[2018 Year in Review] If dramas were emotions
by Guest Beanie
Hundred Million Stars From the Sky
By Foglia
I’ve had less time to indulge myself in K-dramas this year and maybe that’s why I savored every single moment I spent with them. In the end I added new names in my top K-dramas list once more. Since I fancy anything progressive, daring, unusual, and innovative, my 2018 list includes some controversial deal-breakers. Out of the shows I relished, I will share four that are significant to me. Each of them had a different after-taste. Each of them triggered different feelings. I hope that there are many viewers who enjoyed them as much as I did.
Hundred Million Stars From the Sky
EXCITEMENT
Hundred Million Stars From the Sky
Just after watching the first episode of this meticulous remake, I immediately watched the original and began waiting for the surprises that the new version had in store for us. I was thrilled. I was mesmerized by Seo In-gook’s portrayal. The dangerous-looking, reckless, yet broken young man stole my heart immediately. It was a captivating experience from beginning to end.
Sure, the criminal side of the story was quite strong and disturbing. However, the romantic promise of the drama was so strong that it gave me goosebumps. It wasn’t a “no touch, no kiss” kind of unrealistic relationship. The intimate moments that Seo In-gook and Jung So-min shared were very intense, very deep. Seo’s relationship with his lover’s brother, Park Sung-woong managed to be antagonistic but touching at the same time. Hundred Million Stars From the Sky gave me high-voltage excitement.
Familiar Wife
TRUST
Familiar Wife
I have never like black and white descriptions found in old-school fiction: devils and angels, losers and champs, characters you either totally love or totally hate… as if that’s possible.
I’ve always preferred protagonists that are carefully carved. Realistic. All people have flaws. All people have features that they’re proud of. They can be very considerate in one area, but very insensitive in another. That’s the main reason I enjoyed Familiar Wife. It was the story of a married couple that was marinated with time-travel sauce that took an objective approach to its protagonists and it was fun to watch. Neither the Han Ji-min nor Ji Sung was “the villain,” neither one of them was “the angel” either.
I loved the x-ray of that “promised relationship” and reconstruction of the marriage. It was funny, rational, and mostly not sexist. It made me think that it is possible for a couple to solve even the most difficult issues as long as there is love between them. Familiar Wife reinforced that trust in me.
Pretty Noona Who Buys Me Food
HOPE
Pretty Noona Who Buys Me Food:
In the beginning we were a large group of people cherishing this contemporary story. A heartwarming, unconventional noona romance, rich dialogues, and a very cute male lead all came together and won our hearts. (I should admit that I get strongly irritated by the term “noona romance.” Do we call it an oppa romance when the male is older than the female? It’s almost 2019. Anyway…) When the love between Yoon Jin-ah and Seo Joon-hee was in the honeymoon stage there was only joy and excitement. Then began her battle: a strong opposition on her mother’s side and sexual harassment at the office killed the mood, and loyal K-drama fans began protesting against the drama.
Before her newly-found love, it was her family protecting and leading her. Then her young boyfriend intended to take that role. However, although she kept loving him very much, she chose to save herself instead of being saved. Instead of taking shelter under his wings, she preferred fighting for herself. I loved every single minute of it.
Yoon Jin-ah’s mother was a real pest and she had to endure being mobbed at the office. On the plus side, she did have a really adorable boyfriend. In the end, I loved her choosing the hard but self-satisfying way. The happy ending in the finale was a very well deserved one, I think. Pretty Noona Who Buys Me Food gave me huge hope.
The Third Charm
EMPATHY
The Third Charm:
This drama was one of the rare pieces in K-dramaland in that it didn’t comply with the usual-style happy ending rule. The Third Charm offered us a realistic, thought-provoking modern love story. Seo Kang Joon’s male lead was affectionate, devoted, plus very handsome. However, the female lead, Esom seemed unwilling to settle for that and she left him. Subsequently, they went through some tough life experiences. Why did she leave him?
In a romantic relationship, the one who is more dependent on their partner may subconsciously be afraid of losing their partner. This can cause decay in the relationship because it can cause that person to feel uneasy, somewhat guilty, and continuously indebted. The one who loves too much may not leave enough space for their partner to show affection or love. It can take the heat out of that relationship and greatly reduces the excitement. Eventually, one party leaves. In The Third Charm we witnessed something similar. Actually, we experienced it not once, but twice. It made me think over the “formula of love” a lot.
What I loved most about the drama was that the women were unorthodox. There are tons of dramas telling us that women are obsessed with marriage. That they always passively wait for a proposal and even a simple wedding ring makes them die of happiness. In Third Charm women didn’t wait for the other party to initiate the relationship. They chose, they told, they took action, they started, or they terminated relationships when they felt like it. I loved encountering a drama that took a non-conservative view of women in relationships.
—
This is my tribute to 2018. There were a couple of weekend marathons lasting more than 10 hours. There were a few long holiday nights celebrated with drama parties. Some dramas had particular aspects that stole my heart. Some dramas I loved from A to Z.
The Third Charm
RELATED POSTS
- [2018 Year in Review] What tickles the funny bone
- [2018 Year in Review] Sifting through mediocrity
- [2018 Year in Review] Finding myself in dramas
- [2018 Year in Review] Thrill me, heal me
- [2018 Year in Review] An intermission with a crescendo
- [2018 Year in Review] I, who didn’t expect poetry
- [2018 Year in Review] Sinkers and lifesavers
- [2018 Year in Review] Turn up the drama
- [2018 Year in Review] Take my tears
- [Theme of the Month] Year in dramas 2018
Required fields are marked *
Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *
1 fencejumper
December 25, 2018 at 11:26 PM
@foglia Thanks for mentioning Familar Wife and Third Charm! 💕
Both elicited different reactions from me. Third charm took a tired time traveling plot but infused it with assured story telling and direction. It was a drama that worked with an unlikeable main lead who made mistakes so often as seen with real life and then even showed the positive outcome in his wife’s life if she wasn’t married to him. The entire reversal from her side then in taking an active role to patch things up kept the story moving. Sure the drama wasn’t the most exciting or thrilling but instead, it was character rich and I enjoyed the ride.
Third Charm was frustrating at times and mostly bleak but still a nice drama. It was packaged wrong, and the narrative power wasn’t equal, especially towards the end with YJ but gosh, it was such an emotional ride. So much growth and pain and crushing real ness.
Required fields are marked *
Foglia
December 26, 2018 at 1:34 AM
Thank you for your comment Andy. Actually I liked Third Charm very much. For sure It doesn't comply with K-Drama standards, it doesn't satisfy K-Drama viewers, but it is definitely a well-written, solid piece outside of K-Drama Land.
Required fields are marked *
fencejumper
December 26, 2018 at 5:28 AM
Aww thanks for responding!
When you look at Third Charm outside of the rom-com lens it was promoted in, it's actually a very character-journey drama and that I appreciated a lot. I actually liked the ending because it didn't suddenly tie everything unrealistically with a pretty bow but chose to paint life as ebbing and flowing in a realistic way. I wish they had time to properly unfold YJ's story though as that's my main gripe with the show and honestly kept me at arms length from her character.
Required fields are marked *
Foglia
December 26, 2018 at 10:05 AM
"I actually liked the ending because it didn't suddenly tie everything unrealistically with a pretty bow but chose to paint life as ebbing and flowing in a realistic way"...
You are perfectly right. I am exactly on the same page with you.
Required fields are marked *
2 Ally
December 26, 2018 at 5:19 AM
Thank you for your very nice summary of these dramas. I’m also enjoying your critique of “Boyfriend” right now as well. Are you in the entertainment business, a screenwriter perhaps? You seem to have some insight in how to write characters. The only show that I could say I watched (although not to completion) was “Pretty Noona...” and that “...” was everything I couldn’t stand about the misogyny, sexism, and obstructionism in the latter half of that show. I did pop in for the resolution of it though. And it was anticlimactic for me. I lived this show just as everyone else did, and was very vocal about it. But, like many kdramas, the initial excitement fizzled when the main couple faded and corporate and family machinations took over. I’m still bitter.
Required fields are marked *
Foglia
December 26, 2018 at 10:02 AM
Yes, you're right, I've been in this business for quite some time, with performing arts and behavioural sciences background and a couple of books behind.
Thank you for comment and for taking your time.
Required fields are marked *
3 oppafangirl
December 26, 2018 at 6:48 AM
Thank you for your nice words @foglia,
though I agree with what you said about Third charm and HMS, I will tend to strongly disagree about Pretty noona. I had a lot of problems with the show from starting to end. I did not like their whirlwind romance at all because of what it was based on: She was trying to forget her ex boyfriend with a new boyfriend who for me was equally paternalistic.
I did not care about the parents and opposition so much because from the society where I come, its so much standard to expect it.
For me this was supposed to be a story of a woman who wanted to explore her life on her terms but did not know how and how she decided to fight the monsters in her life with or without a boyfriend. She will make a lot of mistakes and learn for them but nothing happened other than her making more mistakes of the same kind.
And the ending was even more horrible. I would be glad if she went to meet him and decided to pursue the relationship one more time.
She as a character deserved nothing in the show and also got nothing because she was wonderful in not taking an step to anywhere and running away from conflicts.
She never tried hard to make her world but tries to fit in the moulds everyone had made for her. And she never realized that. It was not a journey of self-awareness but a journey from from one misery to another.
Required fields are marked *
welh
December 26, 2018 at 8:55 AM
SYJ wanted her Jinah character to be an introverted, immature adult, who repeatedly made the same mistakes and failed to learn how to take control of her own life. In a normal story, a woman such as this would have life altering events that would make her "change" her past behavior to become a likeable, complete, independent woman. But that did not happen, so there was a lot of negative reaction to the show. I found the sudden reconciliation with her mother and the ambiguous reunion ending to be too forced to be acceptable since there really was never a good reason for them to have a deep and lasting relationship.
Required fields are marked *
oppafangirl
December 26, 2018 at 9:38 AM
The ending was the most rushed part of this show, to me it made no sense, was there any change in the Jae-in's controlling/ paternalistic behaviour or not. It was like he went and he came back because he decided so and she like a doormat let him come and let him go. I mean people can sorry without meaning even the "s" of it.
I felt that the story was of a hopeless woman in contrast to what the writer above felt.
On that note being introvert will not stop her from thinking and improving but I am not so sure of immaturity, I learnt from the show that some people never become mature.
Required fields are marked *
Foglia
December 26, 2018 at 9:47 AM
I loved reading such a detailed reply. Even we have totally different views related to the drama, I really enjoyed it. Thank you for taking your time.
Still 'Something in the Rain' is the number one in my k-drama list so far. 'I Need Romance 3' and this one are my dearest pieces. Both of them surprised me in a very positive way.
Required fields are marked *
oppafangirl
December 26, 2018 at 10:47 AM
I think its always nice for people to have different views on shows, this is why the world is so beautiful :)
Even though I did not like the drama but I actually recommended it to my friend as the first korean drama he should watch to tell him how not to behave with a woman on a level where it turns paternalistic or for him to see a very different side of a woman. I hope he will watch it and tell me someday about it.
Required fields are marked *
4 javinne
December 26, 2018 at 7:53 AM
Oh my, here I have nothing to say. I either dropped them or never watch them. 😂
Required fields are marked *
Foglia
December 26, 2018 at 9:55 AM
:)) I see, no problem. I know that I am not a typical k-drama fan. Very often I have similar thoughts for some blockbuster Korean dramas.
Required fields are marked *
marina
December 26, 2018 at 10:40 AM
Omg, not even TSHLYE? 😦🤔
Required fields are marked *
Foglia
December 26, 2018 at 11:36 AM
I think this question is not for me but for javinne.
Required fields are marked *
marina
December 26, 2018 at 11:57 AM
Yeah ^.^
Required fields are marked *
javinne
December 26, 2018 at 12:46 PM
Tshlye??? Stand for??
Required fields are marked *
Shitty Healing Hunter
December 26, 2018 at 10:14 PM
The Smile Has Left Your Eyes
aka Hundred Million Stars from the Sky
Required fields are marked *
javinne
December 26, 2018 at 10:37 PM
Oh yeah, true. I know it as hundred million stars, etc...
Anyway.... nope, @marina... that one I dropped because it was too dark and nonsensical for my taste. Sorry😩
5 Flightey Gazelles
December 26, 2018 at 9:10 AM
Wow, from your review of Prettt Noona and Familiar Wife and Third Charm, I'm inclined to watch them. I've previously heard not-so-good things about them
Required fields are marked *
Foglia
December 26, 2018 at 10:07 AM
Hope you enjoy them.
Required fields are marked *
6 marina
December 26, 2018 at 10:47 AM
You got me with “The dangerous-looking, reckless, yet broken young man stole my heart immediately”. 😍 I can’t imagine anybody else as Kim Moo Young except SIG. He did such an amazing job with not many dialogues but only his eyes and a lopsided smile.
Required fields are marked *
Foglia
December 26, 2018 at 11:34 AM
He is extremely sexy 🙈
Required fields are marked *
Dru
December 26, 2018 at 4:15 PM
He is indeed sexy,,and a brilliant actor too!!
Required fields are marked *
7 Dru
December 26, 2018 at 4:20 PM
I love Third Charm too..💟💟
And love all the characters, esp. the 4D Ohn Ri Won.. She is a gem. Period.
Required fields are marked *
8 missjb
December 26, 2018 at 4:42 PM
Finally, there is someone who appreciate the third charm end enjoying Something In The Rain.
For the third charm. Given the initial promise of the first half... Didn't expect it will be alot of drama going on in the 2nd half and the dramatic conflicts surprisingly fungtional. I really love the unpredictable thia drama bring and didn't regret watching it one bit. Alot better than Kang Joon previous drama AYHT.
Required fields are marked *
Foglia
December 26, 2018 at 5:06 PM
Happy to read that there is someone else relishing those two quality productions. Thank you for comment.
Required fields are marked *
missjb
December 27, 2018 at 1:08 AM
I actually have problem with Something in the Rain with the way they execute the conflict. But compare to how encounter has been executed, make me appreciate Pretty Noona much better. Haha...
Meanwhile, I have ibut problem of the silliness the first half of The Third Charm, turn out to be absolutely surprise me with how mature they present the conflict in the 2nd half. That is just absolutely refreshing and unpredictable execution.
Required fields are marked *
Foglia
December 27, 2018 at 8:11 AM
"problem of the silliness the first half of The Third Charm, turn out to be absolutely surprise me with how mature they present the conflict in the 2nd half"....
Exactly! First I had found it silly and thought that it had been another shallow romantic drama. then a kind of metamorphosis occurred. It was really an interesting surprise:)
Required fields are marked *
9 mugyuljoie is preciousss
December 27, 2018 at 12:06 AM
@foglia After reading what you enjoy in a drama, I want to you watch Matrimonial Chaos and Dance Sports Girls. Although I enjoy a variety of Korean drama, I'm always looking for the less conventional, preferably with a dash of hope and realism.
Required fields are marked *
Foglia
December 27, 2018 at 8:05 AM
Will definitely watch them; thank you for recommending.
Required fields are marked *
10 RenOIshi
December 27, 2018 at 2:37 AM
Moo Young and Jin Kang is my most favourite OTP till date. There were times I couldn’t even tell if they were acting! Kudos to their brilliance as actors!
Required fields are marked *
11 Kurama
December 27, 2018 at 8:02 AM
Thank your for writting about Pretty Noona!
I really loved this drama :) If the story had been only about their cute relationship, it would have been boring. The story adressed a lot of subjects (sexism, family, etc.) in a very real way no miraculous solution, no sudden change of personality, etc. I really liked how the female character learnt to take care of herself even if it took her a very long time :p
All the scenes of the couple were so convincing :) The Jeju Island'end was the best :D
Required fields are marked *
12 drunkfairy
December 27, 2018 at 11:31 AM
HSM was just plain brilliant. So glad you spoke my mind with your beautiful words. This show was everything! <3
Thank you so much for this @foglia
Required fields are marked *
13 zzthorn
December 27, 2018 at 5:08 PM
YES!! for The Smile Has Left Your Eyes/100 Million Stars from the Sky. What an exciting adventure that was! Everything else on this list pales in comparison. This was a drama that really brought out the talent of the actors and actresses. They were so convincing! They deserve high praise for making this intense psychological tale become so believable.
Required fields are marked *
14 Frick
December 27, 2018 at 11:57 PM
Hooray! There are other people who appreciate Hundred Million Stars from the Sky/ The Smile Has Left Your Eyes AND My Pretty Noona Buys Me Food/ Something in the Rain. Both K drama series, were holistic in approach - not everything can be always good or positive...the world is round so there are bound to be ups and downs.
But to me, besides the story plots of these 2 series, it's the acting and the development of characters that drew me like a moth to a flame. The 2 lead couples in the 2 series mentioned felt "real" that you get immersed in their world. Special kudos to Seo In Guk who has really evolved to become a great actor (of course, it helps that I'm biased towards him ever since he started his singing career).
Thank you again for the nice write-up.
Required fields are marked *
Foglia
December 28, 2018 at 2:19 AM
Both Seo In-guk & Jung Hae-in are precious gems. I'd watch every drama without even checking the plot etc. as long as they're in.
Required fields are marked *