166

Open Thread #865

Happy Friday everyone!

Here is your Open Thread, which is here for you to chat about anything you want, whether it be drama-related or not. Nothing’s off-topic here! Spoilers may be rife, so proceed accordingly.

 
RELATED POSTS

166

Required fields are marked *

TAROT, the upcoming Korean TV series of seven self-contained episodes, premiered in 
April at the Cannes International Series Festival with one episode, “Santa’s Visit,” starring “Parasite” actor Jo Yeo-jeong, It became the first Korean series to compete in the festival’s short-form competition section for TV/web series/short programs. Buoyed by the reception, the series’ production company and distributor, LG Uplus' STUDIO X+U, announced Monday that it will release the first three episodes of TAROT in movie theaters in June, then later releasing all the episodes. The thriller mystery series follows ordinary people facing ominous fates after stumbling across tarot cards that predict the future. Each episode unfolds with different stories and separate protagonists, all beginning with them discovering a tarot card.

The movie release will have Jo Yeo Jeong’s episode as well as Dex’s lead role in “Throw It Away” and “Going Home,” starring actor Ko Kyu-pil from the action film “The Roundup: No Way Out.” Perhaps, it is the current blockbuster Don Lee film that got TAROT’s producers to pivot course and release the series as a bundled movie since Koreans this year are actually going back to movie theaters. According to the Korean Film Council's (KOFIC) monthly report on the Korean film industry, April’s box office revenue reached a record high of 63.6 billion won ($46.4 million) last month, marking the second consecutive month of breaking revenue records. March also saw record-breaking admissions, fueled by the huge success of the occult movie "Exhuma." This figure was twice as much as the 31.8 billion won recorded in the same month from 2017-19, before the COVID-19 pandemic impacted the film industry.

Also, the theater release does not stop STUIDO X+U from further licensing to platforms, TV networks or overseas broadcasters.

But this is the first time I recall that a Korean TV production changed distribution so dramatically. Usually, when a film is going to be a flop or underperform, studios would go directly to DVD or cable channels instead of adding the cost of theater film marketing and film distribution costs. Disney did this during the pandemic. STUDIO X+U proclaims itself as a content creator and not just a film or TV production company it must be thinking outside-the-box in an attempt to maximize its star power in the first three episodes. However, it does beg the unanswered question: how did the stars actually get paid when they filmed their roles? Signing up for a web series or small cable distributor like ENA is a small budget/small pay scale model compared to theater film budgets. Also, Korean traditional broadcast contracts have the actors paid after an episode is aired while film actors get paid up-front before filming.

4
4
reply

Required fields are marked *

Very interesting. Thank you. How long does a hit like Exhuma usually take to get to a streaming service like Netflix or Viki?

0
2
reply

Required fields are marked *

It is hard to say. There is one report it will stream on HBO Max in November, 2024 but there is another report that it will stream on digital platforms like Apple in June. It was distributed for limited release in US theaters in March.

1
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

Good to know they do get on eventually

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Well, I'm glad it's getting positive reviews but since it's horror, I won't be watching even if one of my top faves (Seo Ji Hoon) stars in one of the episodes. Together with Lee Joo Bin (mildly interesting after Queen of Tears).

Thanks for the update @welh640

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

9TAILEDVIXEN'S THOUGHTS OF THE WEEK:

1. RANT OF THE WEEK

I have switched from Google Play to Kobo for my e-books because Google Play suddenly decided that the country my account is registered in doesn't match the location I am in... which is nuts because I am in the country my account is registered in.

To cut a long story short: I had a long back-and-forth with them which ended with a stalemate - them telling me they can't release my account because there has been "strange activity". Yes, Google Play - that was me trying to buy an e-book while I was travelling abroad (which I had told you about TWICE in the correspondence to fix this situation) because the eejits did NOT tell their customers they are not allowed to buy their digital (yes - DIGITAL) products outside their country of residence.

So now I can't buy e-books nor use Google Pay because of Google's idiocy. No matter - as I said, I switched to Kobo (who showed EXCEPTIONAL customer service to me helping me set it up and troubleshoot any hiccups) and I have other payment methods I can use.

And just like that, they've lost a long-standing customer who has bought thousands (yes - THOUSANDS) of e-books from them.

I've checked and apparently, this is becoming a common problem with many people facing the same thing.

Take note, Beanies who use Google Play!

. GETTING (UN)STUCK IN THE MIDDLE WITH YOU

I have been making plans for long-overdue mid-career moves and am struck by how complicated it is to do this at this point vs at the beginning of my working life.

It needs proper planning and there are just so many preparations and arrangements to make - one can't just quit jobs/pick up sticks and move jobs/countries.

I'm just happy I'm single and child-free. I heard from married friends that it's at least 50% more difficult making such changes with kids and a spouse in tow.

Any Beanies ever made big changes/moves mid-career?

3. THIS WEEK'S KOREAN WOMEN'S NEWS

(a) Young women in South Korea spend $700 a month on skincare. Now they're risking their jobs, relationships, and status to revolt against the K-Beauty industry.

One-third of Korean women between the ages of 19 and 39 have had some kind of cosmetic surgery, according to a 2020 Gallup Korea poll — 66 percent said they would go under the knife to improve their chances on the marriage market. [

Yet some South Korean women have had enough.

Since 2018, hundreds of thousands of them have taken to social media to post pictures of themselves cutting their long locks and destroying their makeup. They storm the streets in baggy clothes and spectacles.

They called their movement "Escape the Corset."

https://uk.movies.yahoo.com/news/young-women-south-korea-spend-150000641...

8
7
reply

Required fields are marked *

THIS WEEK'S KOREAN WOMEN'S NEWS (CONTINUED):

(b) BLACKPINK's Jennie Makes Billboard Hot 100 History As 1st Korean Female Soloist To Chart A Song For 20 Weeks

On May 14, Billboard revealed that “One of the Girls”—Jennie’s collab with The Weeknd and Lily-Rose Depp from their HBO series “The Idol”—was now spending its 20th week on the Hot 100 at No. 97.

With this achievement, Jennie has become the first Korean female soloist in history to chart a song for 20 weeks on the Hot 100—and only the second overall, following PSY.

https://www.soompi.com/article/1661537wpp/blackpinks-jennie-makes-billboard-hot-100-history-as-1st-korean-female-soloist-to-chart-a-song-for-20-weeks

1
reply

Required fields are marked *

UPDATED LINK FOR THE "ESCAPE THE CORSET" ARTICLE SINCE MY FIRST COMMENT CUT OFF HALF THE LINK:

https://www.businessinsider.com/k-beauty-women-south-korea-spend-700-month-skincare-2023-5

5
reply

Required fields are marked *

Google has been running wild with these mess ups on accounts and locations and vpns! 😑 It is one thing to have a buggy application, completely another thing to have a bug in something as huge and encompassing as Google which messes everything and cannot be undone even by themselves!

2
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

I am just washing my hands of Google Play and Google Pay for now.

Kobo has what I need and I have other digital wallet options anyway.

2
reply

Required fields are marked *

Your beauty comment was fascinating. Some people claim about the endorsements interwoven into dramas but they are obviously VERY effective. I am a women who has never worn makeup- a minority for sure- but I love this “Escape the Corset idea.” For 66% of women to wish for surgery is alarming. I don’t think they wanted to marry any more. I have always been happy in my own skin. I would wish that for anyone, no mater who they are.

5
2
reply

Required fields are marked *

I used to have to wear make-up because I worked in a profession where looking sharp and stylish was essential.

Then I quit that profession and started working in two different ones that do NOT need me to wear make-up unless I'm going for a TV interview or doing events (in-person or livestream). The kids I teach don't care if I wear make-up or not (though hilariously, they quite enjoy rating my hairstyles including my brightly-coloured hair); the activists I work with and survivors of gender-based violence I help don't give a fig about whether I wear make-up or not either. What the kids, the activists, and survivors care about is whether I can do my job effectively - lives and futures are at stake.

It was and is a blessed relief, I'm telling you.

I do look after my skin with a K-Beauty skincare routine, that much I will do because it's part of looking after my body. And I do like going to my stylist twice, maybe three times a year. It's part of self-care and looking after my body.

But yeah, I ditch make-up and nowadays I no longer sacrifice comfort for style in my clothes.

3
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

Such an interesting outlook. I never thought about the fact that most women in Korea, from the article, are working professionals where it is expected. I’m glad you have a career now that allows you to be you. Thanks

3
reply

Required fields are marked *

I wrote this before but again, for the sake of possible engagement, I'm posting it again.
Why is the back half of W: Two Worlds so forgettable to me? I just saw a video and I was like "they got married?!"

I think I've seen the drama twice and I never remember what happens after he jumps off of the roof. I think he jumped off things like 2 or 3 times haha.

But the reason this show came to mind is because I think it reminds me a bit of Lovely Runner. It has a interesting premise and then somehow just loses the plot while also having moments that stand out with the couple. Is this a pitfall of fantasy shows?

Same thing happened with The Heavenly Idol: interesting premise -> loses the plot

I think I've seen somewhere someone say the problem with W: Two Worlds is the villain was overpowered and then they couldn't really course correct. Personally, I'm not sure what they could've done differently. But I just don't know why the back half is so forgettable to me (until I'm reminded)

2
5
reply

Required fields are marked *

I enjoyed W: Two Worlds enough, but can't remember even the first half very well (I watched it within the last six months). For me, the reason is that the twisty-turny, timey-wimey stuff was slightly too complicated for me to keep in my mind...as well as the "other" comic-based complications that the drama interjected.

In sum, it was too complicated for me, and the resolution didn't make those complexities fall together in one satisfying "Kathunk! Ah, now I get it!" for me (like when you finally find that puzzle piece in a jigsaw). That said, I do remember "who did it and why," ...and I do remember some very striking visual scenes.

Also, apropos of nothing (🤣), I also still really like A-ha's "Take on Me" video: https://youtu.be/djV11Xbc914

3
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

It's crazy to me how memorable yet forgettable that show is to me haha

I'm fairly certain that was my first Lee Jong Suk (with him as a lead) drama. Certain it was my first Han Hyo Joo (I didn't even know her name).

1
reply

Required fields are marked *

I belong to a writing group (we write fantasy) and the general rule of thumb is:

If your story world is complex/has complex mechanics, your story needs to be VERY clear and easy to follow. It's all about balance. One of my writing group members is really gifted at this - they create really astonishing fictional settings and then populate it with memorable characters going on adventures that are pretty easy to follow.

I really liked W: Two Worlds and I can remember the story quite well but I think maybe they should have toned it down with the twists and turns or really leaned into some of the more effective twists. Too many twists and most people end up forgetting half of what's happened.

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

W: Two Worlds is a longtime favourite of mine and I have rewatched at least once or twice although it was quite a long time ago now however if memory serves me correctly there wasn't a proposal or wedding scene. We were left with the understanding that they would have an ordinary life as a couple for the next 50 years or so.

My first ever kdrama was Romance as a Bonus Book so anything with Lee Jong-Suk is a must for me except I couldn't finish Big Mouth as (throwing myself under the bus now) I find Yoona unwatchable...ouch!

1
reply

Required fields are marked *

I just finished watching the C-drama Parallel Worlds. The rules governing the alternate world were so random and inconsistent (at least to me) that I gave up trying to follow them, and just went with the flow. I still ended up to enjoying it.

But oh how satisfying when a show gets alternate-reality/time travel right! Those are some of my favorite dramas: Kairos, Live Up to Your Name, Life on Mars, Circle, Signal, My Perfect Stranger, et al.

3
reply

Required fields are marked *

Comment was deleted

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Happy Friday, Beanies! I feel like I've been citing being busy as a reason for not-so-well-prepared posts way too often lately, so today there's one more excuse – power outages lol. Not that it is/was VERY bad, but rather untimely for sure... Anyway, that doesn't stop me for giving yall something at least – how about more lame dancing on top of usual singing? I have no idea why we got so many videos of LYN doing THAT instead of many other possible things he's actually decent at, but alas, gotta work with what I've given. At the very least we all will have a good laugh)))

But some vocals first – to prepare ourselves for the cringe and all. Newest OST and, surprisingly, it's not for his currently airing show like you'd expect, but mobile game “Honor of Kings” and its two main leads having a cheesy romantic duo for Chinese Valentine's Day (May 20th fyi), performed by LYN and Shan Yichun – female vocalist he already collaborated with once on YOUR SONG S3 (I shared it before). Must say, that song was infinitely better musically, but at least we got a whole proper MV this time and they both are madly pretty here. For real – if composer did a job half as good as stylist's, we'd gotten an award winning track! Also mermaidXnon-mermaid ships are super funny by default – once you start thinking about the logistics of such romance... ahem Title is “To be continued”, no subs found anywhere atm:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_x7kafzGo7k

To cleanse our ears from all the saccharine above let's listen to something more meaty – like this old cover of “The City” (I think... this was particularly hard to translate). That's him freshly post-debut, before any substantial idol makeover – awww, the untrimmed eyebrows! He really does look a bit funny like that)))
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9X27D7VKJFU

More city-themed stuff – this time it's “Moonlight in the city”. Idk what's so funny here for him to smile so much – something about lyrics or was it comments online? - but I feel genuinely attacked, pls tone down your blinding charm, mister!
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tpxxcWm26NU

You know, he performs certain songs MANY times, which often makes it really hard for me to choose just one video – usually I go for where he sounds the best or it's remarkable for other reason, but sometimes it's a tie and my brain hurts a lot from such decision-making. Guess that's a curse of dealing with madly talented artist – you want to recommend everything because all of theirs is THAT good! Like this song - “A little happiness”, OST of Taiwanese romcom “Our times” – he obviously likes it a lot to sing over and over, not making my job any easier as result... In the end I picked the most viewed clip - that's got to mean something, right?
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YB56-cObCeQ

3
8
reply

Required fields are marked *

Not to stick to livestreams alone, here's a stage performance – also an old one because I'm having a blast lately digging his rookie and predebut stuff, he's just so cute in his giant fetus era. Ofc there are certain limitations to it - I'm not gonna share the footage from “before fixing his teeth” period out of respect to man's image, for example (I won't hesitate to massacre anyone who mentions my looks pre-braces and he likely feels the same). Other than that, count on me to share the fun))) Song is called “A million possibilities” and while I'm not the biggest fan of the jacket, at least it's not a fugly curtain robe covering them legs, already an achievement! Why did they do that to poor drummers tho?
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0YVYDXTcj7c

Not to say that he ALWAYS looked funny in his early days – that's far from true. He's particularly hot in some of his old MVs – like here in “Ah tacit understanding”. I mean, damn, boy, who allowed you? This is sensually moody in the best way possible – the colors, the angles, the hands-on-face shots (that was sinful, ngl)! I don't mind to re-use that PD for his next album as well – if he ever finishes it ofc...
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=R3qK7leJ3Sg

Bad quality version with subbed lyrics if you're into weeping hard. Love hurts indeed, huh?
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZKg7owaLvO0

OK, enough with sadness, even wet sexy one – let's laugh at silly dancing! First are two practice videos of his HEROES (2024) sect dancing to mandopop (I also shared it before) because why the hell not. Folks say he was the one to choose the song, hah. Guess that means he wasn't beaten blackmailed into the whole thing, right? Final cut version:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=g6dNdzalPa4

And more of an actual learning and practicing process. Feat blink-and-you-miss-it tiny ponytail and utterly unimpressed by her dad's lack of grace Daimi)))
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qvbmTlJ7R3Q

THE TRUTH S2 cast in futuristic styling from upcoming episodes doing some trendy challenge, I believe, wonderfully out of sync (he's not even the worst one, omg!):
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IOy8yvfaDO0

Solo practice – I don't think any additional comments are needed, the footage speaks for itself^^ Was the blatant focus on his... assets really necessary? And then WE are the ones called perverts!
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LmLuVdbmdJA

3
5
reply

Required fields are marked *

5
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

Ohhh love the new goodies! 😘
I appreciate you for all you do to share the Liu Yuning love! 🥰

2
reply

Required fields are marked *

Thank you! It is awesome as usual. I must say the videos are much much more interesting with your accompanying comments. ❤

2
2
reply

Required fields are marked *

You're welcome)))
I can't help it, honestly, so good for yall to like my chattiness^^

2
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

Very much.

2

Comment was deleted

0
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

And now I'm gonna wonder forever what was there...

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Happy Friday, chingu! Thanks for all the Yuning love!

1
reply

Required fields are marked *

Someone please give me insight, why is the SK’s medical staffs are against their government policy to increase the quota for medschool admissions? Aren’t they always understaffed and overworked? (I get the facts from k-drama though, so …). Even so, I don’t even understand why are they have to have a fixed number of seats to begin with. Shouldn’t the number of student accepted is based on how many people passing the required test?

1
7
reply

Required fields are marked *

Fear of competition.
More admissions at medical schools means more doctors in the market in a few years.
Yes, there are shortages of doctors in many areas like OBGYN and pediatrics because many doctors want to practice in the lucrative practice areas of cosmetic surgery and dermatology (which is not covered by national insurance.)
Even medical school professors are against the increases for a personal reason: the schools are not hiring more professors to meet the new work load.

7
2
reply

Required fields are marked *

I may have overreading it, but is it safe to say the residents that are complaining mostly are the one who aspire to be specialist in the aesthetic field? Because if I am an OBGYN, or Peditrician, or ER doctor I would like additional fellas so I can have some sleep.

1
reply

Required fields are marked *

One possible solution would be for the government to offer financial incentives for med students to go into specialties where there’s a shortage. The government could also pay all or part of med school tuition in exchange for the doctor spending the first X number of years practicing in areas of the country where doctors are in especially short supply.

3
reply

Required fields are marked *

I understood it as such: current medical workers have been asking for better pay/work conditions for a while, got none ofc and instead government now basically threatens them with "suck it up or we'll replace you with all this new blood". Feel free to correct me if I got the gist of this debacle wrong.

4
2
reply

Required fields are marked *

I mean, doesn’t better work condition means more people? Because they are overworked and in need of someone to take some of the load. Better pay wouldn’t resolve the working long hours problem.

0
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

It doesn't seem to me like there is a way to ensure that all those new medical students will choose specialties where more people are direly needed, so to a certain degree protesting doctors are right - more new doctors will likely just increase the competition where it's already fierce while the actually shorthanded areas remain unfixed.

Overall, I think it's one of those situations where everyone has a point... and also everyone kinda looks like jerks rn because the problem festered too much already.

6
reply

Required fields are marked *

If I remember correctly I read somewhere that first the medical staffs started asking for better pay and work conditions, and then the medicine universities started pushing for more quota to help ease the work load. The government increased the quota so little that it made everyone angry because they basically listened neither to the universities nor the medical staffs.

3
reply

Required fields are marked *

It's my Dramabeans Birthday today. One year old.

I've blown-out some Dramabeans candles, eaten some Dramabeans cake and made some Dramabeans wishes, some focused on the fact that javabeans is back posting and the possible implications of other small changes that have been happening to the staff (Hello, @starrygazer !) and to the interface...others about how I'd like the dramas for the rest of the year to be more engaging and, frankly, less polarizing.

When's your Dramabeans birthday? And even if it's not soon...what are your wishes for the remaining dramas in 2024??

24
67
reply

Required fields are marked *

Happy Dramabeans Birthday!

Is the birthday the day one discovers the site or the day one makes an account?

7
13
reply

Required fields are marked *

Thank you!

For me, my Dramabeans Birthday is the date I first took the plunge and posted a comment. I'd been lurking for quite some time--and had even had an account for quite some time. But I just HAD to defend the ending of Call It Love, so here I am! 🤣

What spurred you to post your first comment @midnight ? I know it was longer than a year ago!!! ❤️

6
12
reply

Required fields are marked *

I loved the ending of Call It Love! Too bad I wasn't here yet to join in the defense!

3
reply

Required fields are marked *

I was trying to remember--did you get a lot of responses to your defense of the ending of Call it Love? Because I hated the ending of Call it Love, and would have been sure to respond-- considerately, respectfully, of course, the way i always do--but in such a convincing way that you would have completely changed your opinion, so that your second post would have been a retraction of your first.

5
3
reply

Required fields are marked *

Actually, all joking aside I've had my opinion of shows changed many times after asserting it strongly but then reading the other comments and realizing they had an excellent point--and of course commentators like @attiton have influenced my opinions enormously.

8

No, your Eye of Hacja- hadn't yet cottoned on to the fact that I'm helpless in the face of intelligent taunting...

In fact, @jerrykuvira hadn't even said anything in particular incendiary about Call It Love except that it was an "agonizing love story."

I disagreed with Jerry, like you ~always do~, respectfully. ;)

2

Wow, the Dramabeans comment censor is averse to Tolkien jokes today...I'll try again without the accented character:

THE EYE OF HACJA-DUR

5

This makes sense! I discovered DB on April 2010, but I remember I made my first comment on Scent of a Woman ep 1 , because the male lead sounded so much like my favorite Georgette Heyer male leads! So sometime on July 2011.

5
reply

Required fields are marked *

@attiton It might be useful to think of me as the eye of Sauron, watching balefully from a distance. Keep your comments in line, or you're going to have to deal with some orcs!

3
reply

Required fields are marked *

Oh wow you took note of the day. I dont even remwmber when I signed up and when I posted my first comment. I will look that up.
I was similar, I did a lot of lurking before posting my first comment. I think I posted as a guest first before officially signing in an account.

3
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

I haven't 😄😄 I just know the exact recap that I saw the first time I opened DB, and I looked up the date for that. And I looked up the airing date of Scent of a Woman. I can never memorize dates 😅

Also, if you had posted as a guest with the same email address that you later made an account with, db automatically connects your previous posts to your account so you can't discover when you joined by your comments.

3

Call it Love was pretty much at the top of my list for 2023. I was actually staying in Seoul when it first started airing and was staying near the wall where they walked and sat. The only negative for me was the drip of a sister...

PS Happy Birthday!

1
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

Thanks! Wow, that's quite a real-world connection to Call It Love!!! I'm assuming that the air around that wall wasn't actually, and quite mysteriously, all pink? 😂😉

1

I don’t recall the pink but the air was scented with cherry blossoms 🌸

1
reply

Required fields are marked *

Oooh, congratz!))) Mine - 2 years as an official beanie, tho I've been a lurker for ~8 more before that - will be somewhere very late in December, few days before NYE, I believe. Need to go back and check - I think I still remember which article I made my very first comment under.

Regarding wishes... More watchable dramas, esp from SK. Less projects cancelled/shelved because of scandals/taxes etc. Less cyberbullying towards artists (why is it always my faves to have this particularly bad - am I some jinx or what?!). Don't see any of that easily achievable tho(((

5
4
reply

Required fields are marked *

Looks like @marcusnyc20 was the muse that spurred you into action 😂

Still have the same opinion about the lack of "edit" feature now? I stand firm in my belief that it's a good thing we can't edit--it keeps the baddies from doing more bad stuff and makes me (a half-baddie??) think just a little bit more before posting!

4
3
reply

Required fields are marked *

Yes, that was it! Lol I really had a very boring NYE that year, didn't I?)))

I certainly can live even without an edit button... but comment preview option to fish out all possible mistakes would've been a wonderful alternative. Esp for a wordy antihero like me who always posts A LOT)))

3
reply

Required fields are marked *

Happy DB Birthday @attiton Seon-ha and thanks for the shout out.
I do remember that conversation with @gikata about “The Golden Hairpin” which evolved into “OUR BLOOMING YOUTH” which seems to be having a second life here lol. We were probably two of the few beanies that knew the complicated story behind the creation of OBY. It was a full year after that conversation when OBY finally aired and (whispering) sorry to report I made it through episode 14 (of 20) of OBY and pulled the ripcord.
If and when (possibly August) the cdrama THE GOLDEN HAIRPIN finally airs (I believe on Tencent) I will be there.

4
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

You stopped at the right time with OBY, it only went downhill from there on)))

I'm casually optimistic that TGH who managed to stay not-fully-dead even after all that backstage drama will see the light of day eventually. Now, how watchable it's gonna be after such massive reshoots is the real question.

1

My first DramaBeans birthday will be September 12 if going by my first comment (which I think is a good marking point). I was being my usual practical self and helping Blue (@mayhemf) find The Kidnapping Day on amazon Prime.

I popped into DB on and off for over a year, but started regularly reading sometime last summer and then finally made an account so I could start participating. The end of year wrap-up got me posting on my fan wall (thanks to how-to posts you were making last fall Seon-ha!) I'm excited to do the wrap up again this year!

Once I started posting, I haven't looked back. DB is so much fun for me and I appreciate beanies and this unique online space so much. 🤗

My K-drama wishes for the rest of this year: Less threadbare tropes, more realistic portrayals of relationships (c-dramas are spoiling me in this regard), and no more serial killers.

11
3
reply

Required fields are marked *

😅 I do remember this title being so hard to find on Prime! Something good came out of that chaotic searching. Glad you joined DB!!

3
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

Prime wasn't making it easy to find k-dramas at all! I think it's improved, but I'm glad I had a reason to finally join in the fun on DB. Thank you Blue!! 💙🩵

2
reply

Required fields are marked *

With you on the fewer tropes and serial killers, and yes, I've also found China has been doing a much better job of portraying complex, interesting relationships recently.

4
reply

Required fields are marked *

No way you’ve only been here a year! 🎂 You’ve accomplished so much! You made me look this up, my first post were in January 2011 (😲) but I had been lurking since the beginning.

Yay, looking forward to more years of enjoying your talents!

7
5
reply

Required fields are marked *

Wow, 2011!! That's amazing! I didn't even realize DB had been around that long.

3
4
reply

Required fields are marked *

Yeah, the veterans of that time also include @midnight and @asianromance plus many more...Beanies like @bbstl and these folks are inspirational, full of wisdom, and are often the reason we come out of hiding and join in the conversation!!!!

As an aside, we owe thanks to our DB overlords for some great website management decisions that allow us to see (and even interact!) with the history of this site in its earlier incarnations!!

12
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

You're too kind 😘

3

Javabean's first post is dated January 14th, 2007

https://www.dramabeans.com/2007/01/yet-another-side-project/

10
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

❤️ Wow!

1

Happy DB Day!
How do you tell when you joined. It’s been less than a year for myself

3
3
reply

Required fields are marked *

@23new2kdrama I don't know of a way to tell when you first made your account if that is what you mean by "joined" (although the admins would know). But the way you find out when your first comment and/or Fan Wall post was is first to go to your profile page here:

https://www.dramabeans.com/members/23new2kdrama/

The tab that says "Comments" shows all your comments and the tab that says "Fan Wall" shows all of your Fan Wall posts. Then you just go to the first one...and look at the date: In your case, December 11, 2023 at 8:15pm PT. 😉

Everyone can do this, replacing your own user name (not your screen name but your at-mention name) where it says "23new2kdrama" above.

In fact, everyone can see everyone's comments and Fan Wall posts this way, so if you want to ensure to interact with certain folks, you can book mark their public account page and be certain to like and reply to all of your Beanie Besties™!

The fastest way to get to another Beanie's profile page is to click their screen name (or their avatar) at the top of any of their comments or fanwall posts...

6
2
reply

Required fields are marked *

Thank you. I learn new things everyday. I joined because I was tired of the adds but so intrigued with what was going on. And I was thrilled to discover the Beanie count. It was love since then💜

4
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

Also, if you are on a phone, choose view desktop site in your browser settings so that you see page numbers at the bottom of the first page of your comments, that way you can easily click on the oldest page. On the mobile view format there are no page numbers and loading more comments will start driving one crazy very soon!! 🙃

4

I started lurking before there even were accounts (maybe 2010ish?) but didn't actually post anything until 2013. I haven't found this year too exciting k-drama-wise so far, so I'd love to see that change in the coming months.

5
reply

Required fields are marked *

Happy Dramabeans birthday. Your comment influenced me to check mine as well. It is 4/11/2022. The day I first commented and shared my thoughts with fellow beanies.

5
reply

Required fields are marked *

It might be a crazy idea but what if we collect all beanies' dramabeans birthday to see who was here the longest. Anyone on board?

3
3
reply

Required fields are marked *

I think that's like asking a "lady" her "age." We'll all always be 35 😉

5
2
reply

Required fields are marked *

😁

1
reply

Required fields are marked *

😂😂😂😂😂😂

1
reply

Required fields are marked *

Happy Dramabeans Birthday! 🎂🎁

4
3
reply

Required fields are marked *

Thank you! It's been quite the year. Lots has changed. Although, not as much as it has changed since 2008, I bet...my Beanie sunbae!!! ;)

3
2
reply

Required fields are marked *

Oh you bet so much has changed since 2008. Despite all that, DB is still a fun space to talk about anything kdrama. 😁 thank you for all you do to help in making this a great place to hangout! ☺️

6
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

Thanks, and right back at you!

3

Congrats on this special day I can NOT believe it's only 12 months since you joined the comments and expanded the fan wall world for so many beanies.

My first comment was 8th May 2022 so I just had my second DB birthday and it never ceases to amaze me how much time I spend on here and how great the beanies are.

9
12
reply

Required fields are marked *

Thanks, Reply. You were one of the main reasons that I joined in, and any contributions that I have made to this community have been an effort to mirror your openness and generosity. ♥

I'm particularly pleased to see the Fan Wall Community Watches have taken off!!

6
6
reply

Required fields are marked *

Happy birthday @attiton! I am such a newb I haven't even done six months here yet, but I look forward to celebrating my first bd next year!

Please continue my ongoing education by explaining what the Fan Wall Community Watch is??? Colour me intrigued 😁🙏

2
4
reply

Required fields are marked *

Sure thing...aigoo. :)

Fan Wall Community Watches are where folks get together--not in a closed way, but in a truly open way--to watch a past drama together sort of like a live-watch recap.

Here's one that I participated in for Mad Dog: https://www.dramabeans.com/members/Elinor/activity/1473516/

And there's one recently completed for Our Blooming Youth here: https://www.dramabeans.com/members/Seeker/activity/1580584/

Keep your eyes peeled on Open Thread, WWW and on the Fan Wall when folks start these...everyone is truly welcome to join in if you want to watch/re-watch the dramas!

4

Currently we have See you in my 19th life - @claire2009 and @23new2kdrama and we are going to start Soundtrack #1 and Signal soon.

3

Thanks for the info my beneficent beanies! 😍
I am kind of interested in the See You in my 19th Life, except... do I remember seeing people complaining that it has a tragic ending?? Not sure if I am down for that if so.....
But definitely interested in Signal. Will these be on your wall @minniegupta1? Or do you think you could @ me when it starts?? If that's not too much bother..😊

3

@Aig00iness See you in my 19th life doesn't have a tragic ending, its ending and some parts of the story are just deviated from its source materials (the webtoon). If you and @minniegupta1 decide to start it, can you please tag me when you have comments/reviews/etc for that show? It's my newly found gem. And we'll make sure to tag you in Signal CW, starting mid June :)

2

Thanks for your kind words, this DB community has so many generous beanies who modelled how to maintain a safe warm place and I tried to reflect that🥰

2
reply

Required fields are marked *

@attiton @reply1988

My official comment was on March 22nd, but I am sure I browsed through for a couple of days before that before thinking whether I should join. I also remember my first reply was to fellow beanie (whose perspective I absolutely love) was @gikata. I just rented a room in the rooftop and planning a party next week ;-)
But it's amazing how much this has come to be a part of my life. I am travelling for the weekend, and I am already missing it which is not a great sign because I am supposed to be celebrating a milestone birthday of a dear friend with a bunch of girlfriends.

5
4
reply

Required fields are marked *

Have a great trip! No fair checking how many notifications 🥰🥰

2
reply

Required fields are marked *

I feel a personal responsibility here, for better or worse... Just kiddin'^^

Regarding rewatch party groups - I see that HAPPINESS is probably pushed further into July at this point, right?

1
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

Yes, ~the last week of July, Gikata.

2

Have fun at the real life celebration and when you next log in hopefully the weekend go slow will be over and you can catch up stress free.

1
reply

Required fields are marked *

mine was Sept 8, 2011... of course i had to comment on the last episode of Myung Wol the Spy -- cuz Eric was my love...

9
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

Eric 🫰🫰

4
reply

Required fields are marked *

Happy DB birthday!!

So that post about you asking to get in line wasn't you after all! And you are a younger DB than me!!

3
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

Get in line for what? I'm already in too many lines to want any others ;)

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Happy beanie birthday, Seon ha!
I'm with you, dramas we have fun talking about are the best. Good talk, tho. These days it feels like all I want to do is to diss shows but no, I genuinely would prefer to have something good to say.
I still have hope since the year is young.

Mine was on April 13th (first comment with an account). I'm four years old.😂

4
2
reply

Required fields are marked *

Right? May in particular has been very disappointing for me. I'm choosing silence over complaint, but that also means I don't get to have the fun conversations!!

With luck the true summer dramas will bring more delight for us all!!

1
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

Yeah! Let's hope the second half of the year give us all the gems we're looking for. ☺️

1
reply

Required fields are marked *

Happy DB birthday, Seon-ha!

My DB DoB is 12th April 2020. But I knew of DB before that, when I carried out my own treasure hunts. I don't remember when I created an account, but I think I had logged in to like beanies' comments for some time before posting my first comment.

2
3
reply

Required fields are marked *

I don't have any particular wish for the remaining dramas in 2024, I just wish DB would load faster, if it loads at all, because half of my time is spent waiting for DB to load 😂

3
2
reply

Required fields are marked *

LOL. The eternal complaint of a loving Beanie. I have personal experience with the fact that it matters where you are in the world, unfortunately. Those of us in the US have it much easier, I'm sorry to say... I've been in around six countries during my First Beanie Year, and I've NEVER had as much trouble at home as I have had abroad. Grr. I don't think it's our Beanie overlords fault--it's the fact that the internet is only a bunch of gentleman's agreements ;)

1
reply

Required fields are marked *

Amen to that😂😂 and wish for some more functionalities

2
reply

Required fields are marked *

Jung Ryeo Won, Wi Ha Joon's "The Midnight Romance in Hagwon" Swept Up in Controversy.

https://mydramalist.com/article/jung-ryeo-won-wi-ha-joon-s-the-midnight-romance-in-hagwon-swept-up-in-controversy

2
4
reply

Required fields are marked *

I think they should have waited for the end of the drama to judge the whole message about education instead to judge one scene or one episode. There are Kdramas about school like Black Dog, so I won't see an issue that a drama focused on academies.

Their education system is far from perfect...

8
2
reply

Required fields are marked *

I agree. It seems very premature for them to react so negatively to the very beginning of a 16 episode drama that's just laying down the main conflict and characters. Where the show starts is hardly where it's going to finish, and what story would there be if it began with a rosy, flawless depiction of the relationship between tutors and teachers/hagwons and schools? At most, I could see them giving a short statement to the press about how the depiction so far doesn't match reality, but even that seems like an overreaction to me.

And as you said, it's hardly the case that the education system is perfect, so again, this objection at this stage in the drama seems way too defensive and unfair.

6
reply

Required fields are marked *

I'm hoping tvn won't issue an apology here because Ahn Pan-seok is known for his unapologetic social commentaries. It hit a nerve; that's the point. I don't know this rookie writer, but I hope she won't change the script.

6
reply

Required fields are marked *

Given that, as I've written, there are very few favorable portrayals of teachers in kdramas, the only thing interesting about this controversy is why they bothered to protest this particular depiction. It must have been the edits of scenes appearing as memes that bothered some at the association.

Anyway, I doubt this "controversy" will gain any traction, although you never know about the policing of Korean pop culture. I'm always shocked when dating "scandals" result in issued apologies.

2
reply

Required fields are marked *

Being a parent is physically, mentally,and spritually taxing, its also rewarding and wonderful in its own way.

I feel like people are too scared to admit the first part because everybody will accuse you of being a horrible mother (or father, but men/husbands never get shamed as bad as moms/wives).

10
8
reply

Required fields are marked *

I can't open up to this to anyone in case they will call me crazy/selfish/heartless. But I don't see myself as a mother. I can play with kids for a while but having a kid myself isn't something I wish for or more precisely sth I am scared of.

3
6
reply

Required fields are marked *

You are not alone with this, I am sure there is a secret club somewhere with a growing membership.

4
reply

Required fields are marked *

I applaud you for your honesty in this safe space. Making a choice that will affect your lifetime is your right- I wish more people would put this kind of thought into having children. Although I have chosen a very traditional life and feel blessed to have my children does not mean it is right for others. I look at people’s hearts and celebrate their differences and find friends everywhere because of that. I’m not perfect at it but it’s my life goal. You must be who you are meant to be💜💜💜

6
reply

Required fields are marked *

It's not for everyone and that's absolutely all right. But even when one does become a parent, this is what I always say - kids make you a different person, and they fulfill a part that's hard toe xplain. However, it's extremely important that parenthood should not define one's existence. they fly the coop in eighteen years more or less, and are checked out for half of those years, but then they also become your pillars on the other side of it.

5
2
reply

Required fields are marked *

The grammar nazi in me is actively hating the typos and the punctuation errors in the post above, but please ignore them because I hate the 'deleted comment' posts.

4
reply

Required fields are marked *

I love your comment about pillars. Blessed to see this in my own family although each is a different size and shape, playing a different role.

6
reply

Required fields are marked *

Thank you all for your comforting words❤️❤️ It gave me solace ❤️❤️

5
reply

Required fields are marked *

Thanks for raising this, it is sad that the gender differences in terms of parental roles and responsibilities and the attached expectations and judgements are still showing up in this day and age.

6
reply

Required fields are marked *

Lee Joon Gi had a fan concert this week and during it, fans once again asked him to do a fluffy, cute, modern romance/romantic comedy and once again he said he wants to do one but he doesn't get those offers.

And I just can not see him doing fluffy at all. I feel like it would feel like something is missing if he didn't put someone in a leg hold or kick someone haha

Maybe a romcom where he's a self defense instructor?

I would never want him *not* to get to play a romantic lead since that's what he wants to do, I just can't imagine it in any way, shape, or form.

I can see him doing stuff like Flower of Evil which did feature some romance & the family dynamics. I could even see him in a dynamic like Vincenzo, where the couple has a bit of a flirtatious will they, won't they/protective/reluctantly caring vibe. I just can't see a straight "fluffy" romance.

The last romcom he did, that I know of, was Hero and that was meh. Like the overall show is alright but still meh haha. I liked elements of it but yeah...
Not the greatest show of romantic comedy potential (in my opinion). It's alright and fine.

Again, maybe it's just because I personally am not into romance like that (even imagining a fluffy romance made me gag cause it made me think of alot of cringy aegyo (like in Lovely Runner)).

I didn't watch Tell Me You Love Me and the only reason I'm mentioning it is because it was a love story before older characters. Would that kind of romance fit Joon Gi?

When I read webtoons, I sometimes wonder if any actors could play the roles if it were adapted and I've yet to come across a romantic character that I thought would fit him.

I guess I just have a limited imagination.

4
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Happy weekend Beanies and keep Beaning On!

My absence last week worried some Beanies, so another belated apology. I will try to redeem myself with this recap!😀

May has been busy. Lots of holidays with beautiful weather are perfect for visiting all the yearly town fairs and hosting our niece’s first communion celebrations in our garden. My body did well enduring all that on little sleep.😀

The most important thing keeping me and my mind busy has been work. My sick leave has finally ended and I restarted work part-time in another department. I seem to have a cool and patient boss for once, so I am cautiously optimistic that things will finally work out for good, since lots of people tell me they have a good feeling about this.😀

Tomorrow I am hanging out in the city with my two friends, as we do every few weeks, it will be lovely to catch up, eat some delicious sushi, and hopefully buy some nice stuff!😀

9
4
reply

Required fields are marked *

What a lovely update! It sounds like many good things have been coming your way!! Have a great time with your friends tomorrow 🤗

2
reply

Required fields are marked *

Good to see you here this week. I am on my desk top typing this as it means I can use my under desk treadmill to help burn off the frustration while I wait for my comments and likes to post. If I had been using my iPad as per usual, I would have added lots of happy emojis.

How lucky for you all that the decent weather meant the first communion party was outdoors, happy memories for your niece and the rest of your family.

So happy to hear you are settling well into work so far. Enjoy the rest of May with all the fun activities you have planned.

2
reply

Required fields are marked *

I'm glad everything is going well at work. ^^

I hope you have a great time with your friends. ☺️

2
reply

Required fields are marked *

Life is moving forward in many directions for you. 😊 Hope you had a wonderful weekend and a happy working week. Take care. See you in the next OT. ❤

2
reply

Required fields are marked *

Oh! Also during his fan concert, Lee Joon Gi mentioned how in the past, dramas were filmed and then like immediately aired (were filmed concurrent with the airing)

And it made me think about do people appreciate that shows are now finished or maybe mostly finished with production before they air or do people miss the old model?

Personally, I appreciate the shows being done rather having them at the mercy of fans/viewers' reception. Especially in this time of social media. Oh my god, can you imagine the effect people would have on shows if they were still being written or filmed to appease everyone.

3
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

I'm always trying to explain my love (and hate) of romance kdramas --why some of them I find particularly affecting, with scenes that I watch several times, while others I end up totally despising. (This is apart from the issue of whether they end satisfactorily, the ending being something I am often disappointed in.)

I saw this thoughtful review of Anne Hathaway's new rom-com-- https://www.newyorker.com/culture/cultural-comment/the-idea-of-you-and-the-notion-of-the-hot-mom -- "The Idea of You" a movie which, with its noona romance and critical portrayal of netizen fan culture, sounds as if it was lifted from a kdrama. But this particular movie aside, what I was interested in was the reviewer's assertion that rom-coms are primarily a vehicle allowing viewers to "transform shame and insecurity into wish fulfillment." The reviewers argument is that viewers identify with the main character's (usually female) humiliation, and then triumph vicariously when love removes the shame.

So in this movie, the reviewer argues, the shame is being a fan of a good looking male idol, but the triumph is being a single mother so attractive in various ways that the good looking idol falls in love with her.

Of course, I immediately thought of Lovely Runner, where the FL definitely moves from being a fan, and one that is humiliated because she is in a wheel chair, to being a loving "Mom" who has to sacrifice to save her stunningly good looking "boy" who loves her without reservation.

But I'm not so sure that the vicarious move from shame to triumphant love is what always appeals to me in romances. I certainly like the triumphant love part--but very often I'm turned off by the shaming, especially when its performed by initially obnoxious male leads. But then I'm thinking , to go back Lovely Runner and others--are serial killers the stand-in (very extreme stand-in) for male shaming? and is that why they appear so often?

Anyway, anyone have an alternative theory that explains why they like or dislike kdrama rom-coms?

5
35
reply

Required fields are marked *

Thanks for the really interesting comment! I think it is an interesting theory regarding shame/wish fulfillment in rom-coms. I find most rom-coms follow very similar underlying themes that seem to cross culture and media (romantic novels). There is nearly always a very beautiful heroine that must overcome obstacles. Those obstacles will be overcome with the help of a handsome and caring man (man will become caring if not from the start). Queen of Tears follows these themes completely. The idea that it is shameful to not have a partner in love seems to have a grain of truth to me. Another possibility is the idea that the only antidote to shame is finding love. That could explain why viewers get upset with sad and/or love unfulfilled endings like Yumi’s Cells. I don’t know that the serial killer theme is a way to shame men but may actually be a stand in for the idea that the woman cannot be safe without the love of the man. Strong Girl Bong Soon is a play on this theme that I have always found very creepy. Bong Soon may be safe because she has special powers and has a man, but other women will not be safe and will end up in cages. K-drama rom-coms are my least favorite genre. I love romantic stories but I find the underlying themes unsatisfying and predictable.

4
2
reply

Required fields are marked *

Thank you for your reply @amfalulawatching It seems to me that a lot of romance kdramas place the woman as the ML's savior and or therapist; escaping the serial killer is not necessarily a declaration of powerlessness but rather independence from (again, extreme) male dominance.

But I do agree with you that heterosexual rom-coms in the end make the argument that not just love but a lifelong partner is the only antidote to the dilemmas faced by the main character, (who is generally the heroine.).
Still, as someone who is one of those disappointed by the ending of shows like Yumi's Cells, or another show that comes to mind, Dr. Cha, where the heroine's triumph is her realization that autonomy and self-reliance will supply all the happiness she needs, I will justify myself by saying that I like to think that while, in real life, romantic love should not be thought of as necessary for self-fulfillment and independence, it can in fact be a facilitator of self-assertion and independence. I remember @jerrykuvira made this point about Dr. Cha--why couldn't she free herself from her oppressive husband, achieve medical success, ride a motorcycle AND accept the love of Dr. Kim?

I guess the reason I prefer rom-coms to kdrama genres such as sagueks or modern day political intrigue/corruption stories is that in those, the entire theme is the nature of political power--whether its pursuing power or the corruptions of power. In contrast, the fantasy of love as a solution is very appealing to me!

1
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

...why couldn't she free herself from her oppressive husband, achieve medical success, ride a motorcycle AND accept the love of Dr. Kim?

She totally could have. In fact, usually "she" does. Only this time, she didn't.

1
reply

Required fields are marked *

With any entertaining story, there needs to be a believable journey of the main characters. There needs to be a real world factual foundation/experiences so a viewer can believe in the characters and how they solve their problems. In general, the main problem with recent rom-coms is that they lack balance and a complete story. They are either light on the romance or light on the comedy.

There will be always obstacles in the main couple's way (friends, family, work, miscommunications to now serial killers) to the finish line. Shows are having a harder time sticking the landing.

I do not buy that watching TV shows such as rom-coms is viewer "wish fulfillment." The only wish the average viewer has is to be entertained and not insulted by a bad script, bad acting or bad direction.

9
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

I'm totally with you on believeability, even in fantasy rom-coms. Despite how fantastic the premise--time travel, ghost-human interactions, reincarnation, superpowers, grim reapers, etc. if the human motivations and behavior don't ring true throughout than the story is not going to appeal.

As far as wish-fulfillment in rom-coms, I guess that does depend on how much identification viewers experience with the main characters. I generally empathize more with the female characters than the male ones--perhaps, going back to your first point, because I find kdrama male characters generally less plausibly written than female ones. But obviously, there is a limit to which I, as an older male viewer, can live vicariously through a much younger heroine, so my wish fulfillment, if that is what I'm experiencing, would have to be general--the enjoyment of seeing love triumph, for example, or the victory of an underdog.

Whether that common viewer sentiment is more prevalent in rom-coms I'm not sure, but I do think it is a common viewer motivation, although certainly not the only one, for many stories across all genres. The wish to see justice, or the triumph of good, or the emotional satisfaction of romantic love is probably not necessary for entertainment, but it has kept me watching shows that I would otherwise not find entertaining!

6
reply

Required fields are marked *

Rom-coms aren't my favorite genre because they tend to follow very predictable plot arcs (couple meets, couple breaks up, couple reunites), but I'm weirdly simplistic in that when I do watch one I'm looking for sizzling chemistry and a fun sense of humor (that whole romance and comedy thing), and I'm not sure how shame figures into either of those things in a meaningful way. Believable emotional beats are a nice addition as well, especially if the show has a more melo or slice-of-life vibe.

6
2
reply

Required fields are marked *

I find that all kdramas genres--even slice of life ones--follow really predictable tropes, so one's preference just depends on whether those tropes "speak" to one's perspective or not.

Its true that with a couple of major exceptions (noble idiocy being one) I find romance tropes to be more appealing, and generally funnier than those of other genres, but I agree the best rom-coms are either ones that sell the romance as something that includes both physical and emotional attraction, OR are smartly self-aware, making clever fun of the tropes as they employ them.

I guess if you think of the way rom-coms employthe very common "redemption" trope, that's where the shame comes in. I can actually see this in pretty much all the recent romances I've watched, although I agree what the reviewer calls "shame" is not necessarily what is overcome, or redeemed.

4
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

Tropes are definitely a k-drama thing and quite widely spread around, but my rom-com issue is more of a structural problem and one that extends to the genre in general, not just Korean ones. There tends to be a lot of tension and excitement up until the couple gets together, and then the writers flounder around for reasons to pull them apart to fill up the second half of the show. The best romances find ways to do this that feel believable and creative, while the worst ones insert amnesia, noble idiocy and trucks of doom (or, god help us all, serial killers).

6
reply

Required fields are marked *

When analyzing my favourite rom-coms, I find that the journey the leads have to make is more on the mental than the physical side. They grow up, but in a way that make them richer emotionally but not necessarily in terms of money or caréer advancement. This I can relate to, even though I'm neither candy nor chaebol. I Am Not a Robot comes to mind.
Dramas I haven't liked (or liked but have difficulty remembering) take the route of happiness equaling successfulness through changing your outer circumstances. I dunno, every work place has its challenges, the process just starts over. It leaves me hollow. A good rom hurts at some point. The ending might be bad, but life is too. I can forgive this (mostly) - and more importantly, forget.

6
reply

Required fields are marked *

Have you watched "The Idea of You," btw? I did a few days ago, so I found it interesting to read that excerpt--which I guess is more or less persuasive, even though I'm not sure I completely see his argument because the FL herself is not a fan of the boy band here eventual lover is in when they meet. (Hot Take: I liked it, found it poignant and affecting in the angsty bits, and thought Anne Hathaway was really good in it, but I can't say I'll go back and rewatch).

Anyway, I ended up liking the movie more than I expected to, and after reading your question, I think it's probably due to the same reasons that explain why I like romances more generally. I used to think, as many do, that it all came down to wish fulfillment--that is, the tendency to see oneself in the FL and imagine that the handsome, talented, brilliant, young, sexy, whatever ML is in love with you by proxy. But when I really think about that, I don't think it's at all true for me and never really has been. I like a relatable FL, but not because she's like me or could be me, but that she seems like a normal person. And I never imagine that the ML is or could be in love with me or someone like me. Is this because I'm content with my own romantic life or because maybe the idea that people love romcoms because it's playing out their fantasies is just way off base?

Either way, I think I've always loved romance because when done well, it hits on all the major aspects of human existence, including but by no means limited to finding the ideal romantic partner. The best ones incorporate a variety of relationships, conflicts, humor in the everyday, and professional struggles, and then, some measure of triumph on all fronts by the end. No other genre does that or, at least, not in a way that is as meaningful to me.

Kdrama romcoms or romances (I do prefer the more melo ones, to be honest) are appealing because they do this kind of integrated storytelling so well. On a shallow note, I also tend to find them more successful in terms of finding, casting, and directing leads who have more reliable chemistry than many Western shows do. It may also be that Western romances often include more explicit sex than you'll find in any kdrama and although I don't think that's necessarily a bad thing (for instance, I thought the sex in "The Idea of You" was well done and necessary to the story), it does mean that kdramas have to spend more time cultivating attraction between the leads than maybe Western shows do.

As far as your question there at the end about serial killers standing in for male shaming, I'm not exactly sure what you mean. But I see it more as a reliance on the patriarchal trope of women needing to be rescued by men and/or protected by men in order to be truly safe and happy in society. That's the underlying message I find to be present most often. That said, I do admit that I don't hate these kinds of scenes, likely because as much as I might want to...

4
2
reply

Required fields are marked *

dismantle it, I'm still a product of patriarchal norms, and seeing the ML willing to sacrifice himself to save the FL does feel cathartic and fulfilling within the context of romance.

3
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

I'm with you 100% @laurensophie that I don't ever "see myself/project myself" into the female lead's position. If anything, @hacja and I are inverses of one another (given what he said above), with him empathizing mainly with the FLs, and me empathizing mainly with the MLs.

Any wish-fulfillment there would have to do with wielding the idealized, unearned respect and power that "being male" would offer--and I suppose there's some of that. I know in the real world that "being male" isn't all that, but in rom-coms it can be. This is rarely the same for the lead women, that is, they're not usually in any native position of grace or dignity until the attention of the men either saves them, or just as often, the men's attention to the women draws the women's attention to themselves so that they can make internal changes.

2FLs on the other hand often draw my attention, especially/even the more villainous ones, because they have the capacity to take action.

Now that I'm down this therapy lane, this is also probably why Hong-jo from DWY never bugged me with her crazy, dangerous antics--at least she was doing what she wanted without reference to anyone else when she went to that hole in the ground in the middle of a deserted forest because a serial killer sent her a picture of said hole...

4
reply

Required fields are marked *

In my case, this is pretty much impossible because (1) I don't know what shame is, and (2) I usually think the reward isn't worth the trouble.

I relate to the characters in a personal level, but it never has anything to do with the romance (getting the guy/girl). I like watching the character's journey more than the result itself.

That's why shows were the focus is all in a underdeveloped romance (like Lovely Runner, Wedding Impo, Sam Dal, QoT), don't hit that hard to me. I sometimes even end up hating the couples or one of the leads (usually ML), because of how little growth they had, and how much the show only cares about making the two be together just because cute. And a show making you feel like someone is too good for you, or that your worth is in someone choosing you, is definitely not my type.

The romance is just a bonus, imo. Like watching a kid on the street smile, or hanging out with someone with good vibes. Just additional positive energy? 😂
The romance only becomes the prize when it has a firm ground to stand on. But I feel like that works better in melodramas than romcoms. TMTYLM, JBLovers, FoEvil, for ex.

6
2
reply

Required fields are marked *

@enriquequierecagar If I could speak for the reviewer (given that she is female and I'm male, is this a kind of "mansplaining?" yes, I think it is.) I think she would agree that the point of rom-coms is the female lead's journey, and in the case of this movie, from unrecognized Mom, to a Mom celebrated as a woman through the recognition by the hot pop idol, without sacrificing her role as mother. (I haven't seen the movie, and I trust @laurensophie that it has a more complex message than that.)

I get what you are saying about not finding the love part of Kdrama romances that important to you, because the portrayal of love often is the FL subordinating her interests to that of the man, even while she "changes" the ML for the better. I don't like those type of romances myself. In fact my favorites are those where there is mutual growth, and love is a culmination of that growth. There are some good Kdrama romances in that regard.

Lovely Runner is an example for me of one that started out great (in my terms) and has progressively weakened (in my terms). The FL moves from passive fan "crippled" by the serial killer, and simply inspired by her idol, to one taking direct action for her idol, and in the process taking control of her own life. The ML, at the same time, moved from someone passively crushing on her, "falling" into an idols career, to active pursuit and then making a career choice based on her guidance.

BUT now it lost that thread, (again in my opinion) and its just the FL sacrificing for the ML; in fact pretty much giving into her fate as shaped by the serial killer. So where at first I might have been more enthusiastic for Lovely Runner than you are, now I'm probably in complete agreement with you on that show.

1
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

You're right about Lovely Runner.
I think in the first week or two, dancingEm said she expected the show to focus on a healing journey for Sol. And I hoped the was case.

Like you said, she started "taking direct action for her idol, and in the process taking control of her own life."
So I was expecting for Sol to be able to learn something about herself in this journey to the past.
And I thought she was going to learn to feel okay and be in peace with her present.

But now I don't even know what's the point of the show.

4
reply

Required fields are marked *

Same on love-hate with romcoms, kdrama ones in particular. My main problems are that I: a) often disagree with their definition of funny/swoony personally and culturally; b) find the traditional investment in relationship gender imbalance where ML pines/loves/desires/sacrifices for FL way more than she ever does for him rather off-putting and not romantic in the slightest (unpopular opinion, I know). Ofc there are examples of the opposite, sometimes even extreme ones - for the record, I do NOT like those either. If my OTP isn't mutually ride or die for each other, I couldn't care about them, sorry. Which is why I prefer my romances in - ha! - either historical dramas and/or dramas where romance isn't the main genre, because those usually give me stories where OTP have to fight to be together very literally and struggle with getting there NOT due to petty reasons that only make me doubt the supposed greatness of their love. I also have a raging dislike for libido-free FLs because what's even the point of narrative to "reward" them with hot as hell MLs if they aren't gonna properly appreciate their luck? But that's a topic for another day...

Extreme beatdowns of FLs - or MLs, for that matter - in modern shows aren't very funny, I agree. I'll take 100 blood spitting torture-filled crappy days for the hero/heroine over 1 with office coworkers from hell anytime, tyvm.

4
19
reply

Required fields are marked *

I too dislike the portrayal of women being virtually sexless and without desire. The concept of yielding as a reward to a man is loathsome and sets us back decades clutching our pearls.

6
12
reply

Required fields are marked *

It's especially weird and irksome when plot previously goes to great lengths convincing us this is couple that literally cannot live without each other, madly in love... but once it comes to even the tiniest skinship, FL's enthusiasm of actually being anywhere near her man drops below waterline. Bonus points for turning the whole ordeal into "horny wolf vs scared bunny" cheap comedy. Extra bonus points for making ML suffer verbal humiliation and/or violent physical rejection as a punishment for a mortal sin of desiring his beloved.

5
5
reply

Required fields are marked *

What bothers me is that in many kdramas, often its the ML who is reluctant (or even scared) of the skinship

In fact all of my least favorite "comic" scenes in rom-coms are of this variety, designed to show that the ML is not really at all driven by sexual desire. The man leaning forward, apparently to kiss, which the woman is quite willing to do, she puckers, and then he says "you have a leaf on your shoulder" or something and brushes it away; the man shrieking when he is caught shirtless by the FL; the man really uncomfortable because circumstances force him to share a room with the FL, etc. etc. There are multiple examples of this in almost every kdrama romance.

0

@hacja if we're not talking about MLs with "drama traumas" centered around intimacy of any kind, then such behavior usually is presented as just having good manners. As in restraining yourself from those urges and thus being extra considerate to FL who OF COURSE needs all time and mental preparation in the world before she can let her boyfriend as much as hold her hand. Ofc, sometimes it gets further than that, reaching a truly ridiculous point when grown man (teens/inexperienced barely adults shrieking in embarrassed horror over being caught undressed by their crush do not phase me much) acts like a Victorian maiden surrounded by drunk sailors. Even this can be somewhat funny in the hands of a good actor tho - when not overdone.

In conclusion, there is a difference - while MLs also can be jumpy regarding skinship, they are rarely shown 100% disinterested/repulsed by prospect. At worst they are presented shy about it OR scared they'll scare FL if they try to act on their desire without proper rituals OR they are simply ashamed of even having dirty thoughts altogether. Among those 3 reasons, only shyness is usually presented in FL's behavior, but not the fear of going too fast/strong nor the shame of harboring indecent urges.

What FLs DO have more often than not is raging prudishness over any such matters (man you like dares to want you back PHYSICALLY? that pervert, how dare he!) and/or complete lack of working hormones. I recall catching my jaw near the floor when in DR SLUMP leads got stuck in hotel room together at night and it was FL getting all hot and bothered over the fact while ML remained (un)happily clueless, having too many things on his mind atm to be horny... That's how we girls can multitask in a way boys could never

I think that's what annoys me the most - I can deal with repressed desire as long as you give me a valid reason for OTP in love to... uhm... be abstinent, but at least said desire should exist from BOTH sides! And be somewhat acknowledged! Everything else is secondary. Yep, the bar low.

4

First time I got really annoyed by the flip was in "Her Private Life" where she spent some time "cheating" him from sex.
Also in You are my Destiny, towards the end, he is wanting to have sex very much, and she is making all sorts of excuses to avoid it. Because who would ever want to sleep with Jang Hyuk? But that drama's relationship to consent is just horrible anyway.
In Reply1997, she is trying to avoid it, too, and he guesses her door code and locks himself in, and won't let himself be pushed out, and demands tea, and this and that, and finally a kiss, before he will go. And she *does* desire him, but doesn't want to be pregnant, and surprise, she get pregnant. I got all angry there ... even if you have a desire, you still have a right to say no on a level where you can manage it. Her life is okay, but not like she wanted it, didn't get to take the exams she wanted, because he didn't respect her locked door or her go away, and her let me sleep.

4

As for MLs not wanting sex:
I like that it is shown that sometimes, men actually don't want to have sex. Some men are are exposed to nonconsensual sex because they are expected to ALWAYS be pleasantly surprised by it. "The world according to Garp" style, but where they are asleep rather than brain damaged.
ON THE OTHER HAND when it is made fun of as in "ha ha, a man who doesn't want sex and a woman who does" it is really just confirming sexistic gender expectations. Also, probably more women than men have times when they would like to not have sex. Two reasons are obvious; 1) Being pregnant is no joke, and 2) having somebody inside your body is just ... I mean, it's inside one's body, you know.

4

@ceciliedk as much as I enjoyed REPLY 97 overall, FL and her... limited brain process were not my favorites. That moronic crush on ML's hyung? Or unrepentant bully attitude which was always forgiven easily because he loved her? When THAT scene in her house happened, I was like "Well, you two can torture each other forever now, great!".

2) having somebody inside your body is just ...

... if you say so^^

2

Vladdles, yes, Urgh: Sex as reward is just the worst. In the first "Kingsmen" a woman said that if the young hero managed to ... whatever, ... she would let him "do a... " , and it made him really ready to fight. ADRGH!
I had liked the film up to that point, and now that is near the only thing I remember, because it was so horrible and supposed to be funny.

2
2
reply

Required fields are marked *

Oh god don’t get me started on that clusterfuck of an ending! I mean I know that’s the only thing you can ever remember of the film right…I’m getting ticked off just thinking about

1

Oh let's not get started But I am so happy you hate it too. Just like, offhandedly ruining an otherwise perfectly fine comedy-action-secret agent movie.

1

And Gikata, an extreme example of FL prudishness is the recent Eye love you, where the heroine coils up in horror at what's his name, cutest ML in existence Unlock My Boss lead asking her what she would like to eat and whether she likes him. And he is not asking in a suggestive manner, even. It's all smiley, non-threatening BD energy. Even "Young, but not in the "I own the world"-way, but in the "happy, nice, doesn't need his ego catered for"-way.
I giffed it:
https://www.dramabeans.com/activity/p/1548428/

1
2
reply

Required fields are marked *

This looks more like just a bad acting/directing though. Reeeally bad. Whoever approved of this to be in the final cut of a romance show needs to be fired and never let near filming set ever again.

1

Someone commented this kind of frightened reaction was more common in J-dramas.

1

I definitely see where you are coming from with the imbalance, but you know, the reason I don't generally like historical romances, or maybe I should say, romances in historical dramas is exactly that imbalance-- whatever fight the couple must make to be together is so totally weighted on the male side, with the woman's actions so constrained by political, legal, and social conventions, that her romantic victory is also a loss of her subjectivity. Of course, there are fantasy sageuks which posit a different reality, but then I have other issues with those!

2
5
reply

Required fields are marked *

Hmm, interesting. Perhaps I simply consumed too much of period fiction during my formative years to be bothered much by the fact that it's rarely princesses who slay dragons and bandits while their knights have to outscheme and cat fight jealous rivals in isolated harem-like setting. As long as both parts of OTP do their best at working towards mutual romantic HE goal, I'm fine with pretty much whatever distribution of said work. For me problem starts when I get the feeling that one of them - esp FL - is just not as much into it as the other is. Having their hands literally tied by objective circumstances is one thing - lacking the drive to overcome any possible obstacle is another.

Once again, we circled back to the very beginning - me hating modern romcoms for their bad habit of presenting annoyingly manufactured conflicts/obstacles instead of giving OTPs real deal stuff to overcome together. I'm afraid, it's too late already for me to change my preferences here... Dramas can still change and improve their plots tho. And FLs. Now THAT would've been nice!

3
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

Maybe it's the sageuk I have seen, or maybe it's a perspective, but I think I have seen quite a few Sageuks where women are *very* resourceful, also, without necessarily fighting physically.
The most passive Sageuk FL I can think of is from Moon EMbracing the Sun, and her main force is surviving all the horrible things she is exposed to, that would normally (and they say so in the drama) kill you or leave you raving mad.
I actually love her very much. And the plot includes a ninja-shaman and a murderously infatuated minor and a scheming dowager queen as sine qua non of all that.
There Rookie historian, that moon brewing drama, Matchmakers, Knight Flower, and Mr. Queen - none of them are based on a "princess as reward" kind of plot.

1

@ceciliedk I think hacja means historically accurate sageuks. The dramas you have mentioned are mostly considered fusion sageuks, for the exact reasons being discussed here. They are not historically accurate especially about women and love.

3
2
reply

Required fields are marked *

Yes, thank you @midnight, that is what I was talking about, those sageuks that are realistic about what a woman could really do in society when she was married, even if happily so, which was not a lot. @ceciliedk, I was responding to @gikata who prefers the romances where the obstacles were really high--like for example women or men trying to marry for love outside of an arranged marriage system, or when women and men of different social strata fell in love with each other and the marriage would have been legally forbidden. These are classic historical romance scenarios, but I myself can't get out of my head the historical reality that even if the love match occurred, it would not be a triumph for the woman involved because of the historically severely limited rights for married women. Whereas, in contemporary romances, with modern day "companionate" marriages, I can at least imagine a scenario where romantic success would be fulfilling for both partners, so that's why I like those better.
I do understand @gikata's point, however, that (just to take a recent example of Welcome to Samdal-ri) a man and woman in love deciding to separate simply because the man's Dad had a grudge against the woman's Mom is not too compelling a story. And there are plenty of other romance kdramas where just a simple sit-down chat between the leads would clear the air and remove all obstacles to a successful romance. Those are pretty frustrating, I admit.

2

@hacja you forget the very important point - in historical setting EVERYONE's lives sucked, not exclusively just women's, even tho they clearly had it worse for the most part. Once you start considering that the whole genre turns into horror you could never unsee it gets easier to appreciate even small victories and limited happiness leads could achieve. After all, who are we to say that OUR times now are so great and enlightened to look down on our ancestors experience? I wouldn't call love stories of my contemporaries I've seen with my own eyes all that grand, romantic or fulfilling either, honestly... Fiction is infinitely better in that regard because it IS fiction, modern or not. But costume shows still have prettier angst AND wardrobe...

4
0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

“Human rights commission urges Korea to raise awareness of LGBTQ rights” : https://www.koreaherald.com/view.php?ud=20240517050573

3
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

“ Discrimination and hatred must no longer be tolerated in our society. We reaffirm that it is the non-negotiable responsibility of all of us to defend the dignity and worth of human beings and uphold the fundamental values of democracy, which are respect for diversity and human rights. The NHRCK will continue to work to ensure the human rights of LGBTQ people.”‘

3
reply

Required fields are marked *