138

The King Loves: Episodes 31-32

Won becomes more vulnerable than ever as he tries to defend himself from multiple threats and preserve the friendships that mean so much to him at the same time. Rin ends up in a unique position to better understand what is behind all of the chaos that threatens Won’s future, and he makes a bold decision meant to help not only his friend, but the people of Goryeo.

 
EPISODE 31 RECAP

Won hands Jang Eui the letter for San and orders him to deliver it and bring her back safely. Meanwhile, Princess Wonsung instructs Furatai to kill Rin and San if they refuse to be taken into custody.

As he follows the funeral procession, Furatai realizes that he won’t be able to arrest the pair until they near the outskirts of the city, while from his hidden location, King Chungryeol orders Song In to bring Rin there to ensure his safety.

That order is passed down to Moo-suk, but he’s forced back by the crowd of mourners as the funeral procession makes its way through the city.

With Rin and San in sight, both parties move at the same time — but the cart puller, Gae-won, blocks Moo-suk with a broom while Furatai gets stopped by a swinging basket, courtesy of the Geumgajeong cook. Furatai rips off Bi-yeon’s veil to confirm that San has disappeared, and Moo-suk retreats before he’s recognized.

Jang Eui tries to find the funeral procession, but a small carriage catches his attention on its way out of the city. Just then, Gae-won runs by as he escapes Furatai and is forced to hide after Jang Eui delays him with questions. When Jang Eui promises Furatai that he’ll report his actions to Won, he runs off, and Jang Eui detains Gae-won.

Won enters Geumgajeong to find the cart pullers and Goo-hyung waiting. Distressed that Rin and San disappeared during the funeral, Won asks Gae-won and Yeom Bok for details, since he heard that they were involved.

The cook explains, “[Rin] said there would not be a chance once they got to the cemetery,” and Gae-won adds that Rin asked, “If you see anyone with a sword near the procession, stop them.” The cook stopped Princess Wonsung’s soldiers while Gae-won blocked the assassin who had him steal the arrows.

Goo-hyung shares that San knew of the plan and met with the household servants before the funeral. She had explained about the plot to discredit her father to seize his properties and warned the servants that they would be forced to give false testimonies. They had been given money, and San sent them to homes throughout Goryeo as she instructed, “After they carry my father out, you should leave as well.”

When Goo-hyung mentions that San is with Rin, Yeom Bok asks Gae-won if they will get married after the funeral. Gae-won tries to silence him, but Goo-hyung explains that Minister Eun met with Wang Young to discuss his final wish: a marriage between Rin and San.

Won can’t believe his ears and drops heavily into a chair. When he asks his guards about Jang Eui, Gae-won volunteers that the bodyguard followed the carriage with Rin and San to deliver something.

Won laughs that Rin is making him crazy, “He does not know how to scheme. I am the schemer. He should have come to me. I would have helped him. I would have played dirty or been evil to help him.” Won then informs Yeom Bok, “The wedding you hope for will not happen. My foolishly loyal friend, Rin, is protecting my woman.”

Moo-suk finds Bi-yeon in the marketplace before she leaves town with Goo-hyung. Moo-suk wants to know if San will join them, but Bi-yeon confides that she’s traveling east. Before he leaves, Moo-suk tears the veil from Bi-yeon’s face and tells her that if he doesn’t care about her face, then it shouldn’t matter what others think.

San leads the way through a wooded area while Rin keeps a close eye on her. When she loses her footing, he’s there to offer a steadying hand. As the sun lowers, San points to an area where they can rest for the night, and Rin realizes that she’s familiar with their surroundings.

San admits that she traveled this way with her father, and when she falls silent, Rin encourages her: “Go on talking about him. I will listen.” San eventually shares that her father traveled often and that she accompanied him on a few trips. Rin smiles when San confides that she posed as a servant and called her father “Master” in public, but in private, he ignored her until she whispered, “Father.”

Meanwhile, Eunuch Kim is relieved when Won finally returns to the palace and explains that his mother is waiting. When Won turns away, Eunuch Kim reminds him that his bride will be the one to pay if he avoids Princess Wonsung.

Princess Wonsung greets Won with the order, “Cancel your wedding plans.” Won wearily implores, “Stop scheming, and stop harming innocent people.” Before Princess Wonsung can claim, yet again, that her efforts were meant to keep Won alive, he challenges her, “No. It was to keep you alive. You were so bored each and every day that you used me as a toy. To give you a reason to live.”

Won instructs his mother to leave Dan alone or he will make her pay before storming out. A tear trickles down Princess Wonsung’s face, and then she experiences another violent coughing fit.

Boo-yong updates the king on the growing rift between Won and his mother. When she urges him to return to the palace to attend Won’s wedding, King Chungryeol foggily asks, “Is the crown prince still alive?” King Chungryeol remembers what a happy child Won once was and tries to figure out what went wrong between him and his son. He thinks that perhaps Won’s mother made Won hate him but then asks, “Or is that what you whispered? Right into my ear. ‘Your Majesty, your son dislikes you. He hates you. He wants to kill you.'”

Boo-yong hesitates briefly, then asks the king how he could say such a terrible thing. As Boo-yong pours tea, King Chungryeol remembers that San had challenged him to his face for not believing in his own son. When the king mumbles, “The crown prince. Is he still alive,” Boo-yong just lays him down with a satisfied smile.

Once he has a fire burning, Rin produces a small bottle of wine that he brought to help San sleep. When San shares that her father wasn’t very good at drinking, Rin suggests that they offer him just one cup. San approaches a large boulder to apologize to her father for leaving his funeral as she pours out a cup of wine. Rin pours another cup for San to drink, happy to see how much she enjoys it.

San addresses her father again, “Once we get to the ocean, I will get on the ship you prepared and go to the place you prepared. Do not worry. Rin is escorting me until I get there.”

Rin corrects San and explains that not only will he accompany her on the ship, “I will go wherever you go. And I will stay wherever you stay. I will stay with you for a long time.” When San looks at him blankly, Rin shares, “That is what your father wanted. Did you not hear?” San says nothing, and Rin asks if it’s because she has thoughts of Won.

Dan meets with Won, who immediately guesses that she’s been crying. When she insists that no one made her cry, Won decides that Dan must be scared to spend the night in the palace, but Dan explains that she won’t be getting any sleep because of the wedding preparations.

Won apologizes for the the absence of honored guests and an elaborate party due to the rushed wedding. Dan reminds him that the purpose of the wedding was to remove her name from the tribute list and becomes serious when she asks, “Your priority is still not me… and I will never be your priority, right?”

Won ignores her question and summons Jin Gwan to tell him, “You do not have to follow me around anymore. Protect the crown princess from now on.” With that done, Won walks away and leaves his sad bride behind.

Moo-suk’s party thrashes through the woods while Rin throws a robe over San. Rin notices her staring at him as he tends their fire and when she closes her eyes, it’s Rin’s turn to look at her. Eventually, they share a long gaze, broken only when a self-conscious San throws the robe over her head.

In the morning, San finds herself alone, along with a dying fire. She discovers Rin knee-deep in the river trying to catch a fish with his dagger. To his dismay, San drops a large rock into the water as she teases, “Goodness, I do not see anything. Where are all the fish?” San makes fun of Rin’s failure to catch anything, and when she sabotages his efforts with another rock, they playfully splash around in the water.

Rin is the first to see Moo-suk’s party when they appear on the riverbank, and though he and San run away, they’re surrounded by the time they reach a nearby pavilion. Rin reminds Moo-suk that he told him to wait, but the assassin confesses that he didn’t believe that Rin would return.

Moo-suk has orders to escort Rin, and if he refuses to cooperate, “Then I will get rid of the person who is distracting you.” On cue, Moo-suk’s men unsheathe their swords and point them at San. Rin tells her to continue her journey on her own and ignores her offer to fight alongside him as he vows, “Whatever it takes and wherever you are, I will follow you.”

Rin lowers his dagger and agrees to go with Moo-suk, who falls to one knee. The other men immediately follow suit as Rin adds, “I will only leave after I see her leave safely.” After a nod from Rin, San runs off as Jang Eui observes them from a distance.

San returns to the campsite and confronts the person who followed her. When she sees that it’s Jang Eui, she pulls him toward Rin and explains that Moo-suk took him. Jang Eui argues that it didn’t appear that Rin was taken away and then presents Won’s letter. He explains that he must return with San’s answer as she holds her mother’s ring in her hand.

Teacher Lee is escorted by Generals Ko Sung and Lim Chi-young to see Won, who assumes that he’s there for the wedding. He’s actually there to discuss Won’s unnecessary decision to forgive the charge of embezzlement against his friend, because Minister Eun and Wang Young were innocent all along.

General Ko Sung explains that even though the grain had supposedly been in storage for months, the ink from the stamps was fresh. Teacher Lee adds that not only did Minister Eun die in the palace, but so did the court lady who was sent to remove the incense that killed him.

One of the palace doctors testifies that he was told that the court lady hung herself, but an examination of her body revealed that she was poisoned first. Teacher Lee reminds Won that the day after the deaths, an anonymous letter was sent to accuse Minister Eun and Wang Young of stealing the grain.

Teacher Lee concludes that the plot originated within Princess Wonsung’s palace and wants to know Won’s thoughts. Won chooses to ignore Teacher Lee’s grievances and has him sent to a place called Naksujae with orders that no one is to be allowed near him.

 
EPISODE 32 RECAP

The soldiers of the king’s secret palace bow before Rin as Moo-suk leads him to Song In. Boo-yong serves a tea designed to block poison and Rin is understandably reluctant to drink it until Song In explains, “I can only have my tea once you have yours. You are not just Master Rin anymore.”

Rin drinks the tea and reminds Song In that he’s there to see the king. Boo-yong excuses herself to check on him while Song In explains that the king’s health is failing. (I’ll bet it is.) Song In lies that King Chungryeol made up the excuse of a hunting trip to hide his illness so that Won wouldn’t ask him to give up the kingship permanently.

Rin wants to know why Jeon is no longer the choice for crown prince, and Song In explains that because of his drinking and womanizing, “We had a lot of complaints.” When Rin questions his use of the word we, Song In divulges, “The powers behind the curtain who actually run this country. Some of the families go back to the establishment of Goryeo, and there is a general who survived the great war.”

Rin asks Song In if they plan to replace Won with a crown prince of their choice while hiding the sick king. Song In admits to something like that just as Boo-yong reappears to say that she couldn’t wake the king, but Rin refuses to be stalled and goes to see him anyway.

Rin kneels before the king’s room and announces his presence, but when there’s no reply, he parts a door and becomes alarmed at what he sees. He rushes to King Chungryeol’s side and offers to summon his physician, but the king grabs Rin to ask, “The crown prince, is he still alive?” Rin can only stare at King Chungryeol with concern.

A frustrated General Lim Chi-young confesses to General Ko Sung that he wants to confront Won. General Ko Sung urges him to wait until after his wedding the next day and suggests that they go for a drink.

Minister Song runs up with gifts that he claims are from Won, boxes full of silver bullion, with the explanation, “The crown prince said you have been through a lot and that you should cover it up. He shall take care of the rest.” General Lim Chi-young angrily demands to know if Won means their investigation and is asked, “What were you investigating that he would pay so much to make you cover it up?”

Song In next meets with the ministers who regularly work in Won’s office and lies that Generals Ko Sung and Lim Chi-young confirmed that Minister Eun ended up dead because Won wanted his money, as well as his daughter. Minister Song has the ministers hanging on his every word when he claims that San refused Won, who then retaliated by framing her in order to ruin her family.

Won tries to work in his office but notices that the ministers keep staring at him. King Chungryeol’s voice is heard saying, “First, the mother, and now, her son is killing my people.” We then see Rin support the frail king during a stroll in the courtyard with Song In and Boo-yong close behind.

King Chungryeol acknowledges that Minister Eun quietly sent grain and money whenever he heard that the royal finances were in trouble and never asked for anything in return. The king sways when he thinks of what happened to Minister Eun, and Rin looks around for a place to sit.

King Chungryeol studies Rin and admits that he reminds him of his first wife (Rin’s aunt). He observes, “You look most like her… her grace and loyalty. You have them as well.” Rin asks about her, but the king admits that he couldn’t bear to see her again.

King Chungryeol grabs Rin and pulls him closer to warn, “The crown prince is like his mother. They were born with thorns all over their bodies. Stay close, and they will prick and poison you. Then they will hold you even closer. ‘You are mine. You must stay with me. Do not look elsewhere.’ Your blood is spilling everywhere, but they will not let go.”

Boo-yong escorts the king away so that Song In can ask Rin to accompany the king to Won’s wedding. Song In promises that Rin’s appearance will please many officials, and when he adds that the generals are turning against Won, Rin walks off without a word. When Song In follows after him, we see that one of Won’s guards listened to their exchange.

Won reads a scroll to his mother, “Appoint Eun Young-baek’s daughter, San, to take over the financial duties her father once held.” Won explains that because the order falls under her jurisdiction, it requires her approval. He sets the order before his mother and orders Court Lady Jo to bring her seal.

Princess Wonsung warns that the ministers believe Won defended a criminal. He admits that they really think that he’s committed murder, for either money or love.

Princess Wonsung warns Won that San’s presence in the palace will confirm the rumors and cause him serious damage, but Won tells his mother that she should have thought of that sooner.

When Princess Wonsung calmly asks Won to give San up, Won accuses her of framing Rin, but she argues that Rin isn’t his friend. Won evenly explains, “San will stay close to me here. I will keep her close and protect her. If you do not want that, you can leave.” With no choice, Princess Wonsung affixes her seal to Won’s order.

Outside, Won asks Eunuch Kim about Jang Eui, who has yet to return. His other guard returns just then with news about Rin.

Rin sits alone with King Chungryeol as he sleeps, and when Boo-yong offers him a room of his own, he dismisses her. For the first time in a long time, there is no incense burning in the king’s room.

Rin keeps vigil over the king as Won’s guard reports that his father isn’t hunting and that Rin and Song In are with him, as well as Prince Gangyang. When Won learns that San isn’t there, he’s certain that the guard’s report is wrong.

An excited Court Lady Jo announces to Princess Wonsung that King Chungryeol has returned to the palace in time for the wedding. When asked, Court Lady Jo admits that Boo-yong is with the king and informs her that Rin is with him as well.

The king makes his return to the palace with the aid of Boo-yong and Rin. Minister Song runs up and takes Rin’s place to help the feeble king back to his rooms.

As Won is dressed for his wedding, Eunuch Kim reports that Rin arrived with the king. Won starts to leave, but Eunuch Kim explains that Rin is no longer with the king and is probably with his sister.

Rin walks through the palace grounds as Jang Eui escorts San to see Won. Before they can reach him, they are blocked by Furatai and Princess Wonsung’s men.

Rin is surprised when Generals Ko Sung and Lim Chi-young find him to ask if Won had Minister Eun killed. General Ko Sung explains the rumor while General Lim Chi-young worries that the man that they swore to serve killed someone for love.

When Furatai escorts San and Jang Eui to a courtyard and announces their presence, a set of doors opens on Dan in her wedding gown. San assumes that she’s there against her will, but Dan explains she was asked to speak to San on Princess Wonsung’s behalf.

Dan admits that she didn’t believe that San would come to the palace and asks, “Why are you here?” When San doesn’t understand the question, Dan waits until Jin Gwan steps away to explain, “The crown prince and I will be married today.”

San confesses that she was away and didn’t hear the news. When she admits that she’s there to see Won, Dan asks San to leave without meeting him. San explains that she has to keep a promise, but Dan warns that San’s presence will put Won in danger and begs, “I want you to stay far away from the crown prince. I do not want him to see you.”

Rin passes Furatai and his men as they leave the courtyard and runs in that direction to find Dan. When his sister covers her face at the sight of him, Rin thinks that Dan is happy that he made it to her wedding, but Dan tearfully confesses that she sent San away.

Jang Eui meets with Won just as San approaches a small bridge on the palace grounds. Rin finds her and is about to approach when he notices Won in the distance, dressed for his wedding, as he meets with Jang Eui.

Rin seems to make a decision and calls out to San as he recalls his question for her the day before, “Is it the crown prince?” San had admitted that she felt as if they were connected by a thread and that Won was always in her way.

San had worried about what would happen to Won if they both left him and lamented, “I should not have tied this thread with him to begin with.”

A frantic Won starts to run off, but stops when he notices Rin and San on the bridge. Rin steps closer as he confirms that San feels connected to Won and concludes, “It must be the red thread of fate. I will cut off that thread for you right now.”

Rin surprises San when he places his arm around her waist and pulls her close. Rin proceeds to kiss her, and San pushes him away as Won witnesses the scene from a distance.

Eventually, San closes her eyes and drops her arms as Rin continues to kiss her. Won, meanwhile, struggles with the reality that his best friend just shattered his world.

 
COMMENTS

This episode gave us a lot of Rin as he found himself thrust to the front of the plot to depose Won. That cliffhanger kiss was not at all what I expected, since Rin’s motivation has more to do with the knowledge of an impending coup than with his love for San. As the one chosen to replace Won as crown prince, Rin has seen firsthand the grave danger that threatens not only Won, but the king and the entire country of Goryeo.

By shifting attention to Rin, the plot to depose Won picked up steam because he doesn’t present the problems that Jeon did. Plus, Rin has excellent character and is well respected. He’s also loyal to Won, but his feelings for San and the knowledge that the king is being held hostage put a strain on Rin that can’t be minimized. Even if Rin remains rock solid, the rumors that have been created to undermine Won are only growing stronger, and he’s edging ever closer to that cliff that Princess Wonsung alluded to.

Since Won’s priority is having San by his side, he brushes aside the threats to his position as crown prince, but Rin can see that Won isn’t the only one who will be harmed if he’s eventually deposed. Once Song In mentioned that King Chungryeol’s health is failing, Rin understood that it’s a setup for his eventual demise (and we know that Boo-yong is capable of making that happen). His meeting with Prince Gangyang served as a peek into what could be waiting for Won once he’s deposed, since it would be foolhardy to kill him and risk an attack from Yuan. Even though the story is that Princess Wonsung was responsible for Prince Gangyang’s poisoning, Rin is shrewd enough to know that it’s possible to divert blame to an innocent party since his family was just falsely accused in that embezzlement scheme. Who can say that Song In wasn’t behind that plot to build support for his plan to control the throne?

Rin is more influenced by what is best for others, and I don’t think that has changed. He realizes that San has become a dangerous liability for Won, who has the potential to be a good king. If Song In’s allies successfully depose Won, Rin would be made crown prince, something that he’s never wanted, and he and the king would be managed by the very people who set up Won. That would hurt the people of Goryeo because Song In’s faction is dangerous and corrupt, and they would only grow in power. Won is trying to eliminate corruption, but the rumors and suspicions are crushing him, and he will never sever ties with San in order to continue what he has started.

Rin knows Won better than anyone, and he recognizes that San is his fatal flaw. By kissing her, Rin is setting into motion a plan that he hopes will prevent Won from keeping San next to him. I don’t think that his reasons are selfish ones, rather, I think that they are desperate and dangerous ones because he risks making an enemy of Won. It’s a sacrifice that Rin is willing to make for the greater good, but for his gamble to have a prayer, he’s going to need some help, and I can only guess where that could come from. I’m hoping that the king has figured out his dangerous situation and will soon have a clearer head. Hopefully, Rin will be able to reason with the generals — and, of course, there’s still Teacher Lee. Once he figures out that Princess Wonsung isn’t guilty of Minister Eun’s murder, he can help to squash the false rumors. Finally, San is sure to do whatever she can to help Won become a good king, and she has the wealth needed to make a difference.

There’s so much to resolve in the episodes that are left, especially since we still don’t definitively know how San feels about the two men after her heart. With political intrigue and Won’s reaction to his friend’s move on his woman, the pending wedding promises to be memorable for all the wrong reasons.

RELATED POSTS

Tags: , , , , ,

138

Required fields are marked *

For this episode I'm especially thankful for your review and comments. It put a whole different perspective on many of the things that happened. One subtitle I read said it was the red thread of a relationship which was confusing, and you called it a thread of fate, which puts an entirely different meaning. One thought about Rin spending the night with the King and him not being under the influence of whatever drug she was giving him. Before that scene, the King had a lucid moment where he realized she might be whispering things in his ear to make him hate his son. So I'm wondering if a scene we haven't seen yet will be the king becoming lucid when Rin is there and telling him what's going on. The writer does this a lot, where things are more fully explained in a flashback. And things are never as they seem from one episode to the next, so many assumptions we make from one episode and especially the previews, can be very misleading.
Thank you for the details on Rin's motivations and the complicated conspiracies that they're dealing with. I hadn't thought of all these ramifications. I want to re read your review and comments first, but now I have to go to work...

14
7
reply

Required fields are marked *

First, allow me to be shallow and say that Rin looks dashing in his blue outfit! :)
I also appreciated that he addressed the big elephant in the room: San's (complicated yet very human) feelings towards Won. I consider that she likes him (how not to considering the things he's done for her?) and therefore does not want to hurt his feelings, yet cannot return them.
I am a little conflicted about the kiss though: I understand why Rin would do it (protecting San, also asserting his feelings to both San and Won who are both trying to avoid them), but it is a little disappointing that this first kiss is made to prove a point rather than share his love.
I am also a little disappointed that it had to be a forced kiss (although Rin was fairly gentle): I know I cannot expect all drama first kisses to be as consensual as Strong Woman Do Bong Soon or as passionnate as Chicago Writer, but could you please drama writers stop forcing kisses? Interestingly, the 2-episodes version insisted more on San's resistance than the 1-episode version (is the latter more exportation oriented?).
But overall I am very satisfied with this episode (and this love story really) and I cannot wait for the next episodes!
(should we begin a drinking game about every time Rin tries but cannot leave the city ? to become a tribute, a circuit commissionner or to travel the world?)

12
15
reply

Required fields are marked *

Wow. I really thought it was clear that San loves Rin, but these last 2 episodes are messing with me... I don't like Won's obsession with San. I'm hoping that Rin and San will be clear endgame.
The red string of fate...eff you lol

7
5
reply

Required fields are marked *

I wonder when and if Biyeon will ever find out that Moo suk was responsible for slashing her face when she was a child? What would her reaction be then? Would she feel betrayed and used, or sorry that she confided a lot of her beloved mistress's business to the enemy?

Will Won ever find out that his Queen mother was framed for the murder of Minister Eun? How bad will he feel accusing her of a crime she didn't commit?

I suspect that there are some scenes they haven't shown us which would probably be shown as flashbacks. This drama has an uncanny reliance on flashbacks.

I like Rin and San together, I just don't appreciate him kissing her to prove a point to the Crown Prince. Not cool, Rin. It'd have been better for him to declare himself openly to Won, all this underhand business reeks of deception.

And...I officially don't like Dan. I think she's very manipulative, will be more so as the years go by, and will probably be easily manipulated in turn. I don't buy the innocent girl act she tries to project.

Why burst into tears in front of her brother after telling San off and preventing her from seeing Won? If she's going to be mean, she should own it like the Queen who makes no apologies for being mean and is spectacular.

4 more episodes to go. How will they untangle all this? Things are quite a mess right now.

9
3
reply

Required fields are marked *

Thanks for the recap! I still am enjoying the show but this episode was frustrating. I get the feeling Rin has some grand plan, but it has to be guessed at. Flashbacks to tell a story are fine, but it feels more like important scenes are being left out too much to have a "gotcha" later. It works in some shows but here it just feels clunky. It seems like they are trying to make Rin turning bad a believable possibility, but it would go against everything we've seen about him for the whole series. And I feel like Won's suddenly ignoring the generals and Teacher Lee, and becoming cruel to his mother (who is definitely crazy and sometimes cruel) is a bit out of character as well. Its like they want him to go dark but didn't have the guts to. Even if he doesn't betray his friends in the end, I don't buy him becoming a good king and that makes me sad.
On Rin/San - she hasn't shown Won any interest up til now, and now we are supposed to believe she might love him and not Rin? I hope that it's more that she feels a strong friendship bond that she can't break, especially since she understands his feelings towards her and his loneliness.

Overall, I wish we had some internal monologues (i miss Won's!), or have the characters confide in each other. At this point a lot of the plot and motivations feel incomplete. This episode was the first one where I felt like that, so hopefully it's the only one and things get better!

And superficially - I think Hong Jong Hyun is getting hotter every episode :)

6
11
reply

Required fields are marked *

Hmm wondering how Won thinks he can keep San by his side when he is getting married to someone else. Must be due to the warped and twisted mentality back then where polygamy is considered normal. If he is serious about marrying Dan then he needs to let San go since no way she would be happy in that sick little threesome.

7
9
reply

Required fields are marked *

Why show, first you made our hearts joy for the girl and the guy, watched them escaping together possibly not coming back. Then you sank us when the guy confessed he’d be wherever the girl would be just to show that she was thinking about the guy’s best friend. Later you brought us back to cloud nine when the girl and the guy held their eyes at each other and smiled. We then took pleasure in their happy moments of playing around. But of course, you just had to ruin it when suddenly the guy was taken but the girl decided to go back to the place where the guy’s best friend was.
What were all those about? I fully agree with Ally that this show seems to be going nowhere. I understand that all San wanted was Won and Rin’s friendship and to be in romantic relationship was probably the least on her mind. But both guys eventually fell for her and she knew it. She might not want to choose one over the other but she did ask herself who makes her heart ache more. Wasn’t it implying that she also wanted to know who’s the man she loved? And what the drama gave us until episode 16 was San still doesn’t know who that guy is?

7
8
reply

Required fields are marked *

I want a refund! What kind of kiss was that?! Sigh....

3
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

After this ep, so many people said that they are disappointed with Rin's (supposed) betrayal... But I believe that he has a plan and would never betray Won. Rin might be too upright and not a schemer, but all this time everything he does is what he thinks is the best for everyone. So, I am sure he wouldn't go dark.....
On (super) shallow note.. I rack my brain for any other dramas that show so many romantic moments (including first kiss) between the heroine and the second male lead but ends up with the first male lead. Jealousy Incarnate and Hwarang are dramas that crossed my mind. But, in those two dramas, the heroine clearly shown to only love the first male lead. Scarlet heart next, but we know from the chinese version that the heroine will fall in love with the 4th prince (first male lead) in the end... While in TKL, those who read the novel will know who san's heart belong to... So, I am just not sure anymore....

4
4
reply

Required fields are marked *

This is a bit off topic...After watching this drama, I thought I have not watched any dramas where Hong Jong Hyun played so I searched and started watching' Mama, nothing to fear 2014' and ended up marathoning the drama for less than two days. The drama is heart breaking but I enjoyed watching very flawed people in there to see how they developed into more human and how an adult female friendship formed despite of a very thorny background and misunderstandings. I find this drama a slice of life and thought provoking for our life. I highly recommend it to everyone. Hong Jong Hyun has improved since then. His character in this drama is the only one whom I cannot find a flaw but his portrayal of this man makes him seem a genuinely good caring person rather than 'he is too good to be real, he only exists in dramaland.' It's nice to see a young actor developing his acting skills. He was also good in Moon lovers.

1
6
reply

Required fields are marked *

I think this episode actually confirms that San likes and prefer Rin romantically.

Rin confessed to her then asked what's holding her back, she confirmed it's Won. She worried what will happened to Won if they were to leave him all alone. She would to run away with Rin if it's not destroying Won. She still cares for him as a friend, and lamented that she shouldn't have given Won (false?) hopes, or so to speak.

Remember, AFTER this conversation happened... She kept staring at Rin dreamily, they shared a long gaze and he smiled, until she got shy and covered herself with the robe. Unlike before, where they used to avoid each other gaze out of awareness. Then the next morning they played happily in the river. My take is, they finally knew the feelings are mutual and kind of embracing it a lil bit more - while still holding back for their dear friend Won, that is.

11
10
reply

Required fields are marked *

Thank you so much for the recap, TERIYAKI! You were able to elucidate so much more than I gleaned from this episode. I can't figure out how much you interpreted on your own about the plot, or if everything you said was there, but was just lost in translation. That's the main reason I read these because I feel that I only understand things superficially until I read everyone else's interpretation. However, these episodes were infinitely better than the first two this week. I'm getting the feeling that the first hour of the week just sets things up to be explained in the 2nd hour. And I'm waiting for all the flashbacks too. I still want to understand how Rin left the King the first time the night that he took the Minister's body to San's house and what the King may have told him. And the split second the King was lucid--what was that about? Do we see flashes of maybe reconciliation with Won and with the Princess even?

I doubt Rin would totally trust his brother, and I do think the kiss with San, purposely done in front of Won, is instrumental to kicking Won into gear and taking control of the throne at last. Because right now Won is flailing, in denial of everything presented to him. How he kept saying that it could not be Rin next to the King, even with his "GPS" eyewitnesses (I love that description of those two by the way), I thought was too much. He looked really weak this episode to me, going against his mother (who was amazing this week--I really believe she's near death), kind of like a spoiled brat, (paraphrased), "Either you let her in or you're out???"

Thank you for the translation of the red cord--although, I should have noticed this. Red has always symbolized destiny, which now I understand why Won is so obsessed with San and why San is so conflicted herself. I'm giving the writer a pass, trusting that she is not purposely frustrating all the shippers out there. I do hope our writer can pull all this together; I have my own ideas about how it might all work out, but people will have to start confiding in each other (I love a good caper and when a plan comes together), and Song In and "Mu Bi" need to go, like really soon. Why can't someone slip them some poisonous ginseng cookies?

5
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

what a wonderful interpretation of the episode! Rin is not the kind to betray anyone, even at great personal cost. I think what he's trying to do by kissing San is getting Won angry at him. Rin is the only contender to the throne apart from Won. Won is naturally competitive. But he's never been interested in ruling. (Even the real guy, gave away his throne in two years back to his father and then had to be forced to be king when his father died. Then he abdicated the moment his son was old enough to rule. So, historically, Won isn't interested in the position) Rin, I'm guessing, wants to bring out that competitive spirit in Won so Won himself fights for this position.

6
3
reply

Required fields are marked *

My heart aches for Won, I can feel the pain. San ?why you close your eyes when Rin kiss you... do you looking for an answer who the man you loved ?

3
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

What frustrated me the most is that, while the trio is suffering, including the King and Princess Wonsung (yes, they're the victim in this scheme as well), the one who's benefited from their sufferings is Song In. He's just sit back and enjoy the show between the fight, the argument and the snap between the trio plus the royal family. Gah, I hate him so much.

As for Won, I find it sickening when the Goo Hyung said that Minister Eun's last wish before he died is to marry San to Rin and let them escape to other country. Then Won just snapped that San is my woman and Rin is just helping my woman blablabla and the wedding that you hope for is not going to happen. What the hell, Won? First of all, you did steal San and her father moment to be together, then now when her father died and wish for San's safety and happiness, you just bluntly deny her father's wish. Good Lord, I was swearing at you, you with your obsession toward San.

Anyway, I'm mad at that kind of kiss. Oh Rin, you could've done better.

7
4
reply

Required fields are marked *

Can i be shallow for a sec and comment on how gorgeous HJH in his varieties of beautifully made sageuk clothes? With his broad shoulders and narrow waist and hips,the costumes fit him to perfection. I shall not talk about his face and hands cause i'll just go on and on.
I had to watch the show 2 times to focus on him first then subtitle the second time.
As an actor,i'm pretty impressed with him both for his role as evil Wang Yo and pure as snow Wang Lin. I wish he gets a job with dual role as villain and hero(as twin or someone with multiple personality)next time cause i know he'll rock it.

3
2
reply

Required fields are marked *

Teriyaki, thanks for your wonderful POV, written in a clear and logical manner. I was so mad at the writer thinking that she's purposefully making Rin the bad guy, but now all your observations make sense, it can't be that Rin saw all those signs of Song In behind all the conspiracies, and ignored it. The incense, the allegation that princess wonsung gave the order to kill San's father, and Song In's dubious claim that he's doing all these for the people of goryeo, maybe Rin finally saw the reason behind Song In's motives and want to exterminate him from the scenario for good.
Or else it doesn't make any sense to Rin suddenly take 180 degree turn from his usual character. The guy who never got mad even if Won chose San over him, when they were both taken to jail, or when Won took San's hand and took her away in front of him, even if Rin is the one who rescued her.. and then when Won told Rin on face that San is his woman, and pretty much to get his hands off her. So he didn't get mad at Won all that time, even if Won's intention has been clear from the start. I guess we are in for a lot of flashback, which will unfold Rin's plan to save Won. I would be happy as long as both the boys are together and can finally finish that song in, who has been having his ways since God knows when. It has been extremely tiresome to see his triumph over everyone days after days, and my patience is wearing thin.

3
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

I read another recaps about this ep from breathlessurvival (kindly check her blog)... Her interpretation makes me worry for rin.
She thinks rin actually kissed San goodbye. What he try to cut is not won and san's thread of fate, but both his own thread of fate with won and with san. He is going to help won become king but he needs to make sure won is focusing on that (and so he needs to make sure san doesn't know his plan either). By kissing san (won's achilles), he entrusted san to won coz he believe won will protect san while he helps to protect everyone including the king and goryeo. Rin, in the end, will be the one who sacrifice everything for the peple he loved... ??

5
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

I really can't shake this feeling that Rin is polished to be the sacrifice type of character.

Idk if it because I've seen too many saeguk but I can't help that this is how I remember every fallen 2nd lead at the last episode is moulded.

3
5
reply

Required fields are marked *

Stuff that makes me shake my head:

Bi-yeon is still obliviously singing like a canary and spilling the beans to Mr. Red Snake Tattoo. I cannot believe that she's blowing her mistress's escape plans -- to the very guy who killed San's mother and sliced up her own puss. With friends like her, who needs enemies? She's also endangered the poor butler with her loose lips, dammit! I seem to have missed the scene wherein she was lobotomized.

Worst getaway ever!!! Rin and San manage to pull the old Escape In A Carriage From Dad's Funeral Trick, and then goof around in broad daylight trying to catch breakfast in the river instead of getting up before first light to hustle off to the ship. Rin brought the booze, but no food? Not even rice balls from Won's inn HQ?! What the hell was he thinking?! This is brain-dead beyond belief!

I felt terrible for Jin Gwan being assigned to protect Crown Princess Dan (or whatever her new official name is). How inhumane can you get. The poor guy who's guarding her has been smitten with her in a way that Won has never ever been. Not that Jin Gwan would ever have had a snowball's chance in hell of ending up with her. What a crappy next-best deal. Or maybe in Goryeo this is as close as you get to hitting the jackpot if you're a commoner.

Has anyone else developed an overwhelming urge to punch out Ok Boo-yong's / Queen Mu's lights? At one time I used to feel bad for her that she was a toy of Song In before he sent her off to canoodle with the King. Now her often-vacant expression makes her look as if she's been inhaling too much of the poisonous fumes she whips up for the King. (Or maybe she's forgotten to inhale and that's hypoxia we're seeing.) Of course, I'd love to wipe that smile off Song In's face while I'm at it... He's long overdue.

On the other hand, they are representative of the sub rosa Goryeo political establishment's attitude towards the Yuan interlopers in the palace. Perhaps their despicable and underhanded machinations speak to their desperation to rid the country of Yuan domination. They are just as bad as Princess Wonsung, whose ruthless Mongol habit of "kill and plunder now, ask questions later" has come back to bite her in the butt. Because of her horrid treatment of the King's first wife and son, no one would be surprised if she did, in fact, have Finance Minister Eun murdered in her palace.

4
3
reply

Required fields are marked *

OH NO! I'M FEELING A SCARLET HEART RYEO VIBE HERE GUYS! that kiss tho was like Hae Soo and Wang So's first kiss. Don't go scarlet heart ryeo all over again to me kdrama... I don't want to be heartbroken just like Wook and Soo's ship huhuhuhu

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

My Rin and San ship is sailing! I hope Hong Jong Hyun gets the girl this time. HJH's character is capturing my heart... a great way to forget his feisty character in Scarlet Heart Ryeo!

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

It’s really sad that the writing is so muddled down that even dramabeans commenters have a clouded sight on what's going on depending on which OTP they ship. It’s either Rin being an all loving pure angel and the demonization of Won as the obsessive villain but no in-betweens for complex characterization anymore. And I can’t blame it on them because ‚Who gets the girl?‘ is what the writer made the central point of this episode. Observant viewers may have noticed the big loses at stake but they were so much in the background that you really had to be willing to see them and dig deep. The main leads keep getting more and more stupid in the name of love.

I will start with Won. Like I complained before for a guy who is supposed to be the main lead he gets toyed around a lot both emotionally and politically. I can see the complexity of his character thanks to Im Siwan’s great facial expressions but the writing didn’t do him any favors because the writer has forsaken his character progression from complicated anti-hero to whiny clingy love puppy for shipper baiting purposes. He had no agency this episode from his dumb denial about the Rin/San situation, throwing a tantrum at his mother to being oblivious about the political situation around him. And I call it bs and totally out of character for him. Won is cunning and smart you could see it in the first episodes when he acted drunk in front of the king. Yet he’s getting so lovesick and dumbfounded by the San situation this episode that he could just throw childlike tantrums at his mother and everyone around him about the situation without planning or doing anything. He just patiently awaits Rin’s return and thinks the situation resolves itself like that. Nah that’s just not believable for me.

Rin’s first trait was his absolute loyalty to Won. And even if all the recapper said about him this episode was true it’s annoying and out of character that he only realized it after he wanted to run off with San. Rin while not a schemer like Song In or Won still has the capacity to realize the political situation around him like that time in the forest when he foresaw the danger for the crown prince immediately and shot the second arrow. No way he wouldn’t have known that Minister Eun’s death wouldn’t lead to people in the palace turning against Won. He also knew that Song In had the king and wanted to depose Won. Yet he wanted to leave his friend behind in this severe situation and run off with San because of love. Yeah no. He might have accompanied her to the ship but loudly declaring he wants to be with her forever while he knows Won is in danger is just not believable for me. Also not bringing food but alcohol with him? Playing around the river when they’re escaping enemies? Don’t turn stupid in the name of love.

San well she’s still the reason while this drama keeps getting into ship wars territory so I can’t say I have a positive outlook on her. Not only did she destroy the flow of the drama with...

3
2
reply

Required fields are marked *

I don't think Song-In and his faction are fighting for the good of Goryeo, maybe that's what it set out to be, but Song-In himself just seems to be after power for himself now.

That being said, I can't say with any conviction that Won deserves the throne. He does not seem to care about the people, or even about ruling. He just has the seat and lays claim to it because it is his birthright. In the purely political sense, I would have been rooting for Rin's claim to the throne, because like princess Woonsung herself said, Rin could make a great king. I wish the writers would show more of Won's political savvy rather than just having him focus all his energy on having San. Maybe that's what we'll see in the upcoming episodes. There's a lot to resolve in so little time.

1
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

On Won, I do so sympathise with you. How can decency and justicewin when the 'world' is composed thus?

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Rin/Lin has much to commend him but it is in his shortcomings, wether with Won or San, that his true self is seen. Surely, whatever his personal desires, he has a fillial duty to protect and cherish Wong Dan. If he cannot do that, how can he cherish any woman, or the product of their loins? Had he been entirely truthful or honest a long time ago, then nothing would have come to this sorry state. To love the same perso as Won was not a crime and I believe Won himself would understand this, the real crime is not to diferentiate his family from the threat and the conspiricy eveloping all.

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

I like Rin, but he is too stupid and also too conflicted. If nothing else he should understand that one of the principals joining him and his master (Won) is that they each love San, that in saving, protecting her, they fulfil a mutual destiny. So long as they do their utermost to protect and keep her, then they have fulfilled their most sacred duty. I ship won's bodyguards for they have a truly amazing loyalty, which should humble us all. Rin is too conflicted, nothing he does is a mater of substance and principle, sadly. He has somehow lost his finest values along the way. Shame !!!!!!!

1
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

Oh man. I never thought I'd be sad that Rin kissed San. Why did he do it for the purpose of showing Won?! Why didn't he do it when they were alone, give a real confession, and tell her how he loved her since she was crying and saying goodbye to her guards the night of the attack? ? I feel robbed.

I do not like Bi Yeon anymore. She is too foolish, (to put it nicely), always giving away important information that should be top-super-secret. I don't even feel bad for her upcoming sadness to learn that she loves the guy who slashed her face. I feel bad saying that now.

I still think Dan's behavior is understandable and she hasn't turned completely dark, though I thought she'd be more sinister by now!

This drama is still very interesting and keeps me wanting to see what will happen next!

0
2
reply

Required fields are marked *

I am uncomfortable with the way Rin pulled San into his arms. It is so out of character because he was rough and forceful, when the Rin we have seen, gotten to know and fallen in love with is gentle, considerate and respectful.

And I wouldn't call that a kiss.

Both the rough and forceful way Rin pulled San flush against him and the 'kiss' are Rin's tactical strategy for Won's eyes. What Rin is trying to do will probably be revealed soon enough.

So my take of this scene is it is a ruse for a purpose which we will know soon enough.

I refuse to believe that the Rin who pulled San so roughly into his arms is the REAL Rin. He was acting in front of Won and San.

Am I right? We will know soon enough. :)

1
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

The only reason we aren't able to predict the ending is because HJH is second male lead. That's it.

1
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

I thought that Rin actually had a secret plan last episode but it really seemed like he only wanted to run away with San and live happily ever after far away. He knew Song In is after Won and still wanted to ditch him for a girl. He could've just accompanied San to the ship but no he wanted to come with her. For him to just realize the stakes after meeting with the king doesn't make him noble and caring but just extremely stupid. Why would you need that to see the danger surrounding Won and the nation? Song In had made it clear that he wants Won gone and had the king under his control.

I don't share the reviewer's opinion about Rin just finding out and realizing the stakes. He knew very well but choose to ignore it so that he could run away with San. It was a moment of selfishness and his anger for Won and desire for San took over. But then he got caught and had to face reality again.

Even his "plan" for saving Won's Crown Prince position is dumb as well. After witnessing how possessive Won is of San what did Rin thought a kiss between him and San would do? That Won would have an epiphany then give up on San to be a good ruler? Definitely not. Won will freak out and become irrational to do dangerous things. And when he will do them Song In's faction will have a legitimate reason to dispose of him.

The truth is Rin was not brave enough to profess his love for San out loud to Won and demand a fair fight for her heart. Instead he drowns in indecision between acting on his feelings for San, being Won's trusted companion and doing what's best for the country. I know it's making him a tragic figure in this story but I can only shake my head with his stupid behavior. I don't see a heroic best friend trying to fix everything by himself but a distrustful friend who can't be honest with himself and his friend so he makes matters worse by acting on his first thoughts.

0
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

I was surprised when I watched the episode, and realized Rins motivation wasn't just his own brand of possessiveness. Teriyaki I really liked your logical break down of this episode, since I've just been reeling scene to scene prey to my emotions and irritations. Lol

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

I'm assuming no one will see this at this late date so I'm giving my theory as what's to come. There really is a rebellion and Rin places the King back on the throne. Won is sent to China and San decided to go with him as she's his only ally. That's where Won kisses San while Rin looks on. Whether or not Rin temporarily becomes CP I won't theorize, but I still don't know who San ends up with.

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

I prefer Rin with San. If they can be couple, maybe rating to this drama will be high. I Trust it. They match and I like their scene so much. I hope producer can change it ?????

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *