I'm creeper out by the romance. I love the drama. These two contradictory emotions drive how I feel about what I'm seeing on my screen haha.

The female lead did open the show with "I promise you, the story I'm about to tell is not a love story" - and perhaps the early, creepy kiss is a sign of just that.

I have these two/4 episodes to watch still. But I’m staying for the music, most certainly!

How awesome was it when they caught the thief - the lady literally hit him with her bag of bread and sat on his face! I'm still laughing thinking about it.

I'm extremely confused by Jang Yoon's approach to finding out more about his brother's murder. You wanna to find out who the killer was? Fair. You wanna get close to the woman who is either the only witness of the murder or the possible murderer? Fine. You want to see if you can jug her memory? Ok. But the way he go about is incredibly perplexing. He's being strangely seductive with her, while at the same time insisting he's not interested in her "in that way" and is moving in the apartment below her in the hope that... what, she's going to just wake up one day and confess to him? If she IS the murderer and is playing innocent, how does he think his being around is going to push her to admit her guilt? And if he does believe that she forgot anything, is he just hoping that alluding to the murder without giving her any details is really going to be enough to shake her from the trauma? She's lost three months worth of memory and he thinks taking her jogging is the solution? I want to believe that he was trying to manipulate her and fell into his own trap of dark attraction but I still fail to see the logic in setting up the trap in the first place.

I have to admit I'm still a bit confused on how Maestro Nam , Eun-joo, and Yi-young all know each other? Is it from having all been students at the same school?

I'm conflicted. I really like the 3 main characters that surround our heroine and so do not want one of them to be a murderer, but if it is not one of them does that lower the stakes of the story and dilute it? I need more suspects.

That piece they played in the out door theater was so beautiful.

I want to say that @kimbapnoona mentioned the clarinet on one of the Head/Shoulders watches. I wonder if she gets that mad if someone touches her reed?

lmao i love reading beanies comments... I feel like our theory probably make more sense than what will happen in the future though. I hope not, but yeah.

I'm still creep out so much by their relationship, and it's what makes me want to keep watching it. This and the music.

I'm surprised we haven't heard of Jang Yoon sing this week, since the title made it look like the singing was important. I guess even if they stop the evening call, there will be something related to a "song" in the murder case ? idk.

I'm also kind of suspecting Maestro Nam as the "someone he loved" person regarding the death of Kim Ian. Maestro Nam wears the same ring we saw Kim Ian wearing the night of the incident. .... Granted, two people wearing the same style of jewelry doesn't necessarily mean they are in a relationship but it's still a possibility that can't yet be discounted at this point.

I scanned the comments and all I could see was ‘creepy’!
Apparently there is a new breed of male leads called ‘creeper’ male :)

This show’s genre feels all over the place but am enjoying it. Am curious about the circumstances of the murder but I wonder what was the investigation results. This Jang creeper guy stole the murder weapon and stopped the investigation? What did the cops find. Did they close the case without a suspect?
How does Jang know he was killed by his girl friend.
I bet there is some personal diary of Ian that he read and is enacting scenes from it.
Whatever. I will wait. But please stop this kissing gal. Wake up gal. Stay away from creepers.

I am glad to see an active discussion of this show. After watching the first episode without paying careful attention I was close to writing it off but getting back to it a little later, I realized what was going on and went back and watched carefully. At this point I am all in, simply because I love that the audience is involved in figuring out what happened to Kim Ian.

I think that the murderer is the Maestro and the violinist knows about it, which is the hold she has over him. I wouldn’t be surprised if the Maestro is gay or bisexual, and Ian possibly too. It hadn’t occurred to me that perhaps Jang Youn was the boyfriend instead of Kim Ian, but it’s certainly possible.

As far as creepy/manipulative male leads (at least in the beginning of the show), it really isn’t all that new.,.Secret, Hotel King, Nice Guy, Come and Hug Me, and the two similar plot plastic surgery shows from a few months back. And those were shows with happy endings, so it’s possible this one will have one too. But if that’s the case, later there will be much groveling and/or having to prove themselves worthy of the heroine’s love.

I'm loving the comments. How often do you get to have discussions on whether the Candy-esque lead is actually a murderer and exactly how creepy of a (charming) stalker the male lead is? 😂 I knew this show would be crazy, but it's possibly surpassing my expectations on the weird front. I'm here for it.

Well I think that nobody in this drama is sane *munches on a celery syick*
I dunno why I picked this drama up; it's weird. Might wait now till four more episodes are out so I can binge them again.

I don't know with this drama. Like I really don't. I like all of the characters. They're all very interesting and likable. And I really like the strange hodge-podge of a genre mash-up the story is. But I hate everyone's behavior. The female lead is....well, she's dense. I mean, who keeps hanging out with someone who acts the way the male lead does, this weird hot and cold, really scary-intense then flirty and jokey with just a hint of some 'I like to trigger your repressed memories every time we hang out which is obviously on purpose but you're too dumb to figure it out'? And what's with the male lead's behavior anyway? He has no subtly whatsoever, not a millimeter of chill. He's either all over her like an ant on an ice cream cone or he's glaring into her eyes like he's holding a knife behind his back. Bro. Pick a lane. Then we have the secondary male lead who hires her for his orchestra, seemingly unbothered by an audition mistake that would have disqualified her with anyone else and then he FIRES HER FOR MAKING THE SAME MISTAKE AFTER ONLY GIVING HER ONE REHEARSAL TO GET TO USED TO BEING PART OF THE NEW TEAM AND HE DOES IT IN FRONT OF LITERALLY EVERYONE WHICH IS PROBABLY THE MOST HUMILIATING THING POSSIBLE. THEN HE HIRES HER AS HIS ASSISTANT! I! CAN'T! EVEN! WITHYOU!!!!!

Our quasi-second female lead is pretty inconsistent in her own right, but she's not on-screen enough for it to heavily impact the story.

I just don't know with this drama, and I think I'm gonna have to just make peace with it, lol.