484

Arang and the Magistrate: Episode 20 (Final)

It’s time to say goodbye, and the finale of Arang and the Magistrate ties up our ends in a nicely complete way. Truths are uncovered, tears are shed, and things come full circle to give us just the right dose of closure while keeping the door open for our future.

SONG OF THE DAY

10cm – “이제.여기서.그만” (Now. From here. Enough) [ Download ]

Audio clip: Adobe Flash Player (version 9 or above) is required to play this audio clip. Download the latest version here. You also need to have JavaScript enabled in your browser.

 
FINAL EPISODE RECAP

Ejected from the body of Eun-oh’s mother, Mu-yeon runs straight for Arang. But Arang screams, “NO!” and by virtue of her rejection, Mu-yeon gets thrown back like there’s a force field around Arang. In a way there is, because the host body must be willing.

Mu-young grabs Mu-yeon, who struggles to break free and begs him to help her. He says with a pained expression, “I’m sorry to have left you to suffer for so long.” How fitting that he sees her mode of existing as suffering, while she’s desperate to cling to it as a mode of living.

She starts to shake her head no in panic, especially as he adds, “Let’s go together.”

Mu-young pulls her to him tightly and says, “Let’s cut our ties now.” He plunges the Jade Emperor’s dagger into her back, and her body vanishes into smoke.

He’s left holding air… and then stoically sticks the dagger into his own gut. Wow. I’m impressed.

Arang watches in horror and recalls the conversation when she’d asked him whether reapers died. He’d replied, “We don’t die. We just disappear.”

Then Mu-young turns into smoke too.

Joo-wal comes by to witness the rest of the scene, though nobody pays him any heed. Sobbing, Eun-oh holds his mother’s limp body, and the hairpin vanishes from her chest.

Mom’s not dead yet, and he runs carrying her on his back, urging her to hang on a bit longer. She gasps out his name, though, asking to be put down. They both known the end is nigh and Eun-oh cries, “I’m sorry.”

But Mom looks more at peace than she ever has and tells him, “Thank you.”

Mom turns to Arang and gives her a nod, which Arang returns; it rather feels like a father giving away a bride to her groom. Then Mom closes her eyes and dies.

Joo-wal walks numbly, telling himself, “She’s dead. What do I do now?” Such a strange thing, to be finally out from under her thumb. I wonder whether he’ll be liberated by his freedom, or strangled by it. I… am not hopeful.

A new memory surfaces: He sees himself carrying Seo-rim’s dead body—and throwing it off a cliff. Whoa. It’s a pretty chilling image, and it devastates him anew. He trembles and says, “Till the last, I threw you away so terribly and didn’t know. Saying that I didn’t know may not earn me forgiveness, but I truly did not know. How many more memories will come back to me? I’m frightened. How am I to live on?”

Gah! You poor, pititful man. I really hope he doesn’t decide he can’t live on, and not just because I don’t want to see him die. I think it shows more strength and remorse to keep living, bearing the burden of his crimes. Alas, we know strength of character is not his forte.

Up in heaven, Hades tsks-tsks that Mu-young ended up saving Mu-yeon after all. Jade Emperor says that it’s a shame that negating one’s existence is an act of salvation. I suppose it’s because that also negates the weight of her sins? Is this the math version of soul-saving, where zero value is better than negative value?

But he adds, “Mu-yeon might have preferred hellfire. Don’t you remember? She hated the tedium of heaven, where she wasn’t allowed any desire. So she would probably have preferred to endure in hell, holding on to pain and feeling.”

Hades muses, “Then negating her existence may be the cruelest punishment.”

Jade says that at least his human came through in the end, though Hades chuckles that their bet is not over yet, and that Arang won’t be able to solve this problem: “So get that body ready to swap.” Heh.

Eun-oh and Arang pay their respects to Mom’s grave. She notes that the Truth Bell hasn’t rung yet, indicating that the truth of her death wasn’t Mom. Still, she thinks to herself that it’s okay going to hell even without finding out that truth, “because I’d have to go to hell in order to remember him.” Now that’s what I call the lesser of two evils.

Eun-oh tells her that Mu-young tipped him off on a way to find that truth. In flashback, Mu-young instructs him to take a look at the record book of life and death, which should list the true culprit. So… the gods knew all along? Was this just some big wild goose chase for the poor dead girl?

A living person’s records are up in heaven, but the dead’s records are kept in a library in the forest of the afterworld.

The catch is, Arang can’t travel the path to the otherworld until her allotted days are up. Literally, she won’t be allowed near it. So, Eun-oh decides, “I’ll go.” Say what? You mean… you’ll find a way to go while remaining alive and human, right? You’re not entertaining some insane death wish, are you?

Arang balks for the same reason, telling him he’d have to die to get there. Eun-oh starts to argue that Mu-young told him a way to go without dying (phew!), but she cuts him off to tell him to forget it. “I don’t have to go to heaven.” She corrects herself: “No, I don’t want to go.”

Eun-oh’s surprised. What can that mean? We know it’s because she doesn’t want to go to heaven and forget, but who else is getting ideas of a perverse drama where Arang becomes Mu-yeon 2.0? It’s almost funny.

Arang leaves first and trudges through town glumly, telling herself, “Even if I go to hell, I want to remember him.” Oh, honey. I feel for you, I do. But sometimes I wonder whether god gave you extra guts to make up for your brain.

Eun-oh asks Bang-wool if there’s a way to pull his spirit from his body (short of death), so it can go to the Afterlife Forest. There is, but a separate problem exists: He doesn’t know the way. The reaper is the one to guide the souls there, and as we know, he just lost his only reaper contact.

Bang-wool suggests he ask Arang because she’s traveled that path before, but Eun-oh tells her about Arang’s temporary restraining order from the area. So Bang-wool offers up a theory that he might be able to take just Arang’s consciousness along for the ride, to guide his spirit.

Eun-oh tries to persuade Arang to comply with the plan, because it’s dumb sitting here waiting for hell just so she won’t forget him. “You’re somebody who can go to heaven and find a way to remember.” Yes, thank you.
He urges, “Think it over carefully, why you came here.” He asks her to go with him and win her future in heaven; they can figure out the rest when they get there.

Arang thinks back to the day she’d asked Seo-rim’s newly discovered body why she’d just died like a victim instead of fighting. She’d vowed to find out who did this to her—words that ring in her ears now.

Meanwhile, it’s time for Eun-oh to honor his deal with his ghost crew, which I find so cute. He hears them out and gets to work.

Ghost No. 1 left behind a pregnant wife who hasn’t been able to properly name the baby without him. He asks Eun-oh to let him give the child a prosperous name.

Ghost No. 2 drowned, and his corpse was never recovered. Ghost No. 3 worries for his elderly mother, who still waits for his return; he was mauled by a tiger while fetching persimmons for her.

Eun-oh listens to these grievances with sympathy, then turns to Ghost No. 4, who bursts out, “Please marry me off!” Pwahaha.

One by one, Eun-oh takes care of the ghosts. A name is selected, a tombstone is erected for the corpseless man, Mom is given her persimmons and informed of her son’s fate, and Bachelor Ghost… is married off to another ghost? That’s so cute, and strange.

It’s a light-hearted sequence, but still quite moving to see the ghosts beaming at him, souls finally at peace, as they fade away to the beyond.

Eun-oh thinks to himself, “I have done everything I can in this place.” Please tell me you mean this place Miryang, and not this place earth. If you kill yourself out of nobility, imma kill you, I swear!

Eun-oh and Arang take a walk along the river’s edge, where she says ruefully that once she’s gone, time will continue on. Eun-oh replies, “I hated to hear the saying that time is faster than an arrow, above all else. Because difficult times always passed by so slowly. But as I’m with you now, indifferent time keeps going, and I resent it.”

Arang thinks to herself, “Where a flower once bloomed, a flower will bloom again. Where the wind blew, a different wind will blow again. But I will hold onto that feeling forever. Even though if I go to heaven I will forget you, and if I go to hell you will forget me. Even though wherever we are, we will not know each other.”

Eun-oh thinks, “With this heart, I will find you. If a man passes by you and stops, and tears form and your heart races—recognize that it’s me.” He says aloud, “Arang, I love you.” They kiss.

In the dark, Joo-wal gets dressed, then blows out his candle. Uh-oh. This seems ominous. He heads outside, just as his faithful servant watches him go. The man says, “Young master, please be healthy.”

Joo-wal heads into the forest, telling himself, “Days were black even when I opened my eyes. Time stopped even though I lived. These cowardly steps that I took with a fearful heart, I will now end. The me who could stick a dagger in people’s chests and remain unmoved, I cannot forgive.”

Joo-wal arrives at the cliff from which he threw Seo-rim’s body. He stands there for a long moment, thinking of Arang, of Seo-rim. Oh, this is so sad.

Joo-wal: “If ever we meet again, if that life permits, I will just stay behind you. From afar, as a black shadow, just looking, just hurting. I will not dare… to love you.”

He closes his eyes, and falls.

The next day, Eun-oh speaks with an air of finality to Dol-swe and the Bangs, thanking them for looking after him and asking them to keep up their hard work in the future. They ask why he’s talking like a person about to leave, and he answers that he must, having done all he can do here.

His last act as magistrate is to post a notice in town stating that there is a royal order not to hold one’s status against a person serving the government. Those who serve the citizens well will be promoted. He gives the citizens the power to elect their magistrate.

Dol-swe leads Bang-wool through the village, urging her to stand beside him rather than trailing meekly behind, which is enough to make me love him (though I already do). He grabs her hand, which practically gives her a heart attack, but he doesn’t care if people see and intertwines their fingers for good measure.

Bang-wool softens, and says shyly that it’s amazing that the road she walked a thousand times now looks different because they’re walking it together. Dol-swe totally misses the comment but he does earn points for taking her to a street artist to have their pictures drawn.

Then Dol-swe pulls her over to a table of jewelry and asks what she likes. She says she’s not much for accessorizing, but gives a jade ring a longing glance. Oho, are we going jade to suggest marriage?

That night they puzzle over their portraits, wondering if that’s really what they look like. She tells him that his macho aura is spot-on, while he tells her, “You’re like a great big moon.” Which makes her wonder dubiously, “Well, it sounds like praise…” Ha.

Dol-swe presents her with the jade ring and places it on her finger, which it’s a perfect fit—he was taking note when he held her hand. Then he pulls out a second ring and holds it out for her to return the gesture.

She slides it on his finger, and he takes her hand to say, “Till now, I’ve lived thinking that being a man was all about being strong. But I found that’s not so. An ordinary man uses his strength for a woman, but a real man uses his heart for a woman. Will you accept my heart?”

Aw, that’s so sweet! You big lug. She tells him he can’t take his heart back, and they hug.

On to the Forest of the Afterlife. Eun-oh and Arang lie down while Bang-wool ties their wrists together with red string, and I’m gonna be honest, this is not how I envisioned them being tied up in bed. But okay, I suppose they’ve got more important concerns at the moment. Bang-wool explains that this way they’ll stay together in the forest, and she’s attached bells to alert them to come back.

She warns that they must leave the forest before the break of dawn—otherwise Eun-oh dies. Also, they may be tempted by visions, but must resist: “Just look straight ahead and run on.” Is anybody else having second thoughts about this plan?

Bang-wool begins the rites, and they open their eyes to find themselves in the forest. Arang leads the way and sure enough, the path is lined with dull-eyed ghosts reaching out to them. Eun-oh shakes them off and presses onward, until Arang spots a familiar face—Seo-rim’s dead servant. The old woman tells her to come with her (“I’ll take you, there’s something I must show you”) and Arang starts to follow.

Thankfully Eun-oh isn’t affected, but Arang follows the woman anyway, arriving at a scene from Seo-rim’s childhood: her mother’s death. This is a mental journey rather than a physical transportation, and Eun-oh shakes Arang awake in the forest, wiping her tears and urging her to get a hold of her mind.

On they go, until they arrive at a building in the woods, where a warrior stands guard with a huge scythe. Eun-oh asks to see the Book of Life and Death and is told he’s the first living person to ask to see the record of a dead person.

Eun-oh says that he has his reasons and asks to be let inside. The guard warns him that once he enters, he has a time limit—and if he fails to find his answer, he will be unable to return to his life. Eun-oh answers that he’s prepared for that possibility. In he goes, leaving Arang behind in the courtyard.

It looks like a tall order, because it’s a large library with stacks upon stacks of books. However, he doesn’t have carte blanche to look at everything; he can only seek one answer here. The guard instructs, “In your heart, ask yourself what it is you wish to know. Then the Book of Life and Death will answer you.” His time will be marked by the red dots that have appeared on his hand: He has until the last one disappears.

Eun-oh gets to work locating Arang’s records. Already he’s lost two of the five dots. He closes his eyes and chants to himself, “I will find it. I can find it.”

Something comes to him, and he heads in a particular direction. He locates Arang’s book, and starts flipping through it, all while repeating his request: Who killed Arang?

A page wipes itself, then the answer appears. Eun-oh: “The one to kill Arang… was Arang herself?”

Stunned, Eun-oh puts the book back and starts to leave… and sees another book right next to it. Kim…Eun…Oh?

He opens it and reads, “I died at six years old.” A flashback comes to him:

The Jade Emperor carries Eun-oh’s six-year-old body and tells him that he leaves him a debt, and his time is not his own. One day he would remember this.

Eun-oh wonders why the Jade Emperor brought him back to life. If he does not own his own time, then who does? He bellows up toward the sky, “JADE EMPEROR!” I’ve got a few choice epithets to add to that.

Suddenly, he’s somewhere else. Gasping, Eun-oh opens his eyes… to find the gods awaiting him in heaven’s garden. Jade Emperor speaks: “Speak up, Kim Eun-oh. What is it you want?”

Eun-oh asks why he was saved, and Jade replies, “You were the human I needed.” Eun-oh asks if he was the tool to capture the fairy, and gets back, “Yes, but not only for that.”

Glowering fiercely, Eun-oh informs him, “Know this: You may have started this plan, but the one to finish things was my own will. Plunging the hairpin into my mother’s chest was my choice!”

Eun-oh tells Jade what he’s discovered, that Arang was the cause of her own death, but as she is immortal the bell cannot ring. Hades chuckles: “That’s why I said she could never solve this problem.” Aw, so did you sadistic old fogeys purposely give her an impossible task? This is why we mere mortals have laws against entrapment.

Eun-oh is furious, accusing them of sending Arang on an impossible mission and cackling to themselves as they watched from their heavenly perches: “If this is your game, at the very least you should have given her a problem that could be solved! Shouldn’t gods be fair?”

Hades says that he’s relatively fair himself, but this other guy “is rather wishy-washy.” I’LL SAY.

Mr. Wishy-washy tells him, “From the start, Arang did not come here in order to go to heaven. She came to know her truth, and to know who she was. Thus I allowed her to know what she wished to know. If Arang were to realize on her own what you have found out, she will have been rewarded. The matter of heaven and hell comes after that. Now tell me, Kim Eun-oh. What is the real reason you have come here?”

I suppose god-maiming is off the menu? Next thing we know, Eun-oh is bursting out of the library to rejoin Arang in the courtyard. He grabs her hand and starts running back through the forest.

In the real world, Bang-wool frantically rings her bell and begs them to hurry back. But Arang trips and falls, and Eun-oh turns back to find she’s gone. Arang wakes up. Eun-oh remains asleep.

Arang pleads at him to wake up… as her body flickers and vanishes. Arang reawakens outside, in front of a gaping black vortex. The door to hell.

It starts to draw her in, all the while she looks back at the house and begs Eun-oh to wake up: “Tell me that you’re alive. Tell me you’re okay. Magistrate, be well. I’m the reason you can’t wake up.”

As she stares into the abyss, being pulled in, Arang realizes, “Everything was my fault. The one who caused my death was myself. That’s why you didn’t tell me, because I cannot die and am meant to go to hell in the end.”

Eun-oh’s eyes open, thank god. He bursts outside and runs for Arang, darting in front… getting drawn into hell instead…

A flashback shows us how Eun-oh had named his request: Since he caught their rogue fairy for them, he wants Arang’s bell to ring. Jade asked what he’d do in exchange, and Eun-oh replied, “I will give up my life.”

Only, Hades had said a life wasn’t enough: Could he go to hell in her place?

Now Eun-oh looks back at Arang as he’s pulled into hell, hand outstretched. Arang screams for him… the vortex closes… and a bell rings.

Arang sobs, and her body vanishes.

We reopen some time in the unspecified future. Dol-swe is dressed in the magistrate’s robes and assured by a happy Bang Trio that everything here is safe and sound, thanks to him.

Bang-wool gives a taste of her pork-and-kimchi wrap to a tavern mistress, who declares that they should go into business together. Soon they’re drawing crowds and raking in the compliments.

She hasn’t forgotten her roots and takes a few plates out to the ghosts in the yard (with Lord Choi in the mix, HA). What’s even better is that in the ensuing fight, Lord Choi’s minion gets it. Lord Choi balks but the minion is all, “So, whatchoo gonna do about it?”

But! All’s not lost for our main characters, as we find when Hades tut-tuts to Jade Emperor about Eun-oh’s whereabouts. He was going to offer Eun-oh a place in heaven for his sacrifice, but Eun-oh insisted on returning to the living world. He wonders why humans are so intent on living there, and Jade replies, “That’s why they’re humans.”

Hades is bummed at the close call, too, saying he really thought he’d get Jade’s body. To make up for that disappointment, Jade offers a gift, and calls out, “Mu-young!”

Pan to: a white goat. Aw, so he didn’t disappear from all existence after all? True, he has to live as a goat, but hey, he’s a heavenly goat. Hades chuckles that this is the best thing Jade Emperor has ever done. Jade says that it IS breaking the rules, but he couldn’t resist since Hades seemed to miss Mu-young so much. So he reincarnated him. Ha, and also, let’s hope Jade doesn’t set off a whole new chain of misfortune with his well-intentioned rule-breaking.

Hades figures that living out his days in heaven is adequate punishment for Mu-young being unable to cut his human ties properly, and declares, “I’ll have to visit often.”

There’s a new crop of reapers to replace Mu-young… and one of them is Joo-wal. Awwwwww.

Back to earth. In a field, a little boy comes up to a little girl in a field of flowers. Omo. Is this… what I think it is?

A voice calls out, “Eun-oh-ya!” It’s Bang-wool, his mother.

Eun-oh ducks out of sight and tells the girl she looks familiar. The boy’s a little player in the making, saying that he’s met loooooots of young ladies in his life (all five years of it?), but she’s the prettiest.

He asks her name, and she says, “I’m Arang.”

Then the girl bursts out, “Look here, magistrate! I told you not to drink from that well of forgetfulness! Did you drink it? *SIGH* This is too much. What are you gonna do?! What good is it if I’m the only one who remembers, HUH? Can you really not remember? Really? AHHH what do we do, you AMNESIA?”

Arang heaves an adorable sigh of long-suffering and starts her story about a long, long time ago when there was a ghost named Arang and a magistrate named Eun-oh… Her frustration is freaking hilarious, and uncanny.

The picture blurs, giving us a version with adult Arang and Eun-oh. She rants in frustration while Eun-oh stares at her, wearing a smile on his face that seems reassuring. You’re faking this, right? You’d better be faking!

Arang beats him on the arm in exasperation and reminds him he wasn’t supposed to drink, and he finally speaks up, “I know!”

He says, “In any case, for us, what’s most important is this moment right now.”

She smiles, and plants a kiss on him.

 
JAVABEANS’ COMMENTS

Ahhh, what a cute, heartfelt ending. The concept itself is a tricky one to pull off, because if conveyed clumsily I could see this being a real disappointment of a resolution—you create a world and a problem, then pull the plug on the whole situation and just reincarnate them? Sounds like a cop-out, right?

But this is a drama where life/afterlife/rebirth is a central conceit, so I have no issues whatsoever with this answer. I’m perfectly satisfied with it, and I think it directly addresses two major issues I had with two recent dramas, Rooftop Prince and Big. In the first instance, I thought our ending was lopsided, making me feel sorry for one-half of the pairing and less so for the other. And in Big, we also dealt with an ending image that wasn’t technically representative of the reality of the situation—that is, refusing to show us the characters as they really were, choosing instead to end on the illusion.

Arang and the Magistrate, on the other hand, completely works for me. The reincarnation is exactly what I would’ve wanted for Rooftop—they both missed their chances, so they both get new ones together—but in keeping personalities intact, I don’t get the letdown of thinking they have to start all over from scratch. It’s not as vague an ending as hinting that they’ll end up together because they’re Fated To Be, which is a solution that would have driven me nuts.

Instead, I really love this idea that these two earned their next lifetime together, and the fact that they retain their memories and meet as children. Because both lived fairly heartbreaking lives in their previous existences, and this way I get the assurance of knowing they would enjoy every single last minute together of the new ones. These kids get to have their cake and eat it too, starting off already in love and appreciative of it. They get to skip all the heartache they endured in the previous life, and ostensibly starting an ordinary, boring, and long life together. I guess that’s what happens when the great big god in the sky owes you a solid; you get lots of cake-eating.

I also love how the drama highlights that Eun-oh had autonomy, the whole way through. Yes, the Jade Emperor pretty much predicted everything that was going to happen, and he stepped in enough times to steer the situation into being. But he didn’t have the power to force anybody to comply, and Eun-oh still had to prove he was up to his burden.

It’s interesting that Arang and Mu-yeon are once again shown to be of similar mind in the way they both regard hell—that pain and suffering is better than nullity. Maybe that’s a lesson Jade could learn from, because one wonders what kind of place heaven really is if you don’t feel that conviction of emotion.

Joo-wal’s ending was a nice touch that took away that trace of disappointment at his suicide, even though I was in no way surprised he made that choice. All along I’ve felt very moved by his character—never supporting his decisions, but still understanding them. That character was really bolstered by Yeon Woo-jin’s affecting portrayal, because he drove home the desperation and vulnerability at every turn. I find Joo-wal to be pathetic and weak, but not unsympathetic. So even though his new incarnation as reaper is rather grim (hur hur), it eases my mind a bit knowing that he does get another existence. It’s not necessarily a bright future, but he will serve the gods whose rules he defied and have to do his penance in a way he can bear. Perhaps it’s also assuring to feel, as the drama tells us, that a continued existence of any kind is more comforting than just vanishing into the void. Perhaps that’s the best gift for his character.

All in all, the drama showed that it had its story and world well plotted in advance, which is a pretty effective argument against the live-shoot in my book. I’m sure there were aspects that were written as the show went along, but you don’t create this kind of intricate world with expansive rules and sprawling mythology on the fly.

I loved Shin Mina and Lee Jun-ki’s chemistry together, both in the cute romantic scenes and the more melo turns, and it’s thanks to their connection that I felt the pathos of their characters’ situation. I did miss the early comedy, but they sold the emotion so much that in the end it was just all about them earning their happy ending.

 
GIRLFRIDAY’S COMMENTS

Awww. Yay for an adorable ending. In any other show, I might have hated having the couple reunite in an afterlife (and was dissatisfied with the mixing of the two in Rooftop Prince, for example). But in this drama where life and afterlife, and the destinies of two lovers carrying on for multiple lifetimes is built into the universe, and both of them are reborn to get a fresh new start, it’s a nice satisfying conclusion to the story. And how much do I love that Dol-swe and Bang-wool named their son Eun-oh, and he’s actually Eun-oh reborn? So. Cute.

The thing I was most concerned about was the issue of memory, so I’m glad that it was the primary concern for Arang as well. That felt right to me, that she’d consider going to hell just to remember him. The well of forgetfulness (and Eun-oh being called Amnesia this time, heh) was a nice touch, but I also would’ve loved to see them fight to come back rather than just be told about it later. Mostly I’m happier that we end the series with the feistier Arang who started the show, because she spent a good long while making so many self-sacrificing choices that she began to lose her spark. It’s probably my biggest complaint about the late stretch of the show, because at some point, plot-wise, it began to feel like we were just biding time until the end.

It would’ve been nice if the ending had something a little more mind-blowing, like Eun-oh finding a loophole that completely turned heaven’s rules upside-down, or Arang discovering a secret that changed everything we thought we knew. This ending felt in tune with the series and the world they set up, but didn’t rock my world or make me go Ooooh, I never would’ve come up with that! That’s what I want to feel at the end of a fantasy mystery, so while the ending was satisfying (on the emotional front), it wasn’t totally awe-inspiring (on the story front).

Overall I did thoroughly enjoy this show from start to finish, because it really did feel like thought and care was put into the construction of an entire world, where mythology and rules were important (because they certainly are to me). And visually, I’m a big fan of this director. I did see a huge gap in quality between the earlier episodes and when the show began to catch up and shoot live, so I think it’s a show that benefits massively from the extra edit/CG pass, but it was certainly a show that cared to tell its story visually, which makes me a fan.

I thought the contemplative goodbyes in voiceover for each of our main characters was a nice touch, and reinforced the life-affirming, cyclical nature of everything in this world. I’ve always had a soft spot for the epic romances that span multiple lifetimes, but they can be tricky to pull off in a satisfying way. It might’ve worked even better for me if they had crossed paths again as adults, but I do enjoy the humor in having a pair of kids meet with their adult personalities and memories. The chemistry between the leads was so good that it actually transfers onto the little kids, because you can see their characteristics so clearly. I think at the end of the day that’s what made the show so compelling—the world was populated with rich, distinct characters, and they had a sparkling kind of chemistry. It was nice to come along for a ride with a planned story from start to finish, and a really successful balance of humor, action, mystery, suspense, fantasy, and romance. It’s not often genre shows can manage to do all that, with so much heart to boot. And I’m not even mad at the moon anymore.

RELATED POSTS

Tags: , , , ,

484

Required fields are marked *

I love this whole story and am sartisfied with the ending (a first for me as most endings I have seen are rushed, disconnected and at times don't make sense.

I love main and the secondary couples and I am thrilled we didn't have a triangle (JooWal didn't count) or stereotypical evil secondary female who plots to get the main guy. LJK and SMA did a fabulous job and I absolutely love their chemistry. The other actors portraying the other couple were also good.

I also love the actress who portrayed evil mum/fairy and good mum. She was very effective in her role.

I love how the writer and the director knew where to take us from the get go. They knew what story the wanted to tell because a lot of times the story fails in the middle.

Love Mooyeon, he will always be General Chao to me.

I like how the actor playing JooWal was able to clearly depict the anguish he was feeling.

Thanks for your recaps GF and JB.

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

So loved this show! Loved the characters, the mystery and romance, the score... Props to the serial killer guy, who I thought stole every scene he was in. The show was so fun to watch, but I was really confused with the ending. Like why was it such a revelation that Arang killed herself. She remember that she threw herself infront of the knife, like 5 episodes ago. Also, was the scene of her with her mother dying supposed to clear that up? Why was the puzzle impossible to solve when she had done so when she was being pulled into hell? Was it a case of deus ex machina and all the rules got changed? the point of a mystery is to catch the clues and solve the puzzle. haaa... oh well, kensana. Still loved it.

0
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

ah-ha. Had to read through the post to answer my burning questions. It was all about the bell ringing upon the death of her killer. I c, I c.

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

A final farewell to the drama that earned every bit of my laughters and tears. It wasn't exactly a flawless production but it's rare to find an entire cast that is so lovable and every character so distinctive, be (s)he a hero, zero or evil. AATM is also the first drama that I invested time and effort, following the filming developments, news, photos, BTS videos, participating in the outguess-or-be-outguessed game of what's-next in the following episodes. I think that's where the true appeal of AATM lies, creating the space for viewers to imagine and interact. The PDs had fun creating the plot and laying down clues, we had fun deciphering them.

It wasn't an easy sageuk to begin with. It was with apprehension when I started to watch the drama, especially anticipating it because of LJG. This year, too much useless time and energy had been spent on time travel and love-that-is-doomed-to-fail-from-day-one scenarios are aplenty in kdrama-land. To say that ghost-human romance isn't exactly a genre unheard of is plainly an understatement, esp. when it spells a make or break for an actor who has been away involuntarily, out of sight and perhaps out of mind for some. But the first episode absolutely blew my mind because it was so very unexpected - captivating visuals, the comedic delivery by the actors, the witty/ humorous/ cute bickering and OMG! the strong chemistry between our two leads. I hadn't known SMA before this drama and she's so lovable! And then there are the supporting actors whose laudable acting lends credibility to the show.

The greatest challenges that AATM had was twofold - having to strike a fine balance between sustaining suspense throughout the show and not losing audience to the crypticism; the use of Arang as a deuteragonist and eventual exposure of EO as the actual protagonist. The former starts to lose its shine halfway through the show - even if we didn't understand what half the clues mean, we do know what the resolution is and what the executioner has to do. So it ends up that some of the later episodes seems to be only confirming what we already know in excruciating slow-mo. The same applies to the more than excellent visuals in the first few eps, which in this case perhaps too much of a good thing implies having to meet ever higher expectations.

I'm not exactly certain it was a good idea in the first place to use Arang as a deuteragonist and then shifting the attention to EO in the later part of the show (although it probably adds to the suspense). The title of the drama isn't exactly informative as to who owns the show. Say, I can totally identify with LJG's character in Iljimae because the story narrates from his perspective so I can feel the character's emotions like my own. But i find myself sometimes distanced from our two characters in the first half of AATM as the focus keeps changing - it feels as though Jade (or rather PD-nim) is narrating the story. My own suspicion is that a part of the audience dropped out when SMA's character took on second fiddle from the middle portion of the drama where Arang seems to have lost her spark - what a waste since SMA had already established a rapport with the audience with Arang's spunky persona. EO's character development took stranglehold in the later half and boy, was it well-written. I can't say the same for Arang's but her character development did manage to revive in the last 2 - 4 episodes.

The plot obviously isn't perfect. I can't for the life of me see the significance of Arang seeing herself as a little girl with her dying mom, except that it lets us know how LSR looks like as a cute little dimpled girl and that reincarnated young EO and Arang look different to others e.g. Dol Swe (they are acted by two different kids). Why BW's granny retained her memories (maybe she didn't walk down memory (loss) lane in hell), why souls can be summoned (do they need to apply for an exit permit?), why having a fan with Jade's symbol makes one special (didn't BW also have the cloth illustrating Jade's symbol and doesn't it also contain power in creating the vortex?). The not-exactly revelations we had on EO's dad came a tad too late at the rate where events were unraveling. And where is my flashback on EO's dreadful childhood, fighting off demanding ghosts and snickering nobility? But this would be nitpicking a show that has managed to tie in the many small details, thoughtful scripts, and deliver an otherwise well-rounded, logical, and satisfying ending. It's true that Mu-Yeon's 400 years of existence didn't take our hero very long to banish but hey, isn't this drama supposedly belong to the genres of mystery, melodrama and romance? Nobody complained very much about the fighting scenes (which imo are sufficiently good given that this show isn't even about action in the first place) so why start on how Mu-Yeon was fought off? It wasn't exactly epic because we were treated to too much goodies from the beginning of the show - in short, we are spoiled already. Whatever inadequacies the plot had was fully plugged in by the excellent acting from the terrific cast. The cast are the stars. LJG proved his acting mettle once again - his acting has matured and he has shown us that angst and wailing does not always make excellent acting. He looked really tired in his event today in Japan but still managed to be totally animated during the interview session. I look forward to his next project (what a long wait till next year).

For those who dislike or are disgruntled with the drama, tough luck and move on. Dramabeans' recaps and comments always make me feel refreshed and hopeful even when my initial feelings towards an episode aren't that great. That's why I have come to enjoy their recaps/ comments, even for shows I don't watch (Faith, Vampire Prosecutor 2). I just feel as though there are better things for one to while his/ her time away rather than to waste one's time watching 20 episodes and be bitter and hateful throughout the entire time and be silly enough to spend more time posting hurtful remarks. If it's me, I'll just switch off (like what I did with a couple of other dramas) and keep my comments to myself.

0
7
reply

Required fields are marked *

Thank you so much JK for your thoughtful insights! What you wrote really encapsulates the drama for me; although there were definitely some plot holes and flaws in pacing, you could definitely tell that it was truly a labour of love for all those involved, from the writers to the directors to the actors themselves. I enjoyed this drama tremendously, and I'm glad you did too!

This is actually my first time posting on Dramabeans, but I found myself nodding along so vigorously with your last paragraph that I felt compelled to leave a comment. :)

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

JK, reading your comments and insight on Arang was as much fun as reading the recaps themselves plus one of the reasons why I started commenting on DB in the first place - thank you for your words, and how gracious you are with them (we seem to have antis in the comments of some episodes, I've noticed).

AATM isn't flawless, but its flaws are mostly minor and they really fade when placed against the big picture, which is that this is a really good show, and everyone in it pulls their weight - I can't point to a single episode and say 'this was bad/boring', the way I can even with some of my all-time favourites.

(also, thank goodness for the recasting of little EO and Arang - child EO mk. Iwas a bit OTT/pathetic, child EO Mk.II is much better. And Park Min Ha as little Arang is perfection, she got the inflections and body language so right that I could actually hear SMA's grown-up voice saying it too).

0
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

@pogo, I love little Arang too. Her face when little EO approached her was "Duh, don't you recognise me?" And then there was her exasperated expressions when she thought EO forgot about her.. Always make me laugh whenever I replay that scene. :P

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

JK, I don't know if you're still reading but this:

why having a fan with Jade’s symbol makes one special (didn’t BW also have the cloth illustrating Jade’s symbol and doesn’t it also contain power in creating the vortex?).

I thought there's a difference between having a cloth with the Jade Emperor's symbol on it (with whatever power it has) versus having a weapon with the symbol, which to MY may be recognisable as something only available in heaven.

The best way I can find to explain it is that it's like the difference between having a print of a famous painting hanging on your wall versus having the original painting itself, and then running into someone who knows art well- they can tell the difference.

0
3
reply

Required fields are marked *

@pogo, that is an interesting analogy you used there :)

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Re the fan with Jade's symbol, I think Mu Young mentioned that it belonged to Jade himself, along with the hairpin. So as these objects belonged to Jade, they probably contain special powers "placed" there by Jade himself.

The cloth with the symbol could only open the portal to non-existence(?) when it was placed over the portal to hell in the house which was sealed off by talismans. These are probably shamanistic objects. The cloth did not have the ability to "kill" ghosts.

BW's granny retained her memories because she hasn't been reincarnated yet. The ghost/soul only drinks the forgetfulness water just before she crosses over to be reincarnated. That's also why BW's ancestors visits her on ancestor-worship days to eat at her table as they are still hanging around in the afterlife.

There was a flashback where they showed EO being bullied by the other noble kids and adults, and DS protected him. But I also wanted to see EO's childhood with the ghosts.....especially the little girl ghost who he mentioned.

0
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

yeah, I forgot that MY said the fan belonged to the Jade Emperor himself, it's a small detail but makes a lot of difference.

And I never had a problem with Bang-wool's ancestors' memories either, they're ghosts so of course they keep their memories, Arang was an exception as a ghost because she didn't remember anything.

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Hi,
I'm ok with how the story ends. I'm quite happy that they remember each other unlike the ending in RTP. But the ending was quite abrupt n was hoping to see more of their happy scenes together. LJK n SMA really looks good together. Any new drama in the future perhaps?

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Thanks for recapping this drama! I have to admit.. I lost a bit of interest mid-drama, but after the reading the recaps, I started to watch the drama again from where I stopped.

I loved the ending! I've been thinking about how the ending could be, but somehow I never thought about the possibility of them reincarnating and meeting again. I think overall the drama is really consistent and everything comes together really nicely. It is really a better ending as compared to Rooftop Prince and Big (ugh!).

Can someone help me though... I must've missed out something or some part.. but can someone explain to me why was seorim's body still intact after 3 years? What was the reason? (sorry if it's a stupid question). TIA!

0
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

I think the JE stopped Lee Seo Rim's body from rotting somehow, is all.

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Love love love lee jun ki and shin mina!!! Can someone compile all the hanboks that Satto has been wearing?? Dash-shing!!!

On a sep note, Nomu nomu nomu kamsahamnida Javabeans & gf!!

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

What a satisfying ending! I have mixed emotions about this episode since there are scenes which felt dragging while there are ones that could've been extended more and could've been wrapped up better. The CG effects are a bit weird too but who cares? THE ENDING IS SO ADORABLE!!!

- Grim Reaper Ju Wal is hot
- Jade Emperor (and his garden) looked exceptionally good
- Dol Soe and Bang Wool's moments are cute
- the underworld scenes creeped me out
- the little Eun Oh and Arang are adorable! And it's so funny that Eun Oh's reincarnation is Dol Soe and Bang Wool's son. lol
- the last kiss scene was so endearing I kept replaying it and will replay it for weeks on end. Shin Min Ah and Lee Jun Ki's chemistry is no joke.

It's sad that there won't be any Arang and the Magistrate episodes to look forward to. I'm happy that I gave this drama a chance after getting tired of watching kdramas. Definitely going to be on my favorites list.

Thanks for the recaps JB and GF!

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Thanks for the recap.
I enjoyed this drama for the most part , the ending is cute too since they gave us a hint with the Mu yeon and Mu yeoung love story. I just want to say that the I got lost with the Arang suicide story. it's like What?? really ??? so confusing poor Joo wal had to go through all that despair and not knowing that She actually want to die anyways??
That part ruined the drama for me. But I already gave myself migraine from watching this drama so whatever!!!

0
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

No, what the book said was that the person who caused Lee Seo Rim's death was Lee Seo Rim herself, which is the truth that we see all along but don't realise - she died because of her choice to throw herself in front of EO's mother's knife to protect JW.

EO's mother never meant to stab her, but Arang never realised that Lee Seo Rim's death was because of an action she herself took.

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

“With this heart, I will find you. If a man passes by you and stops, and tears form and your heart races—recognize that it’s me.”

For me, this was probably the most beautiful and bittersweet part of the episode. I loved the way this was narrated by Lee Jun-Ki. His heartbreak really pulled at my heart strings and I dissolved into a puddle of tears.

I had hoped that was how they would meet again. They both keep their love for each other, and with that consciousness, with their love remaining in their hearts that would span a lifetime, find each other once again.

All in all though, I am so happy they got a happy ending. I love those two so much and theirs was truly one of the epic love stories of K-dramaland.

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

That was a nice wrap for this drama; and i’m glad that the pessimistic theories i had for it’s finale are moot. About RTP and big, i’m slightly okay with the former. While the latter totally went down the drain for me. Even though the later episode weren’t taped beforehand, Arang and the magistrate never had problems with editing in any of the episodes unlike RTP. So hands up to this drama for never losing it’s spark. Imma start researching the folktale behind this drama!^^

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Am I the only one who thinks baby Eun-oh actually did remember Arang (especially after she called him Amnesia) and he just kept pretending he couldn't, to tease her? I want my Arang and Sato with all their memories of their previous life and love intact, please!

0
2
reply

Required fields are marked *

a lot of people think that way specially when EO did mention that he remembered arang's instruction not to drink from the well of forgetfulness because she said it many times.

0
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

the look on his face seemed to suggest he actually did remember and just kept quiet about it until they grew up. I love them both so much <3

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Awww... happy ending. Trima kasih untuk recap..

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

The ending was so adorable with the little Magistrate and Arang. They nailed it especially the little girl! Loved it. Precious.

JW was so sad to me but he was brought back in the end along with MY. That was good.

Thanks for picking this drama JB.

Oh, and LJK is fine!

0
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

LJK is The Best ....my dear !

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

I just finished watching and can't form coherent sentences about the whole episode yet, but I'm a romance junkie and need to talk about THE KISSING!!!!!!

The kiss by the lake was everything I wanted Arang and Sato to have, I love that she kissed him back a little ad actually seems to hold him closer this time - THANK YOU PD-nim for listening to our prayers, even if you made us cry with what they said to each other before he kissed her!

And then when they're reincarnated and grown up, I almost died at the fact that SHE kissed HIM keke - and then she pulled him closer so they could kiss some more!!!!!!! All of us DB readers really need to thank whoever it was that decided not to skimp on the kissing any more....

0
2
reply

Required fields are marked *

It was also very cute that each time they kissed at the end, he said, maybe he remembered something (at the end). They didn't show subtitles for this on Viki but they did on drama fever.

0
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

apparently that last kiss (the one that happens as the camera is panning out and she grabs him by the hat-strings) was IMPROVISED?!

Thank the Jade Emperor for leads who know what we want to see them doing lol

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Also, I'm so glad that this show was a fitting comeback to dramaland for both Lee Jun-ki and Shin Mina - separately, they're two of my favourite actors but together they just make each other even better, and I'm not just saying that because they have such stellar chemistry.

The whole cast was stellar, especially YWJ (which is incredible considering the character he plays), but these two just brought it like never before - here's hoping they work together in a drama again! Or a movie, I'll take them being cast opposite each other in a movie if we can't get a full-length drama, preferably in modern costume this time!

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

I love DB, very intelligent posts you guys have there.

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

I really love this show. It manages to fry my brain, heart and soul for these past few weeks. I live in this fantasy drama. Nevertheless... Am i the only one who sense than LJK is avoiding SMH? No photos together, not even during the warp up party? Is he afraid than SMH has fallen in love with him, but he's not? Or... Am I imagining too much, or analysing too deep ? Or has finally my brain really been fried?

0
3
reply

Required fields are marked *

let's hope it is your brain fried, girl - I badly want to see them together in another drama and they'd have to at least be on good terms for that!

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

He is avoiding any scandal, kkk

0
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

Junki is too tired...he is worn out...believe me he doesn't mean to avoid her. Do u know ...he tweet the director ...said he collapsed and the next day when he wake up he is in japan. Both jk & shinmina are professionals . Though maybe they like each other we will not show their feeling ...right ? Anyway, i think junki oppa just to busy to date anyone

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

(and also, THANK GOODNESS that even if Arang had to go poof and she and EO couldn't live out this life together, they didn't suffer the same fate as a certain couple from Battlestar Galactica, if anyone knows what I'm talking about. I have never got over that, to this day. And thank the Jade Emperor for no bullshit love triangles either.)

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Anti-climatic, so typical for all Korean dramas... Not really what I hoped to get out of the drama in the end. It was forced and not convincing for me. Since it was a fantasy, I expected them to add a bit of fairy dust and let the two main leads live happily ever after, especially because they saved humanity.

Too bad because the rest of the episodes were really fine.

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

I like the ending. I can't tell if EO really can't remember. But I really love the ending. Oh drama, why must you leave me? You mean this is the last time? No ep 21 and what not?

I'm not ready to let go of you yet :(. You will torture me daily won't you? I will see the moon and then I will remember...

Thanx to JBeans and Gfriday, your recaps were always a pleasure to read. Thanx to viki subs too. They were so fast with subbing and worked really hard!

And all those I met on the comments page, (JK, opheliadrowning, yaya, pogo, albert e.t.c).

:'(

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

- It's amusing that Arang has to work hard to meet Jade. But with a shout from Eun Oh, he finds Jade immediately. Mu Young also hardly answers to Arang. But he constantly shows up in front of Eun Oh, telling him to do this and that. These heavenly guys are kinda gender-bias, lol.

- I want to see Eun Oh and Arang in heaven a little bit, especially Eun Oh as a male fairy. To be honest, I just want to see his mane of glory and prettyness compared to Jade.

0
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

well, Arang wanted to go from regular living-people's world (our world) to see the JE, but EO was already in the Hwang Cheon forest (on the way to the underworld) and then in the dead people's archive when he yelled for him. So yeah, it could be gender bias and it could be just easy accessibility from scary heavenly library :).

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Oh, Thanks for the recaps. I totally loved them.

But I've realized one thing: in the ending where it shows the adult Arang and Eun-Oh, I think it is another time skip as they changed their clothing as well as Eun-Oh saying "he memorized her story". It might have been that Eun-Oh really drank from the fountain of forgetfulness to be reincarnated. Though Arang remembers, Eun-oh did not (but still was able to fall in love with Arang all over again) and in the end was able to memorize her story all throughout the years lol.

As for the death of Eun-Oh before the time-skip, perhaps EunOh was never remembered because he was sucked into hell? or the people might have thought that the previous magistrate really left together with Arang? or Bang Ul-ri knew that Arang was sent to the afterlife and Eun-Oh died and that's why they named her child Eun-Oh as well?

Nevertheless, it was a satisfying ending. It might not have been an awe-striking one, but certainly a good one.

0
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

And I'd like to add for those who think Joo-wal's ending was not that good. I think in one way Yeomra making him a grim reaper is a good choice. When he lived as a human, he wasn't treated as one and when he tried to be treated as human, unknowingly he became a monster following a monster. I think in the very end he was not meant to be human and therefore is more suitable to become a grim reaper. It's like his salvation and punishment to become a grim reaper.

As for Muyoung being a goat also has something else to ponder on. to be reincarnated as an animal in the Confucian principle is a punishment, but well he's a heavenly animal? lol It is also a punishment to become a an animal ans somewhat also a reward to become a part of heaven as he was able to cut ties of his humanity.

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

re: the opening and how much we were all yelling at Arang for coming along, it's actually good that she did because she gets to see Mu-yeon coming straight for her and a mere cry of 'NO!' stops the possession from happening because, as they keep reminding us, it has to happen with the consent of the person.

If Arang had stayed home, Mu-yeon would have probably come straight for her and tried to reboot the possession, under the assumption that Arang's earlier consent was still valid. Who knows if it would have worked, but she would certainly have tried.

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

About Eun oh losing his memories after the reincarnation, I like it that way. Just like what the others commented, it may have been his bargain with the Jade Emperor for him to be reincarnated.

I like it because it emphasizes that Eun Oh really loves Arang, despite forgetting about everything. It's a love at first sight for him. Even though the old memories are gone, it doesn't mean that all those memories were put in vain because it's the reason why they're given a new life, they can make fresh new wonderful memories together.

Arang would always remind him of everything that happened before their reincarnation, so it's okay for me. And I know that Eun Oh believes every bit of what Arang says.

It's really cute that Bang Wool's Eun Oh's mom, and of course Dol Swe's his father haha! Eun Oh's both an ex-slave's, a magistrate's and a shaman's son. That means he can still see ghosts!

Young Arang might have pestered Bang Wool and Dol Swe since she remembered everything.

Ah, their reincarnation is so adorable! How I wish there were fanfics written for it. <3 <3

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Really liked the ending of this one. Tied all the loose ends nicely together and made me smile.

Only one thing I would have still liked to know: how had her body preserved so well? But, I guess that was irrelevant.

0
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

It was jade emperor ...since the beginning he already set this up. Use arang as a bait to catch moo yeon.

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Wow this really was my favorite drama . Loved the acting. Loved the ending. I hate a good drama with a bad ending . I felt same way about BIG. Ending to that drama was so not satisfying. Only extra I would like to have seen was some indication of return of status of mom' family. But the cute kids. And BW and DS as parents of EO - priceless . And that now she calls him Memory Loss. Couldn't ask for better. The humor kept all the death and creepy at bay . Never seen such a drama quite like this.

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Wow!! the writers managed to end this well!! kudos!!! wish rooftopprince ending was nearly as good as this!! this drama managed to pull its weight in the last 2 episodes cuz i snoozed all thru the drama!! another drama that cud hv been 16episodes. Nonetheless, i hate to see it end but i love what's coming next!! YOOCHUN I MISS YOU!!!! YAAYYYYY

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

So fall in love with the ending... it's really satisfying..
ckckkckckck.. and I've been repeating the reincarnation scene.. they are so lovel both little Eun Oh-Arang and Eun Oh-Arang...

their ending make me want to go watch ep 1 all over again!

I LOVE THIS DRAMA SO MUCH!

thank DB for the recap and great comments *always love your insight view* ^^

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

I will admit to a little fast forwarding, but I did watch most of episode 19/20 and I must have missed something in the translation.

I do not recall Arang losing her immortality as being part of the Magistrate's deal with the " gods".

If she is immortal and cannot die, How can she be reborned? I am lost.

0
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

Her body is immortal but it gets taken away from her at the end of the three full moons no matter whether she finds the truth or not. Obviously, she didn't get to keep it and got reincarnated.

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

The more I think about it the more I love the ending. While the show did a wonderful job of world building and mystery, ultimately this show was about the characters, about love, and about what it means to live and how we can and deserve to live.

Thematically, Arang discovering the truth about her death is more like a reveal about LSR's decisions than about who literally killed her. It is LSR/Arang taking that responsibility more than anything. I thought it was interesting and smart. It's the mystery of the human heart.

As for the reincarnation, what a wonderful happy ending that satisfied the story thematically. It was always on the table, but as javabeans wrote, this is their reward: to live life where they are happy and loved and have time with one another. The dream Eunoh had perhaps is the reality that happens to them in their reincarnated lives. While it doesn'take for great fiction, it makes for a great ending.

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

R.E.L.I.E.V.E.D. !! the writer really ended it well, and i believe, left all of us satisfied :D Great comeback drama for Lee Jun-Ki and listed as one of the few good dramas of 2012 in my list (:

Having both young versions of our main casts to appear so hilariously really earned points for the ending too XD

Glad i stuck with it till the end :D

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Thks JB & GF. Like always...Nice Recaps.
LOve this drama

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

I don't understand one thing. There was a loose they didn't explain. After eun oh sacrifices himself and goes into the hell hole thingy, arang was still there. they could only be reincarnated if both of them died. Since arang was immortal she couldn't die. What happened to the arang that was left behind when eun oh sacrificed himself? How did she end being reincarnated when she was still alive and eun oh was dead? i may be confused but I just don't understand this part.

0
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

her body was what was immortal, but she was going to lose it anyway once her three full moons were up, whether she found the truth or not. So she didn't keep that body.

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Well, don't know why some people didn't like the endings. It's really Cute endings.

All problem solved ... both of them reincarnated as humans ...and they able to continue as couple. And their memory still 'intact" ...isn't that great. I'm more than satisfied with this ending. Unlike other typical K drama - usually they choose a cliche endings.

I think This ending is much much better than BIG or Rooftop.

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

also, for all of us afraid that Arang would be reborn as a butterfly, did anyone notice that her hairpin in that last scene is actually a butterfly? :) Nice touch from the costume designers there, I love how much attention was paid to the small details all through.

(and I'm so happy for the subversion of the giving-shoes-to-a-lover trope!)

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Re Arang's death, while some viewers might have felt they were led on a wild goose chase only to find out a simple answer (Arang's self-sacrifice) existed in a simple manner (the book), it wouldn't have done Arang any good even if she had been offered the answer on a platter right from the beginning (not to mention it makes for a more interesting show haha). Arang was self-centred three years into her amnesia and wouldn't have appreciated the cause of her death even if told. And technically, it also wasn't the same - being unintentionally killed by someone (a person could also have been killed by another unintentionally while being in a scuffle) and sacrificing her own self for the sake of a person she had loved. So until Arang realised her action to be her willing sacrifice for another person, her character hasn't fully grown.

While I also kind of agreed with Jade that Arang was only granted her wish to find out the truth behind her death, and not so much to get a chance to be in heaven, it was also mean of Jade that by herself Arang would never have been able to get the bell to ring.

But I think this also reflected the greatest difference between EO and Arang's love vs the love btw MY & MY. It's apparent that Jade has the ability to return anybody in any form of existence but he didn't choose to grant Mu-Yeon's wish of returning as a human. Although I wonder if Mu-Yeon might have been given her chance if she were to just ask Jade nicely (haha), I think more likely there had to be some kind of self-sacrifice involved, and that self-sacrifice isn't only the own-self willingness to bear the pain of returning as a human or being cast in Hell; it also had to be reciprocated by the person one loved to deem the self-sacrifice worthwhile.

Mu-Yeon had pleaded Mu-Young to help her (persuade Jade) but Mu-Young had declined, believing it couldn't be done. But if Mu-Young had equally loved or reciprocated Mu-Yeon's love, he would have tried to help her in other ways short of creating chaos on earth. Mu-Young's lack of reciprocity was perhaps the primary reason why Mu-Yeon was cast out of heaven (since Jade is empathetic: leaving her in heaven by way of serving her penance wouldn't work - Mu-Yeon would have again run away; putting her in hell would only prolong her suffering). By the time Mu-Young comes around to reciprocate Mu-Yeon's suffering, it was too late for her to be redeemed. And Mu-Young was reincarnated because he had learnt to reciprocate another person's love for him but had to pay for his earlier sins - being the cause of Mu-Yeon's misdeeds on earth and whatever penance he was already serving in hell/ heaven being a reaper.

This is contrary to EO's and Arang's case - where Arang had wanted to go to hell in order to remember EO and EO had reciprocated her love by choosing to go to hell in her stead so that she can be in heaven (and although they wanted to be together, they weren't greedy in hoping for that to happen; they only wanted the other party to be able to live happily wherever they are, something that Mu-Yeon never considered for Mu-Young). In short, they both earned each other's love and by virtue of their reciprocity, they earned another chance on earth for a happily ever after.

0
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

exactly, the whole drama is about the process of learning and growth for both of them, and the way they move from selfishness to unselfishness - Arang didn't realise at first, even after knowing the truth, that the real answer to her question lay in a question of interpretation rather than just knowing the facts.

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

@JK I'm so nodding nodding at your comment is so insighful and giving some view explanation...

I love a drama that leaves a.mark or morale to be told.. it makes it somehow worth the watch :)

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

I understand Arang and Moo-yeon's desire to have the freedom to feel. When I was going through my first breakup before my recovery, the stage I hated the most was feeling empty. It was before acceptance and finally moving on, but I hated being devoid of feelings. I thought I'd rather be (or go back to feeling) sad/angry/lonely than feel nothing, even if happiness wasn't going to be part of those emotions.

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Okay, so I'm really confused because I'm not sure what it meant by Arang killing herself. How did she die? Did she stab herself or was she led into the woods?
I didn't enjoy the ending...it made me cry because only one person in the relationship remembered in the end.
Anyways, rather than judging me for my emotional state, PLEASE ANSWER MY QUESTION!!!!

HOW DID ARANG DIE??????? (I get that the paper said that "arang killed herself" but still...)

-Kamsamidah!-

0
2
reply

Required fields are marked *

About Arang kills herself....she was the one who let herself be stabbed when try to save young master,Joo Wal !!! And I think Eun Oh does remember,he just did that to tease Arang…pretended that he didnt remember her.Eun Oh will not drink that “water of forgetting” to forget Arang after every thing they’ve been through.

So far the ending was one of the best ever !!!!

0
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

Yes, I love A&M ending too much!! Very perfect one which is rare to get in k-dramas.

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

I have to say that I loved this ending. So cute and clever, and the look on his face as adults filled with love- so sweet. I think better for him not to remember because he was so filled with anger at Great King Jade I dont think he would have been able to live a happy life.

I can't imagine a better ending to this.BW as EO mom! How cute! and that little girls. adorable!
And Joowal as a grim reaper- I couldn't help feeling sorry for him. And he truly tried to save Arang in the end. and Mu Yeong as a goat- how cute was that.

This is one of my favorite dramas. I loved the humor which balanced out the creepy. The great acting. The chemistry between the characters. I loved the way everything was tied up in the end.- except as someone said, I would have loved for something about the mom's status to be raised again.

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

LOVED the ending!!! I was wondering how they could come up with a satisfying closure and I think the writers did it pretty well! Especially with the 2 uber cute kid-versions of Eun-oh and Arang! =D

Thanks for the insightful recaps too!!!!

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

One more thing. This is silly but I wish they show mom's soul coming out of her dead body. Then she can say a long goodbye to Eun Oh and even shed some light about what happened 3 years ago (I know it's kind of weird to make the sobbing Eun Oh interrogating his mom but it'll help us get the whole story)

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

What a great drama this is! Thanks JB & GF for good recaps of A&M, I love it so much.
Lee Joon-gi.....you're the Best!! ^^

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Very happy for this great drama finished with a lovely satisfying ending, yayyy...!!
Wishing the best for all actors & pd team for many awards, you really deserve those.

Joon-gi oppa, you're toooo perfect~ Always rocking my world!! :D
Waiting your next great projects. See you again as modern smart guy this time, my sweet oppa ;)

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Truth be told, I think the Book of Life and Death was a deus ex machina. They couldn't find the answer on their own, so they just read the answer, which is conveniently located the Book of Life and Death, and they can even travel to the Forest of the Afterlife. Isn't that, like, cheating? Like looking up the answers in the back of the book without attempting the math problem first?

But then when Eun Oh found his book, I realized that that was the purpose of this scene, and not Seo Rim's truth, whom we knew -- and Arang knew -- caused her own death. If Arang remembered she had jumped in front of the knife to save Joo Wal, then why were they shocked to learn Seo Rim killed herself? Did she not share the memory of her death with Eun Oh? The sleeping consciousness and bells to wake them was neat and reminded me of Inception.

I heart the ghosts' final wishes. <3 I am so glad they wrapped up that part of the story. It was especially moving to see our Magistrate fulfilling Ghost No. 2 and Ghost No. 3's wishes.

I was satisfied with the ending. The little kids were adorable; the little girl's portrayal of Arang was spot-on. But I have two grievances: One, I really don't believe Arang and Eun Oh needed to remember their past lives in order to meet in their current lives. If they are fated to be together, even without past memories, subconsciously, they will love one another after reincarnation. Two, I didn't think you had a choice to not drink from the well of forgetfulness. Before you are reincarnated, you must drink.

Thanks, thanks, thanks for recapping this gem of a drama, javabeans and girlfriday!

0
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

re: Arang and Eun-oh's shock at finding her name written down as the one who caused her own death, it was a matter of interpretation rather than knowledge - Arang knew Lee Seo Rim took a knife in the back for Joo-wal from EO's mother, but didn't realise that it was LSR's choice to put herself in the way of the knife that led to her death.

And I liked all the ways in which things wrapped up, too - the ghost crew getting their final wishes were rather touching.

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

I really loved this show, great actors, fabulous! Thank you for recapping it.

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

I would have never guessed the ending. But it was really satisfying and i have no complaints. Im quite surprused that Arang didnt have any plan when she went to Big Bad. But I'm guessing the writers wanted to showb us that a human has a moment of weakness?

EO and Arang, such a sweet couple. I cried when he was sucked in by the void. They didnt even get to properly say goodbye. I wonder if they met again at heaven or something coz Arang kept saying she told EO not to drink from the well of forgetfulness or something?

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

I've just finished marathon this drama yesterday.. ohhh.. and it just can't get enough of it.. and I wondered or I'd like to ask question to Jade Emperor.. when he made that plan for destroying M-Yeon usinv Eun Oh.. did he also know that Eun Oh and Arang will fall for each other.. or is it just his miss calculation there? hehehehe.. silly question right.. but I'm curious ^^

0
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

Think Jade Emperor knew they wld fall in love with each other. There was a part when he looked down from Heaven and said AR was doing fine, then the scene panned to AR and EO (I recall).
Also I think AR wasn't meant to die so tragically (insinuated by the corpse that was not decomposed).

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

First and foremost, thanks JB and GF for the recaps and insightful comments!

Like most of the commenters here, Arang and the Magistrate is one of my favourite korean dramas. I've enjoyed watching and reading (DB’s recaps) throughout the whole show.

To me, I feel that the writers had the whole story thoroughly planned from the beginning. All loose ends are tied in the end, both main and secondary characters developed throughout the show. The use of flashbacks explained to us why the characters behave in that way (E.g. why Eun-Oh was so aloof, why Mu-yeon turned bad, why Joo-wal fell so easily into prey); and hence while we may disagree with the characters’ decisions and actions, we could empathize with them. And I like that the show makes me think about the morals of the story that the writers want to tell us.

Moral 1: Everyone has a role to play in his/her life. Eun-Oh and Arang may be a tool and bait to get rid of Mu-yeon. As mentioned by Jade Emperor, that was only one of the reasons he brought them back to life. Eun-Oh had also realized that his role was to help those who were in need of help, while Arang’s role was to make Eun-Oh realized his self-worth. And they were meant to fall in love with each other. How could they meet when one died when he was six and the other died knowing and loving one-sidedly one man who did not even reciprocate her love?

Moral 2: Desire is a 2-edged sword. When you play it right, it brings happiness to you and others (again, see Eun-Oh and Arang). However, when desire took control of you, you lost yourself (please refer to Mu-yeon, Joo-wal and Lord Choi).

Moral 3: Having a conscience is what made a man a human. (case study: Joo-wal) He was able to continuously murder the innocent girls because he did not have a conscience for life (and also because his memories were locked in the closet by Mu-yeon). However, his conscientiousness began to haunt him when memories returned; and in the end he chose death as he couldn’t face the guilt of coldheartedly disposed the only woman who loved him.

Moral 4: Having a memory keeps us living. Good memories allows the living to continue living (see: when Bang-wol tried to reason to Arang about Eun-Oh’s confession); while bad memories are lessons learned so that we won’t make the same mistake (see Joo-wal for bad example of erasing bad memories)

Moral 5: Love is treasuring the moment we have!

0
3
reply

Required fields are marked *

Btw, I'm one happy supporter of the ending!! :)

Kekekeke, I'm one of the minority here who thinks that Eun-Oh drank the water. He probably drank it when he realised that Dol-swe and Bang-wol are going to be his parents. (I think) it will be weird to be their son (for him and his parents) if he still holds the old memories. Plus as he said (in his thought) at the river, he will use his heart to find Arang, and knowingly that Arang will find ways to avoid drinking. So, he was confident that they will be able to find each other in their next lives.

Like what he said in the end, it doesn't really matter whether they were in love or not in their previous lives, what matter most is that they have each other now.

0
2
reply

Required fields are marked *

Wahh..good point you have.. I'm absolutly agree with your thought... And the other MORAL is You must take your responsibility for all decision you make in your life and not just blame other people for all happens in your life (ex: Arang who just know that Eun Oh mother the causes of her death)

0
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

@ Aurora: Oh yes! We are responsible for our own decisions and actions!

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

@fangy and @aurora.. I love how you point the morals of the story... totally agree ^^

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *