50

Weak Hero Class 2: Episodes 1-8 (Series Review)

Amidst friendships forged and fractured, the specter of guilt casts a shadow over reminiscence and regret. Visceral in its unrelenting intensity of emotion, this sequel echoes the core of what made its predecessor so deeply moving, introducing a new motley crew that tugs at my heartstrings in all the right ways.

EPISODES 1-8

Weak Hero Class 2 Review

If you’re anything like me, you’ve been anticipating this sequel since it was first announced – and I’m happy to report that it’s a return to form, with new characters and a different school environment but the same sympathetic protagonist and heartfelt friendships. Picking up right where we left off in Season 1, the reticent student YEON SHI-EUN (Park Ji-hoon) transfers to Eunjang High in the wake of the tragic incident that shattered his former friend group.

Right off the bat, it’s obvious Eunjang is no place for studying. Its rowdy students barely wear a single piece of their uniforms properly, the teachers don’t bother to enforce any ounce of discipline, and Shi-eun is content to let the rumors about his past reputation keep everyone out of his path. That is, until a bullying case he can’t overlook inevitably gets him tangled up in a regional power struggle — but with it comes unexpected friends, the addressing of unresolved guilt, and the first step towards healing.

(For Beanies who are curious but ultimately want to watch the show for themselves, I’ve structured this two-part piece as a spoiler-free overall review in the first half, and a more in-depth analysis in the latter section.)

Weak Hero Class 2 Review

OVERALL REVIEW

Season 2 opens with a flashback montage of Shi-eun’s old Byeoksan High friends AHN SOO-HO (Choi Hyun-wook) and OH BUM-SEOK (Hong Kyung), and oh, I miss them just as much as Shi-eun does. In his mind, Shi-eun’s trapped in the boxing ring that robbed Soo-ho’s consciousness from him. With guilt haunting every waking moment, sleep eludes Shi-eun, and he winds up dozing at school like Soo-ho once did. While Soo-ho and Bum-seok only have brief (but significant) appearances this season, their impact on the narrative is painfully palpable, not least in the sorrow that dims the light in Shi-eun’s eyes.

Amidst the gripping fights and sleek choreography, it’s a bit of a shame that this season has less strategizing, but perhaps that’s reflective of Shi-eun’s volatile mental state. There’s a raw agony to this iteration of Shi-eun, repressing all his emotions and constantly teetering on the edge until he snaps and the punches come spilling over. In a way, it’s almost as if Shi-eun is still being tossed about in the turbulent maelstrom of emotion that sent him into a destructive spiral in the final episode of Season 1.

Falling back on his trusty pen like a crutch, Shi-eun relies on it as the one element of familiarity amidst the uncertainty of a new chapter he never asked for and the memory of friends he never wanted to lose. Alas, it starts to grow repetitive after several instances, even if it effectively emphasizes his point-blank desperation. To Shi-eun’s credit, though, he does have his moments of brilliance where he uses the environment to his advantage – the rooftop fight in which he tosses a flowerpot of soil as a distraction, then snatches his opponent’s spectacles right off his face to snap its frame and stab with it, stands out in particular.

Weak Hero Class 2 Review

Shi-eun wears his apathy like a shield, which means it isn’t long before the harsh hazing of the timid SEO JOON-TAE (Choi Min-young) begins to crack his facade. As much as Shi-eun tries to turn a blind eye, he can’t ignore Joon-tae’s earnest entreaties for help in overcoming his own cowardice. That’s how they challenge the bully CHOI HYO-MAN (Yoo Soo-bin) — who’s really just full of hot air — and end up cornered by the brawn-over-brains GO HYUN-TAK (Lee Min-jae), who got fooled by Hyo-man’s bumbling trickery into believing Shi-eun is responsible for the damage to the basketball club’s room.

They’re interrupted by PARK HOO-MIN (Ryeoun), or “Baku,” who makes his grand geeky entrance to the tune of the Slam Dunk opening theme, dressed exactly like the protagonist right down to his fiery red hair. Hyun-tak: “Did you style your hair with chili sauce?” Ha, that’s what you call true friendship. Hoo-min slam-dunks his basketball down on Hyo-man’s head like a scene right out of a comic book, and just like that the fight is over. It turns out Mr. Popular Hoo-min is the top dog at Eunjang High, keeping the school in order with jovial greetings. This is where we learn the reason Eunjang students don’t wear their uniforms — because the pacifist Hoo-min refused to join the “Union,” an alliance of school gangs in the region, thereby painting a target on Eunjang’s back. Needless to say, Hoo-min has a bone to pick with the leader of the Union.

Weak Hero Class 2 Review

That would be NA BAEK-JIN (Bae Nara!!), who fights with a lithe grace and impeccably ruthless efficiency. He’s childhood friends with Hoo-min, stemming from the time Hoo-min saved Baek-jin from his bullies — Hoo-min is the one who taught Baek-jin how to fight, and Baek-jin is the one who gave Hoo-min the nickname “Baku,” though they’ve long since drifted apart. Baek-jin runs a shady operation reselling stolen motorcycles, and the only person he answers to is the formidable BOSS CHOI (cameo by Jo Jung-seok). Despite his involvement in the seedy underworld of illegal dealings, Baek-jin cleans up well; he’s a model student with excellent academic grades and no shortage of scholarships. But Baek-jin’s running on empty, and it’s best summed up in the scene where Hoo-min walks into a confrontation and brusquely brushes past Baek-jin to pull Shi-eun away.

A look of quiet hurt writes itself across Baek-jin’s face, twisting even deeper when Hoo-min remarks that he and Baek-jin are simply too incompatible. Baek-jin throws the first punch, but their next ones land simultaneously — and Baek-jin stops in his tracks, seemingly shaken that Hoo-min actually hit him. Oof, that hurts. Baek-jin tugs at my heartstrings in much the same way that Bum-seok did — both mourning the loss of their closest bonds, and doing everything wrong in their misguided attempts to win their estranged friends back.

It’s in this aspect that Class 2 shines, and yet also falters, most. Bae Nara can convey a whole history of emotion in his plaintive gaze and the subtle shifts in his expressions, alluding to everything left unsaid in between the lines — but I wish we didn’t have to fill out quite as many blanks. There’s such deep hurt etched into the irreparable rift between Hoo-min and Baek-jin, and it feels like wasted potential to not expand upon it further.

I could say the same for the absolute whirlwind that is GEUM SUNG-JE (Lee Jun-young), who’s a total scene-stealer with his manic unpredictability and electrifying charisma. As the Union’s loose cannon, Sung-je delivers a rush of adrenaline in his incisive quips and devil-may-care attitude. One moment he’s mocking Hoo-min to end his “lovers’ spat” with Baek-jin, and the next he’s cackling wildly even as Shi-eun is inches away from stabbing him in the face. Though Sung-je’s comparatively limited screen time makes sense since he’s billed as a special cameo appearance, the plot might have been more innovative had Sung-je and his unhinged methods played a more involved role.

I’d like to add a disclaimer that I haven’t read the original webtoon, so I can’t speak on how Weak Hero Class 2 fares as an adaptation — but as a drama series, it strikes its emotional beats in a series of gut punches that leave me reeling from the intensity of the buildup and the intricacies of the relationships. It’s masterfully acted, tightly directed with artful cinematography, and underscored by a soundtrack that both elevates its key moments and allows it to breathe in its liminal spaces. All in all, it’s a show that may not be for the faint of heart, but it’s one I’d definitely recommend for its grounded take on friendship, guilt, and all the gamut of human emotion in between.

(Spoilers ahead!)

Weak Hero Class 2 Review

THE STORY

At the heart of this season is Newton’s third law of motion (or, if you’re Hoo-min, “U-turn’s Law”) — for every action, there is an equal and opposite reaction. When Shi-eun quotes this as a word of advice to call Joon-tae out on his cowardice, Joon-tae interprets it to mean that every good deed will set another in motion. That forms the impetus for the browbeaten Joon-tae to stand up against his bullies and swipe his schoolmates’ stolen phones back, bravely enduring the repercussions and beginning the process of learning how to stand on his own two feet.

What Shi-eun only comes to realize and fully embody by the end is this: he’s passing on the hope and wisdom that Soo-ho once imparted to him. It’s Shi-eun who inspires the quartet towards action, forming the impetus for them to break free from unhealthy patterns and take charge of their own narratives. Hoo-min, cut from the same overly self-sufficient cloth as Shi-eun, snaps out of his noble self-sacrifice to rally Eunjang together in a united front. Joon-tae, despite being the least physically capable of our main quartet by far, has a staunch willpower that undergirds his indomitable resilience and exemplifies the title of Weak Hero. Then there’s Hyun-tak, whose unwavering loyalty is the glue that keeps them all together through thick and thin.

The Weak Hero series shines most in the understated moments that humanize its characters, and this season is no different. It’s the way Joon-tae gives Shi-eun vitamins to help with his insomnia, and how it’s the only thing that actually manages to grant Shi-eun a peaceful night’s rest. It’s the way Hyun-tak ribs Hoo-min for scoring 99 on an IQ test, but proceeds to correct Hoo-min’s proverb to the wrong word order, earning him the hilariously judgmental silence of everyone else in the room. And it’s the way our Eunjang trio waits for Shi-eun at the school gates just so they can walk to class together, slowly but surely melting the walls of their dear “ice princess.”

Season 2 also does such a good job with its callbacks, such as when Hyo-man delivers a brutal beating to Joon-tae, dredging up Shi-eun’s old memories until Hyo-man grabs a chair. That’s the last straw for Shi-eun, who smacks it out of Hyo-man’s grasp and reminds him not to cross the line — just as Soo-ho once told him. There’s also a parallel between Bum-seok and Shi-eun being sent to study abroad as their parents’ way of extricating them from grim situations, except Shi-eun has friends to assuage his guilt and reaffirm their faith in him. Bum-seok hadn’t, because he’d pushed them all away first.

In a similar vein, Baek-jin’s instinctive need to hold onto Hoo-min at all costs inadvertently widens the distance between them. Baek-jin clearly yearns for his old friend more than he lets on, and I can’t help but wonder if Baek-jin lashes out at our main squad not just because it’s the most effective way of ruffling Hoo-min’s feathers, but because their place right by Hoo-min’s side is exactly where Baek-jin used to be. Yet Baek-jin’s targeting of Hoo-min’s closest friends — as well as his repeated attempts to keep Hoo-min under control so he can’t leave him again — simply leads to Hoo-min despising him more.

It’s precisely this irony that makes Hoo-min and Baek-jin’s fractured relationship so compelling in its crossed wires and fraught miscommunication. Everything Baek-jin does to keep Hoo-min closer only serves to drive him away — because Baek-jin’s pride won’t allow him to admit that he misses Hoo-min, and Hoo-min’s righteousness won’t let him see past Baek-jin’s deeds to the concealed hurt festering underneath. That’s what forms the tragedy between them; the sheer preventability of it because both boys still care deeply for each other, and the utter inevitability of it because their natures are too different for them to reconcile their diverged paths.

This star-crossed fate heightens the impact of the climactic faceoff between Eunjang (dressed in full uniform!) and the Union, further raising the stakes of Hoo-min and Baek-jin’s confrontation. Throughout the whole season, Hoo-min is the sole person who’s able to land a hit on Baek-jin — as if he’s the only person who can see right through Baek-jin, and the only person Baek-jin ever reveals an opening to. But by this point, Hoo-min has nothing left but scorn for Baek-jin.

In their duel, Hoo-min relentlessly attacks Baek-jin’s shoulder, gaining a vicious gleam in his eyes and laughing derisively when Baek-jin winces in pain. Eventually managing to gain the upper hand, Baek-jin strikes Hoo-min until his ears ring — but as Hoo-min stumbles, Baek-jin stops, falling back to gaze at Hoo-min with years of hurt reflected in his eyes. There’s none of that in Hoo-min, who resumes their fight with a sneer of a smile. It’s a painful contrast to watch, especially when it’s a grave of Baek-jin’s own making.

Hoo-min winds up collapsing first, but there’s no victory in the guilt that lines Baek-jin’s slumped posture. And when Shi-eun steps in to continue the battle, the clear shift in Baek-jin’s demeanor only serves to make his earlier restraint and emotion even more apparent. This season is as much Hoo-min and Baek-jin’s story as it is Shi-eun’s, which is why I love that Shi-eun and Hoo-min’s strategic tag-teaming culminates in the latter delivering the final blow to Baek-jin; Hoo-min has to be the one to mark the full stop on the chapter of their friendship. “Baek-jin-ah,” Hoo-min says, to his fallen friend. “I’m sorry. But you ought to be sorry towards me too.”

That shot of a tear slipping from Baek-jin’s eye as Hoo-min towers over him in the wake of their fight brings to mind the same image from Season 1’s finale, with Bum-seok and Shi-eun in their exact positions. The fight is as much a testament to the depth of what their bond used to be, as it is a mark of finality that there’s no going back to what they once were.

It’s what makes Bum-seok’s scene, as an apparition of guilt in Shi-eun’s mind, so poignant. Shi-eun’s self-reproach extends beyond Soo-ho, since he blames himself for not being able to prevent Bum-seok’s spiral as well. Bum-seok embodies Shi-eun’s fear of history repeating itself — in the way he points out that Shi-eun will only get hurt again, his voice somewhere between mockery and concern — as well as Shi-eun’s guilt over what feels like leaving his friends behind, punctuated by Bum-seok asking if Shi-eun’s new friends are more important to him than he is. Ultimately, Shi-eun has to make the decision to walk away — even as Bum-seok keeps holding on to Shi-eun’s jacket sleeve, reluctant to let go until his arm finally slumps in defeat — just as Hoo-min has to be the one to cut ties with Baek-jin once and for all.

That’s why I lament the brevity of Baek-jin’s backstory, because he’s set up to be a sympathetic antagonist but his motivations are never fully explained. I really would’ve liked an extra episode or two to delve into Hoo-min and Baek-jin’s past, especially since it’s hinted that Baek-jin’s background isn’t as rosy as Hoo-min assumed. After all, Baek-jin has been donating his exorbitant profits to underprivileged children all this while. My interpretation is that, after little Hoo-min innocently mistook the orphanage Baek-jin grew up in as a rich family’s estate, Baek-jin grew fixated on keeping up appearances and amassing power so that he could stand with his savior Hoo-min on equal footing. No longer the battered victim from before, Baek-jin simply wants to fight by Hoo-min’s side — but Hoo-min doesn’t want to fight at all.

Plagued by the same guilt that haunts Shi-eun, Hoo-min blames himself for the knee injury that Hyun-tak suffered at Sung-je’s hands, which effectively ended Hyun-tak’s taekwondo athlete career. Both Hoo-min and Shi-eun vowed never to throw a punch again, but that’s what makes their resolve to spearhead the final face-off all the more meaningful. This time, they’re fighting with a purpose; not to punish, but to protect. For Hoo-min, it’s his principles. For Shi-eun, it’s his peace. And for all of them, it’s the friendships they treasure. Baek-jin no longer has any of that, and that’s what makes his last scene so heartbreakingly forlorn as he lies defeated and alone in the pouring rain, the reality of all that he’s lost finally sinking in.

Now that the Union fiasco is over, it’s Shi-eun’s turn to wait for his friends by the school gate. Walking to class together with the weight lifted off their shoulders at long last, they pass by a poster of Hyo-man, who’s turned over a new leaf and is currently running for student council president, LOL. As for Baek-jin, he’s seemingly vanished into thin air; no one’s heard from him since the showdown. But there’s good news in store for Shi-eun — Soo-ho regains consciousness at long last, and Shi-eun introduces the Eunjang trio as his friends. Aww, Soo-ho looks so proud of his old pal, and the rare smile that spreads across Shi-eun’s face is such a welcome sight.

Our story isn’t over just yet, though, because the show delivers a final blow in its post-credits scene (major spoilers ahead). Sung-je saunters back into Baek-jin’s abandoned bowling alley, where he finds Boss Choi, who offers him a lucrative position working under him at Cheongang. In true Sung-je fashion, he brushes it off because “it’s no fun,” though he does linger long enough to wonder if Boss Choi has any idea where Baek-jin disappeared to. “I’m plenty curious myself,” answers Boss Choi cryptically. Cut to a condolence wreath sent by Cheongang, alongside our somber boys and a sobbing Hoo-min. It’s Baek-jin’s funeral.

And I’m crying, because that ending absolutely gutted me in the most devastating way. I don’t think Baek-jin could have ever recovered from the hurt of Hoo-min walking away from him yet again, or the guilt of knowing he’d been the one to drive Hoo-min away. And yet there was always that sliver of hope, the slightest chance at redemption, because Baek-jin had never been too far gone. Perhaps, with the Union dissolved and his empire fallen, he could have repented and begun making amends. Alas, Baek-jin’s trajectory was abruptly truncated, in a doomed outcome he brought upon himself. It’s an end that’s all too fitting, and all too tragic.

It’s bound to cut deep for Hoo-min, who only just managed to come to terms with the guilt of introducing Baek-jin and Hyun-tak to the realm of fighting. If he hadn’t taught Baek-jin how to defend himself — if he hadn’t dealt that final decisive blow — if he had extended a hand to the fallen Baek-jin instead of leaving him behind? Hoo-min will have to grapple with countless “what-ifs,” and I don’t know whether a repeat of his guilt-ridden arc is entirely welcome, though maybe it’ll be an opportunity for him to heal in a healthier way this time around.

I can’t predict what direction the story will take from here (assuming there’s a third season in the works), but if Sung-je does take up the mantle of the next antagonist, I have faith that our squad will pull through. After all, it’s Soo-ho who taught Shi-eun how good it feels to have friends, and to laugh freely. Now that Shi-eun’s resolved to follow in Soo-ho’s footsteps, with a newly-forged support system around him, surely he’ll continue to inspire others to take the first step towards positive change. (And maybe Bum-seok can return from his studies abroad for a chance at reconciliation? Hey, let me have my pipe dreams!)

 
RELATED POSTS

Tags: , , , , , ,

50

Required fields are marked *

I have the same issue with this season than the first one. Too many fights, no adult doing their job... I was more drown by the new characters and actors.

I'm kinda tired by Lee Jun-young for now, I don't see any difference in his acting just the same usual faces. I saw him smoking way enough in Melo Movie.

I was frustrated they didn't give more time to Baek-jin and built his character. Bae Na-Ra was great. He did so well in DP2, it was great to see him back.

Lee Min-jae was good too. I was happy he got a better role than his last ones.

It was nice to see Yoon Jong-Bin too. I don't think I saw him since DDSSLLS.

I was surprised by the age of some actors.

At least, this one had a positive end for the main group.

3
8
reply

Required fields are marked *

I love lee jun young .. I think he is awesome and he is out here WORKING.. he has been in like 4 dramas in the last 6 months alone. But the fact that he plays a totally different character from his Life gives you tangerines is cool.. I think he's great.. and handsome and in my comment below.. one of the better characters.

5
2
reply

Required fields are marked *

For me, he was the least intersting character. He was just there, but had no purpose, no background story... And I don't think LJY brought something special to this character.

2
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

I'm with you, I didn't find his character was interesting.

1
reply

Required fields are marked *

I was so happy to see Yoon Jong Bin, too!! Too bad he was given such a small role. I like him so much better as a big teddy bear than a goon.

2
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

His relationship with Lee Jae-wook in DDSSLLS was one of the good part of this drama. The ML was honest with him.

2
reply

Required fields are marked *

Yoon Jong Bin was in Duty after School too. I liked his character there.

1
2
reply

Required fields are marked *

I didn't watch this drama. I think when I became interested to watch it, I read that the end of the second season was bad.

1
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

The end of the second season is peculiar, to say the least.
But the drama was quite entertaining and there were several young actors which now are getting popular.

1
reply

Required fields are marked *

Overall, I enjoyed it alot. It was not alot of fight scenes and Si Eun seemed more like someone trying to overcome PTSD because of the events of the 1st show but still very good. First, there was some undertones of BL lol to be sure which surprised me because I didnt get that from the 1st one. But Baku was crushing hard on Si-Eun. Si-eun was crushing on Suho soooo...lol.. No seriously, I did get the feeling that Baku valued Si Eun alot. I loved the friendship between the guys but honestly my favorite character was believe it or not Seong Je.

Gosh what a fun, crazy character.. I love that he wasnt pure evil ( although I dont think anyone was purely evil even Na Baek Jin who donated all his money to an orphanage. I liked Seong je because he was a grey character and he seemed to be almost testing the loyalty of the Eunjang guys. He may not have liked them but he respected the loyaty they had to one another.

I hope we get a season 3 but with more action .. The dialogue was good but it felt a little slow compared to the first season and there were no girls.. lol unlike the first one

5
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

It does leave things open for a thrid season. . . .

(Some spoilers ahead)
.
.
.
.
.
. . . But without Na Baek-jin, I don't think I would be as interested. I know he didn't have tattoos but since he actually went to school in the drama, he couldn't have tattoos.

-And am I imagining things or did the 2 union members at the funeral scene have smiles on their faces? It made me wonder if Baek-jin was really dead or just faked his death. If they did season 3 I would love it if Baek-jin came back stronger than ever and more like his character in the webtoon.

1
reply

Required fields are marked *

Someone saw "manic unpredictability and electrifying charisma" on the characters descriptions and said: I know exactly who we want.

4
2
reply

Required fields are marked *

But he also actually looks like the character. He really pulls it off well

(And I don't mean necessary *looks* like the webtoon, but more that he's recognizable as him. The styling, gestures, the energy, etc)

3
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

That's great to hear! I'm a huge fan of his, and although I won't be watching this drama I love to hear that he fits the role very well.

1
reply

Required fields are marked *

I watched Class 2 only because I want my closure from Class 1 (I swear, if Su-Ho didn't wake up, I would riot).

Once the demons of guilt have been put to rest, and poetic justice is served - I couldn't care much either way, because the sequel is not reinventing any narrative territory we haven't seen from Class 1

p.s. Whoever thinks there is any lingering yearning on the part of Baek-jin for Baku, I'm sorry there is clearly no ship to sail here. You will find nothing in the directing or acting to support that. None at all.

3
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Wow, I was not expecting the weecap/review so fast haha

Umm, my gut instinct is that S1 was significantly better and that is largely because it had less characters to establish and develop. It was truly amazing what they were able to accomplish with 8 episodes.

With this show, as much as I wanted to watch and judge it on its own merits, I couldn't help but make that comparison. During the first half, I just kept thinking this could've been subtitled "his legend precedes him" cause so much time was spent on exposition on why our heroes are feared vs shown (unlike S1)

I wasn't able to really buy Sieun's friendship with the guys because it just felt fast. Even though all the actors did an awesome job and it's believable that their goofiness could charm Sieun despite himself, it just felt too fast to me. Like how long have they known each other that hearing "you're not at fault" was enough to finally get through to Si Eun and he choose not to go abroad? How long had they known each other that Gotak was sad that he was leaving

However, after some rewatching, I'm seeing a good story about friendships, both healthy and toxic, and moving on. When I first watched, I was kinda irked that Si Eun wasn't kicking the bullies' asses and living up to his reputation but I get that this was about him dealing with his trauma and guilt so it wouldn't have necessarily been right for this version of the character or the story they're trying to tell. That being said, I was still most affected when he was fighting and confronting the adversaries.

Weak Hero Class 1's cast chemistry is just so powerful haha. Hong Kyung and Choi Hyun Wook just did cameos and it was so emotionally affecting. The hold they both have on him mentally and emotionally was shown so well.

6
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

I agree that Class 1's relational dynamics was portrayed with such depth and complexity; Class 2 felt like the Lite Edition.

Everything that has transpired in Class 1 was foundational in shaping the character's psyche (specifically Si-eun) and how he responds to a new slate, second chances and his redemption arc

3
reply

Required fields are marked *

As someone who has read the webtoon, I thought it hella impressive how much of the story they were able to incorporate and adapt. In the webtoon, the gang's friendship *did* kinda start at the underpass and it was solidified because of the guys being considerate of each other (in the webtoon, it was making sure that Gray's bag was returned and in the drama, it was Juntae calling to make sure Si Eun got home safely).

The characterizations were on point. I saw somewhere that people were criticizing some of the portrayals but the actors, all of them, really embodied their roles.

Just like @solstices mentioned, I thought the use of his pen was repetitive even though it was practical. One of the cool things about Si Eun/Gray is that he's able to calculate and use his surrounding to his advantage (but again, Si Eun isn't fully in that mode anymore since he's dealing with his trauma and doesn't want to fight)

Instead we had a moment of Baek Jin being calculating which was also reflective of the webtoon because in that, he and Si Eun are two sides of a coin. Another example of this was when Si Eun corrected his math nonchalantly.

5
7
reply

Required fields are marked *

Is the unrequited bromance on the part of Baek-jin towards Baku actually present in the webtoon? Cos it sure ain't coming across in the drama series

0
3
reply

Required fields are marked *

No, that was a drama invention. In the webtoon, Donald (Baek Jin) and Big Ben (Baka) are the 2 best fighters.

If anything, Donald seemed to want a *thing* with Gray (Si Eun). Maybe a friendship or sunbae/hubae or hyung/donsaeng rapport because he recognized they were very similar. And if he didn't want it, he was at least curious about the idea of it.

5
reply

Required fields are marked *

I think the unrequited friendship is a valid take because Baek Jin obviously just wanted to keep Baka in his orbit. He even says all he wants is him to join him. He was trying to get him to steal the bike to further tether him and solidify him in the union world [by his side]. He was also threatened by Si Eun's prescene in Baka's circle. If you wanna compare it to S1, it would be like when Yeongi showed up. Beonseok was confortable with Si Eun but Yeongi threw him off balance. Baek Jin was "fine" with Gotak and the basketball club but Si Eun represented more of a threat to the relationship he wanted (I would say it's because he saw himself in Si Eun like in the webtoon).

I think Baek Jin even says the words "stay away from him".

Also when Si Eun confronted him, he mentioned "you consider him your friend but does he consider you his?" (Or something like that)

4
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

Yes, I clock all the same story beats you mentioned that are supposedly meant to show Baek Jin's fixation on Baku.

But for some reason, it isn't coming across in the acting or directing - so I don't feel the emotional subtext of unrequited bromance, that's what I meant.

Whereas the emotional punch really lands in C1 - you can literally chart the downward spiral of Beom-seok, the estrangement and unraveling within the group dynamics, the quiet unease of Si-eun etc. And it makes you sick in the guts, like watching a train wreck happening in slow-mo.

2
reply

Required fields are marked *

Which site were you using to read the webtoon btw?

I am now super curious to see how they depict Si-eun physically in the toon.

Park Ji-hoon is a very intriguing and counter-intuitive casting choice at first glance.

1
2
reply

Required fields are marked *

Webtoon
That's the app

1
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

OK I just quickly scan through the webtoon and confirmed my hypothesis.

Park Ji-hoon is indeed a very curious casting choice...no right or wrong. Just curious

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

See, I knew seeing other perspectives would give me a new appreciation. Thank you @solstices for your insights.

Even though I wasn't as emotionally affected as I was with S1, your review clarified things that I didn't even notice because all I could see was the things "lacking" to me.

I hope more people can see the story that you saw and what PD was trying to convey.

4
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Oh, and I've seen people theorize about a 3rd season. That seems unlikely to me personally cause this season covered the major story arc of the entire webtoon including its conclusions. If there were a 3rd season, it would just be inventing a storyline (character wise) or pulling one of the plot points and expanding on it (like the money laundering).

I mean if demand is there, anything is possible (from what I understand, Sweet Home diverged from source material for its 2nd and/or 3rd season) but again, it wouldn't be necessary.

4
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Overall, the drama was good and met expectations. Of course, our Si-eun looks more pale and quiet here, battling his previous trauma, which he portrayed very well. Park Ji Hoon is very good with his roles, but he picks only a few dramas. I felt that line when Geum Seong-je said '' he has a very punchable face'' lol.
The character of Baka felt exactly like Su-ho to me, I mean they have almost the same personality, but Baka also mirrored Si-eun since both suffer the same casualties, and Geum Seong-je is the show stealer here (not to mention this man is everywhere in K-dramaland ), the first victim who experienced our Si-eun's crazy side hehe.. You deserve it, bro.
Okay, aside from drama, Park Ji Hoon has a very ''contagious smile'', I think he hardly smiled once here in the whole series, same with season 1 in the hospital scene, but that smile brightens up my whole screen.

4
2
reply

Required fields are marked *

I agree that Baku was so much like Suho. It was off-putting at first -- I thought Ryeoun was trying too hard to impersonate Suho -- but it made total sense by the end of ep4 when Si-Eun thought Baku was Suho, and spoke to him as such. I'm guessing the way the acting was overdone was a directorial call to make the smiliarities obvious, to highlight how Si Eun would be drawn to Baku and even mistake him for Suho in his confused post-fight state.

0
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

Yes - I had the exact same thoughts.

I felt Ryeoun was trying to mimic Choi Hyun-wook to recreate the same dynamics that Si-eun had with Su-ho. That could be why Si-eun warms up to the hyper-puppy Baku, while the latter teasingly calls him their "ice princess".

At some point, Ryeoun's acting was a little strained even. By comparison, Choi Hyun-wook is a natural in these high school jock roles (see 2521; Twinkling Watermelon)

3
reply

Required fields are marked *

I had to come back to see how our hero's fared this time around and it didn't disappoint. There were too much violence with all the fighting but the actors did not disappoint. I guarantee that they would not be back at school with just a band-aid on their face after getting beat up like they did but its a drama, not real life right? On a side note, where were all the adults in this and why weren't they taking an active interest in stopping all the violence? We saw that a single teenager standing up for himself could make change happen so where were you adults? Yet, if they had stepped in we wouldn't have all the fighting now would we? It was worth watching for me to see the kids work their way toward friendship and working it out for a better life.

1
2
reply

Required fields are marked *

I saw an interview where either Park Ji Hoon or Lee Jun Young (can't remember who exactly) said there wouldn't be a drama if the adults stepped in. So it seems taking adults out of the picture is a hefty dose of literary license.

4
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

I read several volumes of the Tokyo Revengers manga and it is the same. Different gangs of teenagers fighting, killing, riding motorbikes, stealing, smoking... and zero adults involved.

1
reply

Required fields are marked *

Just completed watching WHC2 and wanted an overview and some insight regarding the relationship of Baku and Baek-Jin. However, I am writing not about my thoughts re the drama but about your eloquently written review...truly incisive, precise descriptors,
visceral imagery, succinct recapture. Impressive and much appreciated!

1
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

I'm in love with Seong-je (to the extent that you can be in love with a psychopath). Lee Jun-young was not only a scene-stealer, but he also stole the show. A part of me died when I thought his character would exit the show after Seong-je and Baek-jin's falling-out, so I screamed so loud when he reappeared at the top of the stairs. I lmao at everything Seong-je said, like when the Union members bowed and loudly greeted him as "hyungnim!" and he asked, "What the fuck is this? The mafia? Don't talk to me, or I'll kill you." or when he asked Baku, "Are you a fucking woodcutter?" OMG when he joined hands with Si-eun, but his subsequent betrayal, I expected.

However, I'm so sad because Weak Hero Class 1 is one of my favorite dramas ever and I was so looking forward to Season 2, but it was just... disappointing. There was no tension until maybe Ep.6, but even the Eunjang v. Union fight was anticlimactic. My biggest problem was Baku is way too OP (overpowered). It's unrealistic how he can take down opponents (Union, Seoknam Gorilla) with one punch. He got struck on the head with a crowbar and was fine when we have two characters in comas.

I hate how they K-drama-fied Baek-jin's backstory. There was no need for Hu-min and Baek-jin to be childhood friends. So the reason Baek-jin is so obsessed with Baku is because he's jealous of him having other friends? And the fight, I'm sorry, wasn't a fair fight. Baek-jin won by KO'ing Baku, yet Si-eun tag-teams with a weapon (brass knuckles). The Union ought to have gone 2-on-1 too. I was hoping Seong-je would show back up. Baek-jin's death was so abrupt, and the writing made it seem like he'd killed himself or died from their fight, but that's not how his character dies. Why was Gotak crying?

Jun-tae's bullying arc was the best arc. I loved the montage of him "shuttling" snacks, then switching out the drink and picking it back up when it fell over. Protect him at all costs! Aww when he told Si-eun, "Thanks for today" and asked, "Aren't you tired today? You're not sleeping through lunch." My biggest hang-up about our new friend group is I kept wondering where their other friends were. Before Si-eun's transfer, Baku and Gotak hung out with the basketball club, and Jun-tae was friends with the anime weebs who speak Japanese. Season 1 established that Su-ho had no friends, and Beom-seok just transferred to their school, so the three of them only had each other.

Si-eun's rumors were so dumb unless Jeon Yeong-bin or Kang Woo-young had died, but why would everyone believe that he killed Su-ho? This rumor needs to follow Beom-seok at his new school instead, whom I was happily surprised to see make an appearance (Hong Kyung, not Beom-seok). When Beom-seok told Si-eun, "I wasn't looking for an apology from you," I yelled, "Bitch, we're looking for an apology from YOU!"

Hong Kyung's appearance gave me hope for a Choi Hyun-wook appearance, but to be honest, I'd rather have...

3
5
reply

Required fields are marked *

Hong Kyung's appearance gave me hope for a Choi Hyun-wook appearance, but to be honest, I'd rather have an imaginary conversation between Su-ho and Si-eun at the hospital like S1 Ep.8. Obviously, I'm happy that Su-ho is awake and healthy, but at the same time, I'm so sad because their friendship will never be the same. Si-eun goes to a different school, is a senior, and has his own life and his own friends, but I don't want him to have other friends. (Now I sound like drama!Baek-jin.)

I'm just going to wallow in self-pity for the rest of this week over my disappointment.

2
2
reply

Required fields are marked *

Re: but I don't want him to have other friends. (Now I sound like drama Baek-jin.)
🤣🤣
Indeed, S1 and their friendship is special. S2 feels like the Lite edition

1
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

When Su-ho woke up from his coma and they all ran to the hospital, I was waiting for the three of them to leave. Excuse me, this is a private moment. But they had to stay there for Si-eun to say, "Those are my friends."

2
reply

Required fields are marked *

In the webtoon, the final fight was also a tag team of sorts. Ben fights Donald - Donald wins and then says if anyone else wants to challenge him to which Gray steps up. Gray actually did bring down Donald briefly only for Donald to ultimately win but he did end up calling a halt to the union. I think what happened in the show was their way of simplifying that as well fitting the Baek Jin/Baku narrative they created.

I didn't think Baek Jin killed himself or from the fight; I thought he was supposed to have died because of the gangster.

Hmm, I can't relate to feeling disappointed. I just felt meh haha. I just thought that S1 was better but that didn't necessarily mean this was bad. I liked when I noticed the webtoon allusions. It's really impressive to me how much of the story they adapted.

Like alot of the things you mentioned are things that happen in the webtoon (Baku being super strong, the abrupt death, Suho waking up, etc)

This season kinda makes me think of line from When Life Gives You Tangerines about how it her second love was the right temperature for her vs the fiery/passionate first. S1 was intense, viseral, and impactful while S2 feels like more of a subtle exploration of themes which gets punctuated with the moments of violence. Am I making sense? Haha

5
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

Tangerines is an apt description because I was team fiery/passionate first love and did not care for her lukewarm/boring second/last love. Both seasons took a lot of liberties with the webtoon, but personally, S1 had much better characterization and story.

I know our group of friends are the main characters in the webtoon, but for some reason, I just couldn't get attached to them this season. I thought Baku was like that annoying friend. It was disappointing how Si-eun didn't use any scientific laws during his fights except Newton's Third Law of Motion to Jun-tae.

Baek-jin being killed by the gangster makes sense, but after Si-eun's accident, it would be poetic justice to watch him getting hit by a truck, but maybe the show felt it would've been too repetitive or wasn't necessary. Also, I thought Jo Jung-suk was miscast.

My expectations were sky-high, so I did this to myself, but I did love Wolf, so Seong-je at least helped lessen my disappointment.

2
reply

Required fields are marked *

I really liked the season and I've seemany people compare it to the webtoon... idk about that since I just know the series but i think they did an amazing job showcasing what happened and making us confront it with Sieun and his new environment. All the characters were likeable. Even Baekjin (which I think his motives or the decisive moment he had his fallout with Baku were never really stated but thats in the writing... I assumed the control and power he gained from bossing around the bullies after being bullied and a target seduced him) who has similarities with Beum Seok wasnt entirely bad and even tho he looked composed, his actions came from a place of hurt and in the post credits' scene we see his choices took away the best of him. My favs were Gotak and Seong Je... Gotak had that straight forward way to say things.. wether it was insults or apologies, he did it all in a sincere way. he didnt beat around the bush and wasnt above apologizing when he did wrong. Seong Je... oh thevultimate wild card... Any Naruto fans here? He reminded me a bit fo Deidara with the nonchalant crazy attitude. I doubt he would comeback as the main villain in season 3 on his own but if he does, that would be exciting to say the least.

2
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

1
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Even though I think this season is worse than the extraordinary first one, I liked it too. It is lighter, it doesn't hurt so much, I didn't feel sadness like in WHC1. I like the friendships, the new group is lovely, they are so nice guys!
All the actors were good but imo the scene stealers were Lee Min Jae and Choi Min Young. I fell in love with that duo.

Suho (Choi Hyun Wook) still is my favorite character in this saga and I'm looking forward to seeing him in a third season being part of the team.

0
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

Re: Suho (Choi Hyun Wook) still is my favorite character in this saga
Si-Eun ❤❤ Su-Ho

1
reply

Required fields are marked *

Season 2 is as good as it is uncomfortable as the first season. I liked how Hoo-min and Shi-eun both struggle with the consequences of their violent behaviour and are trying to get away from it, only to be drawn back into fighting over and over again. They find it too hard to escape this vicious circle, also because of their newly found friendships.

This is also why I am still uncomfortable with both series. The problem with the Union and their criminal behaviour is again solved through a massive fight which I consider a glorification of violence. The writer does not allow for adults such as teachers, parents and police to solve the gang problem. The webtoon must have been written for teenagers/young adults and maybe this is reflecting the lack of trust teenagers may have in adults and their wish to be in charge of their decisions.

The cast and director did really well and if there is a third series, I will watch it.

2
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Thank you for the recap! I just finished watching this last night.

I understand that these events are from the webtoon. Honestly, I didn't think this season was as powerful as the original one. It had the best possible ending for the main character: his mother reached out to him and was worried about him, his friend came out of his coma, and he managed to make new friends and reform the new school. OK.

But the character of Si-eun in the first season was already angry and like someone who had lived through trauma, before there was a first fight. He was closed off and mistrustful of everyone. The boiling over of his rage at the end of the first season was cinematic and cathartic yet horrifying.
I am not sorry I spent those hours with the second series, but I don't think I would recommend it in the same way. I didn't believe these were high school students. I didn't even believe this was the same character, even though the actor was working overtime to sell it. Three or four years ago, he looked like an angry teenager. In this one, he looks like a short, deeply weary, depressed man. He looks older than 25 here. Don't get me wrong--I love how this guy works. He's ready to play serious roles. I just didn't like how he was written here. The pen schtick was amazing in the first season, but here he kept using it and failing with it. It felt like the writers had a few signature moves for him and wanted him to keep doing them.

The other actors who were supposed to be high schoolers all looked too old, with the possible exception of Choi Min-young in the thankless role of Seo Jun-tae. Ryeoun is a handsome kid but he's not a great actor. This is the second show where I didn't believe he was his character. I like how he uses his voice, imitating an adjussi all the time--but that's not a character by itself if you aren't doing a voice over.

All of which is to say, Weak Hero Class 1 was a strong show in terms of acting. Weak Hero Class 2 felt like it really was weak--as in, dilute.

6
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

The writing definitely did not try hard to sell the friendship. The characters volunteer once together and the next day Shi-eun has to decide whether it is a friendship worth pursuing.

The acting in this season also wasn't the best. The brief appearances of Hong Kyung and Choi Hyun Wook just made it clear how much better the characters' chemistry was in the first season.

2
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

I wonder who put that picture as Sieun's background haha
(Or whatever it's called). I was thinking either Baku or Juntae but it's still to think someone did it haha

1
reply

Required fields are marked *

I loved it!! Not sure anyone will read this as I'm late to the party as usual! But, it helps my heart to write my thoughts.

Thank you @solstices for this recap and Beanies for all of your comments and insight. I was disappointed not
to have individual episode recaps, but grateful for this detailed recap. 

I have just finished watching both seasons and I have surprised myself by how much I was captivated by this drama. I was not sure about the bullying and violence so I had never watched season 1, which might have been a good thing as I didn't have to painfully wait for the second season. I did have some trouble with the bullying, but it was not as bad as I had feared and I only FF through a few of the fights! The usual question pops up- where were the adults? But, as mentioned, we wouldn't have this drama if teachers and parents were doing their jobs. 

I loved everything about the drama. The art direction, writing, and acting were all spectacular. For such graphic material, it is odd for me to say that it was beautiful visually, but I was so taken with some scenes - the lighting, the framing - just lovely. I loved the gold tone to the dream sequences (I think that was season 1), I laughed so at how they all had umbrellas for the final fight! But, visually it was awesome. And, how they just pitched them aside when they started fighting (surprised they were not used as weapons!) and just left them there at the end! So many beautiful scenes like that.

I loved the intro for both seasons, and unlike my norm, I rarely skipped watching it as it seemed like part of the episode. The OST was perfect, especially the main theme, "Hero", by Meego.

The acting was spectacular. Again, JiHoon blew me away. Every emotion was written in his eyes. I was impressed with how his fighting skills improved and I loved how he always followed SuHo's instructions! I also missed his strategic thought processes that we had in season 1 and the little use of "found" objects to use as weapons. The best this season was the flower pot in the fight with Seong Je. Jun Young plays creepy too well! But, I was confused about him - was he supposed to be a student or adult gang member? I couldn't decide how old he was supposed to be.  I like Ryeoun, but as in past dramas, it seems like he is acting and I don't really feel that he is the character. Ba Na Rae was amazing - such interesting eyes that never seemed to be looking in the same direction! I was not familiar with the others and these young guys will hopefully continue to shine in future dramas. 

Season 1 was so much more special for me. I loved our three main characters and their friendship. I found their relationship to be more believable than the friend group in 2 which seemed to develop too quickly and was a little unbelievable.  Why would Hu Min and Hyuen Tak become such good friends with Jun Tae all of a sudden? That seemed odd. I did love how Jun Tae grew and became so brave and stood up for his...

1
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

continued....
I did love how Jun Tae grew and became so brave and stood up for his guys.

Oh, but I missed SuHo so much and his interactions with Sieun. They were the heart of the drama and it felt empty without them together. I felt Sieun's pain and hurt whenever we would see him talking to SuHo in the hospital and when he called SoHu's name (to HuMin), I just cried. 

I had read spoilers, so I knew that SoHu would be ok. (I am not mentioning how unbelievable it was that he was so healthy after being in a coma for a year, since we all needed to see him looking like we remembered him!) I do wish we had seen more of their reunion. After Sieun's long, painful wait for SoHu to wake up, it was hard to have such a short time with them. And, we needed an indication that they would still be together in the future.

Many have commented on the relationship between Baek Jin and Hu Min. To me, it seemed more about lost friendship and not much more. But, I have seen several clips from the recent cast reunion hinting about the relationship between Sieun and SoHu. I could go either way, there is definitely a special bond there, and I think it is lovely. I just want them together however we can get them and I am hoping for a season 3!

1
reply

Required fields are marked *