D-Day: Episode 3
by dramallama
This is what I’ve been waiting for. Exhilarating and fast-paced with sudden moments of poignancy, our first look into the disaster’s aftermath gives us an excellent overview of the conflicts our disaster response team will be facing. We’ve built up enough context for our marginal characters to care for the few moments they are on screen, and we also know that they’re instrumental in their respective roles. I love the birth of this new medical team, smashed together by chance and Hye-sung’s persistence. They’re daring and resourceful — I have a feeling I’m going to be a fan.
EPISODE 3 RECAP
D-Day. While driving with her son, Chief Kang calls Ja-hyuk to confirm their lunch date. He apologizes that he’ll be late due to a meeting as he walks into said meeting. He yells at his team in frustration.
Woo-jin closes the blinds in his office to take a nap while Director Lee practices his golf putt in his office. At the pool, a boy practices swimming as a part of his rehabilitation. 1, 2, 1, 2…
1, 2, 1, 2. The team at the fire department instruct a CPR lesson. Captain Choi walks by and sits on the fire truck calling his wife, who doesn’t pick up. His “best friend,” Mr. Kang plays the ukulele for change on the subway, singing to children and making them laugh. The children communicate excitedly in sign language, and the man sitting across from them smiles.
We go back to Hye-sung and Ddol-mi, who run outside to look at the strangely lit sky. Slowly, the world starts to shake, the water systems explode, and the world begins to destruct.
Director Lee’s fish tank breaks, the subway screeches to a halt, Sister wakes up to a shaking hospital, and Chief Kang frantically carries young Dong-hwa out of the store. She puts him in the back seat of her car and struggles to pull her heel out of the cracked ground. Leaving her shoe behind, she scrambles into her car and instructs Dong-hwa to fasten his seatbelt. But as she takes off, we see his ambulance toy outside. She tries to drive away, but multiple cars crash in the chaos, knocking Chief Kang unconscious.
As the firetrucks depart the station, Captain Choi reports in and watches the infrastructure collapse behind him. Ja-hyuk crawls under the table (yes, duck and cover!) as others fall in attempts to escape. He grabs an injured woman under the table with him.
The hospitals are in chaos, with patients and doctors helplessly falling and swaying with the earthquake. The two unconscious patients at Han River Mirae lay still while the world around them trembles.
Bridges fall, highways collapse, and the Namsan Tower snaps in half. The ground beneath Hye-sung and Ddol-mi cracks, and they run away as fast as possible. Debris from a fallen building envelops them, and when the debris gradually clears, they’re shell-shocked.
A man desperately asks Hye-sung for help. Still disoriented, Hye-sung follows with Ddol-mi just as a fire explodes in a nearby building. They move a fallen fence, and the man tries to open the door to his car but to no avail. His wife hyperventilates inside, and the three outside notice a spark about to ignite an explosion. The man gets more desperate, pleading for help to get his 8-month pregnant wife out of the car.
Chief Kang remains unconscious until a man stirs her awake. She slowly regains consciousness and realizes that Dong-hwa is gone. She runs outside screaming his name as she sees more explosions. She finds Dong-hwa’s ambulance toy, and we see that he did run out of the car as soon as he got in. Chief Kang continues to cry out for him, but he’s nowhere to be found.
Ddol-mi runs into a bus and finds a fire extinguisher while Hye-sung figures out how to get this pregnant woman out of the car. He breaks the window with a rock and immediately checks if she’s been affected by shock-induced paralysis. Fortunately, she hasn’t lost all feeling in her hands, and Hye-sung orders her husband to carefully carry her out of the car.
Ddol-mi abandons the malfunctioning fire extinguisher and helps with the woman’s escape. As they run away carrying the pregnant woman, the car behind them bursts into flames.
Captain Choi and his team are delayed by a fallen tree blocking their path. They’re forced to reroute, and Captain Choi watches with disbelief as a tower crumbles and falls before their eyes.
Back to Hye-sung and the pregnant woman. He checks her heart rate and assesses that it’s faster than normal. She tells him that she feels pain, but there’s little that he can do. Surprisingly, he decides that he can’t help and advises the couple to find the nearest big hospital with an OBGYN to help her. He bows in apology and walks away.
Ddol-mi tries to get him to turn back, but he’s resolute that he’s not the best doctor for her needs. Also, they’ve got their hospital patients to return to. Before getting on their way, Hye-sung and Ddol-mi notice the fallen Namsan Tower. They stop in their tracks and absorb the gravity of this earthquake.
One hour after the quake. The doctors at the Mirae Hospital ER briefly gather before dispersing to deal with the aftermath. Director Lee looks at his broken ship and dead fish, wondering what just happened.
Hye-sung and Ddol-mi run back to the damaged Han River Mirae Hospital. Hye-sung orders Ddol-mi to attend to their other patients as he runs off to the ICU. He breathes a big sigh of relief when he sees that Ji-na is manually resuscitating their patient. Sister nurse isn’t in sight, and Ji-na says that the nurse left as soon as she arrived. He thanks her and tells her that she saved this patient’s life. He then runs off to check on his mother.
When Hye-sung peers into his mother’s hospital room, she’s not on any of the beds. He finds her on the ground and carefully carries her back onto the bed. He checks her limbs for any injuries and her heart rate. His mother hasn’t suffered any injuries, and he thanks her for it. Hye-sung hugs his mother close, and Ddol-mi happens to see this.
Giving Hye-sung his space, Ddol-mi waits outside to report on their other patients. They head to the triage, where everything is broken and scattered. He expects that they’ll have urgent patients soon and gives Ddol-mi the responsibility of reorganizing the room to make it suitable for basic surgeries. She does as told but asks herself what the hell she’s still doing here.
Hye-sung returns to the ICU, where Ji-na asks about the electricity and the reason for the disaster. He’s irritable because he doesn’t have answers, but Sister, with a wound on her head, returns in shock with the answer. It’s an earthquake. An earthquake just hit Seoul.
Chief Kang walks through the broken streets aimlessly looking for Dong-hwa. She steps on glass without care and hopelessly calls out his name. She carries her limp body with a numbness that’s starkly contrasted by the screams and anxiety surrounding her.
Ja-hyuk walks into the lobby of his building and receives the reports about the magnitude 6.5 earthquake. He directs his secretary to look into the casualties and impact of the quake. He adds that this major earthquake could solve what couldn’t be solved before. Buildings were prepared for 4.0 earthquakes, not an earthquake 150 times the magnitude. He looks up to the broken glass ceiling and wonders, “Should I be resentful or thankful?”
Listening to the radio, Hye-sung tries to gage the intensity of the 6.5 magnitude earthquake. There’s no electricity or water, and they know that their ICU patient needs to be transferred as soon as possible.
Captain Choi arrives on the scene and scolds his minions for sitting around at the sight of fire. They look hopeless as they report that all sources of water are cut off and the roads that would lead to water are blocked off by the earthquake damage. Frustrated that he can’t fulfill his duty, Captain Choi swings his ax at the concrete in anger.
The team carries the ICU patient down the stairs, and Hye-sung lists off the items they need to prepare for the influx of patients. Sister decides that she wants to have no part in this anymore and announces her leave. She needs to check on her family. Hye-sung tries to convince her to stay, claiming that she’s the reason why he stayed at this hospital. He reassures her that her family is okay because our hopes often come true as we believe them to be. She doesn’t believe a word and continues on her way.
As she leaves, Hye-sung asks her where everything is located in the hospital, and it’s apparent that she holds important knowledge to navigate the ins and outs of this hospital. She becomes frustrated with the realization, and Hye-sung uses her name to once again affirm her necessity: “We need your help, Kim Hae-sook.”
Captain Choi yells through a crack in the rubble, checking the state of a woman stuck under the concrete. He calls upon surrounding civilians to help raise the concrete, and they’re able to raise enough debris to carry her out.
Sister scrapes out all the resources left in the hospital and brings them to their newly rebuilt triage/surgery room. She knows it’s not enough, and Hye-sung knows it too. But he’s not giving up and tells his team their game plan. “We’re not using our ammo for the minimal and worst cases. Minimal — they’ll survive without treatment. Worst — they have slim chances of revival. That way, we can save more patients.”
Sister tries to convince Brother that they’re not an adequate hospital, but Hye-sung asserts that as long as they have doctors and medicine, they’re a hospital. They’ll start with the triage.
Ji-na and Ddol-mi go around and categorize patients based on Hye-sung’s directions. Red means urgent — send them to Hye-sung. Blue means minimal or worst — they won’t be prioritized. And black means dead.
In the triage room, Hye-sung realigns a patient’s leg and splints it. He advises the wife that they should head to a big hospital. She asks where to, and Hye-sung simply states, “Whichever hospital survived the earthquake.”
That doesn’t seem to be the case for Mirae Hospital, whose doors have been closed by authorities. Injured civilians angrily protest the hospital closing its doors, and they crowd around the windows, knocking on the glass while people inside stare back. Even the ER has shut down, turning away everyone.
Hye-sung has resorted to splinting an arm with newspaper, and he asks Sister how much lidocaine (a local anesthetic) they have remaining. She answers that they only have one bottle, and Hye-sung drops the patient’s arm momentarily in shock. It’s clearly not enough.
In the lobby, Ddol-mi splits a man’s leg with cardboard. Ji-an is pulled away by a young man who asks for help. His mother is breathing but not responding. Ddol-mi joins them to assess the woman’s condition, and she shakes her head. It’s a basal skull fracture — black.
The son knows what black means and demands that Ddol-mi change the color to red. His mother is still breathing; they can do something. But Ddol-mi knows they can’t and refuses. In rage, the son races at Ddol-mi and throws her on the ground.
Ji-na quickly notifies Hye-sung, and he runs out to take a blow from the son. He’s hit badly on the arm but manages to throw him down. Other bystanders take a hold of the son, and Ddol-mi gets up to give it to him straight. “I want to save her too. I want to save her and return her home with you, but we can’t do anything if we tried. We don’t have medicine, blood, or anything to look into your mother’s skull as we perform surgery. If your mother comes back to life by hitting me, hit me all you want. I’ll take it and bring your mother back to life.”
The mourning son cries out helplessly for his poor mother, and our medical team look upon him with sympathy. Ddol-mi notes, “It seems that your mother won’t forget your voice.”
In the triage room, Hye-sung waits to get stitches for his deep gash. Ddol-mi asks hesitantly if he’s really okay without any anesthetic, and he nods with his brave face on. It’ll feel like a quick pinch, right? Ddol-mi seems to move painfully slowly, cleaning the wound and finally putting in the first stitch, enjoying the sight of Hye-sung squirming. Hye-sung convulses in pain but rejects the last bottle of lidocaine because other patients need it.
The pregnant woman and her husband from earlier enter the hospital, begging Sister to help them. Sister rejects them because they don’t have the resources to deliver a baby, but the man pleads them to help. Every hospital has rejected them because they don’t have an OBGYN.
Just as Sister is about to send them off, Hye-sung yells from down the hallway to accept them. They bring the woman into the triage — now surgery — room, and the medical team quickly gathers for their game plan. Hye-sung decides that they’ll use their last bottle of lidocaine, but then they look at each other blankly, none of them with experience delivering a baby.
Sister audibly complains about how crazy this is, since not a single one of them has delivered a baby before. Then, the couple clarifies that it’s not just one, it’s two. They team turns back to their mini huddle and gasp at the news. They’ll be delivering twins.
Preparing for surgery, Hye-sung nervously convinces himself that everything will be okay despite the fact that they have never delivered a single baby. They also don’t have an incubator, so there’s even more at risk. Ji-na decides that if it comes to it, they’ll prioritize the mother’s life.
Overhearing this decision, the mother shakes her head. She desperately wants her babies to live. Hye-sung makes it clear that he’s never delivered a child before but assures them that he’ll do his best. The whole team comes together to guide the mother in her breathing, beginning the birthing process.
Under the earthquake rubble, a father gains consciousness and calls out for his son. The boy answers weakly, and the father asks if he’s hurt. The boy doesn’t know, but his father notices his son’s foot under a big chunk of concrete. He tells his son to stay strong and throws him his jacket to wear.
In the subway, Mr. Kang finds his ukulele and announces to the people in the train that this area is his home. He knows his way around the subway lines and tells them to follow him. The people file out, and the kind stranger convinces the deaf children to trust him with the little sign language he picked up.
Hye-sung delivers the first baby, a boy who comes out the womb crying. The eavesdroppers outside celebrate the sound of the first baby’s cry. The mother pushes one last time for her second baby, who doesn’t make a sound upon birth. They all notice that something is wrong, and Hye-sung asks for the suction. But that’s equipment they don’t have.
After a moment of hesitation, Hye-sung uses his mouth as a suction device to rid the fluid that’s preventing the baby’s breathing. As he spits out the fluid, we hear the twin’s cry, a sound that relieves everyone in the room. Hye-sung instructs Sister to take care of the babies and Ji-na to take care of the mother. He orders Ddol-mi to follow him to find some Styrofoam.
They head to the old kitchen, where Ddol-mi clumsily climbs and falls off the counter. She successfully finds the Styrofoam, amusing Hye-sung with her successful blundering. Hye-sung quickly packs some essentials into his backpack, and they head back. They’re stopped by sudden debris falling from the ceiling, a sure sign that the building is falling apart.
Hye-sung creates an incubator with Styrofoam and hot packs, an ingenious temporary solution. But they don’t have too much time to praise his ingenuity. He tells the team that he fears the building is unstable and suggests that they all evacuate the building.
In the lobby, Hye-sung announces to the patients that they’ve run out of supplies and need to evacuate the building. Although the patients protest, Hye-sung makes it clear that staying in the building poses greater dangers. He asks Ji-na to lead the patients out while he gets his mother.
Hye-sung runs to his mother’s side and piggybacks her out. He’s extra careful while walking through the building, aware of the building’s instability. When he arrives at the lobby, the patients are still gathered there. He yells at them that the building is collapsing, and they laugh off his claim until things actually start to fall from the ceiling. Then they run out in an instant.
The ICU patient’s vitals and the new mother’s blood pressure are wavering, making their search for a new hospital more dire. Hye-sung decides that they’ll walk to the next available hospital with an incubator for the sake of the babies, but it’s a long walk outside of Seoul. The husband offers to drive a boat there — he’s an electrician, but he’s watched how to operate a boat. Hye-sung agrees that the boat option would be the fastest, and they lead the exodus of hospital patients towards this port.
The patients walk through the unstable streets, helping each other and pushing the gurneys. Hye-sung leads the group with his mother in a wheelchair and stops suddenly at the sight of a sinkhole. He warns the patients to avoid the hole, but two patients decide that they want to avoid this effort entirely. They run back towards the hospital despite warnings from Ji-na and Ddol-mi.
They yell at Hye-sung to stop the two desperate men, so he chases them. Hye-sung sees the men racing into the hospital building, and he demands that they escape. They don’t listen to him, and Hye-sung runs towards the building right as it crumbles from the top down.
From afar, Ji-na and Ddol-mi see Han River Mirae Hospital collapse. They watch wide-eyed, unsure about Hye-sung’s safety.
COMMENTS
That was a lot of crashing and burning, quite the opposite of what I expect will happen with this drama production. After this episode, I’m pretty convinced that the pre-production aspect to this drama is in its favor. I think the writers got the narrative and character moments down, and though they may have benefitted from slight character changes based on response, I don’t think there would have been any significant changes to what we have now. At this point, I would actually prefer to see the original thought in the story and character development over the live writing and shooting.
Regarding the crashing and burning, I think the CGI effects work well to make this earthquake believable. I believe the catastrophic destruction and the characters’ reactions. If they’ve been working with the green screen the whole time, they’ve got me fooled. Narrative-wise, however, I think the explosions and building collapses happen a little too conveniently. I get it, the buildings and cars need to explode behind the people just as they escape for the thrills and cool explosion imagery in the back. But having every explosion happen that way completely kills the suspense. I just expect our characters to escape now, so I find myself just enjoying the nice screencaps I get.
I don’t mind that the effects may be mostly plot devices or cliffhanger mechanisms because I mostly care for the characters. I enjoyed watching how scrappy and resourceful Hye-sung was in creating a “hospital” for incoming disaster patients. But I was completely taken aback when he very quickly (almost too quickly) decided that certain patients would not be prioritized. It was strange to hear those words come out of his mouth, especially since he’s built up a reputation of treating anyone and everyone. When he left the pregnant mother and husband to fend for themselves, I found myself in Ddol-mi’s shoes, expecting and wanting Hye-sung to turn around and help. But I guess that reputation only applies in the luxury of electricity, running water, blood supply, and solid facilities. Contrary to what we’ve seen thus far, it seems that Hye-sung does know his limitations as a doctor. He knows what he’s capable of, and delivering babies was not one of them… until he had to.
The baby delivery scene was surprisingly hilarious and oh so heartwarming. The moment where they stare at each other like soooo… no one has delivered a baby. Ha, that literally threw everything Hye-sung said about priorities out the window. It was a classic Hye-sung moment, and I’m glad we were reminded that Hye-sung is an impulsively good doctor who prioritizes saving lives out of everything.
Ddol-mi keeps growing on me because she’s got this clumsy charm and assertive personality. I wouldn’t say that she’s the best doctor, and she doesn’t pretend to be. In fact, most of the time, she takes orders from Hye-sung in the hospital. Mark foreheads, done. Find Styrofoam, done. But her personality really shines in her contentious interactions with Hye-sung and in her encounter with the grieving son. Her words were painfully accurate, brutally honest, almost too much for the son to handle. She speaks the truth, and she’s not intimidated by the consequences of that truth.
I found this episode to be a great introduction to our earthquake guides. I loved that Mr. Kang was an unexpected addition to this group of disaster leaders. Completely unexpected, given that our first impressions of him were an improv poetry performance and drunk antics. We were given most of the good guys this time around, though, and I’d like to see how Mirae Hospital responds to this earthquake. Definitely not the action that Hye-sung took in leading the exodus of patients to a safer location. That scene almost gave me goosebumps, seeing how much Hye-sung cared for his mother and all of his patients. It was the manifestation of his admirable passion for saving lives, and now, I can’t help but be increasingly invested in his mission to lead his patients to safety.
RELATED POSTS
- D-Day: Episode 2
- D-Day: Episode 1
- Assembling the rescue squad for D-Day
- Explosions and destruction rock Seoul in JTBC’s D-Day
- The earthquake strikes in medical-disaster drama D-Day
- The rescue team is dispatched in disaster drama D-Day
- JTBC picks up Yoon Kye-sang thriller Last, D-Day to follow
- Disaster medical drama D-Day confirms lineup, awaits scheduling
Tags: D-Day, featured, Ha Suk-jin, Jung So-min, Kim Young-kwang
Required fields are marked *
Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *
1 pogo - sailing HMS Queen of Tears and HMS Sailboat Lovely Runner🍉
October 5, 2015 at 12:13 PM
I skipped most of the first two episodes thanks to the lack of subs and them being mostly setup, but I quite like it once our disaster is actually underway.
I just hope that there's a coherent plot and story beyond 'save the patient of the week' going on here, because so far things appear solid and the characters are interesting. I'd actually go so far as to say this drama's main appeal is its characters, from Hye-sung and Ddol-mi to Sister and Mr 'I can't be ordered around! I'm an intern!" Ahn Dae-gil.
I also like that we get the odd flash of humour, I had a good giggle at the scene where Ddol-mi stitches up Hye-sung's arm.
Required fields are marked *
2 tgs
October 5, 2015 at 12:22 PM
Yayyy. Keep up the good work. I have been waiting for this. Subs are so hard to come by too.
Required fields are marked *
3 casserole
October 5, 2015 at 12:38 PM
Thank you so much for recapping! I am halfway through ep 1 and am already hooked. :-)
Required fields are marked *
4 ju
October 5, 2015 at 12:48 PM
A strange disaster story that leads you to think that perhaps Seoul is an island unto itself. And Mirae Hospital the only hospital in existence with only a handful of petty doctors. The scale of scenes of destruction does not match the lack of chaos. You would expect more casualties, more response from the government. Somehow not altogether believable. You will see what I mean when you watch the subsequent episodes.
Required fields are marked *
esjpx
October 5, 2015 at 1:39 PM
I agree, the small-scale ER/hospital/streets scenes don't really match with the big-scale destruction scenes, there's so few people.
Required fields are marked *
fgb4877
October 5, 2015 at 2:20 PM
Dear Ju and Xnanax (BTW, nice palindrome ;) ), please remember that this is a Korean production, with a smaller budget than American series.
But the tone is what is interesting.
Required fields are marked *
Jon G.
October 5, 2015 at 2:56 PM
Well, I understand that they don't have enough money for disaster CGI and medical props.
But they should have enough money to, you know, show a few people out on the street, trying to find their relatives, trying to find some doctors/rescue workers to help them etc. There should be a constant influx of people who seek medical attention at the hospital. This is essential for the story.
Instead, the only people around (and in a kilometer-wide radius) are the ones who already were in the hospital immediately after the earthquake.
Required fields are marked *
fgb4877
October 5, 2015 at 3:26 PM
@ John G. ... I can't discuss with that, since you are right.
Probably a mix of a comparatively small budget and that if it seems very real people could be frightened?. I have no idea.
Cheers!.
Kiara
October 5, 2015 at 3:42 PM
This drama had a very high budget (over 12 million US dollars). That's more than the biggest hit movie of the year. Veteran (2.5 million budget) and currently rocking the box-office at around 89.1 million US dollars.
I hope the ratings hits 2% at least or reuse this expensive set.
Required fields are marked *
windsun33
October 5, 2015 at 5:41 PM
My impression also. You would almost think that the entire disaster is confined to a small area consisting of 2 or 3 hospitals. What I found most notable is the total lack of any military search and rescue teams, and the almost total lack of any helicopters.
One photo I saw of the Fukushima tsunami in Japan had over 20 helicopters in the air at once, directing search crews and pulling people to safety (including at least 3 US Marine choppers).
But on the other hand, judging from how Sewol was handled, this show might be more realistic than we would like to think.
Required fields are marked *
alua
October 6, 2015 at 3:55 PM
<hat I found most notable is the total lack of any military search and rescue teams, and the almost total lack of any helicopters.
I find that so so bizarre!
Required fields are marked *
5 velvetstuff
October 5, 2015 at 12:53 PM
This is getting soooo goood!!! I'm so in love with Hye Sung, and Ddol Mi is just so cute. I was starting to get annoyed at the homeless drunk because he kept making things hard for everyone, but this sudden leadership is pretty cool. I'm also so curious about the brother.
Required fields are marked *
6 bea
October 5, 2015 at 1:08 PM
when i grow up i want to be hyesung haha :) like for real, i want to be an emergency doc. in my country, earthquakes like this is very common along with all those other natural calamities :(
Required fields are marked *
7 Jon G.
October 5, 2015 at 1:09 PM
I'm somehow very disappointed. I certainly didn't expect this kind of "cliche queue" plot, and I definitely didn't expect the utter lack of epicness.
Required fields are marked *
Jon G.
October 5, 2015 at 1:19 PM
Considering the structural damage to buildings and infrastructure, the area around the hospital should have thousands of injured people. Where is everybody? The streets are completely empty. There must be hundreds of thousands of injured people in the area.
The colour system is one of the realistic touches. It's immediately undermined by the fact that only a tiny number of people (most of them already in the hospital in the first place) are to be treated.
And then the entire medical staff of the hospital commits to a very risky, most probably multi-hour-long operative delivery of twins that will very likely not survive the next 24h, despite the fact not one of the team members has any kind of experience or expertise.
Luckily the show doesn't show us all the hundreds people in and around the hospital who died during this operation and could have been saved otherwise.
Required fields are marked *
pogo - sailing HMS Queen of Tears and HMS Sailboat Lovely Runner🍉
October 5, 2015 at 2:02 PM
yeah, the body count is WAY down for a disaster of this (supposed) magnitude.
and also, I don't get how everyone here is so backwards and unaware about earthquakes in a first world country. I guess a comparison to Japan's (the country right next door!) earthquake-proofing standards and preparation would just be breaking out the elephant in the room.
The drama's running mostly on character rather than plot, because to be quite honest, an earthquake and associated fallout alone can't sustain the 20 or so episodes this is supposed to be. But since it's pre-produced, I hope they had time to think it out instead of going by the seat-of-the-pants approach to writing kdramas.
Required fields are marked *
Jon G.
October 5, 2015 at 2:14 PM
... and there's nothing wrong with a character-centered show like that. However, when immediately after the disaster, the disaster doesn't affect the plot and the characters any more than, say, a car accident, I'm a bit puzzled.
Required fields are marked *
pogo - sailing HMS Queen of Tears and HMS Sailboat Lovely Runner🍉
October 5, 2015 at 2:41 PM
I agree, it's a wise decision to keep it character-focused because so far, that is the drama's strength.
But they still need things to actually happen to drive that development, and they just don't have anything on a large enough scale yet since, as you pointed out, all our major characters have hardly suffered more than a few scratches.
Jon G.
October 5, 2015 at 2:51 PM
Not just that. They also have not been challenged by the fallout of the disaster yet. So far, the story of an underfunded and understaffed hospital could have been told without the earthquake without any significant change of the character arcs.
fgb4877
October 5, 2015 at 2:45 PM
Dear Pogo, when this series started it picqued my curiosity and compared big earthquakes both in Japan and in Korea. For Korea, the remembering threshold is Magnitude 5, for Japan is Magnitude 7. It is also said that 80% of edifications in Korea don't follow anti-seismic building protocols.
Recent Earthquakes in Korea:
http://earthquaketrack.com/kr-11-seoul/recent
Historic Earthquakes in Korea (this is a Paper):
http://seismic.yonsei.ac.kr/paper/bssa2013.pdf
(Please be aware that this Paper is more interested in trying to find the epicenters of historical events but it shows events in the past as data)
Biggest Earthquakes in Japan:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_earthquakes_in_Japan
Probably I am not comparing exactly apples to apples, but they gave me an idea.
Required fields are marked *
fgb4877
October 5, 2015 at 3:22 PM
BTW, the state of seismological construction in Korea information comes from:
http://www.rjkoehler.com/2010/01/18/how-safe-is-seoul-from-an-earthquake/
It seems that constructions able to withstand earthquakes over magnitude 7.0 are the norm after 1988, but in that Blog they point out that possibly they are not constructed soundly, which is worrysome.
If you find better sources (observe some of these are only Wikipedia or Blogs), please be welcome to share them :) .
fgb4877
October 5, 2015 at 4:50 PM
Re-Edit:
If someone finds better sources (observe some of these are only Wikipedia or Blogs), please be welcome to share them :) .
(I am in no way challenging Pogo or other Beanie to find better data, but it would be very welcome).
On the other hand, this drama is a good excuse to study again what to do in an emergency.
juniper
October 5, 2015 at 5:07 PM
@FGB4877. Wow, you've put a lot of research into this. I still think the production is over-the-top in its portrayal of the disaster, but maybe not as much as I thought? :)
That aside, though, none of this data can explain how adult, presumably extremely well-educated characters exhibited zero earthquake awareness, let alone safety awareness. Given their proximity to Japan, as Pogo pointed out, that just seems insane.
windsun33
October 5, 2015 at 5:55 PM
Japan is on a different and more stable tectonic plate, which is why Korea has so few earthquakes. Even the extremely few earthquakes in the past were very much localized, not huge shifts in the plates like happened in Alaska, Indonesia, and Japan in the past. http://eurasiatectonics.weebly.com/amurian-plate.html
windsun33
October 5, 2015 at 5:56 PM
Opps.. meant "KOREA is on"..
Moo
October 5, 2015 at 7:18 PM
People really need to get their heads out of the concept of using the Richter Scale as a means to seismic design. You ever say something like "Can this building withstand a magnitude ## earthquake?" to anyone with any knowledge in the matter and they will look at you with a sad look and shake their head. The Richter Scale is not used in the professional world and holds absolutely no meaning without an abundance of additional information. Natural disaster design requirements are based on return periods, which I won't get into as it'll get complicated.
When I heard that crap about buildings being designed to withstand a magnitude 4.0 earthquake, it was so very sad.
Please spread knowledge; if anyone ever tries to relate a number from an obsolete system with seismic design, please slap them in the face, point at them, and say "No."
tl;dr. PLEASE STOP WITH THE RICHTER SCALE REFERENCE. IT MEANS NOTHING.
Moo
October 5, 2015 at 7:37 PM
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Return_period
Just for "The More You Know!", most modern buildings that have a significant chance in lost of life (i.e., pretty much everything that will house people) have a minimum design requirement of 1 in 400 years return period. Many have a 1 in 2475 return period design requirement. This design means that in an event of the design earthquake, the building MUST still be standing and serviceable. That means a maximum chance for a properly designed structure in this age to collapse enough where you can't exit the building is 0.2% (not 2%, and it's even lower for major buildings that go beyond 1 in 400 return period).
This is a design based on historical and local facts; not some nonsense number from an obsolete scale. Is there a chance a huge earthquake comes in and destroys your city that no one saw coming? Yes. But it's so unlikely that it's simply not economical to build every single thing so it withstands a "10.0 magnitude earthquake right below your city".
Yes, there are a lot of old buildings that will not meet this requirement, which is why retrofitting is ongoing in many countries.
Spread the knowledge, young ones. Spread the knowledge.
juniper
October 5, 2015 at 8:10 PM
@Moo. Thanks for taking the time and educating us a bit. I learned a lot from reading your comments! :)
juniper
October 5, 2015 at 5:25 PM
I just want to know who put him in charge of that hospital and why literally no one else was working there besides his scooby gang. Are we just supposed to assume all of his coworkers (and bosses) died?
And yeah, totally agree about the twins. At that point I'm pretty sure they were just trying to one up every medical drama ever. It was inevitable that we were going to run into a pregnant woman in bad condition at some point, but two of them in one episode, and twins on top of that? Drama had something to prove, I guess haha.
But anyway, Hyesung has proven he's incapable of making good, logical decisions. On top of that he's a raging hypocrite. Just previous to this event (or right after? Memory's a bit fuzzy), we just got treated to Hero Moment #2544058454566, wherein he gave a distraught loved one a dose of reality (and a dose of his fists almost, though that's neither here nor there)--"we must save those who can be saved~!!" Cue hours long birth w/ pregnant woman in dire straits, complete with bizarrely triumphant, feel-good aftermath (out of this disaster we've made life~!). Meanwhile, the horde of injured and/or dying (dead?) patients he was just lecturing that poor kid about have been left to their own devices for the last few hours.
Required fields are marked *
windsun33
October 5, 2015 at 5:57 PM
I think every disaster show ever has some kind of birth scene. I guess it's a law.
Required fields are marked *
alua
October 6, 2015 at 4:15 PM
<Where is everybody? The streets are completely empty. There must be hundreds of thousands of injured people in the area.
To be honest, I was watching and thinking that at times it feels more like some sort of alien invasion/apocalypse scenario, where 80% of the population has been mysteriously swallowed up by the earth or abducted by aliens, leaving behind only a small cluster of people, who all just happen to be in the two or three hospitals (or within their immediate vicinity) and who are now the last survivors on planet earth....
Required fields are marked *
windsun33
October 5, 2015 at 5:43 PM
So far, up to ep4, I have seen just about every possible medical and disaster show cliche ever invented, with the sole exception of doctors murdering patients for power.
Required fields are marked *
juniper
October 5, 2015 at 8:04 PM
Maybe things will get all lord of the flies later on? We can always hope. I'm beginning to think the writer's version of research holing up and marathoning disaster blockbusters instead of cracking open a book.
Required fields are marked *
juniper
October 5, 2015 at 8:05 PM
*was holing up, sorry
Required fields are marked *
8 bea
October 5, 2015 at 1:26 PM
also, did you see the tummy padding they used for the pregnant woman??? I was wondering why they didn't retake that scene with better padding. it was so obvious when they lifted her out of the car
Required fields are marked *
Kiara
October 5, 2015 at 3:46 PM
I'm here to check out the rubber twins but I guess I need to start from eps 1:p.
Required fields are marked *
9 jessie
October 5, 2015 at 2:17 PM
i hope nothing happens to Hye-sung pls domt let anything happen to him
Required fields are marked *
10 jessie
October 5, 2015 at 2:17 PM
i hope nothing happens to Hye-sung pls don't let anything happen to him
Required fields are marked *
11 liz
October 5, 2015 at 4:27 PM
Please watch it on Viki.com who is subbing this, other websites steal their subs.
They already subbed 5 episodes, and episode 6 is 77% !
https://www.viki.com/tv/27255c-d-day
Required fields are marked *
Indira
October 5, 2015 at 5:14 PM
Not everyone can access Viki, that's why we are watching the shows on other sites.
Required fields are marked *
12 Sajen
October 5, 2015 at 4:38 PM
Did it annoy anyone else that no one knew it was an earthquake until the radio told them? O.K. sure it was unexpected but really, no one. I kind of forgive the people in buildings an explosion can rock a building but Hye-sung and Ddol-mi were outside and only one thing can do that, besides they must have felt the ground shaking.
Other than that really I love the show.
Required fields are marked *
juniper
October 5, 2015 at 4:59 PM
Um, YES. Like, literally no one was willing to go out on a limb and say ground shaking=earthquake. And then when they find out, the Music of Doom comes on and the drama is like, ~Plot twist!! Shit just got real.
But, but, but! The drama is quick to remind us that there was an earthquake in 1518 so anyone not expecting a repeat in 2015 was totally foolish. Because seismographic measurements are for tools, obviously, and probability is for suckers.
Required fields are marked *
windsun33
October 5, 2015 at 5:58 PM
Yeah, that was freaking stupid. They live a few hundred miles from some of the most earthquake prone zones in the world, yet nobody can figure out that it's an earthquake?
Required fields are marked *
E.Serious
October 6, 2015 at 12:22 AM
Considering South Korea is still technically at war with North Korea and North Korea is run by a nut who is constantly threatening to destroy them, it's conceivable that earthquake wouldn't be the first thought.
Any explosion that was big enough would shake the ground like an earthquake. Especially a natural gas pipeline explosion. A transformer blew up about a mile from where I work. We all thought it was an earthquake.
Even if it's unlikely, it's at least plausible. And after young-pal, plausible is academy award level writing.
Required fields are marked *
windsun33
October 6, 2015 at 10:13 AM
But you have to wonder why nobody there had a radio - not like they are high tech or hard to come by. But even the recent Tianjin massive explosion in China was only a 2.9/2.1 right at ground zero.
Required fields are marked *
plumwine
October 6, 2015 at 2:21 PM
Wasn't the tower that Namsan tower took out a radio tower? Perhaps
Required fields are marked *
13 juniper
October 5, 2015 at 4:53 PM
Like how Our Hero went from Jesus in a white coat to Moses in a white coat at the end. Because this show couldn't get anymore ridiculous. Yeah...
Seriously, this woman had all the time in the world to research disaster relief, emergency medicine, or y'know, earthquakes. Or earthquake safety (did anyone else laugh their head off to see the director get her kid in the car and drive off to Hero Music, presumably attempting to flee the shaking earth?). But research is for lesser mortals than drama writers--why should we bother, when we can act like a 6.5 magnitude earthquake in a first world country is the end of times and watch Our Hero save the world one pregnant woman at a time?
Dr. Jin 2015, calling it. Time will tell if this ends up as lulzy and endearing as that drama, or soldiers on as a blood-vessel-popping parody of itself.
Required fields are marked *
14 t
October 5, 2015 at 5:55 PM
I agreed with all the comments about the scale of scenes of destruction does not match the lack of chaos and people were running around not knowing they were experiencing an earthquake until they heard it on the radio. Also people actually got into their cars to drive. It makes sense to me that if you live in a country that doesn't have much earthquake and always preparing for wars and terrorism, you can't tell what the earth shaking is all about.
I like the intensity of the medical teams when they transition from dealing with day to day issues, case by case of the patient's condition and suddenly it is no longer about that anymore. When they know it was an earthquake hit, No more debate on funding issues and/or following procedures or protocols. They were so unprepared and all scattered. The hospitals are not a safe place to go either and The medical teams also sacrificed their own safety as well.
Required fields are marked *
15 windsun33
October 5, 2015 at 6:00 PM
Was I the only one wondering why they hell the rescue workers were carrying buckets of water up long flights of stairs? Or where the water came from? Or why they were never shown using it for anything?
Required fields are marked *
Sajen
October 5, 2015 at 10:20 PM
I figured they got water from the river to put a fire out and they couldn't get to it by vehicle. But then the water and buckets just disappeared with no explanation.
Required fields are marked *
16 sumee
October 5, 2015 at 6:10 PM
I am finding this drama surprisingly good maybe because i came in with zero expectations, some scenes were over to top but it's a disaster drams so we will have to deal with it and I m really enjoying ddok mi and hye sung's characters
Required fields are marked *
17 sumee
October 5, 2015 at 6:16 PM
But I am disappointed by the lack of government involvement and how fast the military and the army act in such situations .. The omittion of such important aspects make the drama watch a little discomforting
Required fields are marked *
18 boop
October 5, 2015 at 6:40 PM
...I feel like some of the comments here really show their ethnocentrism when it comes to disaster response in a country not their own. As much as it looks like South Korea is a first-world country, it's still very third-world in a number of aspects such as infrastructure and government policies. Judging by netizen response, Koreans IN KOREA think that this is a very realistic drama, 6.5 magnitude earthquake and all, because that country is in no way equipped to deal with natural disasters on this scale.
Honestly, some of you are just nitpicking for the sake of being contrary. :/
Required fields are marked *
crazyahjummafan
October 5, 2015 at 6:49 PM
I agree. Nit-picking. Come on, which movie/drama is 100% realistic? How many blockbuster movies have the hero and heroine surviving against the odds? This drama I feel is more of a human drama rather than a disaster drama. And I'm enjoying the human and inhuman bits too.
What i like about it are the heart-warming and even funny bits shown in the midst of dire situations, such as the team whispering that they don't know anything about ob & gyn.
And the scene when Ddol Mi sews up Hyesung's wound. They were so cute.
Required fields are marked *
juniper
October 5, 2015 at 7:13 PM
...because netizens are the best source for a reality check.
It's not ethnocentrism that's causing my incredulity, I'm honestly very sorry if it comes across that way. I'm not expecting the drama to act like it's taking place in LA or Tokyo, but it would be nice if it would act like it's taking place on planet earth. I am positive that Korea's medical and emergency relief workforce has a basic level of professionalism and competence, none of which is the slightest bit evident here. I am positive that Korean people have some lay knowledge of what an earthquake is and how to stay safe during them, none of which is evident here either. And I'm also certain that there are ways earthquakes work, and ways we talk about them/deal with them, that this drama is ignoring in favor of cheap, exploitative tragedy and staged hero moments. Anyone who thinks that this is a realistic portrayal of earthquakes or disaster relief is kidding themselves.
Required fields are marked *
PeepsLeAwesomePotato
October 5, 2015 at 10:59 PM
I am positive that Korea’s medical and emergency relief workforce has a basic level of professionalism and competence, none of which is the slightest bit evident here.
This is not pretty, but please refer to the immediate aftermath of Sewol disaster. Not to say that ALL Koreans in the medical and emergency workforce are stupid or cruel, because I'm sure many are hardworking and proficient, but there's some rampant corruption (if I can call it that) among the upper rungs that bind their hands.
I am positive that Korean people have some lay knowledge of what an earthquake is and how to stay safe during them, none of which is evident here either.
Not sure why you're expecting a country of people who've never experienced an earthquake or ever expected one to happen right in the heart of said country to know how to identify one right away, much less know how to react in one. I mean, it's like chikungunya. If you have no idea what the heck it is, you'd probably panic and do stupid things. Like drive out in the middle of an earthquake.
Required fields are marked *
juniper
October 6, 2015 at 6:55 AM
I'm not talking about corruption, though, or people being stopped from doing their jobs by corrupt higher ups. I'm talking about supposed professionals that regularly behave in the most unprofessional and idiotic ways possible, which I can only guess is because the writer has no idea what their jobs encompass.
As for earthquake awareness, again, they live on planet earth, right? I will allow that an explosion might be their first thought, but that doesn't really bear up well, because a) there's no fire (which...why were there no fires?), and b) the ground is shaking and cracking. Hyesung and Ddolmi were outside, and have seen the extent of the damage. They should have absolutely no point of confusion, yet they were shocked when the nurse let them know it was an earthquake. Let me use an example. I live in New York, a region that is hardly known for its earthquakes. It is on the other side of the continent from California, and far north of the Missouri area (which is also in a fault zone). However, I have actually experienced two extremely minor earthquakes. The ground shook for a few seconds each time. Literally every single person I talked to that day knew that it had been an earthquake. Now obviously it wasn't dangerous enough for people to panic, so I can't comment on safety practices, but basic awareness? It's a thing.
Again, they live right across from Japan, and south of China. Both countries have had catastrophic earthquakes in the past 10-15 years. It seems very silly that no earthquake awareness has bled over into S. Korea (like...onto their news programs?). Especially when we remember that while these characters behave like idiots, they are presumably extremely well-educated, it just seems insane that they wouldn't know an earthquake when they see one.
Required fields are marked *
PeepsLeAwesomePotato
October 6, 2015 at 11:56 AM
Oh, so you were talking about HyeSung and DdolMi. I have no comeback. I was just thinking of those in buildings and where-ever else.
And still not sure why you'd expect earthquake safety news to "leak" over. Usually the news just reports: Earthquake!!!
Although S.K. does now have a programme called Safety First on KBS. Maybe more people will know now? But really, I don't think its unphantomable that people don't know what to do in earthquakes. Like... HyeSung and DdolMi are not even full doctors. They're still doctors in training. And really, no one really studies stuff like Weil's disease if the probability of occurance in specified area is close to zero - just like no one really studies for an earthquake.
juniper
October 6, 2015 at 1:02 PM
Pretty sure Hyesung is a full doctor. If he's not, I'll have to add "why was Hyesung allowed to supervise/perform surgeries at Mirae when he was not fully qualified?" to my list of questions about things in this drama that make no sense. And anyway, if the only excuse for their unprofessionalism and incompetence is that they're not fully trained, I fear for S. Korea's medical system. But fortunately, I think the truth is that the writer has no idea how doctors operate and has substituted actual research with throwing a mishmash of jargon and cliches at the wall, hoping something sticks.
I think we'll just have to agree to disagree about earthquake awareness. There are only so many times we can have this argument before we start going around in circles. Personally, I think knowing how to recognize an earthquake and stay safe during one is common sense, and that information about such things has been globally disseminated time and time again. And imo common sense was sacrificed to sensationalize something that needed no sensationalizing. But that's just me.
windsun33
October 6, 2015 at 10:18 AM
They have had other natural disasters in the past, such as typhoons and flooding. While the cause might be different, the response is not that much different. And I am not seeing any kind of realistic response here.
Required fields are marked *
PeepsLeAwesomePotato
October 6, 2015 at 11:59 AM
Not sure what you were seeing but all I saw was Mirae Hospital, HyeSung and DdolMi. Plus the fire-fighting department?
It's all behind the scenes~ *waves hands in your face*
Steely
August 9, 2020 at 9:02 AM
I had actually wondered about the 6.5 magnitude question myself when I watched this episode. I was ready to just suspend disbelief, since this is an enjoyable drama with a lot of heart.
However, on researching earthquake scales, I found out that there is actually a different scale used in Japan, commonly known as the Shindo Scale. Based on the Shindo Scale, 6.5 would be in the strongest category.
I don't know which system they were using here, but given the proximity to Japan, it would not surprise me if this was on the Shindo Scale.
Required fields are marked *
19 crazyahjummafan
October 5, 2015 at 7:01 PM
There's something I would like to address: Hyesung's decision not to help the pregnant woman. Initially, I was taken-aback. Isn't this the doctor who would help anyone any time? But I realised, just like dramallama puts it, "it seems that Hye-sung does know his limitations as a doctor. He knows what he’s capable of, and delivering babies was not one of them… until he had to."
The situation at that time was not so dire for the mother. First, she's 8 months pregnant, not 9. Although her pulse rate was faster than usual, it maybe due to the harrowing experience she went through. At that time, he was also concerned for the patients that would arrive at his hospital. So I believe, he went for the practical. And yes, there has to a birth...in the midst of a disaster, cause life just goes on, doesn't it?
After saying all this, there is also something that puzzles me. I'm actually quite amazed that 2 doctors, one very experienced and 2 experienced nurses, have never assisted in child-birth. When I was in Uni, my friends in med school used to tell me that they had to assist and eventually deliver a certain number of babies before they could graduate. It was like the fundamentals of being a doctor. Idk, maybe it's different in Korea, or maybe things have changed since I went to Uni, which was years ago.
Required fields are marked *
20 ⭐ Sera The Ms Temper ⭐
October 5, 2015 at 8:53 PM
i still didnt watch epi 3. need to catch up asap.
Required fields are marked *
21 fantasy
October 5, 2015 at 9:58 PM
I am liking the drama, but somethings do bother me because in my country natural calamities are quite often (specially floods), along with big earthquakes and it is common to see ARMY helicopters, throwing food packets, rescuing people, temporary camps where army doctors work people.
I may get a very wrong impression that Seol is not at all have any plan to face any type of natural calamities. I know that it is a character driven drama but still, rescue process is pathetic. I hope it is not a real scenerio
Required fields are marked *
fantasy
October 5, 2015 at 9:58 PM
ohhh... one thing the recap is ep 3 but my comment is based on upto ep 5 :P
Required fields are marked *
⭐ Sera The Ms Temper ⭐
October 6, 2015 at 6:40 PM
In my country, the common natural disasters normally floods, but earthquakes is not common. We may have the preparation for floods, but... what can i say, the preparation is never enough. I don't know how the govt allocate the budget for this and how exactly they use it. I also cant foresee what will happen if one day, our country also face earthquakes.
Required fields are marked *
22 niyati
October 5, 2015 at 10:09 PM
I'm completely on board with the previous comments wrt people couldn't figure out that an earthquake had struck until they heard it on the radio.. I mean the ground is shaking buildings are crumbling what the hell did you expect it to be? And that oh shit moment when they revealed that, that was what had happened was completely anti-climatic. I mean hello! Yes something horrible has happened, and though you didn't figure it out when you totally should have, its over as is obvious from the non-shaking ground. What was that moment of shock about? Like you heard the earthquake is coming not that it has just passed!
But my largest pet peeve was the closing of the hospitals! I mean I get it.. They're trying to contrast that with the our hero's *ahem* heroism but WTF! I don't know about Korea but in my country hospitals are bound by law to dispense emergency life saving care irrespective of who the patient is or what is their capacity to pay for medical care. But regardless of country who the fuck closes the er in times of a disaster? They're a big hospital, the whole point of their existence is to treat people. It's where people are supposed to go in times of emergency. They should be gearing up not shutting down. And its pointless.. Do they have gold in there that they're trying to guard from the hordes of injured? Are the doctors too lazy to treat them? What? It makes no sense and is an addition just to generate conflict!
Required fields are marked *
PeepsLeAwesomePotato
October 5, 2015 at 11:06 PM
I mean the ground is shaking buildings are crumbling what the hell did you expect it to be?
An underground gas-pipeline explosion a la KaoSiung in Taiwan on 31 July 2014. Or a sinkhole. There are tons of things that cause buildings to collapse and about a hundred different ways that can cause the ground to burst.
Required fields are marked *
windsun33
October 6, 2015 at 10:26 AM
One of the heroes looked out across the river to the horizon and saw all kinds of crashed buildings, fires, and collapsed freeways. Anyone with half a brain could figure out it is nothing like a sinkhole or explosion.
Required fields are marked *
PeepsLeAwesomePotato
October 6, 2015 at 12:18 PM
Eh, maybe Kim JongEun has gone nuts and decided to bomb Seoul.
Required fields are marked *
Jisungie
October 6, 2015 at 1:07 AM
Comment was deleted
Required fields are marked *
niyati
October 6, 2015 at 11:21 AM
"If you really really really watch it like from the start I think you should noticed that people assume that it is IMPOSIBBLE for earthquake to hit Seoul" Maybe, but why? Why does everyone HAVE to assume that an earthquake will NEVER hit Seoul? Do they think it has some magical earthquake shield or something? And what is the point? Just so everyone can make appropriate shocked faces when it strikes? Why because the destruction around them is not enough to be shocked about?
"if you really watch it, you’ll know why they shut down the hospital"
No I really don't, it serves no purpose other than to create unnecessary dramatic tension.
Admittedly I've watched it only until 3 so far, I've yet to get to 5, but still no! You do not shut down a major hospital in times of a disaster. That's not the way it works. People flock to the site of disasters to help out. Medical aid workers fly in from outside countries to help out. The very idea of a hospital shutting its doors makes no sense. Even from a purely mercenary money-minded perspective it is stupid. Shutting down would not only be very bad PR it would open he hospital to a truckload of litigation from people who were refused aid.
I agree with you, it's a drama! But when there is something so phenomenally stupid going on, it interferes with my enjoyment of the story because it pulls me out of the narrative and makes me yell "that does not make sense!!!!"
Required fields are marked *
Jisungie
October 6, 2015 at 11:40 PM
Comment was deleted
Required fields are marked *
niyati
October 7, 2015 at 12:34 AM
"So the conclusion you watch it but you don’t really understand it." I have no idea what you're basing that argument on but whatever..
"In this drama, everybody thought .... when the earthquake was not even that bad."
I'm not really complaining about how or why the buildings crumbled (even though there were parts I found a little illogical). I'm talking about everyone's shocked reactions over the fact that the earthquake happened at all. It was all very silly and pointlessly over-dramatic, is the point I was trying to make.
"Private hospital dont really have to stay open and they can close whenever they want. Private hospitals, private doctors mostly work for money not like the public one."
Not true. I cannot comment upon the exact laws in Korea but I'm pretty sure a hospital (private or otherwise) closing its doors during an emergency would invite a shit load of legal trouble. Also; people in general and doctors in particular are not so cold hearted as to deny fellow humans essential care for no reason.
Also as far as money is concerned @Windsun33 mentions in a following comment and I quote, "And all the talk from the hospital “leaders” talking about getting sued for malpractice, when in fact nearly every country has laws in place that prevent any such suits in emergency situations such as this unless it is gross negligence (like amputating an arm to cure a head wound). Also in nearly all OECD countries the hospital would get reimbursed by the government for any actual expenses, so that excuse is out the window also."
And again.. WHY? Like really.. WHY? To illustrate my point, Closing the doors of a treasury to keep looters out makes sense, closing the doors of say a mall to keep zombies out makes sense, closing a hospital to keep patients out does not.
"Well, you don't have to be so realistic, analytical about everything tho." Oh really? So it's okay for instance if there were suddenly those aforementioned zombies or vampires or an earthquake causing Godzilla running around randomly in the drama as well? All stories require a certain amount of suspension of disbelief. The difference between the good ones and the bad ones is that the good ones are capable of striking a decent balance between fact and fiction. This drama has failed to do that several times at the moment. I don't hate it, but I am saying it could have been SO MUCH BETTER.
juniper
October 7, 2015 at 8:03 AM
It's not that we can't understand it. It's that we can't accept it lol. This drama is full of crap on so many levels.
windsun33
October 6, 2015 at 10:24 AM
And all the talk from the hospital "leaders" talking about getting sued for malpractice, when in fact nearly every country has laws in place that prevent any such suits in emergency situations such as this unless it is gross negligence (like amputating an arm to cure a head wound). Also in nearly all OECD countries the hospital would get reimbursed by the government for any actual expenses, so that excuse is out the window also.
Required fields are marked *
niyati
October 7, 2015 at 12:35 AM
+1 to everything you said, also I quoted your comment in a previous response, I hope that's ok
Required fields are marked *
23 niyati
October 5, 2015 at 11:20 PM
@peeps ok fair enough.. There are are other explanations for the things shown happening. However, speaking from the perspective of a person who has been in a similar situation, when the ground starts shaking and so on, your first thought is "oh shit! Earthquake!" If there is a different explanation for said shaking, that would probably come afterwards. But until you get that information, your first assumption would still be 'earthquake'
Required fields are marked *
PeepsLeAwesomePotato
October 6, 2015 at 2:28 AM
Nope. Not for them (or me for that matter), since we both live on stable tectonic plates far from tectonic fault lines.
Required fields are marked *
juniper
October 6, 2015 at 7:05 AM
That's an assumption, though. I don't live in a fault zone, but when the ground starts shaking, my first thought is still, earthquake! So people have different reactions. It's inconceivable to me literally no one in the entire drama would guess that ground shaking=earthquake.
Required fields are marked *
niyati
October 6, 2015 at 11:27 AM
Exactly. I don't live in an earthquake-prone or even a techtonically active region. I just happened to be visiting a city that was struck by a quake on my very first night there (no walking disaster jokes please :P)
And when the floor started shaking I wasn't exactly thinking "Oh maybe a sinkhole opened up nearby" but rather "*colorful swearwords deleted* earthquake! WTF Ruuuunnnn!! *more colorful swearwords deleted*"
Required fields are marked *
PeepsLeAwesomePotato
October 6, 2015 at 12:23 PM
Eh, what if they thought it was an earthquakes but then went "Nah, can't be." Therefore: Shock.
And that may be an assumption but many people kinda believe in it. And the land doesn't proven them wrong... until it does. But it hasn't.
Required fields are marked *
juniper
October 6, 2015 at 3:28 PM
I'm talking about a gut reaction. I'm just saying, even if we accept the idea that Korean people are completely and utterly ignorant about earthquakes--an assumption I find extremely patronizing, but even so--the ground starts shaking. Cracks apear, buildings collapse, the damage is obviously widespread for those who have a view to the outside. We have like 10 characters. Not a single one of them thinks, wtf earthquake! Instead, the Hero Music cranks on and they start running (or driving) around like chickens with their heads cut off. (Which is completely asinine behavior in a bombing, too, btw. I'm guessing the school system probably educated them on safety procedures for that kind of emergency.) And later, the jaw-dropping earthquake plot twist is revealed to the characters who would have to be practically braindead not to have at least considered it.
Forget about bad science. That's just bad writing.
niyati
October 7, 2015 at 12:35 AM
@juniper +1 to everything you said. My sentiments precisely.
alua
October 6, 2015 at 8:56 AM
But South Korea has earthquakes. Someone posted a link up above:
http://earthquaketrack.com/kr-11-seoul/recent
They are not on Japan's scale, but they occur, and have occurred within living memory.
And also: I've never experienced a tsunami, but I know the warning signs for it and what to do in case it occurs. Why? Because major disasters receive – often massive – international news coverage.
They might not do earthquake training in schools, but I would expect Koreans to pick up some basic knowledge – what to do, what not – from just watching news on disasters elsewhere.
Required fields are marked *
windsun33
October 6, 2015 at 10:34 AM
Nearly all major disasters get wide international coverage. So unless you live in a total bubble, there is no way you would think this was anything but an earthquake.
There actually ARE people that are supremely stupid - one of the videos of the Indian Ocean tsunami shows some British woman running down to the ocean bed to pick up seashells when the water level suddenly went down 8 feet and exclaiming about how cool it was. But those are the Darwin Award winners, not most people.
Required fields are marked *
alua
October 6, 2015 at 3:45 PM
<So unless you live in a total bubble, there is no way you would think this was anything but an earthquake.
Exactly!
Obviously, there are some stupid people (and probably before the Boxing Day tsunami many didn't know). Some people won't absorb even basic knowledge, because they live in a total bubble, but most adult people should at least know that there are such things as earthquakes, that they involve the ground shaking (duh!) and basic things to do/not do.
PeepsLeAwesomePotato
October 6, 2015 at 12:33 PM
Er, none of them even occured on the land near Seoul, much less to say of one with Seoul as the epicentre. The closest one was off the shores of Incheon... 30 years ago. HyeSung and DdolMi hadn't even been born yet.
And were you aware of the safety procedures during a tsunami BEFORE the boxing day tsunami? Probably not, since people don't take in info unless they feel that it's useful. And the people of Seoul just didn't think earthquake-safety was useful - because they thought it'll never happen. There's a difference between blasting info and taking in info.
Required fields are marked *
alua
October 6, 2015 at 3:44 PM
@Peeps
No, obviously after the boxing day tsunami. But that's the ONE major tsunami that educated many people the world round... while there have been many more major earthquake disasters, one every few years. I'm sure some people will think such info is not useful, but in this drama it's almost like no one has any experience with earthquakes... That's not realistic. People in certain professions will know about earthquake scenarios. People who travel will have experienced them (Korean people travel plenty to J/CH). And even very ordinary people will pick up info from news reports, because major earthquakes happen again and again. E.g. Nepal: people were sleeping outside for days b/c of fear of buildings collapsing + aftershocks. That's basic knowledge you acquire – w/o even trying – from watching the news. (If you're unaware of it, you probably didn't know there was an earthquake in Nepal.) Here, people want to stay inside buildings and no one's yet thought of that further earthquakes might follow...
I've watched up to ep. 5 and I just find their reaction to the disaster odd. Okay, so perhaps they can't recognise that shaking earth = earthquake. But I would expect Korea – like every developed country – to have some sort of plan in place in case of either a) a major natural disaster b) a human-made disaster – esp. given the tensions between SK and NK.
But five episodes in, and there has been no sight of the army (that one that every single male Korean has served 2 years for) and the ministers have been just twiddling their thumbs for hours.
Yes, I'm aware of corruption & politics & also the inaction with Sewol, but there's just something off here. It's like no one ever thought any sort of disaster would ever occur. Plus the total lack of people on the street in certain scenes. I also find it odd that there's isn't a constant stream of injured people, but instead the doctors/nurses are sometimes just sitting around and chatting (I would expect them to be either doing something because the urgency of the situation or sleeping to recover their energy). At one point someone even says "The patients will come again tomorrow morning". But in an emergency situation there is no "off" time like that. Not in the first 24-48-72 hours!
Anyhow, it's reasonably entertaining, but the portrayal of the disaster is not realistic at all.
juniper
October 6, 2015 at 3:46 PM
I can't answer for Windsun33, but most of this stuff is just painfully obvious, safety tutorial or no, expectations or no. A lot of it is common sense. Don't run onto the seafloor when the tide pulls back eight feet. Get onto high ground, as far away from the shoreline as possible, when a giant wave is coming in. I get that people lose their head in a crisis, but considering these people's profession, don't you think they should be able to keep their cool in the face of an emergency? Some of it is more understandable--I can see why Mr. Evil Director thought it was a good idea to hide under furniture (even though that's not a good idea), but there's no excuse (or explanation) for the ER director's behavior, for example.
24 Budgie
October 6, 2015 at 1:23 AM
I do believe that the premise of dramas are incredibly important, and there are some things that can break immersion (like, lol, Doctor Jin. I was screaming at that one.)
For D-Day, I have a comfortable suspension of disbelief for this - I'm not going to quibble about the amount of people or the level of damage. Basically, once Namsan Tower broke and toppled over I chuckled and put some part of my common sense away. If I look a shot for every drama cliche I think you'd be dead drunk by the end of episode 4.
And yet, I would like to say that the characters in this drama are the real gems and they have drawn me in - think subsequent episodes do a better job in fleshing out the characterization and the relationship of everyone there.
Also, I feel like the plot may cause Haesung to flip flop a little on characterization; but who knows? In a high-stress situation like the First Ever Seoul Earthquake, maybe I'd make contradictory snap decisions too.
Verdict: Budgie is sufficiently sucked in by the characters to ignore the inconsistencies in the plot
Required fields are marked *
25 growingbeautifully
October 6, 2015 at 2:05 AM
Thanks @dramallama!
I was laughing as I read the comments. Perhaps the great CGI has done a disservice to the show. The disaster looks so thorough and widespread and epic, that the aftermath by comparison cannot help but look so meh. It would probably have helped if the disaster was somewhat localized, ... but no, then we don't get the hospital politics part to get frustrated over.... I suppose it had to appear like grand-scale disaster so that no hospitals were available and rich Mirae Hospital with their various politically-calculating members would have a reason to appear in this show and bring all the difficult personalities together. :)
Knowing what we'll be in for, it looks like I'll watch CGI scenes with awe and people scenes with 'aww...'. And everything in between with a little shake of the head. Forewarned is forearmed? No, I've no ammunition to throw at the screen. Well, at least I'll be prepared! :D
Required fields are marked *
26 chicory
October 6, 2015 at 2:35 AM
Everyone, I'm so sorry to deviate from all the serious talk, but if there are any mommies around... please let me know I'm not the only one who laughed when dr. Kang found her son's Robocar Poli toy! I know I may have a strange sense of humor (associated with the fact that my kids are crazy about the Robocar Poli cartoons), but I actually cried with tears since I couldn't even imagine such ingenious, such subtle product placement :)
Required fields are marked *
27 Ai Sky
October 6, 2015 at 2:39 AM
I love this drama, I'm in love actually...
At first I doubt this drama could gain my attention, except for So Min. But Yess... I'm grateful because in the end I decided to watch it.
I'm nurse and take a master right now in GMU. My faculty really concern about disaster, and earthquake is one of them. So this drama is on point by giving really great illustration about earthquake and how medical staffs have to handle it.
I experienced earthquake at Yogyakarta, Indonesia. And I think it's not much different with how DDay shown to me. So it like reminiscing memory, sad, painful and grateful too because somehow the disaster bring back humanity to the health care. It is what I feel after watch this drama too... the humanity... so thanks to JTBC and SM C n C, that both of them know exactly how the spend big budget with really appropriate drama.
Required fields are marked *
28 Mandy
October 6, 2015 at 2:43 AM
Comparing Japan and the response shown in Korea in D-Day is inaccurate. Japan is in the prone to earthquake zone. The government conduct exercises since young on what to do during earthquake. In D-Day, everyone thought earthquake will never happen in Korea, that's why during the seminar, no one is paying attention. They have the "this will never happen mentality". In order for rescue teams or army to be activated, the authorities need to give the order but the authorities are still playing the "not my problem, not under my care" of pushing blame and responsibility game. Also basically in dramas, private hospitals can basically do what they want, so shutting the doors during crisis is just categorized under another "norm" for them.
One drama that I like about showing medical during earthquakes will be the japanese drama Kyumei Byoto 24 Ji 3. Very interesting.
Required fields are marked *
29 Drama Princess
October 6, 2015 at 6:01 AM
It's frustrating to watch a drama with high expectations for an outstanding production. I don't know the writer but I think we have a good story but the execution of the production is very lacking. The scenes are not realistic enough. Where can you find a disaster -stricken area so quiet with only a handful of people on the streets, not even television reporters visible(except the one who took videos and interviews using his cellpone)? Or a hospital with so very few staff? This is not a comedy drama. It needs to be realistic. Just my opinion.
Required fields are marked *
30 Affie
October 6, 2015 at 8:24 AM
Whoaaaa. I have to check this show out!
Required fields are marked *
31 bridget
October 6, 2015 at 7:06 PM
Can I just say how much I love reading these comments? It reminds of reading the comments section for Dr. Jin. I never saw that show, and I haven't seen any of this drama either and I'm not really interested. I am just going to keep reading the comments for my dose of humor. I sincerely thank you for the laughs.
Required fields are marked *
32 korazylady
October 21, 2015 at 9:34 PM
I'm very late to the party here but can someone explain something that no one seems to have touched on? If Hyesung's mom is in a coma/vegetative state, how could she possibly keep her head up the entire time he was pushing her in the wheelchair? That alone was so distracting for me it took away from some of the other incredulous elements.
Required fields are marked *
33 Kelly Koo
November 12, 2015 at 6:06 PM
I enjoyed this drama so far, looking at the comments here, I just have to comment. Ok, everyone has their common sense and logic when comes to earthquake (even though most of you never experienced it before) and how this drama is not believable. But do not forget that you are watching a drama, NOT a movie. Not even the Americans wanted to make any San Andreas story into a drama series (ok, the movie flopped anyway).
But when did we ever come across such high budget drama in Korea? None I guess? I am impressed with the amount of budget given into this drama, all the explosive, building collapsing, road cracking, and so many different scenes too, so many characters and extras. This drama has more extras than any series in Korea that I have watched before, and yet, people are complaining the amount of people in the streets are not believable enough and the casualties are not enough. Come on! We are watching a drama, NOT a movie.
In most rom-com and melodrama, even sageuk they will only give us a few scene, workplace, home, and occasionally in the street/cafe, ok, throw in palace if we are watching a sageuk drama. And the story will occur in this few repeating scenes. But D-Day gave us, 2 different hospitals, streets, the subway, firemen crew scene, explosion at the supermarket, and there's a boy on a wheelchair? in a swimming school scene (this scene is so short, I still couldn't get hold of it), so much things happening in just 3 episodes and this drama wanted to build stories on so much character, I only worry they couldn't deliver such promises.
Were there any logical thinking when it comes to rom-com and melodrama? I thought we are way pass anything cliche in K-drama.
Required fields are marked *
34 Jerboa83
February 23, 2017 at 3:22 AM
As you probably know, Italy is being hitten by a series of strong eartquakes since last summer, and despite it's emergency response teams are considered to be very professional and well-trained, the situation wasn't that different to the one portrayed by the drama, especially after the first earthquake hit the central part of the country. We are talking mostly about disperse and small towns and villages, this time, but it was more or less the same think with the Aquila's earthquake a few years ago. After many hours from an earthquake, you wouldn't see "that" many people wandering on the streets: they would have either taken refuge somewhere or be hurrying somewhere else. Road blockades would actually prevent many rescue teams and military squads to get there, as it happened here in my country, so I find the drama to be quite realistic.
Required fields are marked *
35 Steely
August 9, 2020 at 9:16 AM
To anyone wondering about the magnitude of the earthquake in the show (stated as 6.5) compared to the extreme damage done, it depends on which scale is being used. If they are using the Japanese Shindo Scale, then 6.5 is in the strongest category and capable of causing extreme damage.
I am not going to say that D-Day is a sterling example of realism, but I thought at least this particular question might be addressed.
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Japan_Meteorological_Agency_seismic_intensity_scale
Required fields are marked *