Bad Memory Eraser: Episodes 7-8
by solstices
As past trauma and lifelong insecurities resurface, our leads turn their focus inwards to examine what they’ve been suppressing all this while. Their hard work may be paving the path towards career success, but when it comes to love, their wires are as crossed as ever.
EPISODES 7-8
Reacting quickly to Gun’s arrival, Shin acts like it’s his first time meeting Joo-yeon. She plays along by pretending to leave work, and on the way home, she explains how she’s monitoring Gun as an outpatient case.
Shin gets chewed out by Mom when he returns home drunk, and the next day, he decides to play hooky by skipping his medical checkup. In a bit of perfect timing, Sae-yan overhears his bluff just as she’s in need of a ride. Her dad cut off her credit card in retaliation for her spontaneous Korea trip, so Sae-yan hops into Shin’s car to use him as a chauffeur in exchange for keeping his secret.
They wind up back in their hometown, where Shin gets roped into helping out in the fields (and tripping over himself, hee). Alas, Sae-yan has no luck finding the person she’s looking for, and her downcast demeanor is a far cry from her usual energy. When she barely responds to his teasing, Shin tries to pull a smile out of her by splashing her with water — only for her to toss him into the creek. His revenge? To drive away without her, all while flipping the bird. These two are such kids, LOL.
Stranded in the countryside with no way of getting home, Sae-yan calls Joo-yeon for help. Our resident doctor just so happens to be in her patient’s car, and Gun offers to drive her there. Not long after they arrive at their destination, though, Joo-yeon’s phone rings with a call from Sae-yan — she’s headed back to Seoul. Aww, Shin came back for her!
This scene really encapsulates just how similar the two brothers are — they don’t like admitting to it, but their actions demonstrate how deeply they care. They’re the type to go above and beyond for others while taking none of the credit, and I really hope their kindness circles back to them eventually.
Since their rescue mission is over, Gun stops at a roadside stall to sate his grumbling stomach. Out of the blue, Joo-yeon opens up about her late father. He’d poured his heart into work, approaching his patients with the utmost empathy and sincerity, only for one of them to fatally stab him.
Witnessing that traumatic scene made Joo-yeon seal her heart — until earlier that day, when she’d seen her apathetic reflection in a patient’s sunglasses. Her dismissive attitude, while a defense mechanism, might be inflicting even more pain upon her patients. She knows there’s nothing Gun can do to comfort her, but it’s still a relief to get it off her chest. In response, Gun notes that it’s the same for her patients — just having someone stay by their side and listen to their woes is in itself a form of comfort.
This advice proves pertinent when Shi-on collapses from nerves at the national team selection. Contrary to common rhetoric, Joo-yeon tells her not to stay strong. It’s okay if she isn’t good enough yet, or if she stumbles — what matters is the act of trying itself. Her best is as much as she can give, and that’s enough. Gun chimes in to reassure her that he’s rooting for her no matter what, and their encouragement has Shi-on stepping back onto the tennis court with a renewed confidence.
Plus, Gun’s come prepared. He knows Shi-on’s current skill level won’t net her a spot, but her strengths make her a formidable player in doubles, where her partner can cover her weaknesses. Shi-on will match up well with a certain player — Shin. Yesss, I love this combination!
Although Shin never plays doubles, he agrees for Joo-yeon’s sake, because Shi-on making the team would allow Joo-yeon to continue observing Gun as the team doctor. With that, Shi-on makes the national team, and after a bout of playing hard to get, Gun officially hires Joo-yeon.
Our leads may be bickering as much as ever, but their burgeoning feelings are beginning to peek through their prickly shells. It’s in the little things, like how Gun buys a charger for Joo-yeon’s flat phone battery but denies it was him, and how they end up in charged moments more often than not. Whether it’s Joo-yeon accidentally falling into Gun’s arms while changing the curtains, or her unknowingly leaning into his personal space, it’s clear both of them are affected by their forced proximity.
Stepping out of the hospital’s insulated bubble is doing good for Joo-yeon, because she’s gradually opening her heart to Sae-yan’s friendship, too. Last week, Sae-yan gave her wish bracelet to Joo-yeon as encouragement, and this week, Joo-yeon makes her one in return, though she downplays the gift. She even ropes Sae-yan in when Shi-on needs an Italian interpreter for her foreign coach, and the pampered rich girl Sae-yan can’t contain her excitement over her first job.
The meeting just so happens to be in the same hotel where the alumni reunion was held, and the location spurs yet another of Gun’s fragmented memories, reigniting the psychogenic pain in his right wrist. Meanwhile, Gun’s childhood friend BANG GUK-BONG (Lee Dal) confronts Joo-yeon, telling her to stay away from the brothers. What drove Gun to his extreme decision was having his first love — on top of everything else — snatched away by Shin. It dawns on Shin that Sae-yan, not Joo-yeon, is Gun’s first love.
He covers for Joo-yeon by acting unrepentant, which earns him a punch from Guk-bong. Though Shin’s words aren’t without merit — he hadn’t known who Gun’s first love was, so how could he have deliberately stolen her from him? After the confrontation, Shin admits to Joo-yeon that he’d been tormented by the guilt of inadvertently ruining Gun’s career. She reassures him, saying that Gun is happy now because of Shin’s decision to push him into the clinical trial, and Shin resolves to work together to protect Gun and prevent his memories from returning.
When a surprise visit by Mom and Dad has Joo-yeon fleeing Gun’s home office without her shoes, Shin finds her huddled outside in the cold. He rushes to his car to get sneakers and a blanket for her, but Gun arrives just then, and she chooses Gun’s slippers instead. Gun picks her up in a princess carry when she complains about the overly large slippers, and they bicker as Shin quietly watches from the sidelines. With a plaintive, wistful look in his eyes, Shin backs off for his hyung.
Unfortunately, our cinnamon roll tennis star can’t catch a break. When Shin tears up the contract renewal document, CEO Hong threatens him with the blackmail photos of the brothers’ scuffle. “That night, you pushed your brother over the railing,” CEO Hong surmises, while a cornered Shin quivers in anxiety.
I’m still insisting on giving Shin the benefit of the doubt, since everything we’ve seen of him so far paints him as kindhearted and self-sacrificing, rather than a vindictive assailant. I think he’s covering up the truth of the incident both out of guilt that it escalated that far, and out of a genuine (albeit misguided) desire to keep Gun happy and safe. Perhaps both their festering resentment boiled over that night, culminating in an outburst that neither could take back.
Now that Gun is being proactive and investigating his memory flashes, I’m starting to warm up to him again. I’m still not sold on the chemistry (or lack thereof) between him and Joo-yeon, but I like that he’s mellowed out beyond the comical caricature of the previous weeks. He’s figured out that he hadn’t been rescued from a fall at home, but from the Han River, and he’s no longer taking his family’s words at face value. I wonder what secrets lie within the old diaries that he used to write in, and what Shin will do with them now that they’re in his hands.
RELATED POSTS
Tags: Bad Memory Eraser, Jaejoong, Jin Se-yeon, Lee Jong-won, Yang Hye-ji
Required fields are marked *
Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *
1 Seon-ha
August 25, 2024 at 3:03 PM
What I love most about this show is that after all the ridiculous things that happen--like throwing a professional tennis player over one's shoulder into a shallow river, having roadkill burials, waking up to kissing a dog passionately because you're dreaming about kissing a woman, and teaching a pre-pubescent boy the best way to HIDE YOUR BEER--having a therapist fall in love with a patient under their active care seems, somehow, tame.
See ya next week! LOVE this show.
Required fields are marked *
DK-Drama ❤️🎄 Giffing n Space Cadetting 👼🏻🌟
August 25, 2024 at 3:20 PM
What worries me most in all this is that honestly, that dog did not seem to give concent at all.
Required fields are marked *
hacja
August 25, 2024 at 5:53 PM
Is Cola a male dog's name? Because if so, I was thinking that maybe he was fleeing from his own sexuality, understandable in a homophobic Korean society.
Required fields are marked *
Mr Everything
August 25, 2024 at 6:55 PM
I thought that the dog is female (and a therapy dog) and that when they got it, ML gave it a male name and they didn't have the heart to correct him... does that ring any bells?
Required fields are marked *
hacja
August 25, 2024 at 5:45 PM
I think its very telling about the way this show's narrative has been constructed, that until you mentioned the therapist-patient ethical issue, I HAD COMPLETELY FORGOTTEN ABOUT IT. I was totally fixated on whether the countryside would smell that much of poop that there would to be three jokes about it.
Required fields are marked *
Seon-ha
August 25, 2024 at 6:12 PM
...and each with their own ambiance and flair! One, where I thought she was saying that Italy smelled like shit (Fighting words, lady!). Another--that I had tried to suppress--in a car where it was really quite clear that "he who smelt it dealt it," and the third that, like most things in this show, came out of nowhere, made no narrative sense whatsoever, and led to the only obvious follow-up question, "What was that??"
Required fields are marked *
hacja
August 25, 2024 at 8:36 PM
Thanks for highlighting the subtlety of the poop jokes, which I hadn't noticed. It also brings up a question: was the writer more focused on getting several sophisticated poop jokes into the story, or in constructing a logical story? Whatever, I respect that choice!
Required fields are marked *
Elinor, Team Glasses team co-captain 🕯️
August 25, 2024 at 9:12 PM
The poop-smell jokes were a miracle of narrative and symbolic cohesion compared to the therapist-ing. That is so spectacularly mishandled that it’s hard to say which aspect is the
worstbest: Joo-yeon’s absolute incompetence at both counseling and research, emotional attachment to mice, lying to and about her patients, or moving in and developing a romance with one of them. It’s a grand slam. I also loved that after her realization that she’s the worst psychiatrist EVER, Gun consoles her by telling her things completely unrelated to what she’s said - and then nothing changes. She’s still the worst! Can't someone tell Shi-on to RUN?God, I love this show.
Required fields are marked *
hacja
August 26, 2024 at 6:36 AM
I have to stop making comments about this show, because it isn't that interesting--at a basic level, its just bad. But just one thing about Joo-yeon's realization. A disturbed patient killed her Dad, pretty horrifying, and she was reminded of that when she saw a reflection of herself looking bored as a patient talked. Does that mean she was suddenly afraid, if she was inattentive, that she would be stabbed as well? Because the lesson that "her Dad was such a dedicated psychiatrist that he was killed by a patient" does not seem like the one you'd draw in this circumstance. And Gun's advice "just be by their side" doesn't seem like the best thing to say either.
On the other hand, looking bored is a heckuva lot better than pushing for an experimental lobotomy based on a single mouse experiment, as she did in the first episode, so I guess there's some sort professional growth trajectory going on.
Required fields are marked *
Seon-ha
August 26, 2024 at 7:41 AM
No judgment here. I have spent an inordinate amount of time mulling over the intricacies of this absolute trainwreck of show. Thing is, it's like the outline of a very complex and fascinating look at what it means to really fuck up your kids. But because it's not fully fleshed-out...it leaves so much room to consider what could be in these gaps.
As for your direct thought here, my most generous interpretation was that she really loved her dad and wanted to be an empathetic psychiatrist just like him, but being that sort of doctor was what got him killed. And so, traumatized by his tragic death, she was unable to be the person she wanted to be, only the frightened damaged girl who lost her father to something he loved (more than her???). Just spitballing because there's only the bare-bones of a plot here, just begging to be clad in meat.
DK-Drama ❤️🎄 Giffing n Space Cadetting 👼🏻🌟
August 26, 2024 at 2:29 AM
I think I am in total K-drama mode ... I am totally allergic to therapist-client/patient relationships, I hate that like the plague, also if propagated in anything like realistic ways ... and yet, I haven't even given that perspective a single thought.
To her K-drama defense, this treatment is dependant on the patient staying in some kind of illusion, and she "had to" pretend that they were true. While keeping up with that and not having the chance of backing away, it could be an ordeal to stay cool.
Anyways, though she is obviously caught in by his charm and constant physical presence, hrm hm, I hope she will end up with the brother.
BTW, my own therapist when I had one, told me she had been active in introducing the concept in Denmark that dating patients should be absolute taboo. (Not as in "We don't talk about it" but as in "We don't do it").
ONe psychologist had countered their argument with "But how am I gonna meet a woman otherwise?"
Ew.
Nota Bene, it was many years ago, idk, 70's or before that.
Required fields are marked *
DK-Drama ❤️🎄 Giffing n Space Cadetting 👼🏻🌟
August 26, 2024 at 2:34 AM
Oops, I used the word "propagate" being almost certain what it meant and I was wrong.
What I meant is, I don't like therapist/client relationships in movies and books either.
Or teacher-pupil relationships, maybe unless they are both at least thirty, and with no remarkable age gap.
Required fields are marked *
Seon-ha
August 26, 2024 at 7:47 AM
Why do you suppose so many shows go ahead and delve into these uncomfortable relationships?
DK-Drama ❤️🎄 Giffing n Space Cadetting 👼🏻🌟
August 26, 2024 at 11:15 AM
For teacher-pupil relationships its a fantasy for little girls to date someone they look up to, and teachers should just hate those stories if they have any sense. But some of them IRL don't. Have any sense.
Generally when psychologist fall for their patients on film, it's the dark dangerous types (I think?), but in this case his obliviousness and vulnerability is part of the package ... (ew, really).
Well, and of course, that whole thing evolves aroung societal grooming. There seems to be quite a bit of that in many K-dramas. (+ in Pride and Prejudice).
Elinor, Team Glasses team co-captain 🕯️
August 26, 2024 at 8:51 AM
Eh. This show is a ridiculous fantasy and I can accept whatever nonsense it presents as “therapy,” as a one-off. It does bring up the issue that when every single show that deals with mental health at all, seriously or speciously, presents treatment as a complete joke that does more harm than good, that eventually becomes the meta-message, whether that happens on the first show or the tenth. It’s pernicious and it’s hard for me to overlook it in a whole season of dramas that are wrongheaded in the same way. This isn’t the worst, by far, since it so obviously cannot be taken literally as a representation of mental health treatment (side-eye at Slump, among many others). At least it mostly gets the tennis right.
Yikes! to the "meet a woman" guy!
Required fields are marked *
hacja
August 26, 2024 at 10:17 AM
We all know that in kdramas, the only therapy that ever works is love.
But, speaking about tennis, as a tennis enthusiast I might disagree that the show actually gets the tennis right, but of all the issues that this show brings up that is the least concern!
vienibenmio
August 26, 2024 at 1:06 PM
As a mental health provider, this is something I really hate about kdramas. Especially with all of the trauma and PTSD that is very, very treatable but no one ever actually does treatment for it (aside from maybe taking meds, which is not recommended over psychotherapy)
vienibenmio
August 26, 2024 at 1:08 PM
Yeah, i can't watch this drama then. I cannot handle any piece of fiction that has a therapist/client romantic relationship (fun fact, we had to watch Prince of Tides in my graduate psychology ethics class and write an essay on the ethical rules she broke. Hoo boy).
In the US our code is that we can't date a patient until 2 years have passed since the end of the therapeutic relationship. A lot of people think that's way too soon.
Required fields are marked *
hacja
August 26, 2024 at 1:40 PM
Of course, in this one you would never be in any danger of mistaking the FL for a therapist, so I think you could safely watch this one without getting offended. If you were an aficionado of Italian coffee, though, you'd have to skip a key scene to avoid being outraged.
2 DK-Drama ❤️🎄 Giffing n Space Cadetting 👼🏻🌟
August 25, 2024 at 3:37 PM
I don't think Shin tried to kill him either. More likely, he was trying to prevent him from jumping, and they got into a that argument that ended with Gun undeliberately falling over that fence.
Required fields are marked *
3 Mr Everything
August 25, 2024 at 4:30 PM
Most romcoms are like a Subway sandwich. They are everywhere, and the flavor is comforting and familiar with not a lot of spice. BME is more like spicy chicken feet. The meat of the show is a bit unpleasant but the spiciness is strangely addictive. My favorite moment was the battle rap scene. Dr Han is such a romantic. Also, the spice might give you some intestinal distress, on your way back from a countryside roadtrip. I can't tell if I think the acting here is great, good or horrible. But, I am amused by the action so far.
Required fields are marked *
hacja
August 25, 2024 at 6:18 PM
This is a funny metaphor but an apt one, given that at times the show's gristle is almost impossible to swallow, and yet there are actually some pretty humorous exchanges that flavor the dialogue. Plus, speaking of food and beverages, the instant coffee PPL with the Italian coach was pretty hilarious.
Required fields are marked *
Mr Everything
August 25, 2024 at 6:58 PM
Like where the mom tries to guilt trip Shin by saying they neglected his brother for him... I thought we were trying to be a better mom since your other son tried to kill himself?
Required fields are marked *
AmnesiaYawns
August 26, 2024 at 3:25 AM
My head spun like in the Exorcist, honestly … making it Shins fault that she dropped her other son the second he wasn't useful any longer. That was a deliberate choice.
I did love his response of calling her Queen Dowager, I hope he keeps that up.
Required fields are marked *
4 hacja
August 25, 2024 at 9:01 PM
Just in testimony to the appeal of this show, I'm currently live watching 4 other weekend shows, and yet this is the show I turn to watch first! Okay, admittedly its to get this show out of the way before I get to the high quality acting and writing of Good Partner and Blackout, but still, its a testament to this show, in some way or another.
The one thing I didn't like about these episodes is that, for whatever reason, the writer seems to think it important to have every member of the cast, including Cola, the dog, fall in love with the FL. I kept asking -- what about the 2FL, Jeon Sae-Yan? What is she, chopped liver? She's attractive, smart, and, lets face it, a lot more charming and personable than the FL. Oh well--we'll see how far the writer wants to pursue the brother's love triangle, and then maybe bring in Yoo Te-O again to realize that he also is in love with the FL? Oh no!
By the way, If there are any DB participants idly checking in on this, wondering if they should start watching this show, increasing the viewership ratings from .04 percent to .04001 percent, just look at the quality of the recap and the commentators (present commentator excluded, of course). @solstices doing the recapping, @attiton, @ceciliedk, @mreverything -- I'm not going to say this show is so bad its good, that would be going way too far. Rather, I'll say this show is so bad its interesting, in a weird way.
Required fields are marked *
5 Elinor, Team Glasses team co-captain 🕯️
August 25, 2024 at 9:25 PM
The editing of this show is either a masterpiece of non-linear storytelling or was done by a rogue riding mower. So many scenes come out of nowhere and disappear back into the void without advancing the plot or our understanding. What was the purpose of Shin’s and Sae-yan’s trip to the countryside? 10+ minutes of complete bafflement, followed by a waterfight. And of course, while you’re waiting for help in the middle of nowhere with darkness coming on, the most natural thing is to sit in the middle of a stream with your feet in the water. The second-most natural thing is for Gun and Joo-yeon, on their way to the rescue, to stop to have a romantic moment burying roadkill, a phrase I never imagined I would type.
I can’t even be sure the confusion about “who is the ML?” is intentional. I still have a flicker of hope that the leads will swap love interests, because that would introduce the first element in this show that makes any sense at all, but the totally unnecessary princess carry points to “no.” And I keep remembering that this was filmed two years ago, so there’s been plenty of time for edits and re-edits, and this is what they chose to keep. I can’t imagine what got left out. Drag musical numbers? Cannibalism? But it’s not over yet! Of course I’m going to keep watching.
Required fields are marked *
Mr Everything
August 25, 2024 at 9:48 PM
I thought the purpose of the trip was to drumroll that there is a mysterious past that she and the brothers share, which 9 times out of 10 will suggest that she was the first love, until it reveals that Shin was actually her first love and someone else is Gun's first love (as we see in the opening credits).
I think it also is meant to show how right they are for each other. He helps her in a time of need and she helps him get away from his controlling parents and his obsessive compulsive disorder. Falling into a dirty field is the opposite of obsessive compulsive.
Required fields are marked *
Mr Everything
August 25, 2024 at 9:52 PM
Oops one more thing. There were already two falls, the one on the hill and the one at the love shack. The physical fall always means that they have fallen emotionally as well... so, don't hold your breath. But I share your pain. I wish writer-nim would focus more on the plot than letting unsteady feet do all the heavy lifting.
Required fields are marked *
hacja
August 25, 2024 at 10:18 PM
Your lawnmower analogy is a good one, but I think it should be combined with @mreverything's chicken feet metaphor: that is, a rogue riding mower chopping up some spicy chicken feet. That captures the essence of this show for me.
Required fields are marked *
AmnesiaYawns
August 26, 2024 at 3:34 AM
Great, now I'll spend all week asking myself what ended up on the cutting room floor. I'm hoping for a subplot for the mom in full valkyrie regalia singing a Wagner aria about how being a mom is like being a serial killer. I mean, we had the rap battle, so it's not too far.
Required fields are marked *
6 runningmanfighting
August 25, 2024 at 10:49 PM
I suppose I'm the only one who doesn't seem to like the 2ML and FL romance. I can't understand why everybody finds them so adorable, I skip over all the scenes that they end up together in - not saying the FL should end up with the ML either - show, you need to provide more proof.
I also don't buy that the ML literally tried to commit suicide by jumping into the river. He may have been suicidal, but he definitely had trauma related to water and that wouldn't be his choice (as was subtly implied, since the ML was surprised he has no trauma related to stairs after having almost lost his life in it - not something a writer would mention if they didn't want to point to the fact that that means he must have some trauma related to water). I do think Shin pushed him - but most definitely by accident. No matter how much you want to side with this guy, you can't pretend that he didn't play a role in the neglect his brother faced at home. If this weren't a drama, Goon's experience at home would definitely be construed as straight up neglect and abuse. (No matter how much you hate you brother, it shouldn't pass your notice that he's holding an umberella over your head while standing in the rain himself.) Nope. Sorry. Can't excuse this. Don't get me wrong, love the actor, love the acting, love the complexity of this character - but I still can't treat him like he's one of the good guys - just can't. He's definitely shady, and I do think he tried to get his brother's memory, not only because he actually believed that removing his bad memories would make him happier, but also because he had a hand in him almost dying.
The only character that actually has any of my care and attention is Goon. Any scene which does not progress his story is a waste of time. (And Sae Yan for being such a cutie!)
And omg, who here does not hate the mom? Talk about bad parenting! She singlehandedly destroyed the dynamics of her whole family. Everyone's messed up because of her parenting choices.
Required fields are marked *
7 Pan cake
August 26, 2024 at 7:13 AM
I think the memory of Gun is right about Ju Yeon as his first love. It is all entangled as they lived in a small village for a short time. I have no complaints about Shin but their parents wow, he lost his career, Dream, and confidence and you made him the manager of his younger brother, the sole reason for his loss. For me, the highlight of episode 8 was Ju Yeon thanking Shin for being considerate of his brother and Gun thanking Shin for bringing slippers for Ju Yeon, the transition phase of the drama. Lastly, I'll take a minute to appreciate the stylist of the drama, nice job the matching coats got my attention and they look awesome.
Required fields are marked *
runningmanfighting
August 26, 2024 at 10:14 AM
I agree, I think the FL is the first love and the show's just trying to throw us off so the reveal can be a shocker. Also, absolutely agreed, ep 8 was the transition phase, so far they've shown us how much they don't like each other and how the FL would be better off with the 2ML, because they want us all to split hairs on who the actual couple should be. There have actually been subtle signs that the FL cares about the ML more than a lab rat and was moved by him. Subtle, very subtle, but there. She obviously does have more chemistry with the 2ML, but it's going to dissolve into "lifelong friendship" or whatever i.e. come to nothing. I'm curious about where this is headed ... Is her research going to fail with the conclusion that a person should try to overcome their failures, rather than erase memories of them? Or the show's planning to save her research somehow - which would be absurd. Or something else?
Required fields are marked *