Descended from the Sun: Episode 2
by LollyPip
We get to the meat of the story in this episode, which is simple on the outside but seems deep with potential for conflict and heartbreak. If nothing else this is an absolutely gorgeous drama, in every possible way. We also get a better look at our leading characters in this episode, with Mo-yeon’s strong sense of justice and respect for life, and Shi-jin’s mischievous sense of humor combined with his fierce loyalty to home and country.
EPISODE 2 RECAP
With a promise to see her soon and one wistful look back, Shi-jin leaves Mo-yeon on the roof to join his team for a top-secret mission. Mo-yeon watches his helicopter take off, and she’s joined by her colleague SONG SANG-HYUN (Lee Seung-joon), who asks what she’s staring at.
She asks him almost distractedly if people in the Special Forces get helicopter escorts and sometimes get shot, and he says that really never happens. Mo-yeon wonders who exactly Shi-jin is, then.
Shi-jin is now in Afghanistan, on a mission to rescue two UN representatives who have been kidnapped by the Taliban. During a practice run, the Korean team’s rookie sets off a booby trap, causing both Shi-jin and Dae-young to holler at him.
An American(?) soldier throws his dagger into a box next to Shi-jin’s head and yells at them to go back home, and of course Shi-jin can’t let that go. He hurls the dagger right back, where it sticks into a box right between the other soldier’s legs.
Now it’s on, and Shi-jin and the other soldier fight viciously, seeming evenly matched. Dae-young holds the rookie back from getting involved, telling him that when Special Forces from different countries get together, something like this always happens. It’s a test to see if the other side is strong and trustworthy.
The fight is pretty awesome actually, between the American’s strength and Shi-jin’s quickness and agility (at one point he literally climbs the other guy). You get the sense that they could do this all day, but the captain finally breaks up the fight and orders them back to work.
Mo-yeon complains to her colleague DR. PYO about the position she’s applying for, apparently for the third time, and her friend is certain that she’ll be accepted this time. Another doctor comes in to make snarky comments to Mo-yeon, seeing as how she’s up for the same job and certain she’ll get it.
The two seem pretty antagonistic, and they end up in the same surgery room, where the snarky woman, Dr. Kim, happily chirps that there’s been a change in plans — she’s in charge, and Mo-yeon will be assisting her. They continue to trade barbs while operating, until something goes wrong and the patient starts to bleed out.
Some pretty slick editing switches us between Mo-yeon’s operation and Afghanistan, where the Special Forces are beginning the real mission. Shi-jin’s team infiltrates the building where the UN workers are being held, while Mo-yeon works fast to save the patient.
Things get ugly during the mission — a booby trap is set off and shots are fired, but Shi-jin and Dae-young manage to keep themselves and their team alive, for the moment. Shi-jin gets creative as he works his way to the heart of the building, and shoots the Taliban kidnappers just as they’re about to kill the hostages. The hostages are saved — mission complete.
At the same time, Mo-yeon stabilizes her patient and orders Dr. Kim to finish the surgery. Dr. Kim complies, but she’s not at all happy about Mo-yeon having to step in to save her surgery.
Mo-yeon could chew nails as she leaves the operating room, ranting about how that doctor nearly killed their patient, but a third doctor, DR. JANG, follows to tell her she did a good job, which calms her down. She pats Dr. Jang’s belly and tells her unborn baby that her mother did a good job too, and Dr. Jang is happy to announce that the father finally proposed.
The father just happens to be another doctor at the hospital, LEE CHI-HOON (SHINee’s Onew). He sidles up to Mo-yeon and makes faces until she catches on that he wants to talk to her privately, smiling way too brightly until Dr. Jang walks away. He admits to Mo-yeon that he lost his couple ring during surgery, and finally finds it in the scrub hamper next to them. He’s pretty adorable, but also seems like a giant doofus.
Mo-yeon wonders out loud to Dr. Pyo how Dr. Jang managed to get pregnant in the first place when they’re always working, and Dr. Pyo just says that it’s a big hospital, ha. She asks if Mo-yeon has heard from Shi-jin again, but she hasn’t, and Dr. Pyo wonders if he’s a spy. She catches Mo-yeon mooning at his X-ray; Mo-yeon says it’s the only picture she has of him, and it makes her grin widely.
Mo-yeon steps outside after an overnight shift for some fresh air, dressed in her sweats with her hair a mess. When she sees Shi-jin beaming at her from across the street she tries to hide her face, complaining that he’s two hours early for their date. Shi-jin just says that it felt good to have someone to wait for, which is so adorable but also a little sad.
He asks why she’s covering her face, and she says that she’s not wearing any makeup. Seeming completely honest, he tells her, “You’re pretty enough now.” Mo-yeon asks if she doesn’t need to take a shower then, and Shi-jin quickly offers to drive her home. HAHA.
She invites him in to wait while she gets ready, and asks if he minds ordering some food because she’s starving. Shi-jin pouts that he was going to take her out for a nice meal, but he’s mollified when Mo-yeon says that it’s the company that matters.
Mo-yeon’s water is cut off for non-payment right as she lathers her hair, but she pretends that everything is fine and goes back out to Shi-jin with her hair in a towel. It doesn’t fool him for a second and he holds up the shutoff notice, and Mo-yeon just quickly grabs some bottled water and runs back to the bathroom. Cute.
As they eat, Shi-jin asks if Mo-yeon thought of him while he was gone. She easily admits it and asks the same of him, and he says that he thought about her a lot. Then when she suggests they get coffee at the movie, he can’t resist teasing, “I should get a bottle of water…”
At the movies, Mo-yeon says that the most exciting part is right before they turn the lights off. Shi-jin leans over to whisper that this is the most exciting moment of his life, being with a beautiful woman right before they turn the lights off. He’s going to have me swooning a lot, isn’t he?
He brings up the fact that she spoke banmal just now, figuring that she saw his age on his chart, and asks how old she is. She skirts the question but says definitely his noona, and he jokes that he’ll need to see some ID to prove it.
Shi-jin gets another call from his commanding officer, and disappointment is written all over his face when he says he has to go. Mo-yeon is obviously upset as well, and she tells him she’ll stay and see the movie alone. He’s not happy about it but he has to leave, and says he’ll call her.
As soon as he’s gone Mo-yeon gets her own emergency call from Chi-hoon, and she runs back to the hospital to find out that she didn’t get the job, again. The snooty Dr. Kim was offered the position because of her family connections, even though the senior doctor had all but promised the job to Mo-yeon.
She’s tired of his excuses for not promoting her, wondering what the reason will be next time. Dr. Kim arrives and starts ordering Mo-yeon around immediately, and taking a lot of pleasure in it to boot. She tells Mo-yeon to cover for her on a television show the following day, because she’s got some schmoozing to do, and will be too hung over.
But Mo-yeon is a thousand percent done putting up with her crap, calls her a bitch, and says she’s sorry for the patients who get stuck with Dr. Kim. The other woman grabs Mo-yeon’s hair, Mo-yeon grabs back, and the others have to physically break up the fight.
Mo-yeon takes herself to a quiet hallway to cry it out, attempting to memorize the information for the TV show despite being unable to speak for sobbing, finally giving up and wailing.
Shi-jin and Dae-young return from their surprise mission, and thankfully nobody was hurt or killed. Their commanding officer rewards them for all their recent hard work with an eight-month break, which isn’t the vacation it sounds like. They’re being deployed, with only two weeks to visit with family before they leave.
Their team looks happy, since this means they will just be regular soldiers for eight months — no special missions, which for them is considered a break. But both Dae-young and Shi-jin take the news hard.
The next morning Shi-jin goes looking for Mo-yeon, and finds her just as she’s doing her live broadcast. He watches her on television, smiling with his heart in his eyes. He’s such a smitten kitten.
He waits at her house for her to come home, and the mood is tense as they go for coffee. Shi-jin apologizes for leaving Mo-yeon that way, but she says that what she really wants is an explanation. He says that he didn’t go far, but that’s all he’s allowed to say.
He can’t even confirm whether or not he’s a spy, and Mo-yeon admits that she thought of him a lot today. She wondered where he disappears to, and what he does, but then she can’t even get answers when she sees him. She tries to put the clues together on her own, and Shi-jin can only give her this sad look, as if he’d love nothing more than to tell her everything.
She asks if he kills people, and if they’re at least bad people, but meets with silence again. She says that her job is to fight for people’s life, and deduces that his job is to protect others by using death. Shi-jin gives the tiniest nod at that, and his only defense is that he’s a soldier, and soldiers follow orders. He doesn’t have the luxury of deciding what’s right or wrong.
He tells Mo-yeon that he’s lost three friends in combat, and that he believes that what he’s fighting for, at least, is peace and freedom. Mo-yeon counters that as a doctor, she believes that nothing is more important than life, and Shi-jin can’t argue with that. She tells him that this wasn’t quite the meeting she was hoping it would turn out to be, effectively ending their brief relationship. Shi-jin says he understands and lets her go, adding that it was nice meeting her.
Shi-jin broods in the shower, but not for long, as Dae-young joins him and they discuss their upcoming deployment. They each avoid talking about their respective love interests, preferring not to go into detail about why they’re not spending time with them before they leave.
Eight months later.
Still on deployment (in a fictional country named Uruk), Shi-jin takes a break while his men sweep a hillside for explosives, and everyone goes on alert when a live one is located. One of the bomb experts asks what they should do — if they report it they’ll be told to leave it alone until the U.S. troops arrive.
Noting the small crowd of children that are gathering, Shi-jin has the man repeat his personal motto: “Go easy and all will be well. Avoid hard work.” Hard work is defined as sending memos, which, ha. Basically, he’s prepared to handle this situation right now, on their own.
Cut to: Shi-jin and Dae-young pulled up in front of their commander, in big trouble for not reporting a live bomb. I just love Shi-jin’s dry sense of humor, as he says, “My second in command didn’t stop me.” And then he whines at Dae-young for not stopping him… doesn’t he know how much he loves sending memos? I feel bad for Dae-young, having to put up with Shi-jin all the time.
Shi-jin and Dae-young are punished to run in full gear, and aww, their entire platoon joins them in solidarity… for about three seconds, and then they run back to their barracks, giggling like fools. Boys.
As it turns out, Mo-yeon made such a good impression on her first live broadcast that she’s now a regular on the show, where she gives medical advice to viewers. It’s made her a bit of a celebrity, and she’s now in charge of some pretty high-profile VIP patients. Their complaints seem trivial to Mo-yeon — stress, DNA testing to determine paternity on illegitimate children, and even one businessman who can’t keep up sexually with his young girlfriend.
Her friend Sang-hyun teases her for being too important to mingle with the lowly surgeon peons lately, though Mo-yeon is aware that things could change on a dime again. It doesn’t stop her from clocking Dr. Kim’s snort of jealousy, though.
Dr. Kim snarks that if she’s not careful, people will start to think Mo-yeon is an actual doctor, and Mo-yeon shoots back that she’s hardly a doctor either — she’s just her father’s daughter. Oh burn. It’s obvious that Dr. Kim is jealous of Mo-yeon’s celebrity, and Mo-yeon isn’t above reminding her that she only got on the show because Dr. Kim thought she was too important to do it herself.
Mo-yeon goes to the roof that night, remembering how Shi-jin had asked her out here, then flown off in a helicopter. We see that when they’d eaten at her place that one time, she’d lit a candle and insisted he not move it, because she’d carefully calculated the best place for it to light her face perfectly. How much do I love that she just admits it?
He’d asked about her work, and she’d told him that she looks pretty sexy when suited up for surgery. She held her hands up to show how her mask accentuates her eyes, and Shi-jin joked that he wants to date that girl.
Still on deployment, Shi-jin finds a soldier digging a hole and awww, it’s Ki-bum, the thief that Dae-young took special interest in. Shi-jin starts to show him how to dig more efficiently when the shovel handle breaks, and Ki-bum laughs that that’s why he was digging carefully.
Shi-jin smiles just a bit when he sees that he’s cut his hand — it reminds him how Mo-yeon never believed him that he was injured “doing labor,” and now he actually has been. He realizes that Ki-bum is writing on his arm the same way he did to the kid (“injured shoveling,” heh), and orders him to attention.
When Dae-young finds them, Shi-jin asks why he brought this kid anyway, and Dae-young simply says, “I like him.” As it turns out, Ki-bum is a great cook, and he’s in charge of making dinner for their sergeant’s birthday today. With his trademark mischievous grin, Shi-jin offers to be in charge of procuring the wine.
They head to a bar, where they argue over who the pretty waitress was aiming her come-hither eyes at. A girl comes in to buy a gun from that same waitress, and for some reason she levels it at the guys. Shi-jin quickly takes it and points it back at her, then disassembles it, asking why she’s buying a gun if she doesn’t even know how to use it.
She retorts that she’s buying it not to kill, but for protection, taking her gun and leaving. Shi-jin asks the waitress who the girl was, but she lets him know firmly that she doesn’t sell information.
Coincidentally, Mo-yeon’s hospital has interests in Uruk as well, and is planning on building an eco-friendly power plant there. They’ve put a call out for volunteers, and Chi-hoon is the first to sign up. The hospital’s director asks Mo-yeon to have dinner with him that night, and with no other information, the doctors all assume it’s a date.
But Mo-yeon is taken aback when Director Han makes it clear that they’re spending the evening at his place, and not just for dinner. He even offers to let her shower first, the slimeball. That handbag to the face was well-deserved.
Mo-yeon wails to Dr. Pyo — what will she do now that she’s assaulted the hospital director? She has to sit through a meeting he’s running about the power plant, and finds herself voluntold for duty in retaliation. At least he made her team leader?
Shi-jin’s team is notified of which doctors will be coming over, so he knows that she’s arriving soon. Dae-young wonders if it’s fate, but Shi-jin just says that it’s a passing coincidence.
Slimeball Director Han calls Mo-yeon one last time as the team is waiting on the tarmac in Uruk for their UN escort, and offers her one last chance to come back — on his terms, of course. She basically calls him a lowlife right in front of everyone, reminding him that she has connections and has even been on television, so she’ll be tendering her resignation the moment she arrives back in Korea. Okay, I officially love her.
The team is relieved to see their escort arrive by helicopter, and who else could it be but Shi-jin and his platoon. Mo-yeon recognizes Shi-jin immediately and freezes, memories of their short time together rushing through her mind…
… and Shi-jin walks right past her.
COMMENTS
It was a strong first week for Descended from the Sun, both rating-wise and story-wise. I’ve been burned before by strong beginnings, but I hope against hope that the fact that it’s pre-produced means that we can expect this level of quality throughout the run of the drama. While the first episode didn’t do much beyond introducing the characters, I thought that this episode set up the central conflict and romance quite well, giving us lots of information and some really nice character moments but never feeling rushed. I feel like I know the characters already, what’s important to them both personally and professionally, and so far I just really like them all. It’s a great start.
While I’m normally one to pay attention to characterizations and relationships first and foremost in a drama, I can’t help but be super impressed with the way this drama is shot, so far. The benefits of pre-production shine brilliantly here, especially in the fight scenes, where interesting angles and creative lighting add as much to the action as the actual combat. I was especially charmed by the scene which had Shi-jin’s mission and Mo-yeon’s surgery weaving and intertwining with each other, setting off and highlighting how each of them finds themselves battling life and death, though in very different ways. The gorgeous way the two scenes switched back and forth was as beautiful as it was innovative, and it’s my hope that, having had the luxury of time to do it right, we get these sorts of treats throughout the drama.
That said, I have to agree with the criticisms about the music editing, because though I actually do like the OST songs quite a lot so far, the use of music is so heavy-handed in some scenes as to completely distract from what’s actually happening in the scene. When your audience can’t even enjoy the moment because they’re rolling their eyes at yet another loud, obvious musical cue, it’s time to find a new way to introduce dramatic tension. You’ve hired some of the best actors money can buy — let them do the work you hired them to do! We don’t need overwrought music to tell us when one character finds another character attractive (plus, we have eyes).
But it’s the characters that really draw me in and hold my attention, and I find myself already very invested in Shi-jin and Mo-yeon, and their growing relationship. It’s so refreshing to see a couple who not only admit their attraction to themselves, but to each other as well, and so early on in the run of the show. Their conflict of beliefs is one I look forward to seeing more of, as they struggle to reconcile their differing ideals regarding life and whether it’s okay to take one life in order to preserve another. The actors are more than capable of expressing these conflicts brilliantly — the scene where they realized that their values clash so profoundly was heartbreaking, and that’s before they’re even in love. Once they can’t deny their feelings anymore, I predict a lot of angst in their future. But for me, I prefer love stories in which the conflict keeping the lovebirds apart is internal rather than external — I’d much rather see a couple struggle against their belief systems, and try to find a way to love each other in spite of conflicting moral values, than the most evil mother-in-law you could imagine.
I’ve been burned too many times to let myself get too excited about Descended, but for the moment, I find the positives greatly outweighing the negatives. Like I said, I’m hoping that avoiding the live shoot system also means that we’ll avoid the many pitfalls that go along with it, and that the show will continue at this level consistently. The show has everything going for it at this point, and I’ll be cheering it on as we go forth into battle.
RELATED POSTS
- Descended From the Sun: Episode 1
- Dueling press conferences: Descended From the Sun vs. Come Back, Ajusshi
- Sparks fly (literally) in Descended From the Sun’s main poster
- Descended From the Sun teases love and war
- Apology or confession in Descended From the Sun’s first teaser
- Song Hye-gyo and Song Joong-ki on the set of Descended From the Sun
- First script read for blockbuster melodrama Descended From the Sun
Tags: Descended From the Sun, Episode 2, featured, Jin Gu, Kim Ji-won, Song Hye-gyo, Song Joong-ki
Required fields are marked *
Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *
1 rockyroad
February 26, 2016 at 8:13 PM
The second ep was soo much better than the first ...
That music director is seriously impeding my enjoyment of their romantic scenes.. although now that it's pre produced.. They can't really alter it much ..
Required fields are marked *
prettysup
February 26, 2016 at 8:23 PM
Oh I thot the opposite, I very much prefer the first ep
Required fields are marked *
changhyun
February 27, 2016 at 1:16 AM
They can still change the music, they have sound engineers and such for that. Post-processing is all possible as long as it hasn't aired yet. When they talk about pre-preducing, they're referring to how things are filmed in advance vs the system of live shooting.
Required fields are marked *
Petra
February 27, 2016 at 11:45 AM
Aha! Good to know; the music is interfering with my enjoyment of what is overall a pretty good show. So far.
Required fields are marked *
Affie
February 27, 2016 at 12:05 PM
So how would we rank "I loooooovvvveee you" on an annoyability scale of 0 -100% against such 'beloved' OSTs as "Love is the Mooooment", " Almost Paaaradiiiise" and "You are my Deeestiinyyy"...
My ranking
YAMD - 43%
AP - 56%
LITM - 72%
I<3u - 99.9%
I still love the show tho, lol. I just have zero likability for this particular OST... And I'm totally a drama OST person... My iPod is full of drama OSTs...
Required fields are marked *
Petra
February 27, 2016 at 2:38 PM
Urm... I like the song itself while I didn't like the other ones much, so I'm going to give it a lower annoy-ability score. It's just the placement of it. But ask me again after 16-20 eps. Haha.
I <3 u= 40% (and rising)
Love is the moooooment- 99.9%
Almost Paradise (that one had overuse of so many other songs too) - 60%
You are my destiny - 65%
And yes, it's funny we recognize all these songs and rating how irritated we got. Smirk.
Required fields are marked *
Miranda
February 28, 2016 at 9:48 AM
YAMD - 92%
AP - 88.8%
LITM - 74%
I<3U - 24%
I notice tracks I like immediately, but it takes a couple of repetitions to clock the ones I don't like - and then I LOATHE THEM and dread them. Like, I'll see two characters start to lean towards each other and think "no, no no, don't do it, don't play th.... AAAAAAAAAGH!"
It's pretty much the opposite effect than the one the director wants: conditioning your viewer to yell "no! STOP IT!" at the TV during romantic builds.
Required fields are marked *
Petra
February 29, 2016 at 1:59 PM
Oh, I didn't realize that Yoon Mirae sings that song "I love you" (Always). I've liked her since Touch Love from Master's Sun. No wonder I liked the song even if not the use of it (except for the ending of ep 2, where I thought it was appropriately used...but I'm sometimes a sucker for sad scenes imbued with histrionic music).
Still sticking with my 40% annoyance rating for overuse and bad placement. Heh.
Required fields are marked *
Cat
February 28, 2016 at 12:01 AM
I'm glad there's people that agree. I wasn't so sure whether it was the timing of the songs or the choice of songs chosen. None of the ost i'm finding is spectacular to me yet, it smells of 'recycled mainstream ballad airplay'. If only they hired whoever is in charge of Signal ost haha.
Required fields are marked *
Miranda
February 28, 2016 at 9:44 AM
The "Signal" soundtrack has me dancing through the opening credits (but not the show itself because it is too intense for moving/thinking/breathing).
I also really like the light, breezy soundtrack in "Cheese in the Trap".
DftS is unfortunately old-school Korean sound design.
Required fields are marked *
Kween Ramyeon
February 28, 2016 at 7:34 PM
Oh gosh, me too! I also have it downloaded onto my phone and play it a lot too.
I love how it's got a slower, much old-fashioned beat, it makes me dance like Young Shin in Healer.
Amel
February 28, 2016 at 5:47 AM
Me too . i prefered more the second ep
Required fields are marked *
bello
June 1, 2019 at 5:22 AM
pls how can i download it
Required fields are marked *
2 laisF
February 26, 2016 at 8:17 PM
I think she "broke up" with him, and it wasn't about his work or idealism, it was more about her, she was having an awful day, and she needs someone to lean on, but at the same time she didn't know him enough to count on him and she don't expect it. He left her twice because of work. Maybe if she didn't have the problem at work she would be more understanding. And he was about to tell her about his eight months missions. It would appear weird to make her wait for him or go on the mission because of him. They needed to be apart.
I like how them flirt like adults. It's refreshing.
Required fields are marked *
bips99
February 26, 2016 at 8:33 PM
I have seen doctors like that but those that who are new and young.
I didn't expect a 30+ woman to have such a black/white approach though. You expect that with age and experience you realise that there are no absolutes. So that kind of struck as me too self righteous.
Required fields are marked *
Wendy Darling
February 26, 2016 at 9:45 PM
What youre saying makes sense. I thinkk its better that they broke up for reason which is not being there when she was at some really low point. That makes more sense.
How can you think of not wanting to date because he is a soldier who follow order and might kill people. That 1 dimensional thinking is unrealistic
Required fields are marked *
guest10
February 27, 2016 at 9:16 AM
Well u know actually its make sense to me..because if u look from doctor's perspective we know their job is to save people without discrimination.. But the soldier save their people by kill the enemy..its pretty much contradicting to me..and u know who wants their loved one have a job where they can be killed anytime and can't come back..so maybe she decide that break up..
Required fields are marked *
Elena
February 27, 2016 at 1:47 AM
Well, I cannot agree there, on the contrary, I find it quite realistic: They just met and she got stood up twice and realized the type of life the guy is leading...it might make anyone to rethink to go ahead with it. They are not so close or in love yet, so for her is not so difficult to decide to stay away, even if she likes him...
It's one of the things that I like about this show, for example the way the leads met and how he asks her out, it's not necessary to be Romeo&Juliet for a love story to be exciting... I like how it feels realistic (except for the helicopter thing :P). I like so much that they are flirting and showing that they like each other, not the typical love-hate drama attraction..., it made me remember situations I went through and relive some emotions, so now I am on board and wanting for more, though I am a bit scared that this is the same writer that produced the Heirs XD
Required fields are marked *
lindl
February 27, 2016 at 2:08 AM
If you mean you find it reasonable that she "broke up" with him because he stood her up twice, I agree with you there. But that's not her stated reason. She ended things (such as they were) because she didn't like his values, or something.
Required fields are marked *
lindl
February 27, 2016 at 2:18 AM
Not that I think there are right or wrong reasons for breaking things off with someone. Everyone has the right to break up with a partner for any reason, at any time. One partner judging the other is an especially good reason for a relationship to end.
Elena
February 28, 2016 at 1:03 AM
Well, to me it looked like she realized they had very different lifestyles and it might not be a good idea to keep going. After all, they only had one date (rather half-date), so it barely fits the concept of breaking up.
Her speech was a way to tell him how different she thought they were and that things would not work. So I did not find it that strange...
kathfurio
February 28, 2016 at 9:31 AM
Sometimes, you need ti have the "feels" to be with someone who you know yoi can rely on at times when you're feeling down. I think that time they "broke up", she's in the state where all disappointments, helplessness came down all at ones. And there's this guy, whom she's starting to have feelings for, can't be communicated with. The heaviness of whst we carry can be lessened once we've shared it to those we have emotional attachments. And this should be reciprocated.
We tend to make grand excuses even of it's only simple.
*I'm blabbing. Can't seem to express the miscommunication that led to their break up.
Miranda
February 28, 2016 at 10:00 AM
It's a blend of him being unavailable, the secrecy, and then the killing. And I also didn't get the feeling that she was trying to pin values as "the reason" - they talked about a lot at coffee, and I think it just snowballed into a breakup.
She's not wrong. She had a terrible, awful 48 hours and if they stick together, there's absolutely no guarantee he would be around to hear about her day. And if he was, then there couldn't be sharing because he can't tell her about HIS day. If you lay out that future, the instant click you feel with someone else gets a lot less clicky, especially when their frequent absences might end up being permanent absences because clearly they do things that could get them killed.
I thought it was a great, realistic scene, especially since the two of them seem to "get" each other on many other levels. The things that keep them apart really are artificial, but they're both entrenched in (and very good at) their jobs, so it's not like there's a choice to give up work for love.
lemondoodle
March 2, 2016 at 2:06 AM
They barely knew each other. He stood her up, their lifestyles were totally at odds and she didn't like his values, so really I don't see what's wrong with it. It's realistic. Even the being stood up is a deal breaker for me in a new relationship.
porschetapa
March 8, 2016 at 3:34 AM
Bum
lindl
February 27, 2016 at 2:06 AM
Yup. I'm a health professional and I thought she was being self-righteous. I also didn't like her in the first episode. I thought she was officious and making much ado about nothing.
I'm watching for Song Joong Ki :)
Required fields are marked *
sel
February 27, 2016 at 7:36 AM
Well she wasn't outing him or claiming he's a bad person, just recognizing they have some fundamentally different philosophies. I don't think it was self-righteous at all, she was being an adult and recognizing that differences in ideologies make a difference in a relationship.
That said, I totally agree with @laisF that a lot of it was also the bad day, the standing up, etc. It doesn't mean that she didn't have a point though about their philosophies, just that that's not all that's going on.
I think in that moment the relationship just felt overburdened with potential problems and current ones even in the baby stages, and breaking up just made more sense.
Required fields are marked *
laisF
February 27, 2016 at 8:59 AM
@sel Exactly! They even may have different ideologies, and certainly had a weight in her decision. But because of the pressure of work and for her right now would be a lot to deal with. For some reason I remembered my sister, she was dating this guy for a few weeks and she decided to break up with him because of the pressure she was having at work, and he was already talking about thing more serious, and mine sister wasn't ready to think about anything else except work, so she ended thing. After things calmed down little bit at work my sister talked to him and things went back to normal.
Somehow everything left her to took that decision, maybe if she got that promotion, things to flow better, who knows?
Affie
February 27, 2016 at 12:14 PM
@lindl... Are we saying it's one or the another? Cos I happen to think it was likely both reasons that led to the break up... I mean, even if she wasn't judging him for taking lives... Would any self-preserving be excited to date a person who can't tell them the specifics of their job and has walked out of every date they have had?
I think not really... Feelings must run deeper for that kind of sacrifice.
Required fields are marked *
Affie
February 27, 2016 at 12:15 PM
Self-preserving woman*...
lindl
February 27, 2016 at 3:41 PM
Actually, as I said in a reply to Elena above, I would find it reasonable if Moyeon broke up with Shijin because of the interrupted dates. And, as you and others have mentioned, the fact that he can't even tell her what he's doing. But her stated reason for ending things is that their values were too different. Of course, there's nothing wrong with that. As I said in another post, everyone has the right to break up with anyone for any reason at any time.
lindl
February 27, 2016 at 3:43 PM
*values are too different
Beanizbaby
March 5, 2016 at 3:05 PM
I agree that it's a combination of having a tough day and realizing that if their relationship progresses, she is not sure if she can count on him to be there to support and encourage her. Their coffee talk is one of my favorite scenes. You can almost see their shared disappointment that this great initial attraction did not lead to the results they have hoped for.
Did anyone think that maybe MY was hoping that SJ would have fought for her a little harder. After her speech, she paused, almost hoping he would disagree with her. Instead, he was so understanding that he said 'good bye' first. Only then did she get up to leave.
nevergreen
March 24, 2016 at 2:50 AM
@Beanizbaby I noticed that pause too! It really seemed like she was still holding onto a sliver of hope that shijin would disagree and fight for her. The acting was excellent at that part! Kudos to Song hye kyo.
Ozatogirl
March 10, 2016 at 3:03 PM
I agree with you!! The character does nothing for me....
Required fields are marked *
fdm
February 27, 2016 at 6:00 AM
he really kills people. it can sound disgusting to MY. their disposition is opposite. i think it can happen.
Required fields are marked *
chocopieb
February 27, 2016 at 8:04 AM
I feel its kinda ridiculous too, but then again maybe at that age, theyre looking for partners for life, and if even before their relationship starts for real, they have diff beliefs already, its better to cut it off immediately than wasting time trying~?
Required fields are marked *
Lwx_23
February 27, 2016 at 8:37 AM
I don't think the break up was just because he protects people by killing at least not entirely. It was not because he stood her up either, because if anyone could understand that aspect, it would be her. Her job similar to his requires that she leaves whatever she is doing if there is an emergency. She did kind of stood him up in first episode too and she might have done the same in any of their dates too.
In my opinion the real problem lies in that she had a very bad day and during that time she was thinking about him and his absence. It proved that something deep could develop between them; however, when he tells her that he can't say anything about his job, she realizes how serious his job is and consequences of it. The problem isn't just the possibility of him killing someone, but also that he might get killed himself too. Not to mention that she might not even know about it, if something happened to him considering the secrecy some of his mission includes. This also came at time when she lost something she carried a lot about, so it was a defensive mechanism something similar happening. Which can also be seen later in how he approaches her job.
Required fields are marked *
Affie
February 27, 2016 at 12:17 PM
@Lwx_23. Exactly. I agree with this one too...
Required fields are marked *
Maryt
February 27, 2016 at 12:51 PM
I like the way you think.
Required fields are marked *
erika04
February 27, 2016 at 1:41 PM
I agree with your thought. at first she just thought that he just a regular soldier not some elite that would suddenly been called and off to battle field and might get killed and kill someone. perhaps she already think a head of her future with him and that overwhelm her because he will me nowhere often and she can see him that is why she said that. better to end it soon rather that suffer for long after she loved him so much then. heck I would do the same.
Required fields are marked *
lindl
February 27, 2016 at 4:04 PM
This makes sense. I'm also glad you pointed out that a doctor, of all people, should be understanding of another person with an irregular work schedule. But she didn't really seem understanding. She acted hurt at the movie theater. Nothing wrong with that, of course, and I'd feel hurt, too, if it happened to me. Basically I just don't think I like the character as she's written.
Required fields are marked *
fdm
February 27, 2016 at 8:13 PM
because of her job, she understands the emergency call. If she was ignorant of it, she would think it lightly. but she knows well.
she wouldn't want a partner with irregular job schedule.
the drama shows they are different and similar.
she is competent at her job but doesn't always like getting orders from seniors.
he also doesn't follow orders.
Required fields are marked *
lemondoodle
March 2, 2016 at 2:09 AM
Yep. Honestly, even if he's SJK most people would get out of that "relationship" really quickly before they actually did fall for the guy.
Required fields are marked *
Kween Ramyeon
February 27, 2016 at 1:45 PM
I hear what you're saying and the thing is, even if one says, ok, I won't be judgemental and I won't have a black and white attitude his military profession, it doesn't mean that it is all that easy to accommodate it for real in one's life.
If your worldview is aligned towards pacifism, and you abhor violence, guns, taking of life, and have strong political views against military force or certain foreign policy etc etc - even if you know your own views are not infallible in certain contexts, it can be hard to think you'll be in a close relationship or even marry someone whose life is completely aligned on opposite values.
Being together would take a lot of blocking out of truths and not really stepping onto uncomfortable conversations, and it might just feel like there's a great chasm in the relationship. No amount of sex appeal of a very fit man in uniform will easily overcome that.
Required fields are marked *
lindl
February 27, 2016 at 4:07 PM
In my posts above, I sound like I'm arguing against breaking up with people over values, but that's exactly what I would do myself. Having similar values with a partner is extremely important to me. I think I just happen not to like the Moyeon character; it's like everything she does rubs me the wrong way.
Required fields are marked *
Kween Ramyeon
February 27, 2016 at 6:37 PM
That's fair enough. I understood what you meant about not having black and white simplistic reactions too. For the record, I think I was answering bips99 though.
kafanyu
February 27, 2016 at 9:39 PM
I find it weird that she started dating a soldier in the first place if she was so opposed to violence. I mean, shouldn't she have realised right back in episode 1 that he kills people?
Required fields are marked *
lindl
February 27, 2016 at 9:43 PM
Good point. But maybe Korean troops don't really see a lot of action, in the ordinary course of things? Still, it's in the job description.
Required fields are marked *
kafanyu
February 27, 2016 at 9:57 PM
In the ordinary course of things, they don't, but she should have known by the end of their first attempt at a date that he wasn't an ordinary soldier. I feel like the gunshot wound and the helicopter were pretty big hints.
lindl
February 27, 2016 at 10:13 PM
Well, yes, about the helicopter. I thought it was weird that the gunshot wound was a big deal, and that Moyeon's being able to recognize one was a big deal. There's a lot that's weird about the writing in this show. It's like the writer doesn't really do her research, or doesn't think too hard about the plot.
kafanyu
February 28, 2016 at 12:49 AM
@lindl
>It’s like the writer doesn’t really do her research, or doesn’t think too hard about the plot.
Maybe c) all of the above ? ;)
Lwx_23
February 28, 2016 at 11:08 AM
Can't say much about Hospitals and gunshots; however, South Korea does have very strict gun control, so it might really be unusual for doctors to have seen gunshot wounds. This is kinda ironic as most of adult male population will have some kind of experience in handling guns. Then again even if something is restricted it doesn't mean people can't acquire it.
lunatic4kd
February 28, 2016 at 1:22 PM
About the gunshot wound...did anyone else besides me understand that it was really a knife wound????? The two guys were battling with knives in the DMZ building - having put their guns down due to the "first shot" rule. This was a real disconnect to me - that the wound would be referred to as by a gunshot in the hospital. There were no guns fired in that altercation and we saw him grimace as he was stabbed.
Am I wrong? Did I miss something?
lindl
February 28, 2016 at 4:37 PM
lunatic, I think Moyeon was referring to a scar above the knife wound. The scar was what she recognized as a gunshot wound, if I'm not mistaken.
Miranda
February 28, 2016 at 9:54 AM
With age and experience, you also see some of this coming, though. She's had an incredibly rough day, and now she's faced with this guy she barely knows but the things she does know are: he's into her, he's been called away on each of their two dates, he's got a mysterious (but legit) job that he can't tell her about, that job sometimes gets him shot, and that he probably kills people.
I don't think she's being self-righteous, she's being a blend of cautious and practical. If she wants someone who will be home at the end of the day and will be able to talk with her about their days, it's not him. He could very well show up missing a couple of fingers and not be able to tell her why. That is terrifying.
I thought this was a very mature and realistic scene. And as she says, I don't think she intended it to work out this way - but she pursued logical trains of thought. And I think the secrecy element is the real relationship-killer here: not only does she know he kills people, but she can never know the circumstances. That's troubling.
Required fields are marked *
nomad
February 28, 2016 at 9:29 PM
I agree with you and Kay. I think that's totally what an adult woman will do.
Required fields are marked *
Beanizbaby
March 5, 2016 at 3:18 PM
I agree. Most of us value the ability to share our lives with someone. What does that look like if you can't talk about or share a major part of your life with someone important to you. Every time he returned from a mission, she can't ask him any questions. Their initial attractionfir each other, no matter how amazing, will not be able to sustain a life long relationship.
Required fields are marked *
kimchikay
February 26, 2016 at 9:39 PM
I agree with this comment...she's a grown adult woman with a professional career...she's past the puppy love stage. I think it made sense for her to sort her feelings out right there and then, rather then dwell over the possibility of starting something with a man who can't even tell her his job. Why should she own him the benefit of the doubt? She barely knows the dude. She only knows she is attracted to him and he is to her....that's why all they did was flirt thus far.
Required fields are marked *
Affie
February 27, 2016 at 12:08 PM
@laisF. I agree with you... I happen to think it was that ...and the idealism combined which made her walk away... That* being her wanting to be able to rely on him...
Required fields are marked *
porschetapa
March 8, 2016 at 3:31 AM
I am really not shocked about her behaviour toward him cause most doctors are like that. They expect everyone to understand their situations but they never even try to understand others'situation. SJ is a soldier and he never hidden that from her therefore what is it that she expect from him. Would she divulge information about her patient to SJ.....never but she wants him to tell her everything. NOT FAIR AT ALL
Required fields are marked *
3 Ataraxia
February 26, 2016 at 8:18 PM
Second comment yay
Required fields are marked *
4 Xuka
February 26, 2016 at 8:19 PM
Thanks for your recap. I love it. It has been so long since I said I loved a drama. SHK and SJK are both doing a great job on which brings so much life into their characters.
Required fields are marked *
sel
February 27, 2016 at 7:48 AM
It's hilarious, there's so much I don't like about this drama, but it's really fun to watch. It has been a while since there's been a good like cheese-munching drama. Just drama and something entertaining and prolly little sense to keep you going but you keep going and enjoy it. Here's hoping! :)
Required fields are marked *
5 apluszee
February 26, 2016 at 8:23 PM
I'm already counting the days till I can see Song Joongki pretty face again. Come fast, Wednesday!
Required fields are marked *
6 prettysup
February 26, 2016 at 8:23 PM
Am I the only one who noticed the luggages rolling away when the helicopter was hovering above them?
Required fields are marked *
bips99
February 26, 2016 at 8:36 PM
me too ... me too ... it made me giggle for some reason. i kept wondering if a light weighted person would be dragged along with it like in a charlie chaplin movie.... *i-need-to-grow-up*
Required fields are marked *
Terbear
February 26, 2016 at 8:58 PM
Nope you not the only one...saw that too.
Required fields are marked *
salt n' pepper
February 26, 2016 at 10:25 PM
Haha, I was looking at the luggages, too!
Required fields are marked *
August
February 26, 2016 at 10:29 PM
Nope, I noticed it too.
Required fields are marked *
Kudo Ran
February 27, 2016 at 12:10 AM
+1 :)
Required fields are marked *
lindl
February 27, 2016 at 2:14 AM
I loved that part, hahaha
Required fields are marked *
Daniel
February 27, 2016 at 3:35 AM
Nope :)
And I was asking myself would the roll away if there where actual things inside :)
Required fields are marked *
lailamajnun
February 27, 2016 at 6:04 AM
Lol. That was so funny. And one of the actress turn to look but looked back as if nothing happened. I wonder if it had stuff in it would it have rolled away.
Required fields are marked *
Nermin Badwi
February 27, 2016 at 10:50 AM
What luggage ?!
Required fields are marked *
Affie
February 27, 2016 at 12:21 PM
@MinaBoom...The luggage of the medical team when they arrived at URK and the chopper was landing to greet them...
They actually rolled away on their wheels and it was so much of a dead giveaway that those suitcases were likely empty....
And like everyone else I found it hella hilarious lol
Required fields are marked *
Kween Ramyeon
February 27, 2016 at 1:14 PM
Nope, I did too - and chuckled like mad...quick, run, bags run!
Required fields are marked *
7 bips99
February 26, 2016 at 8:24 PM
I like it so far ... its shot absolutely gorgeously and all the money they have poured in shows.
SJK is all charm and i am floored. but i am more drawn to the secondary couple story of jin goo
Right now it seems to be more of a romantic rather than a thriller/action .... its like a romance set in an unconventional setting where the 'setting' itself will be more for visuals rather than actual gritty human survival story.
And i am completely of with that :)
just a question - don't you find the styling of Song Hye-kyo dated ? Like something probably 10 years back
Required fields are marked *
cinnamimi
February 26, 2016 at 9:39 PM
Haha, yes, the attire. It's kind of plain (?). When she's on the roof (heli scence), when she went to the movie...
Required fields are marked *
nana
February 27, 2016 at 2:25 AM
I think it was done on purpose to downplay SHK's beauty & to reflect that MY's the character is not a flashy vain pot. I like her wraparound dress (or whatever u call it) a lot..
Required fields are marked *
newbie
February 27, 2016 at 4:36 AM
I only thought, that a surgeon, who has to stand for many hours during his whole professional life, who depends on his feet and legs, would never ever wear high heels like they gave her.
Required fields are marked *
Madridista
February 27, 2016 at 6:15 AM
My sister is a surgeon and I can tell you she only ever wears heels when she's out of the hospital.
Required fields are marked *
Affie
February 27, 2016 at 12:30 PM
Thanks for confirming what I think also... I would find a bit of place if doctors were bona fide fashionistas. The vanity alone needed in that lifestyle is a lot and I'd like to think most docs ain't about that life...
Required fields are marked *
Kween Ramyeon
February 27, 2016 at 7:14 PM
I found the fashion style for Gong Hyo-Jin in It's Okay It's Love, far more realistic for a doctor. At least, I liked it a lot more. Her character did dress up, but they're twists on the practical style - peg or high-waisted trousers, blazer, sneakers.
erika04
February 27, 2016 at 1:47 PM
believe me. I see doctor wore heels and fine dress for tv show. but in daily life sometime they wear casual shirt or jeans depends where they are. same goes with every girl/women out there. I didn't follow trend but still many my student and fellow said I'm looking pretty so define beauty for me? it just one's like
Required fields are marked *
Affie
February 27, 2016 at 12:27 PM
@bips99... I rather find the styling of her hair dated... She's had bangs in everything I've ever seen her in...including her movie with Cha Tae Hyun... My Girl and I...I caught it recently and found it so contrived .. I don't mind her clothes terribly... I was more surprised to see that more flashily dressed doctor-rival of hers...
SHK always has bangs...hm. She's gorgeous and really shouldn't feel that insecure without them
Required fields are marked *
angieya
February 28, 2016 at 12:28 AM
I think she has bangs to look younger, especially here when paired with a baby face like SJK. I usually find people tend to look more mature when they have their hair out of their faces.
Required fields are marked *
8 Mj
February 26, 2016 at 8:26 PM
Swooning swooning away
First SJK drama and am a fan !
his gaze felt so real
Required fields are marked *
Rerec
February 27, 2016 at 6:11 AM
Finally the first drama without bangs on the main actor. I am dying to see the grown up manly character in my screen.
And SJK surely never dissapoint.
Required fields are marked *
angieya
February 28, 2016 at 12:33 AM
Right? I find 99% of actors way more handsome and mature looking when they have their hair out of their faces. Thank the lord SJK just got out of the military before filming started, no time to grow his hair longer lol.
But since he plays a soldier he would've needed to cut his hair short anyway I guess.
Required fields are marked *
lunatic4kd
February 28, 2016 at 1:27 PM
Totally agree with you! Silly me - as much as I loved "My Love From Another Star" I didn't like Kim Soo Hyun's looks (or wooden acting) in it and I knew that 99% of my reaction was due to the straight across bangs. It took me watching Dream High to realize what an astonishing actor he is! Since then, I've noticed that I never prefer an actor with the straight down bangs. They all look more handsome with hair off their forehead - and more manly.
Required fields are marked *
Beanizbaby
March 5, 2016 at 3:25 PM
Agree 100%. I personally like shorter, styled hairstyles on men. Not into the long, girly hairstyles and straight across bangs.
Did not find him as manly in Nice Guy since his hairstyle is sort of girly.
Required fields are marked *
9 lordseungri
February 26, 2016 at 8:30 PM
loving it so far. SHK shined in this episode. SJK is absolutely adorable and charming. I totally swooned at the last scene. I found my crack drama.
Required fields are marked *
10 elvira
February 26, 2016 at 8:30 PM
I watched this yesterday.
Song Joong Ki: praise the Lord! love him even more.
Love the bratty Song Hye Kyo.
The rest of the casts are adorable, however I look forward for 2nd leads. Curious. Curious.
Required fields are marked *
porschetapa
March 8, 2016 at 4:04 AM
I like the fact that you are right when you say MY is bratty.
Required fields are marked *
11 sea
February 26, 2016 at 8:31 PM
I'm not sure how I feel about this drama yet.
Both the characters are pretty normal and realistic compared to other KES dramas, but I find them kind of boring. They're both basically perfect people with no foibles or weaknesses, so I wonder if there's any room left for them to grow.
It also seems like KES is trying to go for a "slice of real life" vibe, similar to the other SHK drama Worlds Within. I really enjoyed that one, but here it doesn't really work for me because KES doesn't commit to the realism, she injects too much melodrama everywhere.
Like Si Jin being taken away by helicopter. Like the brawl with the white special forces officer (I highly doubt special forces units fight each other like that upon meeting). Like the stereotypical "rich mean girl" at the hospital. (Also, are we supposed to believe that surgeons are going to start pulling each other's hair in the workplace?) Like the hospital chairman randomly propositioning Mo Yeon. WTF?
And then there's the sappy direction and OST. They literally only met each other once or twice and there's so many sappy slo-mos of them staring at each other and love songs playing in the background. It's just way too melodramatic to be considered realistic. I don't know how I feel about it.
Required fields are marked *
sorrynotsorry
February 26, 2016 at 8:39 PM
Yes, the slow motion is horrible. And the fight with the special forces guy was just ugh because those guys tend to really respect each other.
Required fields are marked *
Wendy Darling
February 26, 2016 at 9:41 PM
+1
Because they are no amateur. They are like most disciplined to follow orders. Because you dont wanna send there guys who will as Joon-Ki did make some decisions on his own. Or calculate by himself.
The politician calculates. The soldiers follow orders.
Required fields are marked *
sancheezy
February 27, 2016 at 1:02 AM
Tbh I find the scene is realistic, they both in same rank and they follow the higher order when they get confronted.
The fight is personal, the western insult shin ji and he wants to make sure that doesn't happen again
They doesn't acknowledge each other but when the other doesn't fight, it is their own quarrel. They didn't joke on the real field.
Required fields are marked *
Kween Ramyeon
February 27, 2016 at 1:38 PM
I don't actually find it realistic. Higher level ranking officers don't just do stupid things like throw knives or fight as viciously with chairs and shovels. That could have got them court-martialled if any serious injury was caused, not to mention the diplomatic headache since both teams, I believe was contributing forces to the UN peacekeeping corps.
Required fields are marked *
lindl
February 27, 2016 at 4:08 PM
+1
Sancheezy
February 28, 2016 at 5:26 AM
maybe we heard another things since I heard there's lots of internal fight but personal meaning, especially when they train, idk about UN corp
They don't usually blasted it directly like in drama, but fight between captain often happen, they do punch each other cause they just gets warn for the 1st time. The heated situation and insult can make that happen.
the adrenaline punch+insult always worsen things, if it's no the captain then the captain will punished them for the language.
Even if the other injured, they don't really care cause they just can be replaced. People in army is not a s cool headed as people perception, they really sensitive to insult.
That's why when they throw the knife they don't really want to hurt others, it's example for saying don't joke to me, but fist fight like they did is often happen for personal reason.
I don't say it always happen, but it happen sometimes. even Peace corps in army consist of soldier and people, the one that follow order and the one that has pride. They are not robot that will never fight just because they are sent to peacekeeping force. They get sent there not choosing it.
cinnamimi
February 26, 2016 at 9:44 PM
When Mo Yeon sent him on the roof, she stared with that kind of look as if they knew each other long enough which was actually unnecessary, plus the lyrics "I love you..." was too soon to be there... But I'll keep watching it though.
Required fields are marked *
lindl
February 27, 2016 at 2:04 AM
I know! It was a first date! Seriously.
Required fields are marked *
coffeeboysgirl
February 27, 2016 at 6:16 AM
i agree...i dont feel the chemistry at all...i just see two ridiculously good looking people.
however the second leads totally interest me...the chemistry! scorned Kim Ji Won is so fun!! she doesnt hold back her anger...i will keep watching for the second leads...
n yes the long intense gaze with the sappy music is as bad as heirs's looooooove is the mooooment!!!!!! totallly grates on my nerves!!!!
Required fields are marked *
Petra
February 27, 2016 at 12:01 PM
The last paragraph. I could get into this show more if they weren't playing "I loooooove yooooooouuuuuu" when the characters just met. It's incongruous in the context.
Not that I think they should play "I maybe kinda like you" but perhaps something light. Or, here's a thought, let the actors do their job without telling us how to feel so melodramatically with musical cues. ?
Required fields are marked *
Affie
February 27, 2016 at 12:32 PM
@Petra. Loooool! +1000
Birdie
March 1, 2016 at 11:03 AM
Yes!Totally!
jaesukisourgod
February 27, 2016 at 6:51 PM
I don't see the chemistry either. they're obviously two beautiful people, but I don't feel the tension that the dialogues want me to feel. and the terrible slow motion scenes and bgm music just always put me off.
Required fields are marked *
porschetapa
March 8, 2016 at 4:16 AM
There is something happening for SJ and i dont know if it qualifies to be called love but with MY i cant really tell, so took my time to look at some of her dramas and realised that in all her character such as Full house and worlds within she could not be able to show her love just like her male partners. I dont know if its because of the characters or plainly her not being able to show the love emotion.
blessingwind
February 27, 2016 at 2:24 AM
Exactly my thoughts..
This drama really doesnt make me feel attracted to it..It is boring.
Required fields are marked *
newbie
February 27, 2016 at 4:46 AM
Everything you said and more.
It's formulaic and there is no real plot. They create all those grand scenes to cover this fact up.
The whole special force mission was crap. As if guys who were going to risk their lives would form a team with foreigners who barely speek coherent English. The writer needed this scene to show how masculine and ballsy Si Jin is.
And this whole transferring the doctors and nurses (against their will!) into a conflict area. Why didn't she quit her job?! She is well known and popular due to her TV show, she'd find a job in an instant. Even weirder, as she mentioned it herself in the show. She could open her own clinic after the operation. Why not before?
This is sloppy writing. The writer lacks imagination to solve this questions properly. That's why we get all those stupid questions by an 'elite' soldier, too, to answert the audiences questions.
Required fields are marked *
Kiara
February 27, 2016 at 5:38 AM
She has been riding on the popularity of the pretty actors for her last few projects.
Song Joong Ki why?
Required fields are marked *
alua
February 27, 2016 at 11:23 AM
<And this whole transferring the doctors and nurses (against their will!) into a conflict area.
I find that a bit mind-boggling to be honest. You can't send people into a war zone against their will. Not unless they are soldiers, or something. More so, most people would never want to go to a war zone willingly and would do everything to get out of an position like that.
The few people who do want to go (soldiers, select doctors who SPECIFICALLY sign up for Doctors without Borders or something similar, select photojournalists, etc), are specialised and volunteer to go – but even they wouldn't just immediately get to go. There'd be checks and training.
<Why didn’t she quit her job?! She is well known and popular due to her TV show, she’d find a job in an instant.
Jejejeje... so true. I was expecting that MY would go because she decided to sign up for MSF or some charity, not because her boss wants to punish her/piss her off (seriously????). That would have made a lot more sense (you'd still get the very "fated" coincidence of the OTP somehow ending up in the same place, but at least MY going would make logical sense then).
Required fields are marked *
Affie
February 27, 2016 at 12:42 PM
@alua. I agree with all your sentiments. I found it all very fate-y ... And blame the writer for lack of ideas...
I think I would be liked an extension of the idea that MY doing this volunteer work could make her coveted Professorial position a lock... I would've liked to be a relentless pursuer of that end to an almost obsessive point such that viewers can tell that despite her obvious newfound fame and connections or whatever, she still considers making professor her endgame...
Plus, I got from the ep. That she was FORCIBLY transferred by the sleazy chairman and not that she VOLUNTEERED to escape him... She really had no desire to go to URK in the lead-up to the decision... She and the entire medical team she is now conveniently with..except the young expectant father doc...
I don't think I'm wrong...lol
Required fields are marked *
Affie
February 27, 2016 at 12:49 PM
I would have liked an extension of the idea that MY considered doing such volunteer work a plus that would lead to her locking down her much-desired Professorial position... Sorry if that got lost in translation above...
Such forced transfers are par for the course in certain countries with that kind of superiority-has-the-final-say power. I live in a country like that... And depending how widespread company operations are...you can get transferred all over the place for the silliest of reasons considered insubordination by superiors...
alua
February 27, 2016 at 4:38 PM
<Such forced transfers are par for the course in certain countries with that kind of superiority-has-the-final-say power.
You know, I don't doubt that. I can also buy into companies/parents/elders/superiors having excessive power over people, but as problematic and hierarchical Korea can be, I can't believe a medical institution there can force a doctor to go to a war zone (soldiers yes, but doctors, no no no).
If she'd volunteered from the start, at least one could assume it's something she thought about very carefully, maybe as a long-time ambition of hers (even better of course would be to show that e.g. with details on what kind of volunteering she did in the past exactly).
Kween Ramyeon
February 27, 2016 at 1:36 PM
I got the impression that while the Chairman did force her transfer, she was not entirely opposed to actually going, just his underhanded sleaziness. After all it had been emphasised that she had previously done volunteer work in Africa. Also, she had been talking with her team who were sort of enthusiastic, and while she was reserved at first about it, due to general grumpiness about not getting the promotion, I didn't get the impression she was deadset against it.
Required fields are marked *
alua
February 27, 2016 at 4:30 PM
<she was not entirely opposed to actually going
Yeah, well, I think even KES with her love for Melodrama (with a capital M) realised that writing YM as totally opposed and shackling her to the plane wasn't going to go down well...
<After all it had been emphasised that she had previously done volunteer work in Africa
I had a feeling someone was going to say that the moment the "volunteering in Africa in the past" was brought up. Here's a newsflash: volunteering in Africa is nothing like being a doctor in a war zone. There's a lot of people (though not everyone of course) that would go do volunteer work in Africa, including in very poor conditions. There are very few people who'd go volunteer in a war zone. (I'm tempted to link some of the photo stories showing Syria from the recent World Press Photo Awards to remind people what war looks like.)
Kween Ramyeon
February 27, 2016 at 7:06 PM
Hey patroniser - I'm aware that volunteering in Africa isn't like necessarily like being in a war zone. I have friends who work or volunteer with the UN, journalists who go to conflict areas and have a friend mad enough to join the Australian peace corps. I've even visited the said UN friend at post. I also tend to follow political news and political analyses, rather than relying simply on newsflashes written as poorly as yours.
In the first place it's problematic that Africa is used so generically by the show or you since it comprises of multiple nation states. Secondly, there are actually UN peacekeeping corps currently in Africa - namely 9. Just because there are peacekeepers in the zone, doesn't make it the same level of Syria, which is currently designated a hotspot, no-fly zone and have active invasive military force in action.
Take Cote D'Ivoire, for example - there are UN peacekeeping corps there currently. Only part of Cote D'Ivoire is considered really dangerous and no-go but the rest is considered safe enough with volunteer programmes running, especially for healthcare. I think that's how Uruk is positioned, rather than what Syria is currently, considering the boys are hanging about digging drainage rather than be on high alert and in combat.
My point is that if someone has the mentality of being okay with going outside their comfort zone, they're a little more likely to be open minded enough to go to a UN zone. Furthermore, the show didn't tell us where in Africa she was, perhaps she's already been in one of those UN areas.
nomad
February 28, 2016 at 9:35 PM
At first, I really like the two episodes. I've missed SJK...and thennn reading the comment made me realize, OH NO! The same writer as Heirs! Dang it! Now I'm just apprehensive. And thennnn reading more comments, I begin to see more pot holes. :( I want SJK's comeback drama to be excellent!
Required fields are marked *
Sancheezy
February 28, 2016 at 5:45 AM
I find the scene as she didn't knew that beforehand and get forced to be the team that sent to the border.
She didn't want to resign since she still want to be professor, even with her capability, change job isn't that easy since it means she kicked out from her former place.
She is forced but she is not opposed to the idea cause it means she will lose to him (she has a really big pride), she doesn't want to do but if she get choose to go, she doesn't really complaint about it.
I find it that simple,
Required fields are marked *
sel
February 27, 2016 at 7:25 AM
Yeah that fight was hysterical. I think KES dramas are distinguished not only by unfortunate gender dynamics but also horribly unconvincing scenes with foreigners. Like a bunch of dramas have the bad english lines, but KES dramas have the most hackneyed and kinda trashy portrayal of Americans LOL.
Also, it's kinda small but it annoyed me when the scene right after Si Jin and Mo Yeon's break up (and he was like 'soldiers follow orders') was of him defying orders by going in first to deal with the explosives. The point of soldiers obeying orders is that it applies to just about everything - I doubt that imperative goes away just cos defying rules will make him look like a cooler hero.
Pretty sure it was a negligible moment, but it undercut the image of him more than it helped. Plus I couldn't enjoy the cuteness cos I had to roll my eyes. KES drama male he is.
Required fields are marked *
Kween Ramyeon
February 27, 2016 at 1:33 PM
I think it might have been a choice to highlight another aspect of his character - that he's not the bookish, writing type and prefers a more physical approach. He seemed gleeful to be running with a full pack for punishment.
Required fields are marked *
Petra
February 27, 2016 at 2:54 PM
Gleeful. Haha. Apt word for that scene. Agree on the characterization.
You get the sense that he really likes being a soldier. It's beyond the mandatory military service; this is a life he has chosen.
Required fields are marked *
kafanyu
February 27, 2016 at 10:10 PM
>Also, are we supposed to believe that surgeons are going to start pulling each other’s hair in the workplace?
IKR! I was cringing through that whole fight. How juvenile can you get?
Required fields are marked *
angieya
February 28, 2016 at 12:45 AM
Every time I watch a drama by this writer I feel thrown back 10-15 years ago with all the cheesy plot devices. The directing doesn't really help here as well, sigh.
But I'm sure the ratings gonna continue to rise, ahjummas love stuff like this.
Required fields are marked *
Birdie
March 1, 2016 at 11:02 AM
I also find it is not working with me. The characters are kind of bland and their romance seems forced especially at their supposed ages, the love songs are too early in their relationship. Come on they hardly know each other.
They are both individually very good looking but as a couple they don't seem to match yet which is weird.
Required fields are marked *
Wang in the north
March 1, 2016 at 8:38 PM
my feels exactly.
Required fields are marked *
12 prettysup
February 26, 2016 at 8:34 PM
Although I am watching this for SJK, I just discovered that his dark handsome friend next to him very attractive!
Required fields are marked *
FireHorse
February 26, 2016 at 9:28 PM
This! I totally agree!
Required fields are marked *
Who's Scruffy Looking
February 26, 2016 at 10:30 PM
In 2008 he was in a movie with Park Bo Young called The ESP Couple. He's been in other things but I have only seen this. He was adorkable in it.
Required fields are marked *
day
February 27, 2016 at 1:07 AM
Comment was deleted
Required fields are marked *
coffeeboysgirl
February 27, 2016 at 6:19 AM
i saw ESP couple and Wolf Boy both...Man i just love Park Bo Young!!!
Required fields are marked *
Petra
February 27, 2016 at 2:57 PM
I like his acting chops. He can convey a lot with a simple movement of his eyes. I always did like that stoic type. Heh.