I’m telling you. Lee Sang-yi can sell a relationship with a ROCK. Love ya Kim Young-dae, but you’re simply out-acted here.
The ensemble physical comedy of this drama is also simply masterful. Here, maybe the edge goes to KYD! 😉
No, for realz…What did y’all decide these two were acting out? I thought elephant…but then maybe it turns into harpooning a seal??? Or is flailing dude a fish on a hook?
I just like that they all can shine. 😊
And I personally like KYD here a lot, I think he fits the role, he often surprises me with better delivery than what I expect… and the director knows what to do with him. 😁
(Like the director with Suzy in While You Were Sleeping. )
Gah! I’m just showing my colors left-right-and-center here. I have trouble enjoying dramas about high school, so I haven’t seen Extraordinary You either.
Since I’m in full confession mode, may I also now admit that there are times when I’ve been writing a comment about Kim Young-dae (the actor) and my fingers actually type out Gong Tae-sung (the character from Sh**ting Stars), subconsciously thinking that’s his actual name, so strong is my conflation.
First, I admit to not liking Waikiki and now all this!! Maybe I’ve never actually seen a single K-drama and I’m just a rando using ChatGPT.
Though I would argue @attiton that Extraordinary You is not the typical high school drama. The first part had me in stitches because it is all about TROPES of a romantic (well, yes, high school) kdrama/manga.
I think it was @enriquequierecagar who said something like they could make 10 spin-offs with different groups of characters together and it would be still be fun. No matter who we’ve got on screen, this show is never boring haha
I’d say elephant having a good day until he’s disrupted by a gazelle (or a ballet dancer doing it for the ‘gram)
I was wondering that myself. It had to be scene in water the way they were swaying, and the guy with the tie as his nose might have been a fisherman- so your guess of harpooning a seal or a whale, might be right. It must be a reference to some movie or show, but I don’t know how we could find out. The balletic move the guy who was “shot” was really impressive!
How about this, then…thinking through what @moomoomoondog said…what if the whole charade from both the guys is a safari and therefore an “Africa” reference to Sh**ting Stars??
I think we’ve got it. The elephant, a famous thespian, putting on show for his fans, turns violent when the gazelle tries to steal the spotlight. Thus, he is a shooting star.
It’s one of Kipling’s own illustrations of his Just So stories. And one of the stranger illustrations – He drew very few people (luckily) and other animals that he drew looked more like real animals.But the jumping fellow in the gif above reminded me of this kangaroo, not of any other kangaroo.
And well, I dearly love most of those Just So stories and it was not very pleasant to grow up and find out the author was super incredibly terribly racist.
Seon-ha
September 17, 2024 at 9:22 AM
I’m telling you. Lee Sang-yi can sell a relationship with a ROCK. Love ya Kim Young-dae, but you’re simply out-acted here.
The ensemble physical comedy of this drama is also simply masterful. Here, maybe the edge goes to KYD! 😉
No, for realz…What did y’all decide these two were acting out? I thought elephant…but then maybe it turns into harpooning a seal??? Or is flailing dude a fish on a hook?
NGNL, aka Not Gonna Lie, episode 7.
vienibenmio
September 17, 2024 at 9:53 AM
I find Gyu-hyun faaaar more interesting than Ji-uk; I think part of it is also the writing, but acting is definitely part of it
Seon-ha
September 17, 2024 at 11:43 AM
They’re both great characters. I look forward to hearing the word “hyung” come out of Ji-uk’s mouth if/when the day comes!
Dorotka
September 17, 2024 at 11:35 AM
I just like that they all can shine. 😊
And I personally like KYD here a lot, I think he fits the role, he often surprises me with better delivery than what I expect… and the director knows what to do with him. 😁
(Like the director with Suzy in While You Were Sleeping. )
Seon-ha
September 17, 2024 at 11:43 AM
I like KYD in everything I’ve been able to watch him in 😉…but in that scene, all I thought was, “Wow, how can you not fall for this guy, Ji-uk?”
Dorotka
September 17, 2024 at 12:13 PM
😁 I’m a fan… but… ehm… he does have some limitations… 😁
Have you watched him in Cheat On Me if You Can? I totally fell for him there. 😍
They are a nice couple, Lucifer and Mr. Volunteer. 😄
Seon-ha
September 17, 2024 at 12:28 PM
I have NOT seen that **heads over to MDL to learn more** GETS TOTALLY DISTRACTED…OMG…have you seen KYD’s headshot on MDL? He’s an infant!
Dorotka
September 17, 2024 at 12:50 PM
You don’t remember him from Extraordinary You? In his strawberry pullover?? 😄
Seon-ha
September 17, 2024 at 1:03 PM
Gah! I’m just showing my colors left-right-and-center here. I have trouble enjoying dramas about high school, so I haven’t seen Extraordinary You either.
Since I’m in full confession mode, may I also now admit that there are times when I’ve been writing a comment about Kim Young-dae (the actor) and my fingers actually type out Gong Tae-sung (the character from Sh**ting Stars), subconsciously thinking that’s his actual name, so strong is my conflation.
First, I admit to not liking Waikiki and now all this!! Maybe I’ve never actually seen a single K-drama and I’m just a rando using ChatGPT.
It’s always possible!! 😁
Dorotka
September 17, 2024 at 1:18 PM
😄😄
Dorotka
September 17, 2024 at 1:26 PM
Though I would argue @attiton that Extraordinary You is not the typical high school drama. The first part had me in stitches because it is all about TROPES of a romantic (well, yes, high school) kdrama/manga.
vienibenmio
September 17, 2024 at 12:06 PM
This is my first time seeing KYD in a role, and I like him a lot more than I thought I would.
Cori
September 17, 2024 at 1:14 PM
I think it was @enriquequierecagar who said something like they could make 10 spin-offs with different groups of characters together and it would be still be fun. No matter who we’ve got on screen, this show is never boring haha
I’d say elephant having a good day until he’s disrupted by a gazelle (or a ballet dancer doing it for the ‘gram)
Seon-ha
September 17, 2024 at 1:20 PM
Oooh…love gazelle!! I buy it. Or even a gazelle doing ballet for the ‘gram? 😂
Cori
September 17, 2024 at 2:12 PM
Plausible 😂
hacja
September 17, 2024 at 1:39 PM
I was wondering that myself. It had to be scene in water the way they were swaying, and the guy with the tie as his nose might have been a fisherman- so your guess of harpooning a seal or a whale, might be right. It must be a reference to some movie or show, but I don’t know how we could find out. The balletic move the guy who was “shot” was really impressive!
Seon-ha
September 17, 2024 at 1:49 PM
How about this, then…thinking through what @moomoomoondog said…what if the whole charade from both the guys is a safari and therefore an “Africa” reference to Sh**ting Stars??
hacja
September 17, 2024 at 2:04 PM
What about just a reference to “Shooting Stars” itself?
Cori
September 17, 2024 at 2:20 PM
I think we’ve got it. The elephant, a famous thespian, putting on show for his fans, turns violent when the gazelle tries to steal the spotlight. Thus, he is a shooting star.
DK-Drama ❤️🎄 Giffing n Space Cadetting 👼🏻🌟
September 18, 2024 at 3:38 AM
It’s an Australian Elephant and a Kangaroo, obviously.
DK-Drama ❤️🎄 Giffing n Space Cadetting 👼🏻🌟
September 18, 2024 at 3:43 AM
This kind of kangaroo:
Seon-ha
September 18, 2024 at 5:09 AM
Uh, that whole cartoon seems super suspect…poorly representing both the humans and the animals of the Australian continent.
DK-Drama ❤️🎄 Giffing n Space Cadetting 👼🏻🌟
September 18, 2024 at 11:15 AM
It’s one of Kipling’s own illustrations of his Just So stories. And one of the stranger illustrations – He drew very few people (luckily) and other animals that he drew looked more like real animals.But the jumping fellow in the gif above reminded me of this kangaroo, not of any other kangaroo.
And well, I dearly love most of those Just So stories and it was not very pleasant to grow up and find out the author was super incredibly terribly racist.
DK-Drama ❤️🎄 Giffing n Space Cadetting 👼🏻🌟
September 18, 2024 at 11:20 AM
The people on this illustration are at least part magical, as I recall. I don’t remember the specifics – it’s one of the weirder of the stories.