

Required fields are marked *

Great rundown! I don't know much about more classic sageuks, but you've got me interested. I usually go to movies to get my fix of beautiful, elegant swordfights, but I might have to try one of these!

3
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Speaking of Queen Seondeok, Bidam has some cool sword fighting scenes. My favorite one is "ten paces to Deokman."

3
3
reply

Required fields are marked *

"Ten paces to Deokman" is an unforgettable sequence. As much as Bidam himself is an unforgettable character.

3
2
reply

Required fields are marked *

Oh yeah...

2
reply

Required fields are marked *

Found the scene on YouTube and watched it a couple of times today...

1
reply

Required fields are marked *

Some nitpicking thoughts : why swordswomen are such a rarity in sageuk and any historical fiction Kdramas, or even historical fantasy sageuk? It is always the male lead who did all the swordfight and the fighting.

If you saw Xianxia dramas it's the other way around; and even more so in Wuxia dramas : it's almost like a tradition to have one female swordswoman!

3
2
reply

Required fields are marked *

If you want a total packed cast of female sword wielders, you have to watch Iron Empress. They had close to 8 of them. And they were prominent secondary characters.

2
reply

Required fields are marked *

Which is why more appreciation is needed for actresses like Ha Ji Won and Kim So Hyun who delivered brilliant sword fight scenes. Empress Ki and River Where The Moon Rises do not get enough appreciation for breaking genre stereotypes.

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Comment was deleted

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Love swords. Love fighting. Unfortunately, rarely love the sword fighting in Kdramas these days, because it's not realistic; they don't often get the balance between flare and accuracy in that sweet spot for me. Haven't seen most of these older sageuks yet though 😂

4
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

My favorite kdrama swordsman will always be Gil Tae Mi (Park Hyuk-kwon) of Six Flying Dragons, eye shadow and all! He made everyone else forgettable for me 😉

2
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

People keep pushing swordfights and bow-and-arrow work as somehow 'romantic' but to me its sheer butchery. Your trying to do to other people what hog farmers do to pigs, but less humanely.

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Jang Hyuk actually made a movie titled The Swordsman. He plays a legendary swordsman who suddenly disappeared and hasn’t been seen for years. It turns out that his eyesight was beginning to fail. But when his daughter is kidnapped by a member of the Qing imperial family, he comes out of retirement to save her. Having to compensate for his impaired vision adds another dimension to Jang Hyuk’s swordplay, which is—as always— simply breathtaking. Unfortunately, other than the sword fighting, the rest of the film is a dud.

1
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

I vividly yet faintly recall the Swordsman. I don't recall much about it anymore but I remember the blind swordsman and his daughter.
So that man was Jang Hyuk. I watched The Swordsman at a time when I hadn't put a face to the name Jang Hyuk, which I'd already heard a thousand times over.

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Oooh great write-up. It is a shame that recent sageuks do not have epic swordfights like they used to.

I do love the adrenaline rush and anticipation when I'm watching a sword fight play out. The clashing of swords until one is defeated.

Still have not watched Six Flying Dragons. >.<;;; Haven't seen enough swordswomen!

1
2
reply

Required fields are marked *

Try Iron Empress, you'll find enough swordswomen there. Mind you, they are very skilled in the art.
Also try Gwangaetto. They have close to 3 prominent fighters and like 4 completely side characters as swordswomen. The 3 prominent ones are introduced at the beginning, 1/10 of the drama and halfway through the drama respectively.

1
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

Thanks for the recs! =)

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

I also love great fight choreography, especially when swords are involved. For me, Six Flying Dragons reigns supreme in this department. The fights were aesthetically stunning, but they also felt genuinely dangerous, a combination that shows rarely pull off. Also, they never felt gratuitous. Every sequence revealed character and furthered the story and no moves felt wasted. Maybe one day we'll get similar dramas again from k-drama land?

1
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Swordswomen , Han Hye-jin as Soseono in Jumong .

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *