163

[Drama chat] When screenwriters let you down hard

Last week we waxed poetic on our favorite screenwriters. This week, though, the chat is all about the letdown (whomp, whomp).

You know the scenario: you love a drama, your heart is stuck to the script and the story and the characters like a barnacle, and you wait patiently two-ish years for the writer’s next work. In other words: me, waiting for Yoo Bo-ra’s follow-up to Just Between Lovers. Then, you finally get the drama, and it’s… well, in this case, Reflection of You. You want to love it. And when that’s not possible, you want to at least like it. Okay, if I can’t like it, can I just not totally jump ship? (Answer: no.)

While these sorts of ups and downs are expected with any creative’s work, sometimes they sting more than they ought. Expectations too high? Maybe. But that’s what dramaland is all about.

What are some instances where screenwriters you loved have let you down with one of their dramas?

 
Let the chatting begin!
 
RELATED POSTS

Tags:

163

Required fields are marked *

I don't usually put too much expectation on dramas. But yes, there are a few cases where the writing was seriously unbelievable.

1. God's Gift 14 Days; after a rollercoster of emotions throughout the series, suddenly the writer felt it was cool to crush our hope in the worst way possible.

2. CCIR; I was so psyhed watching the queen of Korean Movie industry on my screen just to find the writing was such a mess. I had no idea where the writer got the idea that happy ending means all characters getting love line. And don't get me started with the way they ended the culprit.

3. I think Taxi Driver was my only hate watching drama so far. The writer needs to get the fact straight; did they write fantasy or action thriller? I wouldn't care AT ALL even when the ML raised from the dead if it's fantasy. But if not, they need to research better; it's outrageous!

I have many more in store for other dramas like Shadow Detective, The First Responder, Jinxed at First, Moon Lovers, but let's just say that dropping the shows reflected their bad writing.

That said, yes it's impossible for any writer to always write amazing script. I've yet to watch Grid from LSY but I'll still follow her even if it turns out to be a dissapoint.

4
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

I agree that there are certain writers I'll pretty much always watch (even if an occasional show is terrible), because I find their work interesting even when it's uneven. I also have not seen Grid (thanks, Disney+), but I'll definitely check it out if it ever lands on a screening service I subscribe to just because of the screenwriter.

3
reply

Required fields are marked *

Han Jung-hoon wrote one my favourite dramas of all time! SQUAD 38. I love fun heist capers. And this drama delivered and then some!

So do you know how personally attacked I felt when I watched the ending of MISSING NINE??! Which also just happens to star one my favourite actors Jung Kyung-ho??!

I know and agree that the ending of HEARTBEAT was WTF

But nothing I mean NOTHING has topped the ending of MISSING NINE. We literally have our protagonists playing with paint and laughing merrily with a SERIAL KILLER who KILLED THIER LOVED ONES. WTF WTF WTF 🤬🤬🤬

So when I saw praise for MY FELLOW CITIZENS and looked up the screenwriter, instant flashbacks flooded my brain. I was traumatised y’all and I don’t I’ve forgiven Han Jung-hoon to watch SONG OF BANDITS, it looks good but can’t help but be suspicious…

4
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

I have no screenwriter in particular to point out. I do want to give a special shout out to all the screenwriters who try to force the destiny trope down our throats by having the leads bound together somehow in childhood. Please stop. It is beyond tired as a plot device.

8
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

I'm imagining a screenwriting night class somewhere in Seoul with the instructor yelling "you MUST have the leads bound together somehow in childhood!" all the tired students who work jobs during the day nod their heads in unison and shout back, "yes, teacher!"

5
reply

Required fields are marked *

I have one that most people will not agree with. But Kwon Do Eun, who as far as I can tell has only written two dramas, is in my opinion enormously skilled in writing not just storylines but also characters and dialogue. But after Search WWW, which I thought was excellent (although I wasn't thrilled at the FL noona's qualms about the guy who loved her) then wrote 25-21, which was also excellent IN PARTS. But its big flaw was a writing one, not directing or acting: the retrospective framework of the narrative, which in the end meant that the ending was just an enormous letdown. If the show had ended with the bittersweet goodbye between the FL and the ML then I would have said another classic. As it is, I felt really let down. Still I really want to see another drama from her.

8
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

The drama love of my life is City Hall. So, I do keep track of the writer, the now super famous Kim Eun Sook. I don’t know how to say this, nothing has lived up to City Hall… I love a little bit of every of her drama, but not as whole heartedly for the wit and chemistry in City Hall.

7
8
reply

Required fields are marked *

that is the magic of casting :)

6
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

Exactly.

2
reply

Required fields are marked *

I only looked her up after a recent rewatch of City Hall and I was surprised to see her other work. It's a long and successful list, but compared to those, City Hall feels to me like it came from a different writer.

4
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

I agree, it's singular. I wish she wrote a few more like City Hall. I think the casting of Cha Seung Won and Kim Sun A was probably one of the best out of all her dramas. If you look at her filmography and how different the dramas are in tone and subject, it's hard to believe they're all written by the same person, isn't it?

4
reply

Required fields are marked *

I know what you mean about City Hall being special and even a bit out of place among her other works. City Hall also has a special place in my heart, it made me feel a lot of emotions, like the sense of longing, etc. It's such a smart and funny romantic comedy. Wouldn't it be nice if she made a few more just like that? This screenwriter's dramas are all very different from each other and so makes it frustrating for those of us who fell in love with one and then can't find another one like it anywhere else.

5
2
reply

Required fields are marked *

It's kind of cruel that she's so prolific. You have to watch a dozen other of her shows before realizing City Hall was a one-off. Maybe the closest in tone, and not really that close, was Secret Garden, but I actually thought it was the Hong sisters all this time somehow. Wouldn't have connected it to the Lovers trilogy, so that does show versatility.

3
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

There is no doubt in her versatility as a writer to making all those hit dramas. Hats off to her for trying different genres and topics. Oftentimes, her other works after City Hall had some amazing scenes and dialogues, but some did seem as if she’s opting in to attempt new stuff but came out short.

3
reply

Required fields are marked *

I've never heard of City Hall but checked it out on MDL. No streaming options mentioned there (but very high reviews) so I checked Kocowa on the off chance it was there since it was originally on one of the broadcast stations. It's now on my Watchlist. Thanks for mentioning it. 😊😊

5
reply

Required fields are marked *

I want to say, if Heartbeat writer decided to borrow an idea of a vampire mansion and an independent girl trying to make it in a rough world, it should have copied more thoroughly, concentrating on the weirdness of guests who stay at the guesthouse, threats of redevelopment and the attachment we grow to people and places.
in my version they really had to fight for both their identity and their nature, and their rights as individuals. Their ideas and goals in a world that constantly tries to make you give up.
It dragged, I´d say. the setting and visuals were perfect, but you can have more tension and less filler.

4
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

The screenwriter behind W and Memories of the Alhambra has burned me for the last time.

I watched W early in my Kdrama addiction, and didn't know anything about it or the crew going in. I loved it at first, but despite its overall potential the ending was a confusing letdown.

Then I watched Memories of the Alhambra before the final ep had aired (another mistake I will never repeat) and, once again, loved it at first. Lots of potential, beautiful Spanish scenery, Hyun Bin was fantastic, etc etc, and then... that ending. Yes, I'm still pissed off about that ending four years later. No, I'm probably never going to get over it, lol.

I didn't even realize until well after the fact that both of these shows were written by the same writer. And now I know not to bother wasting my time with any of their future dramas, no matter how great the premise or cast might be, because the endings will inevitably leave me feeling 🤨 at best, or 🤬 at worst.

8
0
reply

Required fields are marked *