254

I Remember You: Episode 10

The most unlikely group of Three Musketeers find themselves being roped into working together on the same case—two heads is better than one, but in this case, three hits the sweet spot. At least their elevated IQs make up for their slightly lacking EQ, making them quite the unexpected Dream Team.

EPISODE 10: “Find Me”

Ji-an is knocked out cold by the two kidnappers while Team Leader Kang suffers a knife stab to his gut. Unconscious, Ji-an is loaded into the car, and Fat Guy Kidnapper mutters their destination to his lady assistant. They quickly drive away, leaving Team Leader Kang bleeding in the garage.

Back at Hyun’s cozy lunch party, Joon-ho comments that Hyun’s cooking is always spot-on for his taste buds. Lawyer Jung observes that the two must often eat together and Joon-ho simply explains that it’s because they’re neighbors.

Lawyer Jung has taken on the case of the body transporter, and Hyun details his original intention to investigate a corpse-less murder. Lawyer Jung pokes holes at Hyun’s description — without a corpse, it would merely be a “suspected murder.” Hyun concurs, and Joon-ho jokes that all this talk about murders make for lovely mealtime conversation.

Myung-woo reads the note that Team Leader Kang left behind, which reveals nothing about the location he and Ji-an went to. Luckily, Team Leader Kang rouses in the garage, and barely ekes out Ji-an’s name in a phone call to Myung-woo. But before he can reveal his location, he fades back to unconsciousness.

The team traces Team Leader Kang’s cellphone location, and finds him motionless in the garage. Thank goodness he’s still breathing, although Ji-an is nowhere to be found. Her phone is also turned off, and Deputy Chief Kang commands them to find Ji-an at all costs. Eun-bok follows Team Leader Kang in the ambulance, while the other two attempt to find some leads regarding Ji-an’s disappearance.

Their first target is Victim 1’s boyfriend, and Myung-woo demands to know where his younger brother (kidnapper Jae-shik) and his car disappeared to. Boyfriend in incredibly unhelpful, snarking back that the police should be looking for the culprit instead of wasting time interrogating him. Seung-joo grabs Myung-woo in a back hug to hold him back from resorting to violence, and Myung-woo recalls that Team Leader Kang followed this lead because of Hyun’s information.

Dinner conversation moves on from corpses to a list of composers labelled “victims of the tenth symphony,” because they all passed away after their ninth. The number nine strikes Hyun as particularly interesting, since there were also nine beads on the body smuggler bracelet (corresponding with nine bodies he transported). So either the tenth one is unfinished, or never existed. In his head, he thinks, “Either this is an act by you two, or a third party. No matter what, there won’t be a tenth murder.”

Joon-ho likens it to the curse of nines (a superstition that ages ending in the number 9 tend to be extra unlucky), and notes that baseball also has a ninth inning. But Lawyer Jung cryptically states that baseball has an extension beyond the ninth. I’m sure there’s ten more layers of subtext going on here.

Hyun receives a call from Myung-woo, and his expression hardens when he hears that Ji-an is in trouble. The two dinner guests look on with unreadable expressions, and they cut short their tea session to assist in the investigation. Cue: Most Silent Car Ride Ever.

Hyun arrives at the kidnapping scene, and Myung-woo immediately pounces on him for leading Team Leader Kang and Ji-an into a trap. Hyun keeps his emotions in check and asks for the kidnapper’s brother, who is then interrogated by a very intimidating and perceptive panel of Hyun, Joon-ho, and Lawyer Jung.

The panel takes turns offering observations and conjecture: Older brother seems to have little to no concern for his sibling, and in fact, constantly looks down on Jae-shik. Suffering from an inferiority complex, Jae-shik took his brother’s girlfriend as his first victim. It’s likely that Jae-shik was lusting over his brother’s girlfriend and was a peeping Tom (taking hidden camera footage). In the end, his complex, coupled with anger at his brother, drove him to become obsessed with his murders and the vicious cycle began.

Hyun notes that the murder seems to be well-planned, since the hostages’ holding place is well-hidden. Lawyer Jung offers to look into the family’s real estate holdings, but Hyun already learned that most of the real estate left to the second son has already been sold off.

Ji-an wakes up in a warehouse, where she’s locked together with the other victim, who was also Myung-woo’s blind date. Victim Hyun-sook is relieved that Ji-an’s with the police, although not that encouraged by the fact that Ji-an’s similarly helpless. Ji-an recalls that there were two culprits who ambushed her, and guesses that since Team Leader Kang isn’t here, he must have been left behind in the garage.

Ji-an asks for more information regarding the kidnappers, and surprised to hear that there’s a lady involved.

Using triangulation, Hyun marks out the area of probable hideouts. Joon-ho shoots down the possibility that Jae-shik would use his brother’s property given the animosity between the two, although Lawyer Jung begs to differ, seeing it as a plausible act of defiance.

Hyun deduces that there’s an accomplice involved, acting as driver in the speedy getaways. If there was a second person, that also explains how the victim’s faces were wiped clean, and Hyun hones in on the kidnapper’s secret girlfriend. She fits the bill.

Jae-shik’s girlfriend approaches Ji-an, who shrinks back when she tries to touch her face. Thinking back to Hyun’s earlier profiling, Ji-an supposes that the woman cleaned the victims’ faces out of guilt, and the girlfriend agrees that she felt pity for the victims.

Encouraged by this sign of humanity, Ji-an tries to appeal to her sympathies by painting herself and the other hostage as people with friends and family. She pleads with the girlfriend to help them out, although all the girlfriend does is creepily walk over to the other hostage to trim her nails — she’d accidentally scratched Jae-shik, so she has to be “cleaned.”

Deputy Chief Kang and Chief Hyun anxiously wait outside the operating room, and the doctor comes bearing good news that Team Leader Kang’s condition is under control. The knife avoided the major organs, so other than a mild concussion and minor fractures, there’s nothing to be worried about.

In a moment of vulnerability, Deputy Chief Kang lets slip a few tears, and repeats his thanks for his son’s safety before slapping his trademark stoic expression back on. Aww.

He perches worriedly over Team Leader Kang when he awakes, and is adorably annoyed that the first thing out of his son’s mouth is Ji-an’s name. Team Leader Kang berates himself for not protecting Ji-an properly, and although he recalls hearing the kidnappers mention a location, he can’t recall the words due to his concussion. He gets so worked up that he begs the doctor to do anything — even cut his head open — since those memories hold the key to Ji-an’s location.

Ji-an gives the other hostage some advice on how to deal with their captors: Don’t defy or cave in to the kidnappers’ requests, pretend to be on their side, and don’t let them see your fear. Acting like everything’s okay will confuse the perpetrators, increasing one’s chances of survival. Behind Ji-an’s bravado, she worries, Hyun, am I doing this right?

When the other woman brings up the possibility that no one will ever find them, Ji-an is absolutely confident that someone will find them no matter what, referring to Hyun. And on the other end, Hyun has full faith that Ji-an will come out alive. Aw, you two.

In the meantime, Eun-bok has found a property owned by the creepy girlfriend that falls within the triangulation zone. It’s a junkyard a little out of the way, and Hyun & Co. immediately make their way there.

Jae-shik approach the two hostages and matter-of-factly states, “When a new one arrives, the old one has to go.” He leans toward the first hostage menacingly, and Ji-an volunteers to be the first target. Jae-shik insists on following the proper order, and doesn’t fall for Ji-an’s distraction tactics. That is, until Ji-an throws out her conclusion that he’s sexually impotent, based on evidence of indirect sexual assault on the victims. From the look on his face, she hits the nail right on the head.

Ji-an continues goading him, mentioning that it’s not the first time she’s seen the likes of such sexually challenged criminals. She insinuates that he compensates for his disability by bulking up on his size. Her tactic works, and Jae-shik moves to target her instead.

Team Leader Kang finally recalls the destination he overhead from the kidnappers, and informs Hyun about it. Turns out that it’s the same place that Hyun suggested and Joon-ho announces that Hyun won (since Joon-ho earlier suggested another location), although Hyun responds that he wasn’t playing a game.

Jae-shik gets violent with Ji-an in the junkyard, and her skills are unfortunately no match for his formidable size. She gets thrown around like a rag doll, but thank goodness Hyun & Co. finally make it to the junkyard. They spot the girlfriend outside, who tearfully explains to Joon-ho that she didn’t know about Jae-shik’s murderous tendencies at first.

Hyun and Lawyer Jung run ahead to find the hostages, and arrive just in time to pull Jae-shik away from strangling Ji-an. Hyun checks on Ji-an, Lawyer Jung jumps in to fight the murderer, and then the two brothers take turns covering for each other. They deliver the final one-two kick together to knock out Jae-shik.

Outside, Joon-ho listens to the girlfriend explain how she was too scared to disobey Jae-shik, but he doesn’t buy her words, claiming to be excellent in reading people. He stares intently at her while taking small steps towards her, and in her fear, she shakily points a gun at him. Nonetheless, Joon-ho is nonplussed, smiling at the gun’s barrel.

But when Myung-woo and Seung-joo arrive on scene to disarm her, Joon-ho pretends to have been scared out of his wits. Hm. The two kidnappers are handcuffed and brought away, while Myung-woo is reunited with his blind date. Lawyer Jung looks on in slight jealousy as Hyun helps Ji-an to walk, and she subsequently faints in his arms.

She lands in the hospital, and wakes up to find literally everyone peering at her. She covers her face in embarrassment, but thanks them for her concern. Upon spotting Team Leader Kang, she asks about his injury, and he smoothly boasts that a stab wound is a badge of honor for a policeman, though he cringes at his own cheesiness.

Not forgetting her saviors, she expresses her thanks to Lawyer Jung and Joon-ho, before sneaking a look across the room at Hyun. He looks away, pretending to be all unconcerned, but a little grin forms on his face. Ugh, are you guys allowed to be this cute?

Hyun follows Lawyer Jung and Joon-ho out of the ward, expressing his gratitude for their help, and Lawyer Jung replies that it was fun. Hyun hopes that they can meet under such circumstances more often in the future, since he wants to know them better.

Myung-woo is stuck in the interrogation room with Jae-shik, who admits to everything but the torture charges. Hyun takes his turn to interrogate the girlfriend, who claims to have been ordered by Jae-shik to torture the hostages. Since she can’t even hurt a fly, the process was traumatic for her.

Hyun diagnoses this as susceptibility disorder, a mental illness commonly found in couple murderers. Following this train of thought, he wonders if Min was kidnapped by Joon-young, and under the influence of a murderer, Min suffered from this same disorder and fell prey to Joon-young’s ways.

Together with Joon-ho in the hospital, Ji-an has reached the same conclusion, thinking the girlfriend was unlucky to meet a guy like Jae-shik when she might have lived a normal life without him.

Not convinced, Joon-ho describes a hypothetical situation: If ten people are placed in identical situations, would all of them make the same choice? His point is that the girlfriend probably already had a predisposition to violence and murder.

He stills when Ji-an looks up to find Lawyer Jung bearing a bouquet of flowers, and Joon-ho briefly states that he’s seeing Lawyer Jung a lot more regularly now. The two exchange subtle looks while Ji-an admires the flowers.

Hyun-woo is so lost in thought that he doesn’t register Myung-woo trying to make a lengthy thank-you speech, and storms off to Deputy Chief Hyun’s office to find some answers. He confronts her about Joon-young, and she recalls the time that Joon-young provoked her about being a female in the conservative police force, understanding that she has to work doubly hard to rise up the ladder.

It was originally Dad’s suggestion to prohibit all communication between Joon-young and the outside world, so all visitations and letters were stopped. But Joon-young made a deal with Chief Hyun to relax that rule, in exchange for information about other criminals, which she used to boost her performance record and get promoted. She had no idea that a couple of letters and visitations would allow Joon-young to coordinate an escape plan with his accomplices, which eventually led to Dad’s death and Min’s disappearance.

Hyun’s voice grows icy cold as it dawns on him that she raised him out of guilt. He asks if she really looked for Min, and realizes from her silence that she never did. He flares up at her, remembering how he’d put all his faith in her to find his brother because he was too young to do anything. She offers a weak apology, but Hyun merely puts the blame on himself, for trusting her and not personally looking for Min. It strikes him then: I didn’t look for him.

Cut to: Lawyer Jung thinking to himself, “Why did he not look for me even once? There are no signs that he even tried to look.”

Chief Hyun opens up her safe and hands over a stack of Fishing magazines, which she received not long after Joon-young’s disappearance.

Hyun pores over the issues, and each one contains a personal ad under the name Lee Joon-young. All they list are addresses, and Hyun hypothesizes that they led to the other criminals. He also chances upon a letter from Joon-young to Chief Hyun, a poem from Kindertotenlieder that speaks of grief over a child’s death.

So, Joon-young sent that note, intending for Chief Hyun to convey the message about Min’s death to young Hyun. Hyun wonders if there’s more parts to Joon-young’s messages, and contacts the magazine to place his own ad: a copy of that same poem. Hyun thinks to himself, “Don’t you think it’s time for us to meet?”

At the same time, a mysterious person enters Hyun’s house and leaves a journal on the table.

Hyun’s friend completes the background checks that Hyun tasked him with, and curiously, he’s found no trace of Lawyer Jang anywhere — no birth record, adoption file, nothing. But he did find out that Eun-bok was from an orphanage.

Ji-an gets ready to be discharged, and she grumbles that Hyun showed his face only once. Team Leader Kang drops in to visit, and she apologizes for leaving the hospital before him. He bucks up the courage to request a visit from her, but belatedly remembers that he will be discharged the following day. Once again, he apologizes for failing to protect her, and watches her head out with a wistful look.

As she’s waiting for Aunt who’s stuck in traffic, who else would show up but our shining knight, Hyun. Ji-an bashfully accepts Hyun’s offer of a ride, and quickly tells Aunt over the phone to turn back.

They head back to his house together, and he lets her enjoy patient privileges for a day. He allows her to choose her desired menu, and she revels in the feeling of power. Lol. Unfortunately, her cheeriness is short-lived as she thinks back to her ordeal, and confides that in that moment, she really thought she was at death’s door. But thanks to Hyun, she lived to tell the tale.

The near-death experience brought to mind memories of her dad, and she wonders if he felt the same fear of death. A lot of her thoughts flashed through her mind in that short moment, and one of them was the scary possibility of never seeing Hyun again.

He takes a step closer, so that she can take a good look that he’s right in front of her. And then out of the blue, she swoops in for a kiss. Omo omo.

COMMENTS:

Dude, do something, REACT.

Before we grumble about Hyun’s reaction (or lack thereof), I think this episode hit it home for me about how in tune and similar Hyun & Co. are. It’s no doubt that they’re all extremely smart and quick on the uptake, but the way they complete each other’s sentences, complement each other’s thoughts, and are completely on the same wavelength drives home the point that there’s something that sets them apart from the others. It’s quite fascinating how well they work together despite the tense undercurrents, and only time will give us the full picture of their complicated past.

The revelation about Chief Hyun totally came out of nowhere, in a good way. She’s one of those characters I assumed to be on the periphery, and it’s astounding that she’s pretty much single-handedly responsible for Joon-young’s escape. In her greed for a quicker promotion, her little disturbance set in motion a huge ripple of events — Dad’s death, Min’s disappearance, Ji-an’s family destruction. Of course she had no intention for any of the above to happen, but it goes to show how a moment of misjudgment can cause a lifetime of regret. The only upside is that she gave Hyun and Ji-an a common enemy, which plays a part in their eventual romance?

With the truth finally surfacing, I find the situation absolutely tragic for both brothers — Hyun for realizing that he personally never lifted a finger in looking for Min, and Lawyer Jung for desperately looking for a shred of evidence that his brother even bothered looking for him. And once again, this fatal misunderstanding circles back to Chief Hyun. As a kid, I don’t blame Hyun for trusting in his guardian, although my heart goes out to Min, whose unwavering faith in Hyun got chipped at day by day, and eventually crumbled to pieces. However, it’s little clues like this that give me hope that wide-eyed, Hyun-loving Min is somewhere still in Lawyer Jung, albeit under layers and layers of jadedness.

This title for today’s episode is pretty poignant, as a desperate request from the lost to be found. It’s a line that both Min and Ji-an implicitly direct to Hyun, and it’s his burden to bear. As psychotic as Lawyer Jung is supposed to be, the new revelations help put things into perspective and allow the viewers to sympathize with his simmering resentment of Ji-an. To him, his brother never once tried finding him, but actually goes all out to look for Ji-an. Min’s own request went unheard, and it’s tough to watch someone else’s request get through to Hyun.

The case of the day is a possible eerie foreshadowing of the future, which I hope never happens, where Lawyer Jung is like Jae-shik: Both feel slighted by their brothers, and seem to be looking for ways to get revenge or seek attention. It was a notable clue when Lawyer Jung saw Jae-shik using his brother’s property as a plausible act of defiance. Instead of avoidance, both Jae-shik and Lawyer Jung yearn for vengeance and embark on the path of offense, and could their target just happen to be… their older brother’s girlfriend?

I’ll give the Show considerable props if this case is an actual foreshadowing of how Lawyer Jung intends to deal with Ji-an. I pray that I’m wrong, but it would be incredibly smart of the writer to actually follow through with it. Of course I still hold out hope for Lawyer Jung’s redemption, especially with how fully onboard he seemed to be with saving Ji-an, even getting beat up in the process. Although I must say, the way he looks on Hyun’s interaction with Ji-an gives me considerable goosebumps.

Which brings me to the final scene; kudos to Ji-an for making the first move. Hyun’s romantic feelings are still somewhat opaque, but Ji-an probably saw Hyun’s harmless flirting as a greenlight and took the gamble. We are all evidently smitten with her, and the way she stood her ground when her life was threatened proves how much of a fighter she is. If only Hyun could see it too, because everyone else already does.

RELATED POSTS

Tags: , , ,

254

Required fields are marked *

The three phsycoteers i've read that word in IRY forum soompi thread..haha..it does really match to those three..

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Oh man, I enjoyed our trio far far too much. I wish there were more episodes planned just for more interactions. I really love them. Alas, I don't really see how it can end well for them.

The cases are interesting I think because often they can be reflections on the past, present, or future. But most importantly I think they always show that one small decision or event could create a completely different scenario. What creates a "monster" isn't one single thing...but it's also not one single thing that can keep a person 'human'.

I still just really love the overall tone of this show, and how it's balancing a quirkiness with some pretty heavy subject matter.

Also all these hints about our extra police guy have be completely baffled. I have some random thoughts but nothing very solid.

0
6
reply

Required fields are marked *

Really enjoyed the trio as well. I think that´s the only way they should interact in the future. I´ve personally had enough of them tea parties where they have a pissing contest of weirding each other out, lol. Sometimes it just comes off as unintentionally funny, especially when they profess for the umpteenth time how they want to know each other better or use flower metaphors (!) for that matter. Still, love the show through and through.

0
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

You know, sometimes I'm not sure if it's meant to be funny or not. Obviously the getting to know you has layers of meaning but the way they shoot it and say it...I think it's intentionally quirky and funny. Maybe playful is a better word.

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

@4D

I'd really like more occasions when those 3 brilliant minds get together to do a verbal character profile - we get their train of thought and it was entertaining! It was actually totally amusing, that they did their analyses right in front of their subject, dissecting his relationship with his brother and drawing conclusions without ever considering the subject's feelings (or that he could take offence LOL!) or so much as a by-your-leave, and then they suddenly quit the scene without even a bow or a nod. That was played so coolly by all three. True psychopaths!! If only they did go in for committing murder themselves, they would be the ultimate serial-killer busting dream team! :)

0
3
reply

Required fields are marked *

Awww, you've summed up the full glory of that scene so much better than I could have.

If only the TV stations would accept virtual votes for follow-up seasons!

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

It was a great scene. (I actually sort of wish we'd seen that guys realization later when he learns the full truth of the situation instead of just feeling baffled and insulted). But the three of them playing off of each other was great. And in the car when H says "it's not a game" I was like....well, yeah, but you're still enjoying it. And if it wasn't Ji An you would so be in game mode.

0
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

@osmanthus tea and 4D

True +10 ! :)

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

this drama is absolutely the best right now. In the beginning I choose to watch Hidden Identity because of the synopsis more interested to me & because of team leader Jang but after few episode I already bored with their stories & stop watching it.

For I remember You, I never saw Seo In Guk acting & Jang Nara always in Comedy drama so I really not looking to watch this but after give it try I'm really love this drama. Two of them is seriously good & their acting is so satisfying. Same goes to Lawyer Jung, Jun Ho, Myung Soo & Leader Kang. I do thing EunBok have many scene after this.

Leader Kang seem have a feeling to Ji An & quite jealous with Hyun. ^_^

0
2
reply

Required fields are marked *

@eynay

I too was noticing how Team Leader Kang has been shown to wish for some notice from Ji An. I felt that he looked like a boy going out for a treat when he had the opportunity to go out investigating with Ji An. I recall that when she was attacked in her home, he bothered to call her to find out if she was OK and he went to the house the next day to check on her, and even offered her his home for a place to stay.

I'm not sure if he is jealous of Hyun, but he may be. I do notice that he just wants her attention and is sad that she just sees him as the Team Leader and nothing more.

0
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

I also noticed! I find Team Leader absolutely adorable in his attempts to be closer to Ji An. He is like a high schooler with a crush, finding excuses to get her attention...I love him but sadly he does not stand a chance with Hyun :'(

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Thank you for the recap.

The casting of Lawyer Jung and little Min is sublime.
I don't have to exercise my imagination to see Min as Jung. Which makes Hyun inability to recognize the adult Min/Jung so appropriately galling to Min/Jung.

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Please consider the ratings of internatinal fans :D How I love the casts most especially the story behind those cases and the experiences forgotten by the psyco brothers. My questions might be answer soon !!! :) <3

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

<3<3<3

Many thanks for the recap, rejoycie!! Fantabulous drama!

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Awwwww, PBG ur breaking my heart so much ╥_╥
Min questioning why hyung never went looking for him. Min taking care of his hyung when he offered to drive. His look when Hyun helped Ji-an walks out... was a tragic mixture of longing, resentment and jealousy. I can't even imagine what he'll engineer next, possibly what everyone's guessing - putting Hyun in a situation to choose between him and Ji-an, oof the heartbreak...
Is it really impossible to have Min and Hyun back together being brothers, living in the same house? Just look at what you've done to these brothers, Chief Hyun, and Ji-an too. How could you not expect the worst of Lee Joon-young, a psychopath murderer? A few communication with the outside world is more than enough for him to pull off an elaborate plan to escape prison AND kill someone. Well, on the bright side Hyun did met Ji-an.
I'm curious as to how the death of the boys' mother puzzle will turn out. Probably it's the missing dot to complete the mysterious constellation in Hyun's complex mind. What if the brothers' sociopath ways were sparked by their mother's death?
Oh god, I have so many questions running loose in my head about a drama when I'm supposed to focus on my work. I can't stop thinking about this freaking awesome drama, ughhh! I'll just have to start counting down Monday then

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

I have a small inkling.
Could Hyun's father still be alive somehow ?
Someone mentioned in the soompi forum that the corpse of Hyun's father had been removed by lee joon young but he was never was really confirmed to be dead though.
Think about it Hyun came out of the room and saw his dad in a pool of blood and we immeadiately came to the conclusion he was dead but he didn't check if he was still breathing.He could have just been unconcious even though that was a huge pile of blood.

It just my theory but it would be a shocking plot twist..

0
8
reply

Required fields are marked *

Oh man, you're totally right-- you can't assume anyone to be truly dead in a kdrama, especially without a body.

0
3
reply

Required fields are marked *

IIRC, when adoptive-mom-police came to get little Hyeon, he was sitting by himself with an injury (how did he get injured? Wasn't he safe in the locked room?) and there weren't any bodies around.

0
2
reply

Required fields are marked *

In one of the earlier episodes, it was shown that after the fight between Professor Lee and Lee Joon-young, someone unlocked the door of the room Hyun was in. When he came out, he saw the body of his motionless father on the ground, and Lee Joon-young exiting from the bathroom.

After everything had happened, Hyun tried looking for Min and saw him being taken away in a car (driven by Lee Joon-young, unknown to him) and ran after it. He tripped and fell unconscious, resulting in his head injury.

When Hyun woke up and came back to the house, the body of his father disappeared.

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Lol. totally irrelevant, but it bothered me when the adoptive mom stepped on Hyun's dad's puddle of blood to get to the kid... I mean, tampering with the crime scene much? O.o

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

The show's doing a great job developing Hyun’s growing internal conflict over Min. I’m drawn in to the point of denial, when I briefly bought into pseudo-PI’s ‘Eun Bok was an orphan’ moment. And more than that, I think, the show is getting pretty close to giving Min a fair shot at actually being accepted into viewers’ hearts despite his atrocious record. Hyun’s brotherly love must be additionally burdened by his sense of responsibility for the events following their father’s death. It’s possible his childhood chat/promise with LJY in the jail cell revolved around his concerns/observations of Min. To think that Hyun has on his shoulders the likelihood LJY made use of his info to ‘upbring’/influence Min, especially in light of Hyun’s new hypothesis of Min’s ‘susceptibility disease’… aigoooo :'\

Surprisingly Min’s character was one of the bright spots in this episode. I think I could get use to Min’s sweet refrain, “it’s a relief” which he says whenever he has helped save the day/Cha Ja-in.

Was it a hole in the plot, or did I miss how they figured out who Jae-Sik’s girlfriend was?

0
3
reply

Required fields are marked *

Was it a hole in the plot, or did I miss how they figured out who Jae-Sik’s girlfriend was?

I was thinking the same. I realy don´t know. Did his older brother tell them? Or maybe she was known to be his girlfriend.

0
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

I watched the interrogation twice, and I think we were supposed to infer that it was info from the elder brother. But that part would have really benefitted from more details, because it was disorienting to go from day to night suddenly, with the brother being so cocky and indifferent about the murderer. Even if he's not surprised, shouldn't he be indignant for his dead girlfriend, or disturbed by the number of people killed right under his nose?

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Interesting idea there, that little Hyeon might have confided in LJY about his brother, since it seemed like LJY was the only person who'd understand. That'll make things even more screwed up than they already are.

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

I always appreciate the recaps as they really help me when I translate the subs for my hubby (he doesn't speak english).
But this time I'm quite puzzled with a scene (when Huyn's friend answers the questions about Lawyer Jung's family records). I don't think that there's nothing about him, that would be quite strange imo (he's a lawyer, he has a driving licence).
Could it be that there's nothing strange, not a single anomaly ? I really would appreciate your help with this ! Thank you so much !

0
4
reply

Required fields are marked *

Yes, Hyun's gallery friend told Hyun that Lawyer Jung doesn't have any suspicious records--- He wasn't adopted. He doesn't have even one driving arrest. It meant Lawyer Jung's identity is squeaky clean. It's confusing because we are confident that He is Min because of the paintings the he draws. If he's Min, then why was he not adopted? So either the drama is playing with us or there's a powerful person who cleaned up Lawyer Jung's records.

0
3
reply

Required fields are marked *

Couldn't prosecutor shin have been that powerful person?? I believe in the gallery friend, but Min/Jung is such a mystery, it's not so far-fetched to think he has some meticulously forged documents.

I like the mystery of Eun Bok as an addition, but I'm def crossing fingers that it isn't him. I feel like we've spent ten episodes connecting with Lawyer Jung, the last few almost explicitly connecting Jung with Min--but I feel like the brothers-storyline would be cheated a little if it was Eun Bok instead. We don't have much of an emotional connection with him anyway, and all the baggage of the story would be tied up in Lawyer-Not-Min instead. Still interesting and all, but I like this brother story more!

0
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

I'm definitely on the brother ship too. I just know that Min is the lawyer. It feels right. Eun Bok could be a red herring, or by an epiphany that I just realized through :katshirou:'s comment below, could it be that Eun Bok switched identities with Min? Is perhaps Eun Bok connected to the powerful professor Shin?

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

You're so kind ! Thank you so much !
I only understand very fews sentences and some common words in korean.

I'm really enjoying this drama, plus there are so many interesting details (like in this episode the Kindertotenlieder, poems written by Rückert, music by Mahler or the number 9). It's always great to learn new things !

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

I wish in the next episode Lee Hyeon would kiss Ji An back. hehe

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

is Eun Bok Joon Young's biological son? He was sent to an orphanage because of family circumstances, and Joon Young was dissatisfied because he wasn't "special". So he sought out a suitable heir/minion, and found Hyun and Min. But then again it doesn't seem plausible because of the character's ages.

0
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

Plus, LJY didn't seem then to be the type to bother with relationship attachments. especially to the extent of having a girlfriend and 'family'.

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Cha Ji An soared fast and destroyed my bias list of favorite female leads, placing herself as my now #1 heroine, a position I previously gave to Chae Young Shin of Healer. I love tough women who can stand tall and fight, though sometimes enemies give them double hard times when the tough girls fight back.

I feel so wrong for cheering hard when the brainy Three Musketeers were formed, with one side of brain shouted "YEAAY!!" while the other side screamed "Watch out, Hyuun!". With two murderers on your gang, you'll never know when they stab your back while smiling.

And the last... the kisssssss!!!! OMOOOOO!!!! HYUN, YOU BETTER MOVE YOUR LIPS NEXT EPISODE OR I'LL BE REALLY MAD. It's not time for Park-Shin-Hye kiss, and the Seo In Guk I know has been well-known as a great kisser. I allowed you to enjoy a shock for a while, but I DEMAND a lengthy response after that. In bed or on the floor, I don't mind.

0
2
reply

Required fields are marked *

"in bed or on the floor, I don't mind"

Haha this! Don't we all want the same thing? ;)

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

"I allowed you to enjoy a shock for a while, but I DEMAND a lengthy response after that. In bed or on the floor, I don’t mind."

I'm kind of imagining that too. hahahahahha how funny is that.

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Symbolism and foreshadowing aside, today's case reminds me a little of that Criminal Minds episode where a girl pretended to actually be a victim of a torture show but is actually the part of the organizers and criminals behind the torture show.

That aside, I am loving Bogummie oppa more and more every episode. I feel his pain watching his hyung care and seriously finding Jian when he grew up hoping to see at least little effort from Hyun to look for his younger brother. At that, Hyun truly is at fault for not trying. He was probably too fixated on LJY, which I don't blame him doing since they had those unforgettable conversations about monsters and secrets and maybe perhaps tips on growing up handsome since young LJY (oh, Kyungsoo oppa your little screentime steals my heart) and current Hyun as well as current Min are definitely eye candies. Hahahaha. Joke.

Anyway, I am excited for the opening scene of Ep 11. Will it be immediately after the kiss? Or a few hours or days ahead? GYAAAAH! CJA is definitely one of the best female leads in drama history!

0
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

Well, it's sort of Hyun's fault for not personally looking for Min, but it's totally understandable. As a young kid, there was no way he would have the resource to look for a person, and it was very reasonable for him to trusted his foster mother who was his father's good friend and a police officer with manpower, to do the searching for him. And now, he has grown up and he started to look for Min. I don't think we can really blame him on that.

About the mystery of Eun Bok, is that possible Min and Eun Bok's IDs have been swapped? But they are not babies when the incident happened, it would be very difficult to do that when one of them had a family. I'm so puzzled

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Also that tidbit mystery on Eunbok (oh Seungwon oppa, I lurve you)... at this point, the show has established SH is definitely Min... so how Eunbok fits in the main story of Hyun-Min-LJY, I hope it's big because of all the mysteries around EB, from the list of people Hyun asked for to his adoption.

My current theory is Eunbok may have become Min 2.0 under LJY. Perhaps deadman Prosecutor Shin had helped Min get away from LJY eventually, and he cleaned SH's records so Hyun's Art friend foubd nothing because deadman ahjussi helped SH have a fresh start and clean history on paper. He did tell a story before hand about a kid coming to him personally to tell his story. Maybe that kid was Min. Then when Min left, LJY found Eunbok? Do excited at the prospect that Seungwonnie might play a bigger role in the next episodes.

0
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

Perhaps, is it possible that Min switched identity records with Eun Bok?

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Super love this drama, it's eerie, poignant, romantic in some... All in all well executed, might be wrong to say it but it's the first time I'm liking the creepiness of the lawyer Jung and Joon ho, some creepiness of Hyun!!

Love Ji an, a heroine that does not need protecting. She is bad ass herself, cuteness is out of the window.

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

I am still under the impression that what Hyun can't remember is that his little brother has been a psycopath the whole time. When his dad caught him burying the dog and hyun said "it was dead when I found it" is because Min killed it. The drawings are all done by Min and he blames them on his hyung to Dad. I think the promise that Joon Young made w/Hyun had something to do w/helping fix his lil bro. Dad mistakenly puts all the blame on Hyun for being crazy and Hyun starts repressing those memories. So... I think Min is nuts. Likeably nuts. Like Dexter, but more adorable.

0
2
reply

Required fields are marked *

I have same thinking as you. The one who killed the dog & that drawing all done by Min. Min also ask their dad not to believe what ever Hyun said after dad ask him about who draw all that. Hyun knew what Min was doing but keep secret of it.

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

actually i've always thought those brain pictures were drawn by Hyun because i think he's aware of this brother's psycho tendencies and is curious how his brain works to make him that way. that's why he's fixated on drawing the human mind. i think it's his way of trying to or wanting to understand his brother.

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

When Ji-an talks about thinking of her father and how it feels knowing that this is the end for you, and her eyes just get full of tears, oh man I got goosebumps. g o o s e b u m p s.

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

3 of my favorite female leads' names start with a "C"

Chae Ji An
Chae Young Shin
Chun Song Yi

0
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

Cha Ji An *stupid fat thumb*

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

At the end there Jang Nara really wowed me with her acting. While revealing her true feeling, her eyes... they were just brimming with emotion, I could feel it.
She kept looking at Hyun with that gaze prodding him to action, and then she just couldnt keep it in anymore and went for the kiss herself. LOVE IT!
I swear, Ji An is making me squeal more than any of the guys in this drama lol!

0
5
reply

Required fields are marked *

LOL! Jang Na Ra is 'jang'!!!

0
2
reply

Required fields are marked *

think its spelt with a double jj as in jjang

0
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

@bjharm

Thanks! That's the beauty of the romanised version, words get spelt for sound but somehow we understand. :)

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Totally true. JN harmed both cool and cute aspects and made it believable. I didn't love her fragile roles till this show but still appreciate her talent and efforts. I would love to watch her in a movie after this.

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Well its JANG NARA. bwahhahahaha! her eyes gosh
I really love her, omo!

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

I saw another thread discussing that the journal actually belongs to Eunbok... apparently he has been carrying around during investigation. Is that true?

0
3
reply

Required fields are marked *

Oh gosh! Now I have to go and watch all the Eun Bok scenes to see what book he carries!!!

0
2
reply

Required fields are marked *

while i believed it's the police diary the Ajusshi wanted to give Hyun about LJY investigation but didn't get to being killed in the early episodes

0
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

I think this makes more sense :)

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Loving this show so much that I now want to watch seasons of Criminal minds and Bones that I missed.
I kinda kept hoping Hyun would show more panic at her disappearance and maybe hug and spend loads of time with her immediately after the kidnapping it's good this drama isn't following the usual drama tropes but I can't say I wasn't dissapointed.

0
2
reply

Required fields are marked *

and my mind is still stuck why Eun Bok didn't mention to Hyun that he is the first one on the crime scene rather than the Doctor (autopsy doctor)

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

i 2nd to you it makes me want to watch that show criminal minds.

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Now a new idea is hitting me, will Min die at the end??? I am talking about lawyer, I don't know why but I am just hoping and hoping that he is not the bad guy :(

0
3
reply

Required fields are marked *

@ fantasy

That thought did occur to me for the simple reason that if he is such a flawed individual and cannot be redeemed because he has become so evil, the only recourse of the show might be to have him die. If not, Hyun will be so broken, so guilt-ridden, and yes... even ready to take the wrap as he did for little Min.

If Min dies to save someone... Hyun? or Ji An?... he gets a stab at partial redemption and he does not have to face the full consequences of his crimes. It will be painful but have more of a resolution, giving more peace and less painful than having him alive and incarcerated for life.

0
2
reply

Required fields are marked *

Mmmm.... But honestly the thought hurts me :( let the logic fly away :P

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

But... I don't think Min is the kind of person who will be broken by incarceration. He's quite steely, other than when it comes to his beloved brother. Couldn't it be like in Pinocchio, where the incarceration is understandable and inevitable, but at least there's closure and the brothers can focus on rebuilding their relationship?

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Random Question

What is the name of the girl accomplice? It feels like I saw her before already but I can't pinpoint exactly where.

0
5
reply

Required fields are marked *

someone said in comments epi 9 her name is Lee El (if what you mean is her real name)

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

liar game?

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

you might saw her in "The Liar Game". She was the previous evil contestant in that game who turned to be a good one.

0
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

Lee El.

She was wife who destroyed Chucky's career in Divorce Lawyer In Love. She was the transgender patient in It's Okay It's Love. She was the escort who blackmailed Park Mu-Yeol in Wild Romance.

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Also Divorce Lawyers in Love as the actress Han Miri.

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

rejoycie, thank you for the recap!

"DUDE, do something, react."

Haha so true. Will we have that on next ep? Can't wait then. This drama is so addictive that I want to watch this everyday. Every intriguing ending, the cliffhangers, and now the kiss. PD-nim sure likes to play with us haha...

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Thanks @ rejoycie!

Is it too soon to say – what a wonderful show!!! Will I have to eat my words? Somehow I don't think so.

I’m really enjoying this show, no holds barred... no reservations about the motives of the leads, no holding back loving the main characters who’ve stayed true to form, no need to sigh over incomprehensible stupidity or glossed over plot holes, and no need to use tropes to create plot.

I’m basically getting everything I hoped I would:
- A really good crime-mystery with a romance enmeshed.
- An OTP who came about naturally, who can communicate truthfully (need I mention another show where that’s not happening?), who can work as a team, who trust and depend on each other.
- Police who actually are smart as well as funny, effective as well as flawed and who make a great back-up team to the OTP
- Villains who are compelling and extremely smart, reveals and mysteries smartly given to us at the right times, interesting crimes that add to our knowledge of how so many big characters interact and think and feel.
- Crimes that give us foreshadowing of what could come
- A romance that is given enough attention so that viewers get to grow more invested in it, moving slowly along with Hyun in this, and enough time is given to it, for it to blossom.

I like how this is so well written, that hardly anything depends on coincidence, everything flows well and the pace is well maintained. I cannot get enough of this good thing!

0
4
reply

Required fields are marked *

+1

to everything you said about this drama. Truly my favourite one so far out of the currently airing ones ?

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

@Growingbeautifully, just so you know I replied to your post at Healer thread :)

0
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

Okie dokie... I'll look for it. Getting too sleepy now to do much reading/commenting. LOL!

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

+2 !

0
reply

Required fields are marked *